The Arizona Republic conducted an analysis to learn which students were using vouchers. Remember that vouchers are supposed to “save poor kids from failing schools.” But that is not what is happening in Arizona!
As Arizona’s school-voucher program has expanded rapidly in the past year, students using taxpayer aid to transfer from public to private schools are abandoning higher-performing districts in more-affluent areas, according to an Arizona Republic analysis.
This year, more than 75 percent of the money pulled out of public schools for the Empowerment Scholarship Account program came from districts with an “A” or “B” rating, the analysis showed. By contrast, only 4 percent of the money came from school districts rated “D” or lower.
The findings undercut a key contention of the lawmakers and advocacy groups pressing to expand the state’s ESA program: that financially disadvantaged families from struggling schools reap the benefit of expanded school choice.
Critics, meanwhile, argue the program is largely being used by more-affluent families to subsidize their private-school tuition bills. The ESA program allows parents to take 90 percent of the money that would have gone to their school district and put it toward private school, home schooling and other educational programs.
The Empowerment Scholarship Account program funding grew to approximately $49 million this year, from about $30 million last year, according to February data from the Arizona Department of Education, which oversees the program. Republicans in the Legislature are advancing bills that would expand the program from the 3,360 students currently using it to all 1.1 million Arizona public school students after four years.
The legislature pulled a fast one on taxpayers. Taxes are being used to subsidize students from affluent families at private schools, not poor kids from low-performing schools.
This is a hoax!
Hello, Arizona taxpayers! How do you feel about your taxes subsidizing the private school tuitions of rich kids?
Hello, retirees! Do you really want your taxes to be used to destroy the public education system that benefited you, your children, and your grandchildren?
Hat tip to Pat Hale for bringing this important article to my attention.

I’m hoping state lawmakers won’t be dumb enough to accept DeVos’ voucher bribe money after their experience with RttT.
Schools that took RttT money in Ohio ended up putting in expensive measurement gimmicks that the grant funding didn’t cover. It was a net loss of funding. My son’s school somehow didn’t rate RttT- rejected!- and that turned out to be a blessing.
Don’t be dumb. Don’t accept DeVos’ assurances that her voucher money will cover costs. It won’t. Add and subtract. For once in your lives LOOK A GIFT HORSE in the mouth. YOU will pay for this, not the federal government, and by the time the bill comes due Betsy Devos will be back sailing her fleet of yachts and the public will blame STATE lawmakers for dumb decisions. Act accordingly.
LikeLike
Democrats for Education Reform join Eli Broad in crying crocodile tears for kids in public schools:
The #TrumpBudget released today is an assault on public education. Read our statement on it here:
Can it be possible that ed reformers just realized 90% of US kids attend public schools?
Why did they wait 20 years to offer some weak, useless advocacy for kids in public schools?
Whoops! “Education advocates” somehow omitted 90% of students! Might be time to call a meeting. Figure out how this happened.
Every single one of these people is directly responsible for what happens to kids in public schools under DeVos. They cheered her on for 20 years. It was wholly predictable she’d screw kids in public schools. Too little, too late.
LikeLiked by 1 person
DFERS openly expose themselves when they join with Broad and other charter school opportunists to lament a possible shift in public money from “public” charters to private school vouchers. This is so not about the kids.
LikeLike
You know what the DC debate over DeVos’ budget will consist of? A battle between the ed reform charter faction and the ed reform voucher faction.
Can public school kids get ONE person in the federal government who has some interest in the schools they actually attend? That’s too much to ask? That ONE of these debates have SOME relevance to 90% of students and parents?
How did we end up here, where we have NO representation at the federal level? Does it seem ludicrous to anyone else that our lawmakers spend 99% of their time working on schools that MAYBE 10% of kids attend? This would be the dictionary definition of “capture”, would it not?
Do you know how many LA kids attend charters? 16%. 84% of LA students and parents were totally ignored in a school board election. This is NUTS. It’s insane.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
I wonder what all the true “civil rights” believers think of the mess they have created. It started with charters, and now its vouchers for all, even if it makes no sense. Instead of providing opportunity for the poorest students, they are using public funds to subsidize affluent students. As for the most vulnerable students, they are left in a public school whose resources have been looted. The disabled, ELLs and troubled students will be left with few services and large classes after the fools form the state have allowed the coffers to be raided.
LikeLike
Correction: it’s vouchers
LikeLike
The right has adopted the jargon of civil rights and choice on many issues
Years back long after the Construction Trades had integrated the work force . Davis Bacon was attacked using civil rights as a ploy. Always can find one or two black personalities to pretend they are civil rights activists. The minimum wage for construction may have been passed because of black migration northward in the 20’s . But that dynamic had changed by the 80s .
Right to Work the perfect example of how republicans use language better. You do have a right to work for less.
Cloaked in freedom is the attack on schools. free to be free of minorities.
The Republican healthcare plan gives many the choice to die .
LikeLike
“the true “civil rights” believers”
Who believe that state sanctioned discrimination against students via the sorting and separating and ranking schemes of the standards and testing regime.
Civil rights schmivel rights. The state is prohibited from discriminating against students through race, gender, disability, and other categories. Why discriminating against a student due to his/her innate mental abilities is fine and dandy is beyond me
THE “civil rights” issue of today is that it should not be okay as it is now for the state to discriminate against students through mental capabilities/abilities which are both naturally inherent and out of the individual’s control.
LikeLike
This is not a hoax in that the original intent has always been to subsidize the private education of rich kids. Rich people have always resented that they have to pay education taxes when their children don’t go to public schools. They have tried various approaches but vouchers is the one approach that they have targeted as reaching the holy grail for them. The “spin” regarding helping poor kids or kids of color was just a smokescreen to get them off of the hook for their education tax money (by getting a government paid rebate on their private school tuitions).
LikeLike
Seems every day gets worse for this country. When I read what’s going on, all I want to do is VOMIT. I feel a knot in my stomach, my heart rate goes up, I am nervous. All I want to do is pull the covers over my head and CRY.
What is WRONG with this country? Oh forgot, WE GOT HAD by both parties. And now we have the WORST…that DUMP, the psycho illiterate man-boy.
LikeLike
To continue your last statement:
. . . with his monstrous minions doing his bidding.
LikeLike
And where are our professional organizations? SILENT.
LikeLike
Randi of the AFT made a rebuttal to Trump budget, but she offers no plan of action. https://www.facebook.com/AFTunion/videos/10154916074199160/
LikeLike
What? She didn’t get specifically mentioned for all she’s done for the children??
LikeLike
Is there a link to the original story?
LikeLike
http://www.azcentral.com/story/news/politics/arizona-education/2017/03/30/arizona-taxpayer-funded-vouchers-benefiting-students-more-affluent-areas/99707518/
LikeLike
Kind of seems like a NSS* conclusion, eh!
*NoShitSherlock
LikeLike