The students are our future. And the students give me hope.
When I hear “reformers” like DeVos and Gates and Klein and Rhee claim that our schools are “failure factories,” that they are “obsolete,” that they are a “deadend,” and that our students are woefully undereducated, I will think of the students at this typical high school in Kansas. They unmasked a fraud. They engaged in critical thinking. No one paid them to do it. They demonstrated initiative, intelligence, and persistence. They are far smarter than the “reformers” who run them and their generation down.
In Kansas, student journalists checked out the credentials of their newly hired principal. The “university” that she cited as the source of her MA and doctorate didn’t exist. They investigated further and broke the story. The new principal resigned without ever taking office.
Connor Balthazor, 17, was in the middle of study hall when he was called into a meeting with his high school newspaper adviser.
A group of reporters and editors from the student newspaper, the Booster Redux at Pittsburg High School in southeastern Kansas, had gathered to talk about Amy Robertson, who was hired as the high school’s head principal on March 6.
The student journalists had begun researching Robertson, and quickly found some discrepancies in her education credentials. For one, when they researched Corllins University, the private university where Robertson said she got her master’s and doctorate degrees years ago, the website didn’t work. They found no evidence that it was an accredited university.
“There were some things that just didn’t quite add up,” Balthazor told The Washington Post.
The students began digging into a weeks-long investigation that would result in an article published Friday questioning the legitimacy of the principal’s degrees and of her work as an education consultant.
On Tuesday night, Robertson resigned.
This is a reminder why freedom of the press is so important to our democracy.
This is really cool, and I congratulate the students who pursued this story. I hope they all plan careers in journalism.
Way to go, Kansas student journalists! You did well for yourselves and others.
Now this is what we’re talking about – investigative journalism, critical thinking, doing research, seeking the truth and fact-checking! Congrats to the students for being concerned and persistent! Best Wishes to you all!
Perhaps these enterprising young journalists could next unmask the fraud who occupies the White House.
Or the state capital in Topeka. Governor Brownback needs to be investigated. I think his brain is at home in his closet.
Great story. The Kansas City Star article (linked in the Post coverage) is interesting, too. The superintendent is quoted as saying that one of the reasons why the principal in question was hired was because, “…she is very familiar with Common Core…” Ha, ha, ha. Yeah, that figures. And, the now former principal is quoted as dismissing the kids, saying, “…their concerns are not based on facts.” Must be that alternate reality thing we keep hearing about. It’s a sign of the times.
“It’s a sign of the times.”
Indeed, it is, but perhaps the work of these exemplary young people is a sign of times to come, when people (especially young people, who are inheriting this pathology-ridden system) have sickened of all the lies, and there’s a backlash demanding facts and integrity.
Don’t worry.
The revolution is coming.
I was just thinking the same thing as I was eating breakfast a few minutes ago. I sure hope that’s the case.
The superintendent “felt” that the principal “was knowledgeable about what is going on in education today in college and career readiness (and)…Common Core.”
Consumer products replacing educational values-It’s happening across the country- thanks to Gates and, his support from both political parties.
It is also a commentary on the pitiful state of investigative journalism in an age when everyone wants his news for free. We will never have a good, free press unless we pay for it. Our generation has watched the public go from watching the press take down a president, Nixon, to creating the myth of a president, Reagan, to looking into the personal life of a president, Clinton. Downhill all the way.
Best wishes to the younger folks. You are off to a good start. I want to be like you when I grow up.
I was going to mention that Broad Academy of Supes isn’t accredited either, but apparently in 2015 it was granted accreditation by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges. Imagine my chagrin to see that, and also looked up Relay, which is accredited. I’m stunned.
Therlo,
The Broad Academy and Relay are both bull-pucky.
Add to the list, Gates-funded Frontier Set, introduced on 30 college campuses to “create new institutional delivery methods” i.e. money for the tech industry and the richest 0.1%’s personal investments, in products like, for-profit, schools-in-a-box.
Public education works. It works! It works.
Kudos to these students! We recently read that Rahm Emanuel wants students to have a college/military/career plan to receive high school diploma. Seniors could establish a business vetting credentials for school administrator applicants.
Every time I applied for a teaching job, I had to supply all my transcripts. Official transcripts were always part of the formal hiring process. I even had to track down a former colleague from a school for which I had worked over thirty years before that had closed. She was allowed to provide written confirmation that we had worked together. How does a woman get hired as principal with bogus credentials? It sounds like more administrators than this woman were incompetent.
This IS heartening news… but… at the same time a troubling sign of how understaffed local newspapers are and/or how unwilling journalists are to seek out stories that undermine the status quo.
Reblogged this on Network Schools – Wayne Gersen and commented:
This is good news… but also bad news since it illustrates how understaffed newspapers are. A free press depends on robust staffing.
Journalism teachers and school newspapers, especially high school, are at the center of civic education made real. Great work.