David Kirp, professor of public policy at Berkeley, often contributes articles to the New York Times about successful public schools and districts.
His latest is a terrific article that you will enjoy about an innovative public school district in Oklahoma.
At the Union Public Schools district in the eastern part of Tulsa, Okla., “more than a third of the students are Latino, many of them English language learners, and 70 percent receive free or reduced-price lunch. From kindergarten through high school, they get a state-of-the-art education in science, technology, engineering and math, the STEM subjects. When they’re in high school, these students will design web pages and mobile apps, as well as tackle cybersecurity and artificial intelligence projects. And STEM-for-all is only one of the eye-opening opportunities in this district of around 16,000 students.
“Betsy DeVos, book your plane ticket now.
“Ms. DeVos, the new secretary of education, dismisses public schools as too slow-moving and difficult to reform. She’s calling for the expansion of supposedly nimbler charters and vouchers that enable parents to send their children to private or parochial schools. But Union shows what can be achieved when a public school system takes the time to invest in a culture of high expectations, recruit top-flight professionals and develop ties between schools and the community….
“This individual attention has paid off, as Union has defied the demographic odds. In 2016, the district had a high school graduation rate of 89 percent — 15 percentage points more than in 2007, when the community was wealthier, and 7 percentage points higher than the national average.
“The school district also realized, as Ms. Burden put it, that “focusing entirely on academics wasn’t enough, especially for poor kids.” Beginning in 2004, Union started revamping its schools into what are generally known as community schools. These schools open early, so parents can drop off their kids on their way to work, and stay open late and during summers. They offer students the cornucopia of activities — art, music, science, sports, tutoring — that middle-class families routinely provide. They operate as neighborhood hubs, providing families with access to a health care clinic in the school or nearby; connecting parents to job-training opportunities; delivering clothing, food, furniture and bikes; and enabling teenage mothers to graduate by offering day care for their infants…
“Superintendents and school boards often lust after the quick fix. The average urban school chief lasts around three years, and there’s no shortage of shamans promising to “disrupt” the status quo.
“The truth is that school systems improve not through flash and dazzle but by linking talented teachers, a challenging curriculum and engaged students. This is Union’s not-so-secret sauce: Start out with an academically solid foundation, then look for ways to keep getting better.
“Union’s model begins with high-quality prekindergarten, which enrolls almost 80 percent of the 4-year-olds in the district. And it ends at the high school, which combines a collegiate atmosphere — lecture halls, student lounges and a cafeteria with nine food stations that dish up meals like fish tacos and pasta puttanesca — with the one-on-one attention that characterizes the district.
“Counselors work with the same students throughout high school, and because they know their students well, they can guide them through their next steps. For many, going to community college can be a leap into anonymity, and they flounder — the three-year graduation rate at Tulsa Community College, typical of most urban community colleges, is a miserable 14 percent. But Union’s college-in-high-school initiative enables students to start earning community college credits before they graduate, giving them a leg up.
“The evidence-based pregnancy-prevention program doesn’t lecture adolescents about chastity. Instead, by demonstrating that they have a real shot at success, it enables them to envision a future in which teenage pregnancy has no part….
“Under the radar, from Union City, N.J., and Montgomery County, Md., to Long Beach and Gardena, Calif., school systems with sizable numbers of students from poor families are doing great work. These ordinary districts took the time they needed to lay the groundwork for extraordinary results.
“Will Ms. DeVos and her education department appreciate the value of investing in high-quality public education and spread the word about school systems like Union? Or will the choice-and-vouchers ideology upstage the evidence?”

It is perhaps ironic that the school is named Union?
LikeLike
And the district that Kirp wrote a book about about is Union City, NJ
LikeLike
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/13/protest-persist-hope-trump-activism-anti-nuclear-movement?CMP=share_btn_tw&utm_content=buffere3681&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Protest and persist: why giving up hope is not an option
LikeLike
This matters a lot
“Counselors work with the same students throughout high school.”
In addition to getting to know each student, teachers know when and how to supply information of use to the counselor.
In my own case, two teachers and a guidance counselor enabled me to attend college.
LikeLike
Community based programs are what we should be looking to expand and promote as the results are promising. We cannot reverse students’ poverty, but also cannot ignore it. In the district and the Blue Ribbon school in which I taught, while we did not call what we did a “community based school,” outreach to the community was our focus. We had fantastic counselors, social workers, bilingual-bicultural liaisons and caring teachers that helped struggling parents connect with social services. If a family had a fire, lost a job, apartment, or a loved one, we sent someone to help them out. We met parents on their own terms, and tried to make attending a meeting or visiting the school an inviting experience. We made parents our partners. The efforts paid off when lots of our students successfully went to college or other post secondary programs.
LikeLike
As I said in an earlier post . It was a positive article . I did find it odd that he felt compelled to compare teacher wages in Tulsa Union district, to teachers wages in Scarsdale NY.
The reference was unnecessary . A teacher with a Doctorate making 50,000 in Scarsdale ,would qualify for assisted lunch if the school in a community on Forbes 10 wealthiest communities list even had one.
LikeLike
http://capitalandmain.com/mississippi-learning-moving-beyond-betsy-devos-school-choice-trap-0327
Another feel good public school story…from ITPI!
LikeLike
I am happy that some people in Mississippi are aware of the charter trap. However, the state is now on the privateers’ radar, and I hope people do their homework and avoid falling for the hype and spin. All they have to do is look at states like Michigan, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Louisiana to understand that corporations will be happy to grab their public money and stuff it in their pockets. They need to be skeptical about signing contracts with educational vandals, and the results will be disappointing. Once the privateers move in, it will be hard to get them out as they will “buy” all your local representatives. Beware!
LikeLike
I have a question. Isn’t this the district that Deborah Gist is superintendent at? Tulsa?
On Sun, Apr 2, 2017 at 2:00 PM, Diane Ravitch’s blog wrote:
> dianeravitch posted: “David Kirp, professor of public policy at Berkeley, > often contributes articles to the New York Times about successful public > schools and districts. His latest is a terrific article that you will enjoy > about an innovative public school district in Okla” >
LikeLike
I HATE STEM. I’m glad this district is doing well, but as a non-STEM subject educator, I am SICK TO DEATH of hearing about STEM.
There are many other equally important, or more important, functions of education besides STEM. And the focus on STEM has reduced the salaries and job prospects of people in STEM industries.
What happened to public schools being important for teaching and nurturing citizens to fully participate in democracy? Or learning to read and appreciate literature? Or enjoying the arts (for the arts’ sake, not because it “helps STEM”)? Or learning to appreciate and speak with other cultures? Or learning how to care for one’s body and home?
The focus on STEM is hugely destructive to all of those important aspects of public education.
Sorry to rant, but this blind devotion to STEM is driving me crazy.
LikeLike
RANT AWAY, Threatened Out West. Focus on STEM is indeed destructive.
Have to share this though some may consider it to be off topic, but I do hold the opinion that the RICH think the poor deserve to be poor.
I viewed again the Oscar winning film, Gandhi. I had to. Gandhi said:
“Poverty is the worse form of violence. – Mahatma Gandhi. TRUE!
Question: Do we have a violent government run by violent people? My reponse: YES, we do!
What also happens is that the people in charge like to PIT people against each other. This scheme has worked for eons. Don’t let governments and the billionaire boys and girls club pit us against each other.
LikeLike
The thing that concerns me about this article is that it implies resource inequities don’t matter:
“Union has accomplished all this despite operating on a miserly budget. Oklahoma has the dubious distinction of being first in the nation in cutting funds for education, three years running, and Union spends just $7,605 a year in state and local funds on each student. That’s about a third less than the national average; New York State spends three times more. Although contributions from the community modestly augment the budget, a Union teacher with two decades’ experience and a doctorate earns less than $50,000. Her counterpart in Scarsdale, N.Y., earns more than $120,000.”
Are we then supposed to believe that we don’t need to adequately and equitably fund schools? That all the innovation Kirp cites doesn’t require adequate funding?
Comparing Union, OK to Scarsdale, NY makes no sense: they are completely different labor markets with completely different wage costs. But even if Union has found a way to have some success on the cheap, it is an outlier. Adequate and equitable funding are necessary for educational success.
I don’t know if it was Kirp’s intent to contradict this basic fact, but the article came off that way to me. And I find that disturbing.
LikeLike
Jersey Jazzman,
I had the same reaction. Money doesn’t matter. Just doing the right things without adequate funding.
LikeLike
Sounds like a great school. “Start out with an academically solid foundation, then look for ways to keep getting better.” A recipe for success.
LikeLike