A nonprofit parent-led group called Fund Education Now created a fact sheet about Florida’s Corporate Tax Credit plan, which was designed to evade the state constitution’s explicit ban on using public money to fund religious or private education.
In 2006, as governor, Jeb Bush pushed through a universal voucher plan, which was subsequently ruled unconstitutional by the Florida Supreme Court.
In 2012, Jeb Bush led a campaign to amend the state constitution to remove the prohibition on spending public money on religious schools. The amendment was cleverly called the Florida Religious Freedom Amendment, on the assumption that not many people would oppose “religious freedom.” However, a majority of people figured out that it was an effort to make vouchers for religious schools legal, and the “religious freedom amendment” was defeated 55-45. Probably, had it been honestly named the Vouchers for Religious Schools Amendment, the margin would have been even larger.
Florida now has a large voucher program funded by tax credits to businesses that get large tax write-offs in return for funding vouchers. It is called the Corporate Tax Credit (CTC) program. It is administered by four groups, which collect an administrative fee of up to 5% for their services. The largest of the administrative groups is called Step Up for Students. As of 2012, Step Up had more than $300 million in its coffers at present. By 2014, it reported that it had assets of $439 million. The administrative fee is very significant on assets of this magnitude.
At the time the Fund Education Now brief was written, the voucher was worth about $4,500, far less than the cost of the private or religious schools available to the children of Jeb Bush and other elites. The participating schools are largely unsupervised and unregulated. Numerous evaluations have shown that students in voucher schools do no better on tests than students in public schools.
The reason for CTC vouchers: the assumption that voucher schools are cheaper than public schools, which is true, and save taxpayers the cost of educating children well.

So where does the tax credit come from? Fewer other employees, or deducted from the school money?
LikeLike
From the faq sheet referenced above:
What is the source of revenue for CTC Vouchers?
Corporations are encouraged to divert corporate taxes into one of four private entities called Scholarship Funding Organizations bypassing state coffers, allowing these funds to remain “private.” This is an apparent device to avoid any accusation of direct funding of private religious schools with public tax dollars.
Corporations can get the credit for 100% of their direct pay sales taxes. (Ex. Walgreens). HB 965 increased both corporate income (ATT) and insurance premium (United Health Care) to 100%. For alcoholic beverage taxpayers (Budweiser), the limit is 90%, and for oil and gas severance payers, the limit is 50%. It is unclear whether companies may claim this contribution as a charitable deduction for federal tax purposes.
LikeLike
Instead of paying taxes to the state, they put it into a huge fund for private school scholarships, and get a tax credit for taxes not paid to the state, which would have funded public schools.
LikeLike
So the reduction in state taxes is shared out proportionally between the public schools and their “lost” pupils, or is it a general reduction proportional to the general expenses of the state?
If the former then it really is a FIX.
LikeLike
I love how they never use Ohio as an example to push these reforms. We have all of them! We immediately adopt anything Jeb Bush even suggests! Charters, vouchers, cybercharters, ever-changing teacher, school, student measures- the full roster of ed reform experiments. They “flooded markets” with charter schools in this state yet we’re completely ignored.
Have to wonder why such “data dependent” people do so much picking and choosing or why DeVos never points to her home state of Michigan when promoting her national plans.
I was reading about ed reform charter growth plans and wondered if existing public schools would be mentioned at all.
“Local charter school advocates also need to engage in assertive but respectful conversations about how to manage district enrollment loss so that students in district-run public schools do not pay the price for unfettered growth.”
That’s the best ed reform can offer existing public schools. They promise students in public schools won’t “suffer” as they transition to privatized systems. They might want to let the parents and students in public schools know their schools have been designated a disfavored default system.
Is this the official policy of the DeVos/Trump US Department of Education? Good to know we’re paying 4200 federal employees to manage a transition to a privatized system. What happens to the 90% of kids in public schools while this ideological vision is realized? Does anyone advocate for them?
LikeLike
Have any of the 4200 public employees at the US Department of Education offered anything worthwhile or of value to the 90% of US kids who attend the unfashionable public sector schools?
Maybe they could offer us something. I’m having trouble coming up with a reason why any public school should work with them. What’s the benefit to kids in public schools? Testing? That’s what we get? Our schools are data collection centers ?
LikeLike
None,
Yes, all the time!
Yes, pretty minimal, eh!
Yes!
LikeLike
It is true that our public education is in dire need of Re evaluation. However there is grave danger in throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
Is this a refundable tax credit?
LikeLike
There was a flood of these “religious freedom” bills in state legislatures last year, and more are expected this year. The ACLU is gearing up to fight this. Many are designed to allow discrimination against the LGBTQ community. Here is an overview http://www.cnn.com/2016/12/16/politics/aclu-religious-freedom/
LikeLike
For what it’s worth, here are some Catholic educators (or former ones) pushing back on the voucher photo op at a Catholic school in Florida…
http://ndsmcobserver.com/2017/03/open-letter-from-ace-alumni-to-nd-ace-academies/
LikeLike
Funny thing how tax credits are good for corporations funding education but not good for individuals funding their own health insurance. Because one is funded? And one is not? How does that work? Someone, please explain this to me? I’m just a graduate of the failed public school system with a master’s degree and I just can’t figure this out. Ill try. Is the answer Corporate welfare is good, working stiff welfare is bad..
LikeLike
Arturo Rodriguez I am also a product of our failed public school system. That rhetoric is so old and boring – they seriously need to come up with another lie I mean slogan. I live in FL which is Ground Zero for Jeb’s experiments and get-rich quick scams. He is not the governor anymore but he is DEFINITELY in the driver’s seat for any and all @education” reform. Jeb and his 2 foundations (FEE & FFF) tell the FL legislators, senators & politicians what to do and what to vote in (through ALEC) with the help of his right hand person – Patricia Levesque. Its too nad our senators, legislators & politicians have their heads so far up Jeb’s a$$ that they can’t see the truth, It’s horrendous the damage that man has caused in our state which he is now expanding to other states. Fliorida tax credit program is another one of his scams. Take a look at the maps in Muckety (www.muckety.com) to see the hundreds (if not thousands) of companies, foundations, politicians, corporations, ed-tech companies, think tank and his family who are all benefiting from the MILLIONS they “donate” to the program. Take a look at “Florida School Choice Program” maps in Muckety – if you can stomach them. Such a blatant scam they are running that is making them wealthy off our kidss. Absolutely sickening and the worst part is they continue to get away with it. Our kids certainly don’t benefit one iota from Jeb’s scams, policies and programs HE puts in place but he sure does.
LikeLike