Peter Greene didn’t see the whole hearing because he was teaching. But he saw enough to know this was a play with preordained roles. A sort of political theater. Democrats stewed (although they didn’t berate Duncan for having similar ambitions). Republicans protected Mrs. Moneybags and praised her sacrifice, her willingness to mingle with us commoners.
She was smug, because she knew the hearing was unimportant.
“The closest thing the woman has to educational experience is being the political muscle behind the Detroit Experiment. The DeVos’s are perhaps the only people who are in touch with every major player in that charter revolution, and they’ve been on top of it for decades. She has served as a self-appointed official of the state of Michigan with education at the top of her portfolio. It is the one card she had to play against the “inexperienced” charge– and she totally blew it. She has learned nothing. From the destruction of a city’s school system, the gutting of educational opportunities for Detroit’s poor, she has learned nothing. She felt expert enough to call for the dissolution of Detroit Public School system, but she has learned nothing.”
True ideologues never ever learn anything. They know it all. Like Trump. She is ignorant but no one will tell her.
Best of all is her exchange with Tim Kaine, when she insists that she is in favor of accountability. Greene cites the transcript. This is the same DeVos that rewarded legislators with gifts of $1.4 million after they gutted a bill to impose accountability on charters in Michigan.
Stephen Henderson, the editor of the editorial page of the Detroit Free Press, wrote an article about Betsy DeVos and “the twilight of public education,” where he wrote:
“The DeVoses have helped private interests commandeer public money that was intended to fulfill the state’s mandate to provide compulsory education. The family started the Great Lakes Education Project, whose political action committee does the most prolific and aggressive lobbying for charter schools.
“Betsy DeVos and other family members have given more than $2 million to the PAC since 2001. GLEP has spent that money essentially buying policy outcomes that have helped Michigan’s charter industry grow while shielding it from accountability.
“This summer, the DeVos family contributed $1.45 million over two months — an astounding average of $25,000 a day — to Michigan GOP lawmakers and the state party after the Republican-led Legislature derailed a bipartisan provision that would have provided more charter school oversight in Detroit.”
Accountability? What a joke. Accountability is for public schools, not for charters or Betsy’s beloved religious schools.

Esquire Magazine: “WASHINGTON, D.C.—It was not a hearing. It was the mere burlesque of a hearing, rendered meaningless by a preposterously accelerated process that rendered all questioning perfunctory and that left all cheap evasions hanging in the air of the committee room the way cigarette smoke used to canopy the proceedings back in the day.
You would not hire a gardener through the process by which Betsy DeVos likely is going to become the Secretary of Education. A public school system wouldn’t hire her to work the cafeteria line at lunch. It was appalling. It was unnerving. It was a grotesque of how an evolved democracy should operate. It was business as usual these days and it likely isn’t going to matter a damn.”
http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/news/a52357/betsy-devos-hearing/
LikeLike
It was dismaying to see Mrs. DeVos persistently evade answering a question as to what she had learned from her experience in Michigan. I got the impression she’s not used to being challenged. I also got the impression she’s not used to being wrong. Will we ever have a Secretary of Education with humility and introspection?
LikeLike
She’s Queen of Michigan. And God loves her more than most (she’s going to Heaven for eternity; I and many others will be suffering in Hell for eternity).
LikeLike
You’re kidding of course. Who decides who gets into heaven or goes to hell? No one really knows who will go where.
LikeLike
What if God really is a pro gun right winger, who believes in free market solutions, limited government, personal responsibility, tort reform and the privatization of everything? I’m imagining Newt Gingrich with thunderbolts under each of his 8 arms. Just kidding, I hope.
LikeLike
She’s a Calvinist –a nasty, mutant brand of pseudo-Christianity that’s leached into many American evangelical sects. It is totally divorced from the actual message of Christ. I hear Calvinism in the mean and self-righteous remarks of many of my ostentatiously “Christian” students. When I characterize Jesus as caring about the poor and weak, they seem dumbfounded. They’ve never heard that from their creepy, pandering Ayn Randian ministers. They hear the opposite: that the poor and weak are losers who deserve our contempt.
LikeLike
That’s a good description of DeVos. … a nasty mutant …
LikeLike
I’m not religious, but if Heaven and Hell actually exist and folks like Betsy and her brother Erik Prince are going to Heaven, I sincerely hope I am going to Hell because there a a high likelihood that God has switched the signs.
LikeLike
I think she wants to so weaken public schools, and so strengthen religious schools, that in many communities even non-evangelicals will be forced into attending evangelical schools (budgets bolstered by billionaires’ donations). There they will receive Christianist indoctrination and Common Core skills-building –the fig leaf that will enable them to say they’re adhering to the same standards as public schools. The only well-funded schools in town may be the evangelical ones. The public schools will hang on only as a repository for the hard-to-educate.
LikeLike
Why do I sometimes think that the Littlefingers gang, that includes Betsy DeVos, is like a drooling wolf pack, snarling, and closing in for the kill and the rest of us are the target, fresh meet?
LikeLike
I am not sure it has not happened by accident—I do not think the republicans are smart enough to display genius in the selection of education commissioner—but they have somebody so clueless, so unqualified, so downright disgusting that none of the gutless democrats will ever dare to do the necessary work of criticizing Obama for his choice of Bill Gates to damage public education.
They can nominate her, and some of her idiocy will be challenged enough to stop the vouchers from funding religious schools, but the direction Gates and Duncan were pulling things will be sped up, as they mouth off (like that ignorant Morning know it all Joe) about the horrible “teachers union monopoly” on public education…. thrilling that important part of the nation which believes using more than 30 characters for tweets is an irresponsible waste of time.
LikeLike
From the article:
“This is one of the big problems with zealots and True Believers– they do not learn and grow because they already Know The Truth, so no new learning is necessary.
DeVos is ignorant– and she will stay that way.”
And any teacher worth his/her salt knows that there is not one single good, decent, even average teacher who isn’t constantly learning. Teachers are learners first and foremost.
Anything less is, well, shall we say “A BetsyD”.
LikeLike
I don’t have cable so I couldn’t watch C-Span either. Did anyone confront DeVos on her intentions of spreading God’s Kingdom in public schools and making churches replace neighborhood schools as the anchors of communities?
I think the reason for this aim is not just religious, but also political. Communities inundated with charters have no more neighborhood schools, school PTAs and democratically elected school boards. Taking neighborhood schools out of the equation forces people into segregated, like-minded groups living in echo chambers. It’s an effective way of robbing people of a place in their communities where diverse people can come together, organize, find common ground, collaborate and collectively address their concerns, including protesting adverse political policies.
LikeLike
thoughtful words. thank you.
LikeLike
Exactly right “homelesseducator”. The aim has been an explicit strategy to destroy the alive and kicking democracy of neighborhood schools and elected school boards. And if the strategist can make some New Market Tax Credit Cash on the side, then so be it.
LikeLike