Politico reports on the new chair of the House Education and Workforce Committee:
FOXX IN THE HOUSE: Virginia Foxx wants to dismantle the Education Department and erase Barack Obama’s education legacy – and she’s poised to become one of the Hill’s power players with the authority to do that. The 73-year-old GOP lawmaker and former community college president is poised to assume the leadership of the House Education and the Workforce Committee, and she wants to veer far away from what she regards as Obama’s wrongheaded approach. “I’m going to push to diminish the role of the federal government in everything it’s in that isn’t in the Constitution,” Foxx said in an interview in her district in North Carolina. “That’s education, health care. All the things that the federal government does that it should not be doing. I’m happy to diminish its role.”
– Foxx’s small-government views are rooted in the Blue Ridge Mountains in a slice of Appalachia where she grew up without power and running water and began working as a weaver to help support her family at age 12 – experiences that convinced her it’s an individual’s hard work, and not federal programs, that lead to success. She is a strong supporter of school choice as President-elect Donald Trump pushes his $20 billion school choice plan emphasizing vouchers. Foxx would love to dismantle the federal Education Department, but is realistic enough to acknowledge that that is probably unlikely in the near term. “I definitely don’t think the Department of Education has any business doing all the things that it’s doing,” she said, “but I don’t think you do it overnight. I think you have to devolve it over time.”
– Foxx remembers a time when community members like her father went “into the wilds” to gather plants to sell in New York to make ends meet. Her district is more prosperous now because of tourism, but it’s still deeply conservative with an occasional Confederate flag flying in the wind. As she walked down the main street of West Jefferson, N.C., one recent day to line up for the annual Christmas parade, she greeted many people by name who cheerfully congratulated her – and the president-elect – on Election Day wins.
Politico also reports that Arne Duncan will join Bill Bennett and Rod Paige at Jeb Bush’s education reform conference, where they will no doubt agree on the progress they have made in promoting charters and school choice and testing.

As a teacher in NYC, I hope that Foxx will end the finger pointing at teachers and address the low socio economic issues associated with poor student performance. In addition, address the policies related to English language learners, that expect students to take a standardized exam after 1 year in the system. We would be better served if our focus was on improving access to books for these students and providing curriculum that is beneficial to students. Stop letting textbook companies drive instruction.
LikeLike
The Daily Kos is the Fox News for Liberals. I use them as a clipping service.
http://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/11/22/1602901/-Kids-in-Michigan-have-no-right-to-be-educated-in-state-s-schools?detail=email&link_id=17&can_id=83b9da2e1b3f913c45a5994d93d18556&source=email-cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment&email_referrer=cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment&email_subject=cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment
http://theconversation.com/what-cyber-charter-schools-are-and-why-their-growth-should-worry-us-68471?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Latest%20from%20The%20Conversation%20for%20November%2030%202016%20-%206199&utm_content=Latest%20from%20The%20Conversation%20for%20November%2030%202016%20-%206199+CID_27bea8ed8b87c67da040be63cd323379&utm_source=campaign_monitor_us&utm_term=What%20cyber%20charter%20schools%20are%20and%20why%20their%20growth%20should%20worry%20us
LikeLike
Not sure what you mean ‘Fox news for liberals’, as I associate Fox news analysis w/ spreading memes & outright false innuendo. The 2 articles you clipped seemed fairly informative & more-or-less balanced. However I do find Daily Kos an ‘echo chamber’, & not particularly useful as such.
LikeLike
I disagree–I think the Kos sold out during the Democratic primaries (actually, during). Since they continue to ask for money from we, the people (& probably didn’t get much), I’m convinced they took money from some more affluent sources, if you know what I mean. Lots of Hillary, Hillary, Hillary.
&–no matter how many times I’d tried to unsubscribe–their e-mails continue to glut my Inbox.
I simply delete all their messages, as I receive far more valuable, progressive, action-oriented groups’ e-mails.
Disappearance of the Kos wouldn’t sadden me in the least.
LikeLike
http://theconversation.com/what-cyber-charter-schools-are-and-why-their-growth-should-worry-us-68471?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Latest%20from%20The%20Conversation%20for%20November%2030%202016%20-%206199&utm_content=Latest%20from%20The%20Conversation%20for%20November%2030%202016%20-%206199+CID_27bea8ed8b87c67da040be63cd323379&utm_source=campaign_monitor_us&utm_term=What%20cyber%20charter%20schools%20are%20and%20why%20their%20growth%20should%20worry%20us
http://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/11/22/1602901/-Kids-in-Michigan-have-no-right-to-be-educated-in-state-s-schools?detail=email&link_id=17&can_id=83b9da2e1b3f913c45a5994d93d18556&source=email-cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment&email_referrer=cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment&email_subject=cnns-brooke-baldwin-brought-to-tears-when-guest-uses-n-word-in-quoting-trumps-appointment
LikeLike
Virginia Foxx is a far right wing troglodyte who often puts her foot in her mouth. From 2009: Judy Shepard doesn’t think Rep. Virginia Foxx, R-N.C., was sincere when she apologized for calling the 1998 murder of Shepard’s son, Matthew, “a hoax.” [snip] During a debate in the House of Representatives Wednesday, Foxx said that the death of Matthew Shepard shouldn’t be used to justify a hate crimes bill because it wasn’t a hate crime. Foxx said Shepard was killed during a robbery.
http://www.nbcnews.com/id/30505428/
LikeLike
She should really go back to where she came from and see about getting some running water and shelter and stop trying to change an institution that has made america great. I just love these stories of these bizarre people who claim they came from no where had no running water bla bla bla and now she knows about school choice?? How bout making mud castles in the sand more like what she may know about
LikeLike
I concur, how does school choice vs pubsch compute for Appalachia? Probably a bit further down the list after food, water, shelter. To me (v-à-v her upbringing as justification for govt spending priorities), she sounds like an on-steroids version of the usual ‘I… by my bootstraps, so can they’ meme, where speaker trumpets own achievement out of contexts such as family support, economic era, native language, or even am I an outlier.
LikeLike
The Democratic legislature of West Virginia, the heart of Appalachia, rejected charter schools, as a “two class system”.
LikeLike
Linda, that is great news!
Shall I call charters a “two-class system” or a “dual school system”? I tend to prefer the latter because it reflects segregation pre-1954. But I am open to ideas.
LikeLike
Diane: my suggestion is to use “class” too. It strikes at the heart of the whole thing.
LikeLike
Linda,
I googled, and it appears that the quote and the action in West Virginia was in 2015. Democrats in the state senate killed the charter school bill, but soon after, Republicans in the state senate revived it. I can’t find out what happened this year. If anyone on the blog lives in W Va, please let me know: did the legislature pass a charter law?
LikeLike
Two years ago, when reauthorization of the No Child Left Behind was under consideration, federal overreach became the rallying cry from critics of overtesting and the Common Core State Standards to haters of all things Obama. Sensing a dangerous argument, I wrote an article for the Washington Post entitled,
“U.S. education policy: Federal overreach or reaching for the wrong things?” (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2015/01/13/u-s-education-policy-federal-overreach-or-reaching-for-the/?utm_term=.3f90775ffdce) The resultant bipartisan consensus, ESSA, greatly diminished federal authority in education. A victory? Not so fast. The widespread attack on federal authority may have provided some intellectual and propagandistic grease on the road to more charter schools, more vouchers, and more segregation, and more inequality. Now, with the principle of a federal role to ensure equitable education eroded and privatization-loving Trump about to assume the presidency public education itself is threatened.
We careful what you wish for!
LikeLike
Arthur,
We (BE) careful what you wish for!
I agree.
Republicans control 33 governorships and 32 state legislatures. The opportunities for serious mischief cannot be overlooked.
For example, the “flexibility” in ESSA has been steered by many of the same billionaire foundations that became the policy wonks for Obama.
Several months ago in Ohio, surveys and regional meetings were set up, as if intended to demonstrate “grass roots support” for specific flexibilities in ESSA. The meetings were actually financed and staged by an operative “repesenting” the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation in Ohio. Citizens were duped participate is a survey and discussion groups that prevented questioning of the assumptions and the pre-determined “specifics” for discussion.
The latest poitical pitches for educational reform are not just about “choice” but full throttled free-marketeering rebranded as “innovation.”
Digital Promise and Bellwether are pushing the importance of venture capital and state/local subsidies for edupreneurs who develop “new forms of governance” for education. In this narrative about education, truly “innovative” states and cities rid themselves of public oversight of education dollars, including taxes earmarked for public education. Student failure on standardized tests is actually valued as signal that the local environment is likely to be open to innovative practices (a large basket includes choice, charters, vouchers, TFA, digital anything, venture capital and non-profit investments in innovation, and so on. There is a very large role for bnillionaire philanthropies in this effort. See http://bellwethereducation.org/publication/us-education-innovation-index-prototype-and-report
Meanwhile, the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) is at work supporting non-disclosure of philanthropic activities.
New ALEC model legislation would prevent any publication of IRS 990 forms, effectively stopping any investigative reporting on one of the largest tax-supported “sectors” of the economy and who is getting those benefits.
Here are the key points of the model legislation from ALEC: Begin quote
Section 1. Notwithstanding any other law, any entity with a charitable tax exemption under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code (or any successor provision of federal tax law) shall not be a political committee and shall not be required to file any reports set forth in this chapter.
Section 2. Notwithstanding any other law, this state and any agency or political subdivision of this state shall not require any organization organized under Section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code (or any successor provisions of federal tax law) to file with this state or any agency or political subdivision of this state an unredacted version of the 501(c) entity’s Internal Revenue Schedule B Form (Form 990 or 990-EZ), any successor federal tax form, or any other document that includes the names or addresses of the 501(c) entity’s donors or contributors.
This section shall not be interpreted as (a) superseding any reports required to be filed by political committees if a 501(c) entity (other than a 501(c)(3) entity) otherwise meets the definition of a political committee, or (b) otherwise precluding any lawful warrant for information issued by a court of competent jurisdiction.
(A) The documents, forms, and reports described in this section are not subject to public disclosure under this state’s public records laws. End Quote but there is more.
See the rest at
https://www.alec.org/model-policy/resolution-in-support-of-nonprofit-donor-privacy/
LikeLike
forgot to spell check…sorry.
LikeLike
A case can be made that Republicans have at least 35 governorships. The governors of R.I. and N.Y. may be DINO’s.
LikeLike
Linda,
Add to RI and NY the state of CT, where Gov. Malloy works for the hedge funders and pushes their agenda of privatization
LikeLike
Idiots are in charge.
LikeLike
If federal intervention in education is reduced, then I say “Hooray!”. Where in the US Constitution is the federal government empowered to dictate public education policy????
Ronald Reagan promised to eliminate the Dept of Education. He did not. Donald Trump has made a similar promise. I cannot imagine this promise being kept, any more than Reagan’s promise.
Education can and should be a local (municipal/state) affair. The Feds have no business and no constitutional authorization to get involved in education.
If hammering against federal involvement in education, will pave the way to school choice (vouchers/charters), then fine.
LikeLike
If education is left to states and localities, no one will have vouchers or charters. The only place they exist is where the DeVos family or some other billionaire have given campaign contributions to buy legislators’ votes. Whenever the public votes, they reject vouchers and charters. Not ONCE have voters in a state referendum abandoned public schools for charters or vouchers. Take a look at the most recent charter votes in Massachusetts and Georgia. Take a look at every state referendum on vouchers, such as the DeVos sponsored effort in Michigan in 2000, which was defeated by 69-31%.
LikeLike
Where did you arrive at this prediction? Many states and municipalities have brought in voucher/choice programs (Ex: Milwaukee, Cleveland, WashDC, Indiana).
States and municipalities can and will bring in choice programs.
When it comes to referenda, the record is mixed. Mass rejected an expansion of their charter program in the recent election.
If the people are satisfied with their public education program, and do not wish to give themselves choice, then fine.
Referenda are pure democracy.
LikeLike
Cema,
None of the voucher programs you cite–Milwaukee, Indiana, Cleveland, DC–are the result of a popular vote. All were imposed by the legislature. Vouchers have never won a popular vote.
Cema, you are abusing my blog by posting repeatedly. Henceforth, no more than one comment a day.
LikeLike
cema, try article one, section 8: The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;
To provide for the general welfare: that would be publicly funded education, public schools.
LikeLike
I have read the US Constitution front to back. I do not find the word “education” anywhere. I do not find any specific authority for the US federal government to become involved in education anywhere.
For the first 150+ years of our republic, the feds stayed out of education policy, and left it to the states and municipalities.
LikeLike
Fordham’s study, by Dr. Figlio of Northwestern, showed Ohio vouchers are a failure. BTW, don’t believe the paper’s foreword. The “finding” about the benefit of school competition wasn’t in the research.
LikeLike
Ditto, Yvonne. That said, “erase Obama’s education legacy”–& WHAT “legacy” would that be? Appointing 2 of the most G-d-awful Ed. Secretaries in history? Praising & pushing charter schools (& proclaiming “Charter School” week during “Educators’ Week?”)? Talking out of both sides of his mealy-mouth (“too much testing,” “schools must be accountable–need testing”)? Sending his children to private school while allowing the forcing of harmful policies, teaching-to-the-test-Common-Core curriculum shoved down the throats of “other people’s children?”Ignoring hundreds & hundreds of letters, e-mails, etc., sending out rubber-stamped, aide-written replies? ESSA, w/its Goldman-Sachs “Pay for Success?”
&, of course, I could go on & on, but every reader of this blog has heard/seen it all.
Thanks, Obama & cronies.
LikeLike
^^^^THIS^^^^
LikeLike
In the article, Virginia Foxx says: “I’m going to push to diminish the role of the federal government in everything it’s in that isn’t in the Constitution,” Foxx said in an interview in her district in North Carolina. “That’s education, health care. All the things that the federal government does that it should not be doing. I’m happy to diminish its role.”
Well, here’s what the Constitution says in its preamble: “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”
Besides the “promote the general Welfare” idea, there’s “secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity,” not to mention Justice and securing domestic Tranquility, and then common defense.
Though I don’t think “providing for the common defense means to build a wall on the southern border; I do have trouble translating those comprehensive ideas into something like this: “provide protection (including imposing regulations on businesses), education, and health care only for those who can pay for it themselves,” or: “Deprive those of a certain color and background, or those without resources, of an education.” Now THAT will keep the “Blessings of Liberty” going over the generations, don’t you think?
I wonder what Foxx thinks that part of the Constitution means?
LikeLike
I forgot to mention again: I”In order to Form a more Perfect Union”?
LikeLike
“Foxx’s small-government views are rooted in the Blue Ridge Mountains in a slice of Appalachia where she grew up without power and running water and began working as a weaver to help support her family at age 12 – experiences that convinced her it’s an individual’s hard work” ,
Time to knock her lights out literally . The one thing that was not in the constitution was the kite string and the key thing, that Old Ben Franklyn fiddled with. .
So lets get rid of the TVA and turn out the lights leaving her in the dark with Trump.
https://www.tva.com/About-TVA/TVA-in-North-Carolina
LikeLike
great suggestion, Joel.
LikeLike
Virginia Foxx didn’t win in Watauga County where she was a college professor at Appalachian State University. She was well known for having an affair with the Chair of her department and for getting caught shoplifting in a local store, but was never charged.
LikeLike
Why am i not surprised . just like the deplorables I know .
LikeLike
Beware those who want to justify things with the constitution. Political spin involves looking to the constitution if it helps your point, but ignoring it if it is painful for you. The use of the constitution is sort of like the use of the Bible: folks get an idea they do not like something, and then go plowing through the document to get some philosophical backup.
That said, the department of education has not done me a lo of good in my classroom. Mostly, it has been the source for paperwork and unfunded mandates. I see 160 kids a day in my classroom. No level of government seems to care. I am teaching kids that are homeless. No level of government cares about that either. All I get is evaluation rubrics.
LikeLike
“Beware those who want to justify things with the constitution.”
Say what???
What other document should we refer to when justifying whether something is either constitutional or not, or whether something adheres to the principles inherent in said document.
And NO, looking to and using the constitution for legal justification is not the same as doing so with a roughly 2,000 year old compilation of Eastern Mediterranean desert tribal myths.
LikeLike
My point is that deciding what you want and then looking in documents for justification has it backwards. The general idea of the document in interaction with realities you perceive yourself should lead you to your beliefs.
LikeLike
This is all to heavy for me. I am a title one pre k teacher and a veteran and my future is……..
LikeLike
Wanda,
Join the Network for Public Education. We fight for you and your profession and your students.
LikeLike
“This is all to heavy for me.”
Well, then it seems to me that you need to be doing a lot of reading and research on public education as being a teacher means being a learner, especially of the “heavy” stuff.
What does being a veteran have to do with anything?
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
Foxx’s threat to Title 1 funding should have every Title 1 district in the country acting like their execution is imminent. Waiting until the last minute would be suicide. Reallocation of Title 1 funding endangers tens of thousands of careers and the most vulnerable of our children. Spec ed teachers, support services, remediation and literacy programs would all go on the chopping block. Further downstream, as remaining funds are prioritized, non-mandated programs (art, music, band, theater, chorus, etc.) are threatened as well as extracurriculars.
What do I hear from state and nat unions?
LikeLike