Rachel Levy–blogger, teacher, graduate student, parent in Virginia–offers sound advice about what the election means for education and how concerned education voters can respond to it.
Here is a sampling.
Pay attention to high-quality research (and I would add, pay attention to who pays for the research).
Read writers from different perspectives, including those who don’t share your views.
Support investigative journalism, which is badly needed and in need of supportive readers.
She writes:
“3. …Trump supports the current traditional Republican agenda, that is privatization, school “choice,” and the complete elimination of education as a public good. In my opinion, those are not good policies–they are not good for public education but they also are not good for our society. Public schools are flawed and as an institution have been tools of segregation and oppression but they are our best model for sustaining a pluralistic democracy. Public schools are where kids (hopefully) from all kinds of backgrounds and families come together and navigate the world. Privatization and “choice” will end that. Keep in mind that privatization and school “choice” are part of what we’ve been contending with for a long time, including from the Obama administration, though most centrist Democrats do draw the line at vouchers.
“And education is a matter that is largely left to states and localities. Trump has indicated that he would leave education to the states and localities to a even greater extent than ESSA does. However, at the same time, he has said things such as that he wants to abolish Common Core, which is a state matter. He has no record of governing (he has never held office), has no demonstrated expertise or knowledge of policy, is unpredictable, is, and is especially interested in amassing power. Education does not appear to be much on his radar screen. So some of what happens will depend upon his education-related appointments, but otherwise, who knows how much he will leave education to states and localities and how much he will want to control himself? Who knows what he will do?
Recommendation #3: If you are not already, now is the time to get engaged in your local and state governance. That is the only thing that is left. Learn all about your local and state governing bodies, including your school boards. Learn about the issues and policies. Get informed. Talk with your fellow community members about the issues and policies. Comment publicly on what your local and state governing bodies are doing and what you as a citizen, taxpayer, and constituent want them to do. Cherish those public democratic institutions and work to preserve them and keep them healthy. Work to get people from diverse backgrounds and different groups elected and appointed to such bodies. Serve in those bodies yourself. Contribute and be a participant. I can’t stress this enough.
“I have long said that local and state governance is the most important and this is more true than ever. Neo-liberals have demonstrated disdain for institutions and matters of local and state governance. Obama’s principal Secretary of Education Arne Duncan thought school boards were dysfunctional and a nuisance. Do not follow this example. Set a new one. When you fail to engage with your local and state institutions, you leave a void for others or nobody to fill. Local and state political leaders are obligated to serve their constituents and they need to be held accountable. We have to make them serve the public, ALL members of the public.
“4. Going back to federal education, while I stated that much of what Trump has said about education aligns with current initiatives in education generally, there will be a large, devastating difference from the Obama administration in terms of the focus of the Department of Education. Trump may work to eliminate the Department of Education, he may completely redirect the way federal funds for education are used (Title I, for example, and Pell Grants). Civil rights components and integration initiatives will be gutted. So much of the work that has been done towards establishing even just a fragile understanding of white supremacy and just a small start to countering and dismantling it will likely be lost. This will have devastating effects.
“Recommendation #4: Get involved and be present in your community’s schools, in your children’s schools. Advocate for diverse school staffs and diverse curricula. Tell your local educators that you know that they can’t control what kids learn at home, but that once in school, you expect everyone be treated with respect and dignity and to be kept safe. If you hear something or see something, say something. Right now, there are many kids in schools (including many traditional public schools) who are just trying to survive. Read this –it’s alarming but you must read it. It’s always been this way on some level, especially for Muslim, black, Latino, LGBT, and immigrant students and students with disabilities, but now it’s even worse and female and all other non-Christian students are also in more danger. The country will have a president, unless the electors of electoral college step up to the plate, who is a white nationalist sexual predator and whose behavior would violate the code of conduct in many of our children’s schools and warrant suspension if not expulsion, not to mention arrest and conviction outside of school. Our schools will be charged with enforcing codes of conduct to keep students safe from sexual assault, bullying, harassment, and attacks. Many are being bullied, intimidated, provoked, and in some cases attacked. They need our support and protection.”
http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/education/303815-loosely-regulated-charter-schools-pose-fiscal-risk
And
http://www.dallasnews.com/news/education/2016/11/01/parents-say-kids-mistreated-one-dallas-biggest-charter-schools
Life is an oxymoronic experience.
It’s a helluva lot more puzzling than jumbo shrimp or baggy tights or a dull shine. That’s amusing stuff. But putting up word-walls on any anti-Common Core site is not so amusing. It’s disturbing.
Isn’t discussion the stuff of real education? Or is there a new paradigm that insists that certain discussions are better than other discussions? Did I miss the Orwell memo?
That is the very worst display at very best moment. And that is why we are our own worst enemy.
There has never been a brighter time for the Common Core resistance than right this minute. There is now an unexpected window of opportunity for those able to get over the political shock.
Though the opposition to Common Core been both fierce and fervent, the results have been disturbingly dismal.
That truth is a hard swallow.
Common Core is becoming cemented in place. Our tactics are like shiny objects … and that’s about it. Defense is the favored strategy … and we react like predictable bobbleheads.
We have stale, unsurprising, and uninspiring strategies that are neither potent nor feared. We are, in the kindest terms, disjointed. Inchoate. Even spasmodic.
We are mighty only because we insist we are.
We are hopelessly fractured into dozens of very unconnected fiefdoms of opposition. Some are dominated by free thinking and others are citadels of egoism. Some seem consumed with a single issue or two, and others are in need of focus. But we all share an undeniable and powerful passion for children … and the innocence that is theirs by right.
But until this resistance comes together under some banner of unity… and with a renewed commitment to children … this reform is doomed to wheel-spinning and concocted fame.
The opportunity presented by this dramatic changing of the guard is ours for the taking. And to cop an expression from our nation’s past … (and pretzel it a bit for this moment) … we’d better all hang together, or we shall all fail separately.
And that means that our children will share in our miserable defeat. And they are not as shock absorbent as we are.
Perhaps our success is to be found in our nation’s own rich history.
This moment demands a grand confab of local giants in this resistance. Those energetic figures who command small militias of defiance. Those charismatic doyens who have lengthy experience and essential connections with other power figures. Why shouldn’t we expect them to all band together?
This is not the moment for the more famous figures in this reform. This is the hour for the grassroots talent. And there is plenty. We all know them by name or by website. Right?
But the thriller questions are these …
Who’s going to step forward and stitch themselves to a cause greater than their ego or their admiring constituency?
Who will help rejuvenate this resistance?
Who can glue us together and make us more mighty?
And who will be the grounded leaders who ever asks … “How are the children?”
So … oxymoronically speaking … who will turn us from doubting believers into a sure bet?
There’s no time to waste. Any takers?
Denis Ian
“Pay attention to high-quality research (and I would add, pay attention to who pays for the research).”
Paid (off) researchers rarely conduct “high quality research”.
What a lesson for the DNC elites! Rather than blame others…they should blame themselves. I know I do. I hope others will as well. Time for some serious soul-searching and introspection.