- Breaking news: today’s WSJ reports that the National Enquirer bought exclusive rights to a story from a model about her affair with Donald Trump–while he was married to Melania–and never published the story. The publisher is a close friend of Trump.
Election 2016
Tabloid owner American Media agreed to pay $150,000 for story from 1998 Playmate of the Year, but hasn’t published her account
The company that owns the National Enquirer, a backer of Donald Trump, agreed to pay $150,000 to a former Playboy centerfold model for her story of an affair a decade ago with the Republican presidential nominee, but then didn’t publish it, according to documents reviewed by The Wall Street Journal and people familiar with the matter.
The tabloid-newspaper publisher reached an agreement in early August with Karen McDougal, the 1998 Playmate of the Year. American Media Inc., which owns the Enquirer, hasn’t published anything about what she has told friends was a consensual romantic relationship she had with Mr. Trump in 2006. At the time, Mr. Trump was married to his current wife, Melania.
Quashing stories that way is known in the tabloid world as “catch and kill.”
In a written statement, the company said it wasn’t buying Ms. McDougal’s story for $150,000, but rather two years’ worth of her fitness columns and magazine covers as well as exclusive life rights to any relationship she has had with a then-married man. “AMI has not paid people to kill damaging stories about Mr. Trump,” the statement said.
Hope Hicks, a Trump campaign spokeswoman, said of the agreement with Ms. McDougal: “We have no knowledge of any of this.” She said that Ms. McDougal’s claim of an affair with Mr. Trump was “totally untrue.”
Ms. McDougal expected her story about Mr. Trump to be published, people familiar with the matter said. American Media didn’t intend to run it, said another person familiar with the matter. Ms. McDougal didn’t return calls for comment.
Mr. Trump and American Media Chairman and Chief Executive Officer David J. Pecker are longtime friends. Since last year, the Enquirer has supported Mr. Trump’s presidential bid, endorsing him and publishing negative articles about some of his opponents.
In a written statement, Mr. Pecker said that it is no secret that he and Mr. Trump are friends and that he greatly admires him. However, he said, the Enquirer under his management “set the agenda” on Mr. Trump’s affair with Marla Maples when he was married to his first wife. “That in itself speaks volumes about our commitment to investigative reporting,” he said.
A contract reviewed by the Journal gave American Media exclusive rights to Ms. McDougal’s story forever, but didn’t obligate the company to publish it and allowed the company to transfer those rights. It barred her from telling her story elsewhere. The company said it also would give her monthly columns to write and would put her on magazine covers.
AMI said in a written statement the company was pleased to hire Ms. McDougal as a columnist.
The tabloid publisher didn’t publish Ms. McDougal’s story of the alleged extramarital affair even after Mr. Trump’s alleged relationships with and comments about women became a campaign issue. In October, the Washington Post published a videotape made by “Access Hollywood” of Mr. Trump, in which he spoke of groping women. Several women subsequently said publicly that he had made unwanted sexual advances.
Mr. Trump has denied their accounts and apologized for his remarks on the tape, calling them locker-room banter.
Ms. McDougal, who continued modeling after appearing in Playboy, told several of her friends she had a relationship for about 10 months with Mr. Trump, beginning in 2006 and lasting into 2007, according to people familiar with her account. Another friend told the Journal that Ms. McDougal’s relationship with Mr. Trump lasted about a year.
A friend of Ms. McDougal’s recalled attending the Miss Universe pageant at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles as a guest of Mr. Trump in 2006. Mr. Trump’s limousine picked up Ms. McDougal and her at Ms. McDougal’s Beverly Hills home, and the two women sat in the front row with Mr. Trump and music producers Quincy Jones and David Foster. Mr. Trump escorted them home, the friend said.
Messages left with representatives for Messrs. Jones and Foster weren’t immediately returned.
In July, Ms. McDougal was in talks with producers at ABC News to tell her story, but she ultimately agreed to the deal with AMI, guided by her lawyer Keith Davidson, according to two people familiar with the discussions.
“I did indeed represent Ms. McDougal and currently represent Ms. McDougal in her negotiations with American Media Inc. to provide services to them,” Mr. Davidson said.
Mr. Davidson also represented Stephanie Clifford, a former adult-film star whose professional name is Stormy Daniels and who was in discussions with ABC’s “Good Morning America” in recent months to publicly disclose what she said was a past relationship with Mr. Trump, according to people familiar with the talks. Ms. Clifford cut off contact with the network without telling her story. She didn’t respond to requests for comment.
An ABC spokesperson declined to comment on Ms. McDougal or Ms. Clifford.
The Trump spokeswoman, Ms. Hicks, said it was “absolutely, unequivocally” untrue that Ms. Clifford had a relationship with Mr. Trump.
Mr. Davidson’s work for Ms. McDougal was in connection with “claims against Donald Trump and or assisting client in negotiating a confidentiality agreement and/or life rights related to interactions with Donald Trump and/or negotiating assignment of exclusive press opportunities regarding same,” according to a copy of Mr. Davidson’s agreement to represent her, which was reviewed by the Journal.
The agreement between Ms. McDougal and AMI doesn’t mention Mr. Trump by name, but gives the publisher the rights to “any romantic, personal and/or physical relationship McDougal has ever had with any then-married man.” The document says AMI is entitled to damages of at least $150,000 if she discloses her story elsewhere on social media or gives interviews about it.
Ms. McDougal hasn’t appeared in or written for any AMI publications since signing the agreement, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Mr. Trump’s relationship with Mr. Pecker, the chairman of American Media, is well-documented. In the 1990s, when Mr. Pecker was president and chief executive of Hachette Filipacchi Magazines, the publisher put out “Trump Style,” a custom quarterly magazine distributed to guests at Trump properties.
As the presidential race ramped up last year, the Enquirer published a series of columns by Mr. Trump. One began, “I am the only one who can make America great again!” Another was headlined, “Donald Trump: The Man Behind the Legend!”

Inquiring Minds … Don’t Ask …
LikeLike
We all have the evangelical vote wrong. They see Donald as a polygamist fundamentalist Mormon and are will to forgive him his trespasses
LikeLike
I don’t think so, since Mormons tend to HATE Trump. As do many evangelicals.
LikeLike
Exactly, Threatened. Isn’t that why (“Mormons hate Trump”) you have a 3rd party candidate running in Utah (sorry, forgot his name) & he is expected to win there?
LikeLike
Sadly, not so much now. Evan McMullin is now trailing he who must not be named. A lot of Mormons are being snookered into voting for party over morality. Makes me sick.
LikeLike
Party over morality – interesting. I know democrats who are against abortion, but still vote for Clinton. Is that the same? I know democrats who are against lying, but still vote for Clinton. Is that the same?
“If you are a Republican but are not voting for Trump because of some skewed moral view or principle and Hillary gets elected, what happens to this country is on your shoulders. You and people like you are directly responsible for what we get as Supreme Court justices.”
That’s what I was told when I made it clear I could not vote for Trump. I wonder if there is a democratic version of such a statement.
LikeLike
While this story should get out to the media, it will probably roll off the deplorables’ backs like water off a duck’s back. I hope the Christian right will find this story offensive and withdraw their support for this scoundrel, although there are so many offensive words and deeds already in the mix that have not seemed to bother them.
LikeLike
The Evangelicals don’t care. They don’t care about Trump’s morals or ethics or integrity. They care only that he will stop abortions.
LikeLike
The evangelicals say it is about abortions but, that’s just a cover. They’re misogynists and bigots, who want a white patriarchy. The women involved in the movement, want to “be sweet”, because they like authoritarian decision making, that excludes them.
LikeLike
This story about Melania Trump just broke. She worked in the US illegally before she obtained her H-1B visa. She had a visitor’s visa and was eligible to look for work, but not to actually work. https://thinkprogress.org/melania-trump-model-visa-problems-48ece6795adf#.qbysu1kmw
LikeLike
Donald Trump should build a wall between the US and Slovenia to keep out illegal undocumented workers like Melania.
LikeLike
Melania should build a wall around herself to keep Trump out.
LikeLike
Come on, really? I guess you have forgotten about some of obama’s appointees? Having illegal immigrants working for them as nannies and house keepers and such?
The best thing Obama did for the IRS was appoint people who finally paid up on their outstanding taxes!
Maybe Obama should have an appointment for Trump; might make him pay his taxes, too.
LikeLike
I’m afraid it’s a rather old story …
LikeLike
Going for new lows hourly now. Let s/he whose candidate is without tabloid-like sin cast the first stone. And, it seems, every other stone.
You know why this election is particularly despicable? Because the very people who cringe at the disgusting sleaze of their opponents (or past opponents) are wallowing in the self-same tactics and claiming the moral high ground, while continuing to go publicly insane over any evidence that their own hero(ine) is deeply corrupt. FDR would have been thrown out of office if sexual improprieties (not to mention deceiving the American people about his physical condition) were sensible grounds to do so. Let’s not even start discussing Jack Kennedy. But what about Eleanor Roosevelt? Shouldn’t she have been condemned for her extra-curricular relationship(s)? Where was the Inquirer and the rest of the sleaze rags in WW II and the Cold War? Sadly, they focused on Hollywood. What a service would have been done for the nation and planet had they only outed FDR back in, say, 1932. And how we didn’t hang Bill Clinton in the public square by his heels for his “immorality” and mendacity about same eludes me. Forget his shameful mandatory sentencing and welfare reform: it’s the blue dress that matters, right?
I wish I could feign surprise a bit better. I didn’t care in the ’90s who Bill Clinton had sex with or not. I don’t care now who Hillary or Donald have sex with or not. Or did. Or didn’t. If you honestly need to get worked up about that sort of stuff (selectively, of course: your own choice’s sex life is above-board or no one’s business, and how sexist to even mention it!) in order to actively support HRC or work against Trump enthusiastically.
And as I write, I just got an anti-Trump ad I saw before that said: 1) nothing whatsoever about Hillary Clinton or why she’d be a good POTUS; 2) said nothing whatsoever about Donald Trump’s proposed policies, foreign or domestic; and 3) was a non-stop Inquirer story. Do I think any or all of it is false? Doesn’t matter. I won’t vote for him for political reasons. Will it make me want to vote for Hillary Clinton? No, and also for political reasons. There are a lot of people rolling in the muck, seemingly gleefully, and only serving to highlight my 1970 epiphany about means and ends. You are how you play.
LikeLike
MPG,
Trump has policies?
LikeLike
No, he has things with his name on them made in the intellectual sweatshops of the GOP. Trump says lots of words, but the actual policy details may be found in the 2016 GOP platform, once you dig through the ideological boilerplate. His supporters are voting for a party that is against overturning Citizens United among other things they are against and want ended, all of which they blindly think they are getting fixed with Trump. Buyers remorse will be massive unless the spin continues under a Trump presidency where supporters will either be told the things they know to be bad are good (black is white) or that it’s the other teams fault that the Trumpologdites aren’t getting what they want.
LikeLike
To MPG:
Would you be rather to roll in the muck, seemingly gleefully OR to work in mud without food? = to live UNPLEASANTLY in America in the past 30 years isn’t it better to live WITH FEAR in Syria, Iran and Egypt? Please read history and watch documentary film in order to think about fascism in history of WW II in German or in war of Japan vs. China. Back2basic
LikeLike
Even if Trump loses, and we can only hope and pray he will, I fear that there are scenarios that could come into play which will divide our country even further and could cause our government to be even less functional.
My view: Trump is a catastrophe for us and for the rest of the world as our country is vital to what happens world wide. The “news” media which gave him so very much free press in the beginning, it was extremely beneficial to their bottom line, have facilitated the rise of a demagogue so much like Hitler that it is or should be terrifying.
The fate of the planet, our political future could be in jeopardy.
My view:If Hillary wins AND we back the Democratic agenda she “says” she will follow and we ALL follow the lead of Bernie and Elizabeth Warren have we any real hope for our children and grandchildren.
LikeLike
I think this is what Elizabeth Warren meant when she agreed with Trump’s contention that the game is rigged, in HIS favor.
LikeLike
Had I published an article like this with Hillary as a head liner, what would your reaction have been??
This close to the election…
You really don’t understand the goose – gander concept…
LikeLike
How many times is Melania going to rise to the call and answer, “That’s not the man I know”?
LikeLike
It is not surprising to see this with Trump.
In my opinion, we are all getting a great lesson on a high-functioning narcissistic sociopath (or at least a person with a severe Narcissistic Personality Disorder).
I have done extensive research on this topic, and have had two psych doctors weigh in favorably on this position on the comments of my post. You can read it here. https://twoifbycharmwordpress.wordpress.com/ .
With these people, there is always mayhem and upheaval once they integrate themselves into a group, and there will be wreckage in their wake.
If Trump loses, the narcissistic injury will turn him into a “raging bull.” Narcissists and sociopaths do not possess the mental hardwiring to process EVER being wrong, EVER being less than others, or EVER being apologitic. If they ever admit to being wrong or apologizing, it will be for strategic and/or manipulative reasons. Don’t expect him to go away.
Thank you. B. Ashley
LikeLike
Thanks, B. Ashley,
I think you nailed him.
My guess is that you described all the famous dictators in history.
I saw Donald Trump just went to Minnesota, a strongly Democratic state, to warn them about the Somalis in their midst.
LikeLiked by 1 person