Howard Blume reports in the Los Angeles Times that the Los Angeles school board is considering closing three Gulen charter schools. The schools are part of the Magnolia Science Academy network of 10 schools.
The problem is that the schools rely heavily on a Turkish teachers brought in on temporary work visas.
The three charters now under review have five-year operating agreements that are expiring, and the L.A. Unified School District must either approve or deny their renewal applications. The official word, with no accompanying explanation, reached their campuses by email Tuesday afternoon: School district staff will recommend denial.
The Board of Education is expected to vote next Tuesday on the recommendations for Magnolia Science Academy 1 in Reseda, Magnolia Science Academy 2 in Van Nuys and Magnolia Science Academy 3 in Carson.
Magnolia’s schools have attracted increased attention in the wake of a failed coup in Turkey in July. The government of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has accused Turkish cleric Muhammed Fethullah Gulen of masterminding the revolt. Erdogan claims American charter schools with Turkish ties supported — and even helped fund — Gulen’s alleged activities.
L.A. Unified has not yet released its rationale for recommending that the schools’ renewal requests be denied. But sources inside and outside the district make it clear that one major issue is Magnolia’s foreign workers, most of whom came in to teach.
The school group applied to bring in 138 teachers from abroad, almost all from Turkey, and 97 eventually worked for Magnolia. Thirty-seven still do. As required by law, Magnolia covered the visa-related costs, which it estimated at about $3,000 per employee, and chose to pay for the visas of spouses and children.
L.A. Unified estimated the total cost of that effort at about $929,000, according to Magnolia Chief Executive Caprice Young, the former L.A. school board president who took over Magnolia in 2015.
Young said she ended the practice, though she has brought in a Chinese citizen to teach Chinese.
L.A. school board president Steve Zimmer, however, says Magnolia’s past actions remain a problem. Magnolia never indicated it intended to import teachers en masse, Zimmer said, when before the Board of Education for approval.
“The role of an authorizer includes making sure that a charter follows the instructional and business practices outlined in its petition,” said Zimmer, who declined to discuss the district’s internal report.
The significance of any alleged ties to Gulen is a matter of intense debate. The cleric, who lives in self-imposed exile in Pennsylvania, has denied involvement in the coup. And Turkish-associated charter groups, including Magnolia, have denied financial or management ties with each other or with him.
Magnolia’s Turkish employees agreed to be interviewed only on condition of anonymity, out of fear that family members back home could be targeted in a wide-ranging crackdown on dissidents and suspected Gulen followers. Magnolia governing board member Umit Yapanel recently stepped forward as an admirer of Gulen, he said, to emphasize the peaceful intentions of like-minded people.
“In discussing whether the schools should be renewed, L.A. Unified officials will bring up the spending of public education funds on the visas, the employment of foreign nationals over American workers and the failure to disclose the hiring strategy, said district sources who were not authorized to speak on the record. The work visas, known by the designation H-1B, are supposed to be used only when no qualified American job seekers can be found.”
Like other Gulen schools, the Magnolia chain denies any ties to the Turkish Gulen movement yet is heavily staffed by Turkish teachers. Gulen schools typically have Turkish board members and in other states have been investigated for steering contracts to Turkish contractors and vendors.

Re the Gulen movement, read Dexter Filkins’s long article “The Thirty-Year Coup” in the Oct 17 New Yorker. — Edd Doerr
LikeLike
Thank Edd…the New Yorker article is most informative.
LikeLike
H1bs are the equivalent of indentured servitude for the scab workers imported into America, and unemployment for hard working Americans, mostly over forty, who are replaced. Or in the Gulen case, a way to bring in unqualified teachers from Turkey and circumvent regular immigration laws. Trouble is, both Republicans and Democrats support H1bs, including Hillary.
LikeLiked by 1 person
a succinctly necessary explanation
LikeLike
Here in Alachua County, Florida two Gulen schools closed due to poor achievement scores. We found they had the lowest average salaries, below the district beginning teacher salaries, in the district. They had very high lease payments made to their privately owned facilities.
LikeLike
GULEN Charter Schools = BAD. Gulen is a FRAUD.
LikeLike
I think more accurate information (the big picture) is always valuable.
The authorized maximum H1-B visas per year is 85,000. Out of which 20,000 is set aside for those individuals who enter American Universities and obtain at least a Masters degree. A vast majority of these visas are granted to the software sector and financial sector. Most of them work for industry giants such as Microsoft, Google, Qualcomm, Yahoo, and Federal Government entities such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, etc.
The visa duration is 3 years with one extension of another 3 years allowed. One is not permitted to switch jobs. During the H1-B visa, a person may apply and obtain a permanent resident status. Therefore there can be a maximum of 510,000 H1-B visa holders in this country at a given time. This represents about 8% of the tech workforce in this country. How many of H1-B visa holders transfer to permanent resident status by the end of six years is unknown, but they do take up slots reserved for immigrants using our existing immigration law.
One requirement to hire a H1-B visa holder is to get approval from the US Labor Department showing a lack of qualified American workers in that area.
These visas are so coveted that when a new years quota becomes available on April 1st, all available visas for the year are grabbed by qualified individuals in a matter of days.
I would be interested in knowing how Magnolia charter schools proved to the Department of labor that teachers were in short supply and got approval to obtain Turkish teachers.
Statements such as indentured servitude, scab workers etc are not defensible. No immigration laws were circumvented. H1-B is a part of our immigration law.
LikeLike
Raj,
Are you aware of a documented teacher shortage in LA? The charter acknowledges paying nearly $1 million for visas.
LikeLike
LAUSD one of the largest school districts was able fill all vacancies. I don’t see the shortage. Was it manufactured and what did Magnolia charter schools do to prove to the Department of labor that they had a shortage?
LikeLike
Just FYI, I wrote a reply to Raj and the server said I’d already posted the comment, and wouldn’t let me try again. I was unable to copy for pasting. I think it was an hour ago.
Somebody tell Bill Gates to stop screwing with the web!
LikeLike
Left coast teacher: I had the same experience. My comments in reply to Raj disappeared but then after a bit of time all the comments magically appeared. Weird.
LikeLike
Joe,
The answer to comments not appearing is usually that I am offline.
Some comments, for unknown reasons, are held in moderation waiting for my approval. Any comment with 2 or more links is automatically put into moderation. That means I must personally approve them. If I am at the movies or sleeping, they sit in moderation.
.
LikeLike
LeftCoastTeacher: same thing happened to me and even with this comment!!!! 2nd attempt. What’s up?
LikeLike
Raj,
After the election, we can get into where precisely in Los Angeles, whether and why shortages exist, the duplicity behind the HB-1 law, who created it, when, how, why, and how easily charter scams can use it to circumvent hiring qualified citizens to teach citizenship. In the meantime, Trump is a jerk, so is Gulen, and
!!! only hiring fully qualified U.S. citizens to teach in our country is acceptable to people who care about education and country.
LikeLike
The LAUSD Inspector General was asked at a board meeting if he had found a connection between the Magnolia schools and the Gulen movement. His answer was “YES”. But, that does not mean that there was a basis to deny the renewal of a Magnolia school. It’s simply not part of the charter law.
The good news is that the recent full length documentary “Killing Ed” is being shown at theaters all over the country and in film festivals. It is a scathing report on the background and shady operations of Gulen affiliated charter schools all over the country, not just in California. There are FBI investigations ongoing into these schools in Indiana, Illinois and Ohio. Texas is also carrying on their own investigation. Too bad the public has to wait so long for resolution while more of our public tax dollars are being diverted to these charters.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fetullah Gulen has been indicted for treason in Turkey, and is accused of fomenting their recent revolution. They demand the US return him to his native land. Yet, despite a few weeks when media focused on him, once again the Imam remains secreted in his Poconos fortress. His power in the US and around the world still seems impenetrable. He has managed to win the protection of some American Billionaires and some of our legislators, and evidently of now three administrations (both Dem and Rep) since 1999.
It would be telling if indeed the FBI and state/local audit investigations into his schools, including the Magnolia schools in LA, were to actually cause them be shut down. Caprice Young who now runs his LA schools was head of CCSA and has made a fortune by protecting and advancing charter schools. She is protected by Eli Broad and his co-conspirators to charterize over half of LAUSD. Now, with the advent of Broad’s “Great Public Schools Now” we see the collusion with the LAUSD BoE and with the Supt of Schools. Deasy’s goal as Broad’s puppet is now coming to fruition.
Terrible tale of how the insiders can, and have, overcome the public’s and taxpayer’s input to keep our public schools public, and not use our public funds to support privatization for investment opportunities..
Even as El Camino HS is being investigated, the BoE folded and is paying the charter teachers pensions totaling over $30 Million as the district struggles to recover being deeply in the RED due to Deasy’s sham decisions wherein he wasted public funds of over $650 Million with obsolete iPads and other tech failures, lawsuit settlements, and his own vast misuse of public funds for traveling around the world to bizarre meetings, staying at the best hotels, and eating at the best restaurants. . Disgraceful. He should be indicted for all the shenanigans he perpetrated…and now the new Supt Michelle King, carries on his agenda by lauding HER charter schools.
LikeLike
Raj, why are employers opting for H1-B visa workers when there are plenty of qualified American tech workers? For pity’s sake, the American workers have to train the very H1-B worker who will replace them.
LikeLike
Joe,
I just stated the facts about H1-B visas. It is wise to know to know the overall picture. I never said anything about shortages.
The employers are not opting for H1-B visa holders. There is no dat to prove that. It is just in the blogosphere. All the private sector wants is some one who can do the job and produce results.
A a matter of fact data shows that there was no shortage of teachers in LAUSD. It also known that a few California school districts have used incentives of signing bonuses of up to $7000 to attract and fill vacant positions successfully. But there may be teacher shortages in the charter school sector, because they do not pay well or the working conditions are poor.
The tech shortage story is complex. People can not even agree what is a tech job. I worked in the Tech field and I know we had difficulty in finding qualified engineers. Internet search shows tech jobs range from 6 million to 10 million.
The story is similar to “Global warming”. You will be able to find many stories that global warming is real and dire consequences are imminent. This is supported by a vast majority of scientists of which I am proud to one. But you can also find published reports that global warming is a hoax.
Now here is my opinion. I would rather hire a competent H1-B visa holder than an incompetent one just because he is an American. All I want is to get the job done. That is just me. That is how the private sector works.
In public sector if one does not do the job, keep him/her and simply hire another one to do the actual work and pass the cost on to the unsuspecting public. This is where I depart from the opinions of many of the bloggers here.
LikeLike
Testing…
LikeLike
From the atlantic, @Raj: “A compelling body of research is now available, from many leading academic researchers and from respected research organizations such as the National Bureau of Economic Research, the RAND Corporation, and the Urban Institute. No one has been able to find any evidence indicating current widespread labor market shortages or hiring difficulties in science and engineering occupations that require bachelors degrees or higher, although some are forecasting high growth in occupations that require post-high school training but not a bachelors degree. All have concluded that U.S. higher education produces far more science and engineering graduates annually than there are S&E job openings—
“http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/03/the-myth-of-the-science-and-engineering-shortage/284359/
LikeLike
There is no tech shortage. From bloomberg: Along with temporary deportation relief for millions, President Obama’s executive action will increase the number of U.S. college graduates from abroad who can temporarily be hired by U.S. corporations. That hasn’t satisfied tech companies and trade groups, which contend more green cards or guest worker visas are needed to keep tech industries growing because of a shortage of qualified American workers. But scholars say there’s a problem with that argument: The tech worker shortage doesn’t actually exist.
“There’s no evidence of any way, shape, or form that there’s a shortage in the conventional sense,” says Hal Salzman, a professor of planning and public policy at Rutgers University. “They may not be able to find them at the price they want. But I’m not sure that qualifies as a shortage, any more than my not being able to find a half-priced TV.”
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-11-24/the-tech-worker-shortage-doesnt-really-exist
LikeLike
The Strange Case of Caprice Young & the Imam Fetullah Gulen
– – – – – – – – – – – – –
Caprice Young is the CEO of the Magnolia Schools charter chain here in California, which are allegedly under the control of an Islamic cleric in exile in Pennsylvania, the Imam Fetulleh Gulen.
In that position, Young has always steadfastly denied any connection of the Magnolia Charter schools, or of herself to the either the Islamic political-religious Gulen Movement operating in Turkey and in the United States, or any ties to to its Islamic cleric leader, the Imam Fetullah Gulen living in the U.S. in exile, or to any internal matters in the country of Turkey.
————————–
“I haven’t seen a connection (between the Magnolia schools and Gulen / Turkey),” she (Caprice Young) said.
————————–
For that quote, go here:
http://laschoolreport.com/new-chief-of-troubled-magnolia-ive-done-this-work-before/
… or for another Gulen-connection-denying quote form Ms. Young:
————————–
“Absolutely, categorically, Magnolia has nothing to do with the Gulen movement as an institution,” said Caprice Young, Magnolia’s CEO and superintendent.
————————–
For that quote, go here:
http://www.ocregister.com/articles/schools-707539-magnolia-school.html
However, as a non-Turkish American, Caprice Young sure does tweet a lot — and make a lot of public comments to the press — about about the minutiae of internal Turkish politics, even to the point of drawing a contrast between Magnolia Charter “staff” and those Turkish politicians currently in power whom Young views as not “value(ing) human rights.”
————————–
“The president of Turkey is busy shooting down Russian planes and smuggling arms to Syria. Doesn’t he have better things to do?” Young asked rhetorically. “The members of my staff are folks who value human rights.”
————————–
For that quote, go here:
http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/mar/04/magnolia-charter-schools-caprice-young/
Hmmm … a Khomeini-like Imam-in-exile (who controls over 100 U.S. charter schools, including the Magnolia schools managed by Ms. Young) , the Imam Fetullah Gulen, is attempting a coup in the country of Turkey, with the Imam Gulen’s ultimate goal to impose a brutal Islamic theocracy and dictatorship like the one imposed on neighboring Iran in 1979 … yet Ms. Young prattles on about her and her Magnolia Charter Schools’ staff’s commitment to “human rights,” in a condemnation of human rights violations of those serving in the democratically-elected government that the Imam Gulen — again, Caprice Young’s alleged boss — is now on the verge of overthrowing.
What-ever.
From the comments section on the above article:
http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/mar/04/magnolia-charter-schools-caprice-young/
—————-
Tina Andres ·
CSUF, National University, UCI
“For someone who vehemently denies that her schools are even associated at all with Gulen, Young sure has quite a lot to say about Turkey.
“I suppose it is just a coincidence that the Magnolia schools hire Turkish teachers on VISAs. She literally denied any connected to Gulen charter schools in a school board meeting in CA, saying that she doesn’t know anything about it.
“The jig is up, Caprice. These schools have also charged for more for their building rents to the state of Oklahoma than they have paid.
“This (proliferation of Gulen-controlled charter schools) is a scam and it is being perpetrated in many, many states under multiple names but the connection to Gulen is very clear and easy to find.”
—————-
I agree with Ms. Andres.
… as well as with this other commenter:
——————-
Thaker Bil ·
Tucson, Arizona
“(Ms. Young stated): ‘The members of my staff are folks who value human rights.’
“Obviously Caprice Young does not keep up on current events. She is a sock puppet for the Gulen-controlled schools and repeats back like a parrot what the Imam Gulen tells her what to say. This is hardly something people that value human rights do when Gulenites ran the parallel state in Turkey. Officials under the control of the Gulen Movement regularly arrest journalists and suppresses freedom of speech
————————
Also, as a non-Muslim, Young also sure does tweet and write a lot about “Islamophobia” towards certain Turkish people currently living in the United States. (Tweets BELOW)
Given Ms. Young’s repeated and steadfast denials of any connection between the Magnolia schools and the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen, or with Islam, or with the country of Turkey, this tweeting of hers — and the subjects of these tweets — seems a very odd avocation on her part.
Once again, Ms. Young claims no ties or interest in the Gulen movement that originates in Turkey, but out of the 200 or so countries on Earth, she spends so much time tweeting and talking about Turkey, and Islam … more perhaps than she does about her own country of origin, or her own religious persuasion, whatever that may be …
Weird.
Here are some examples: (NOTE the picture of two Turkish politicians in this first tweet of Ms. Young’s:
https://twitter.com/capriceyoung/status/730831337804857344?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
————————-
Caprice Young:
“Freedom of religion is a core value in the US https://t.co/8y7BGp2qwL @magnoliascience @laschoolreport @edsourc…
————————-
Here’s more of Caprice tweeting away about Turkey and Islam:
https://twitter.com/capriceyoung/status/730822933325570048?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
————————-
CAPRICE YOUNG:
“Please oppose Islamophobia in all its forms.”
https://t.co/NElGJ4gKEO via @ocweekly”
————————————–
Oh, and here’s Ms. Young tweeting just yesterday, tweeting about internal Turkish politics, and its effects on Turkish people in the United States. (She’s referencing and condemning a U.S. Congressman from Texas who is calling for an investigation of the Gulen charter school conspiracy.)
https://twitter.com/capriceyoung/status/753593138762035200?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
——————–
CAPRICE YOUNG:
“Texas rep does bidding of Turkish Pres = US students suffer.”
State Rep Investigates Top Charters
https://trib.it/29zlq08 via @TexasTribune
——————–
Wait, Caprice.
I thought those charter schools of yours had no ties to Turkey of Gulen. Why would any such investigation be any bother to you at all or cause your “students” to “suffer” … as the claims of your schools’ connections to Turkey and the Imam Gulen are all a hoax perpetrated against your chain of charter schools? You sure are quite upset about something that you otherwise claim is a total canard.
LikeLike
Way more damaging to the charter school industry — and to California’s Magnolia chain of charter schools in particular — is the Twitter account and activity of Caprice Young, the CEO of the Magnolia chain of charter schools . For those who are not aware, Magnolia is the chain of charter schools here in California that has been accused of being under the control of the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen and his Gulenist forces, an accusation that Magnolia’s current CEO Caprice Young has denied “categorically” on numerous occasions.
Time and again, Ms. Young has vehemently denied that there was any such Magnolia connection to Gulen or to any part of the Gulenist Islamic cult in Turkey, the group which executed a failed coup to overthrow Turkey’s democratically elected government this past July 15 – 16.
However, you can see (BELOW) that something interesting was going on when the news of the Gulenist coup broke, (again, the goal of this coup being the overthrow of the sitting Prime Minister Erdogan).
At first, it appeared to be a successful coup.
Then, at THAT moment in time — Friday night, July 15 — Caprice Young re-tweeted Gulen ally & U.S. Congressman Brad Sherman’s tweets where Sherman was hoping for the Gulenist coup’s success … AGAIN, ON THE VERY FRIDAY NIGHT (July 15, 2016) THE COUP BEGAN.
Again, Sherman tweeted that was his hoping that the Gulenist coup would be successful, and the the anti-Gulen prime minister Erdogan was deposed, in favor of Gulen forces embedded in the Turkish military.
Go to Ms. Young’s Twitter page here …
… then scroll back back to “July 15” to see the following re-tweets Young made of Congressman Brad Sherman’s cheering on of the coup:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
… and then, the next morning of July 16, after the coup fell apart, and Erdogan re-assumed control of the country, sore loser Sherman whined in this tweet (which Young also re-tweeted) about the coup falling apart, and wished shame upon Erdogan and anyone else who would used the now-failed coup “to white wash Ergodan”:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
The first one of Sherman’s tweets got this snarky response:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
V @vpandey16 Jul 15
@BradSherman @zaidbenjamin
because real democracy starts by kicking out democratically elected leaders????
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
So here you have Ms. Young apparently monitoring and cheering on the Gulenist coup ON THE VERY FRIDAY NIGHT (July 15, 2016) WHEN IT WAS HAPPENING, and at the very moment when it looked like the coup engineered by the Gulenists looked like it might succeed.
Here’s a couple questions that people can ask Ms. Young (or ask anyone) at next Tuesday’s LAUSD Board meeting when the future of the Los Angeles Gulen schools will be discussed?
What the-hell is Caprice Young, the former California Charter Schools Association (CCSA) President and current Magnolia Charter Schools CEO doing keeping track of an ongoing coup in the Middle East country of Turkey as it’s unfolding … when, at the same time, she, Magnolia, and the CCSA all deny any connection to or interest in the fate or politics of that same country, or any connection or interest in the Gulen movement of the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen, the architect of the failed coup?
Could California Charter School Association (CCSA) President Jed Wallace, Caprice young, or anyone else at the CCSA please explain or defend this Twitter activity of Ms. Young’s?
(NOTE: Magnolia Charter Schools CEO Caprice Young was the first President of the CCSA when she and others first formed it. Jed Wallace is her successor, so he’d be a good person to whom one can pose this question. As with Donald Trump’s recent troubles, it’s going to be hard for either Caprice or Jed to talk their way out of this one!)
Back to Caprice.
Hmmm … for someone who vehemently claims to have no dog in this Gulen fight, it seems kind of odd of Ms. Young to be apparently spending her Friday night (when the coup began) monitoring this coup in a Middle Eastern country — with the outcome determining the future status or survival of the Gulen movement — and re-tweeting U.S. Congressman Brad Sherman’s tweets cheering on the coup. You know… the same Gulen movement that her charter school chain has no connection whatsoever, as she “categorically, absolutely” claimed in a newspaper article.
C’mon Caprice! Don’t you got something better to do on a Friday night?
LikeLike