Jonathan Pelto wrote an illuminating and informative post about the members of the “Billionaire Boys Club,” or should I say the “Billionaire Boys and Girls Club,” since Alice Walton, Laurene Powell Jobs, Penny Pritzker, and several other women belong.
Pelto writes:
The colossal and disastrous effort to privatize public education in the United States is alive and well thanks to a plethora of billionaires who, although they’d never send their own children to a public school, have decided that individually and collectively, they know what is best for the nation’s students, parents, teachers and public schools.
From New York City to Los Angeles and Washington State to Florida, the “billionaire boys club,” as Diane Ravitch, the country’s leading public education advocate, has dubbed them, are spending hundreds of millions of dollars via campaign contributions, Dark Money expenditures and their personal foundations to “fix” what they claim are the problems plaguing the country’s public schools.
These neo-gilded age philanthropists claim that the solution is for parents, teachers and education advocates to step aside so that the billionaires and their groupies can transform public education by creating privately owned and operated – but taxpayer funded – charter schools.
In addition, they pontificate that students learn best when schools are mandated to use the ill-conceived Common Core standards so classrooms become little more than Common Core testing factories and the teaching profession is opened up to those who haven’t been burdened by lengthy college based education programs designed to provide educators with the comprehensive skill sets necessary to work with and teach the broad range of children who attend the country’s public schools.
The billionaire’s proclaim that the solution to creating successful schools is really rather simple.
They say that public schools run best when they are run like a business…
Cut through their rhetoric and the billionaires want us to believe that by introducing competition and the concept of “profit” they can turnaround any school, no matter the challenges it or its students may face….
Privatization, they argue, will lead to greater efficiencies while opening up the public purse to those who have products that they seek to sell to our children and our public schools.
John Dewey famously wrote that what the best parent wants for his child is what we should want for all children, but the billionaires have flipped that sage advice on its head. They say, “My kids need small classes, experienced teachers, and beautiful schools, but your children don’t.”
Jon Pelto has an exhaustive list of the billionaires who are out to undermine public education.
He identifies them by name, by their net worth, and by their pet causes.

Most of the problems if not all of the problems the community based, democratic, transparent and non profit public schools have is the billionaire boys/girls club.
Get rid of this club/members and most of the problems the traditional public schools face daily would go with them.
The two problems left would be proper funding that includes lower class sizes in addition to higher standards for teacher training that does not include TFA and/or high stakes tests that profit private sector corporation like Pearson that isn’t even a U.S. corporation.
LikeLike
Lloyd…how come no one ever mentions the billionaires involved with Alliance Charters, the largest chain in California????
LikeLike
You just did.
Then there was this in The Washington Post about corporate charters in California. Alliance wasn’t named but still …
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2015/03/24/california-charter-schools-vulnerable-to-fraud-report-says/
Then there is this from the Hartford Courant
Alliance Charters interfering with unionization efforts, complaint says.
http://www.courant.com/la-me-ln-union-charter-complaint-20150407-story.html
And this one in the LA Times
http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-0525-state-audit-alliance-20160525-snap-story.html
LikeLike
BTW…Alliance is the chain of schools fighting UTLA to keep their teachers from joining the union.
LikeLike
“Get rid of this club/members and most of the problems the traditional public schools face daily would go with them.”
And students would agree with you on that?
LikeLike
Rex Sinquefield has only 3 billion dollars, but he dominates Missouri as successfully as any of the billionaire boys I can think of. If he can get Catherine Hanaway elected governor, that should qualify Missouri for emergency education aid.
LikeLike
We need to add Amazon’s Jeff Bezos to the list…another billionaire for charters.
LikeLike
Perhaps they are right . May be we should just give them their way . A few conditions imposed, they pick up the entire tab , they can not profit in any way, shape or form from the reforms and parents and communities decide whether it is effective. At 650 Billion a year I doubt their would be any takers . A few million here or there that they get to deduct off their taxes is chicken droppings. Their donations to politicians influence a whole lot more than education policy. Chicken droppings was last weeks Billionaire issue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d like to see two simple columns added to Jonathan’s chart:
1) Attended public school – no charter
2) Children attend or attended public school – no charter
My guess is we could easily fill in the answers without much research but visuals are often better than words.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d like to see this added to the chart too.
LikeLike
Do you really want to highlight we live in an oligarchy?
LikeLike
It’s not just the billionaires. It’s also the successful pushing of the Reaganesque ideology of privatization, the notion that everything in private hands works better than in government hands–water, transport, housing, airports, and, of course, education. For those interested, check out
LikeLike
Sweden and Chili have both already tried the privatization experiment and it failed horribly.
LikeLike
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/features/privatization/one/
LikeLike
The billionaire’s proclaim that the solution to creating successful schools is really rather simple.
They say that public schools run best when they are run like a business…
WoW! What took so long for this epiphany to emerge? Oh, the lack of billionaires and their smarts? A recent phenomena?
LikeLike
“My kids need…your kids don’t.” It’s worse than that, because the biggest venture philanthropists want their corporations to get a significant cut from our tax dollars, that are intended for education. The “philanthropists” want to deny us, democratically elected school boards. And, they want to own the assets that our taxes buy, like school buildings and equipment
If Americans can’t protect their communities, children and taxes from the greed of Silicon Valley and the financial sector, it is absolute proof of US oligarchy.
LikeLike
The destruction of “public goods ” in order to maintain the Oligarchy, is far more significant than the pittance to be made by most of these billionaires.
LikeLike
This is the death knell of the America of Whitman,Lincoln,
Emma Lazarus, Woody Guthrie,FDR,MLK…the billionaires
want to be the masters and the rest of us willing slaves.
No fanfare for the “common” man and woman…just a conempt
for the non elite…how did we get to this place…there must be some
way out of here, said the joker to the thief.
LikeLike
As evidence, a Facebook board member recently praised the colonialist period that India suffered through. America is without the will to follow a Gandhi-like leader or, another revolution-inspiring person.
Gates-funded organizations describe schools as “human capital pipelines”. Wall Street drags down GDP, and, we allow them both to take over our schools, to further exploit us.
LikeLike
Privatization and running schools like a business is shorthand for cheap, expendable labor.
LikeLike
It is always easier said than done. But, people want to eat, they must go to the kitchen.
If we are educators, we need to educate the public = parents + students:
1) HOW TO unite in opt out movement,
2) How to gather in any public place to expose bribery, to call out all crooked business owners, to identify all corrupted politicians weekly, monthly, semi-annually, or annually,
3) How to promote a writing essay contest, or a poem that a winner will have a chance to shine in their community in the subject like education, community service, patriotic action or experience from others or from oneself.
This is the only way to strengthen a community and to groom the FUTURE regional best leader.
From this “humanity” concept, we extend to interstates. This will help people to mutually decide accurately to vote for the best leaders for country and for all states regardless of ideology, religion, and race. We are all for peace, harmony and humanity.
Please DO NOT allow business to sponsor these contests.
Our local tax fund will carry out these contests under the panel judges of all local educators.
I may be a dreamer, but I am not the only one. (From Lennon’s song “Imagine”). Back2basic
LikeLike
Of the 45 billionaires on the list, it is the tech industry moguls I fear the worst — the bizarrely eccentric Big Data miners. (Great international fiction bestseller about the tech industry cult, The Circle by Dave Eggers. You probably won’t find it on Bill Gates’ suggested reading list.) I should have cringed as I’m sure most did when the FBI chief said yesterday that his interview with Hillary Clinton revealed she was far less technically sophisticated than one would think. But I find it reassuring that perhaps the next president might, while being easily beguiled by the wealth the owners of shopping mall outlets and real estate, not be so entranced as President Obama by every assembled-by-Foxconn gadget, every app, every networking site, and every edutech product that comes along.
LikeLike
Hillary’s list of tech supporters reads like a Who’s Who of Silicon Valley. http://www.businessinsider.com/tech-ceos-endorse-hillary-clinton-2016-6
LikeLike
True, retired colleague. I guess, as Jon Awbry wrote in a post about Hillary yesterday,

Once I had Hope. Now I have Wishful Thinking.
LikeLike
I wanted to invest in mutual funds with a recent inheritance. But when I looked up the companies in which various funds invest, I was so turned off I couldn’t do it. They were all the funders and fighters for privatization.
So I thought, what if I made my own mutual fund? What if I created a way to invest only in publicly traded companies with clean records regarding public education? Sure, I probably wouldn’t be able to compete with the S&P 500, but it would be an appealing investment for anyone who cares about democracy and public education.
So then, I thought, what are the responsible, caring businesses in which I would invest? … Well, there went that idea. There are no good hearted captains of industry that I know of, nowadays. At least, there are no good elected leaders forcing businesses to be responsible. All you can do is avoid hedge funds. Looks like I am living in the wrong century.
LikeLike
Our problem isn’t a few Billionaire Boys, and they aren’t playing. Every powerful institution of the financial elite is consciously attacking the public sector, and every time you accept their word, “accountability”, you give them ownership of all our work.
“Student-Centered Accountability Systems”? Read ALEC’s list carefully. Teachers have been blindly lobbying for their legislation.
Essa puts the insatiable, data-driven heel of free-market profit mining directly on every child, as schools and teachers become its instruments of direct control. Hillary Clinton has promised us a place at the table of its corporate backers.
ALEC writes:
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the American Legislative Exchange Council recommends that states, utilizing their properly restored authority under the ESSA, consider the creation and implementation of STUDENT CENTERED ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEMS designed around the following general principles:
Timely Provision of Student-Level Data
Measure Student-Specific Progress and Restore the Focus of “High-Stakes” Testing to be on Advancing Individual Student Instruction and Growth
Develop Important Individualized Measures Beyond Sole Reliance on “High-Stakes” Tests, Including Engagement, Teacher Input and Assessments, and Satisfaction
Account for Mobility in Graduation Calculations and any other Aggregate Data Indicators
LikeLike
I forgot the link on my comment. Please post it.
https://www.alec.org/model-policy/resolution-in-support-of-student-centered-accountability-systems/
LikeLike
You guys might like this essay:
“Such frictionless and fictitious humanitarianism persists only because it expresses a deep yearning for a quasi-magical world, where technology – and today technology is indistinguishable from private capital – could step in and miraculously resolve all our problems.”
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jul/02/beware-technology-giants-claiming-compassion-for-refugees-evgeny-morozov
My eldest son works in this industry and he says this himself- that politicians believe it’s “magical”. He went to some kind of meeting in Ireland and he says it’s international, this magical thinking. He had a conversation with an Irish politician where she told him tech firms would “solve” global warming. He asked her how that would work- what program would he write to “solve” global warming. She was annoyed with him for asking. She had no idea what she was talking about.
LikeLike
Yes I did like that essay. Reform could be called school-washing. And politicians are certainly not the only ones who believe tech is magical. There are so many school administrators who do. They will buy any product and assume that if it’s not “Transformational” there’s a teacher to blame. Not that I speak from painful experience, wink wink. It is people’s belief in magic that makes Gates, Ballmer, Zuckerberg, Jobs-Powell and the rest so dangerous. Thank you, Chiara, and best wishes to your son.
LikeLike
And the worst magical thinker lives at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
LikeLike
Here are words of wisdom from Glenn Kelman, chief executive of Redfin, the online real estate site. The link is:
Be Yourself, Redfin’s Glenn Kelman Says, Even if You’re a Little Goofy
[start paragraph]
“If I haven’t found evidence that someone’s ever done anything hard in their lives,
then I just don’t believe they’re suddenly going to be able to jump into a phone booth, come out wearing a cape and learn how to be tough on this job.
I want to know about anything you’ve done that’s hard, really hard. So I tend to focus on that.”
For example:
“What you want is to have them do the work.”
So when I interview engineers, I give them a coding problem and I ask them to work through it.
When I interview a marketing person, I say, “Write a press release,” or, if you’re in P.R., “Write a pitch.”
I want to see the actual quality of their work.
In short, I think the corporate world is pretty starved for personality.
The reason you have comic strips like “Dilbert” and sitcoms like “The Office” is that people just can’t be genuine human beings in a corporate environment.
[end paragraph]
I thought that we can apply and emphasize Mr. Kelman’s wisdom in decision -making for Presidential Election in 2016. Back2basic
LikeLike
We live in an Oligarchy and this is just another illustration of that.
LikeLike
Just because we live in an oligarchy doesn’t mean we have to accept it. Did the U.S. Founding Fathers accept what King George was doing to the 13 colonies that became the United States?
LikeLike
Privatization is just another example of what happens in an Oligarchy, which is what our society has become.
LikeLike