This alarming article describes the destruction of the Highland Park, Michigan, school district.
Once a thriving community, Highland Park suffered as the automobile industry declined. Its schools declined as the community became poorer and blacker.
The Highland Park district is more than 90% black. That makes it just right for a state takeover because it does not have political power. So, get ready for the “civil rights movement of our time” to step in, take charge of the schools, and kill off the district.
Governor Rick Snyder thought he knew how to fix the ills of Highland Park: He appointed an emergency manager to set its financial house in order in 2012. The emergency manager was an accountant. He also had spent some time working for White Hat, the for-profit charter company in Ohio, which has perfected the extraction of funds from public money for private gain.
The first emergency manager was gone in a few months, and a new one was installed.
Instability and churn were the watchwords of the districts that Governor Synder took over.
In all, the Highland Park School District has had five emergency managers at the helm over the 4 1/2 years it has been under state control.
Still, Highland Park’s public school system continued to disintegrate, finally reaching the point today where it barely exists at all.
For anyone seeking a measuring stick to assess the job done by the district’s emergency managers and the for-profit charter school company hired to run Highland Park schools, the most telling statistic may be this:
At the time of the takeover, the district had 969 students. Today, that number, according to the state’s school data web site, is 311 — a drop of nearly 70 percent. Moreover, all of the students attend the district’s last remaining school, which serves both elementary and middle school students.
The state takeover was complicated:
Operating under a paradigm similar to the new system created for Detroit Public Schools, there are two public school districts operating side-by-side in Highland Park.
One is the “old” district, known as the School District of the City of Highland Park.
That district is overseen by an elected school board that has virtually no power and nothing to do with governing the education provided to the city’s children.
The “old” district exists only to pay accumulated debt.
Just how much is owed?
School board members have been asking for that number. But, according to the state of Michigan, no one — including the emergency manager put in place by Snyder to ensure the debt gets paid off — can say exactly what it really is, because legally required financial audits haven’t been filed for the past two years.
A second, “new” district was created in 2012 by Joyce Parker, the second of five EMs appointed by Snyder to control education in Highland Park. This new district, unencumbered by the debt being paid off by the “old” district, was supposed to flourish because all per-pupil state funding was, ostensibly, able to go toward education and not toward satisfying the demands of bondholders.
However, in 2014, Michigan Radio reported that the new district was already facing a deficit of about $600,000, a shortfall attributed in large part to a continued decline in enrollment.
This new district — known as the Highland Park Public School Academy System — is operated by The Leona Group, a private, for-profit charter school management company with a checkered past.
The entire district was handed over to a for-profit charter chain. No more public education. Families are fleeing. Soon there won’t be a district.
Michigan has perfected a formula for destroying an entire school district.
Just one chapter in How to Destroy a State by Reinventing It.
You won’t read about this inside the ed reform echo chamber. They redirect all negative news to glowing reports on charters in NYC and Boston. As if “Boston” has anything whatever to do with Highland Park.
President Obama does it himself. He completely ignores the charter mess in Ohio and promotes Breakthrough Schools- a charter network in Cleveland. He’s as cloistered inside the echo chamber as any of the paid lobbyists. He was still charter-cheerleading in Ohio WHILE every single Ohio media source were producing reams of investigatory articles that contradict his every word. It didn’t matter. His national narrative remained unaffected. I guess he confused Ohio with “Massachusetts”? They’re the same, right?
The neoliberal Democrats are in total denial. They are too busy selling the fantasy of charters to actually understand what is going on. They need to take an unbiased look at the academic findings, the impact on students, families and communities, the damage done to public education, and the tremendous costs. The problem is the lobbyists have totally captured their support without much evidence. They remain committed to a movement that causes more harm than good. While they keep harping on accountability for teachers, how about some accountability for politicians that sell out public education?
When Hillary Clinton travels thru Michigan, maybe someone on her staff could tell her 80% of Michigan’s charters are for-profits.
This ed reform “fact on the ground” may complicate her national narrative. Unless she chooses to completely ignore it, like President Obama and his team. That worked for 8 years. Who knows? Maybe she can pretend Michigan ed reform is the same as their idealized “national” version too.
She can ignore the charter game just like Obama ONLY if she gets a green light from the teachers’ unions and the Opt Out movement.
One of the many, many mysteries or the Michigan charter sector is the authorizers. Why is Grand Valley State University such a big authorizer for charter schools that serve minority students? It’s located in an area of Michigan that is overwhelmingly white. What possible special insight could this university have into urban areas in Michigan? Why was this university chosen to get a cut of every charter dollar?
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2013/05/grand_valley_state_university_62.html
Authorizers are the point of the spear. You can have all of these charter wolves baying at the door, but some political authority has to open it. Less blame on the charter industry more blame on those who allow the industry to flourish.
Reblogged this on Mister Journalism: "Reading, Sharing, Discussing, Learning" and commented:
This alarming article describes the destruction of the Highland Park, Michigan, school district. Once a thriving community, Highland Park suffered as the automobile industry declined. Its schools declined as the community became poorer and blacker. The Highland Park district is more than 90% black. That makes it just right for a state takeover because it does not have political power. So, get ready for the “civil rights movement of our time” to step in, take charge of the schools, and kill off the district.
Reblogged this on Crazy Normal – the Classroom Exposé.
And in every case, protesting parents, children and teachers are ignored while the autocratic, for profit, opaque, often inferior corporate charter schools continue to use the Nazi tactic that says if you lie enough, the lies will become the truth. That is how you fool enough people to stay in power. The corporate reformers, who are turning ‘reform’ into a dirty word, are using the same play book that Donald Trump is using and by now most people who use their brains to think know what book The Donald keeps by his bedside.
And history teaches us what it took to get rid of the Nazis who used the same tactics to get into power that Bill Gates, the labor union hating, poverty wage paying Walmart Walton family, Eli Broad, hedge funds, etc. are supporting with their great wealth and the power money buys.
AMEN, Lloyd. The DNC and GOP are totally corrupt. And the DNC is in total denial. It’s SIC.
Vote 3rd party. Absolutely NO $illary 4 me. Both Drumph and $illary = HUBRIS to the MAX. The fact that they are running for president is a big fat joke on us.
The charter legacy: less help for the underprivileged underclass, more cash for the uber-wealthy. Another American success story. And even the NAACP promotes this!
A series of “emergency managers” for Highland Park, appointed by Governor Rick Snyder, and the district continued to fail.
Gee, a series of “emergency managers,” also appointed by Snyder, worked so well for Flint, Michigan, and its lead-filled poisonous water.
How in the holy living he!! do Snyder and his enablers even sleep at night? {{Sigh}} 😦
Psychopaths have no trouble sleeping at night no matter what they did.
Sadly, Lloyd, that’s all too true.
so what is the answer to fix school districts?