Reactions to the mea culpa of Sue Desmond-Hellman, the CEO of the Gates Foundation, continue to roll in. Sue D-H admitted that “mistakes had been made” in the education arena and promised to listen to teachers. Many who have read the memo think that the foundation still doesn’t understand why its promotion of test-based teacher evaluation is failing or why the Common Core is meeting so much resistance.
Susan Ochshorn hopes that the Gates Foundation will listen to early childhood education professionals.
At the bottom of the totem pole of influence are early childhood teachers. None of these stewards of America’s human capital weighed in on the design of the Common Core standards. They were back-mapped, reaching new heights of absurdity, including history, economic concepts, and civics and government as foundations for two-year-olds’ emergent knowledge.
Most importantly, the standards make a mockery of early childhood’s robust evidence base. Young children learn through exploration, inquiry, hypothesis, and collaboration. Play, the primary engine of human development, has vanished from kindergarten and first-grade classrooms, replaced by worksheets, didactic learning, and increasingly narrow curricula, in keeping with standards’ focus on literacy and math. Policymakers are talking about bringing rigor and the Common Core down to four-year-olds.
If all lives have equal value, the core belief of the Gates Foundation, then our most vulnerable kids must have access to the kind of education enjoyed by those with greater resources: teaching and learning that nurtures creativity and innovation, attuned to the whole child. Too often, they’re subject to rote, passive, and joyless assimilation of knowledge. Collateral damage of your initiative—all in the name of higher test scores.
What if the Gates Foundation undertook a course correction, and put education back in the wheelhouse of educators?
Ochshorn points out that poverty is an enormous barrier to school participation and engagement. She briefly reviews the research base that establishes the harmful effects of poverty (an idea that Gates has derided in the past).
It’s hard, indeed, to be deeply engaged when you’re hungry or homeless—or traumatized by the growing number of adverse childhood experiences that plague our little ones. (As an oncologist, you have a deep understanding of physiological damage.) Moreover, it’s challenging for educators to do their job, no matter how well they’re prepared. The schools in communities of concentrated poverty are segregated institutions starved of investment, places fit for neither children nor teachers.
The results of a recent survey of teachers of the year, conducted by the Council of Chief State School Officers, are illuminating. When asked about the barriers that most affect their students’ academic success, family stress, poverty, and learning and psychological problems topped the list. Anti-poverty initiatives, early learning, and reducing barriers to learning were the teachers’ top picks for investment.
The Gates Foundation has done remarkable work across the globe. How about taking some of your formidable resources and bringing them on home to America’s children and communities?

Gates is a victim of his own class. He was born into a wealthy family that had the money to send him to an expense, exclusive private school where he sends his own children. But most wealthy individuals that never lived in poverty think those who live in poverty are lazy and without discipline. What he is doing is imposing that thinking on everyone below his class.
The super wealthy and their minions often think the only thing that stops most people from being like them is because we are all lazy and without discipline. Their thoughts run like this: “If you aren’t one of us, you have to be a loser and we will treat you like the loser you are that doesn’t deserve to have the best schools like our children attend, and we don’t want our children anywhere near the children of losers.”
In fact, we have seen this minion type thinking here in comments from the few we often call and/or think are trolls because they are often ignorant and refuse to accept any evidence that doesn’t support the agenda of the 0.1%.
And because of what Bill Gates grew up to think and believe from his limited perspective, we all suffer as The Bill attempts to restructure the world into the environment he things is best for everyone but him and his family and friends.
LikeLike
There is nothing more base than a certain loathing for the oppressed that goes to great lengths to justify their downtrodden state by pointing to their shortcomings. Not even great and lofty philosophers are entirely free of this failing.
Elias Canetti
“Words of wisdom, Lloyd, words of wisdom.”
Jack Nicholson
The Shining
LikeLiked by 1 person
“…we’re in it for the long haul,” wrote Sue D-H. The B&M Gates Floundation is going to make more websites for teachers and students to yield more data to play with. They will not stop until the temperature reaches 451 degrees and every minute of Common Class instruction in the world yields personal data.
LikeLike
RE so-called “remarkable work across the globe”
The Gates Foundation has taken the same ignorant approach in other countries as it has taken here in the US: basically not asking for and/or disregarding the input (concerns, customs, etc) of people who are most affected by their policies and imposing GF’s own ignorant “solutions” on those people.
It’s no surprise that the GF has had the same kind of dismal (and in some cases downright disastrous) results abroad as it has here at home.
With Gates Foundation, ignoring the input of the people affected by the policies is standard operating procedure.
LikeLike
I don’t want his help at all…..period.
Now let’s get to work eradicating GERM and ALEC from dictating education policy here in the USA and abroad.
LikeLike
“A Plea for Help”
Help the children
Mr. Gates
Just butt out
From all their fates
LikeLike
The Gates Foundation could begin to correct the harm it has done to education by getting entirely out of education.
LikeLike
Agreed!!
LikeLike
Mr. Gates is more interested in helping himself to public money than he is in helping children. Doubling down on his failed CCSS and “personalized learning” are two ways he plans to help himself to more public money. Most of his educational “largesse” amounts to seed money for his misguided, top down, non evidence based initiatives.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Amen. He is so obsessed with data I am still waiting for the survey of all US teachers about the impact of CC in the classroom. That would be the only data I would be interested in.
LikeLike
The Gates Foundation offers up a lot of sweet talk about listening to teachers.
The “listening” pitch is an excuse to get teachers’ emails. These provide teachers who cooperate in this deception with edited and hyped feedback designed to ensure any voices heard will be Gates-compliant.
Here is the link to one of the most recent “invitations.” It is one of many others that creates the illusion that “nobody knows teaching more than teachers.”
http://k12education.gatesfoundation.org/learning/nobody-knows-teaching-like-teachers/
There are other initiatives to extract information from teachers and tell them what they should do and think.
In December 2015, the Gates Foundation solicited application for new positions. One was “an opportunity for a multi-talented strategist and communicator who will be responsible for managing and developing programming, partnerships and campaigns to support Teacher2Teacher including face-to-face experiences, integration of social media channels and other digital platforms, identification and management of key partnerships, and ongoing analysis to ensure that all efforts are meeting the needs of teachers. This Program Officer should be a team player, an experienced project manager, and have significant experience managing and integrating cross-channel campaigns and partnerships. Experience working across multiple teams in complex environments is preferable, as is demonstrated commitment to education and the values of the Foundation. This individual will work closely with the Teacher to Teacher working group, which spans different teams at the Foundation, and will provide the expertise and creativity to fuel community growth and engagement.”
At about the same time, the Gates Foundation had a job opening for “program manager” of Teacher2Teacher. Teacher2Teacher was described as a portfolio of “Teacher2Teacher managed platforms.“ “The aim is to “grow” the portfolio through an annual marketing campaign to increase the engagement and connections among traditional and nontraditional “partners” and participants in Teacher2Teacher managed platforms. The manager will negotiate then oversee all contracts, communications, budgeting, and reporting. This position also requires monitoring the efficiency and effectiveness of all aspects of the program, internal and external. It includes a duty to work with Foundation staff on expanding the portfolio based on research and evaluation of marketing trends and other strategies to ensure the program is ‘cutting edge,’ especially in social media and digital activity.”
The Foundation spawns initiatives and markets these as if the interests of teachers are a major concern. No so, by a long shot. The Gates Foundation pretends to listen while building a cadre of teachers who will comply with the Gates Foundation efforts to remove all remnants of independent professional thinking among teachers.
http://k12education.gatesfoundation.org/teacher-supports/teacher-collaboration-leadership/teacher2teacher/
http://www.teacher2teacher.education
Gates-loyal teachers are being cultivated in ways that distract attention from the longstanding role of teacher renewal, education, and advocacy offered by professional associations of teachers in specific subjects (e.g., National Association of Teachers of English) or grade levels (e.g., The National Association for the Education of Young Children).
Here is an example of the Gates strategy of endless mission-creep.
http://teacher2teacher.education/ecet2/
LikeLike
I am sorry. I won’t even repost this. Gates has NOT done remarkable work across the globe. He’s done the same there as he’s doing here in education. In fact, Global Justice Now has asked for an investigation of his foundation. They accuse him of buying his plan in Kenya among others places;
http://www.nation.co.ke/business/-/996/3046152/-/xgrduf/-/index.html
It is time to stop asking Bill Gates to listen to teachers and correct his trajectory into a better direction. It’s time to insist he get out of the education reform business ALTOGETHER. He has proven he is not good at it. Enough is enough!
LikeLike
Nothing wrong with trying to make education as efficient as possible. School choice actually makes things less efficient by replicating administrative bureaucracy, and increasing costs for transportation. One school system is best from an economy of scale perspective, and neighborhood schools are the most efficient to get to. I’m sure there are pros and cons of other things, but if Gates are two engineers at heart, they can’t ignore those two basic realities of efficiency.
LikeLike
Gates is not an engineer. he does not think or act like one. he’s a hack. It’s very telling that he never got a degree.
I’ve worked with lots of engineers and no good engineer would ever take the ignorant approach he takes to problem solving. Even in the very beginning at Microsoft, Gates was basically little more than a marketer — of bad products. And when Gates took over as chief software designer, he nearly destroyed the company.
Other people like Paul Allen did the actual “engineering” (if you can even call it that), although not very well, since most of what they produced is not very good.
LikeLike
SomeDAM Poet,
WELL SAID!
LikeLike
Here’s another ed reform defense of Gates. In this one, we learn that “failure is a part of success”.
No one knew that before Bill Gates, apparently 🙂
They recite these commonly understood slogans as if they invented them. I think I have heard some variation of “failure is a part of success” since I was 7 years old.
Next they’ll tell the teeming masses that it’s important to “get back on the bike after you fall off”, because no one has ever heard that incredible insight before 🙂
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/peter-cunningham/failure-is-a-part-of-succ_b_10280556.html
LikeLike
Most people understand that you sometimes need to fail to ultimately succeed, but Gates would have us believe that failure IS success.
Falling off the bike is the same as riding it.
LikeLike
The problem with the “failure is part of success” meme is that Gates doesn’t seem to shoulder the costs of his failure. Those who were unfortunate enough to be the target of his largess seem to be the ones left to clean up the mess. He just takes his marbles and goes home.
LikeLike
This is how the echo chamber operates:
Former TFA , now Walton Foundation director, lectures potential TFA’s :
“Marc Sternberg (New York ’95) is K-12 Education Program Director for the Walton Family Foundation.”
These are the only people your lawmakers listen to, which is why your lawmakers sound exactly like them!
https://www.teachforamerica.org/top-stories/teach-america-take-job-and-love-it?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=ownedsocial&utm_content=sternberg&utm_campaign=mktg_twr
LikeLike
Listening to teachers is not the most effective strategy for creating material, unless one really means “sell” the teachers. Listen to experienced, research-based ideas and incorporate these into your product, Gates, and then offer well-constructed social research evaluations in your sales material.
If what I knew about teaching in my 30’s were all there were ever to be, I would have been the greatest. But guess what, we can’t predict what future research will uncover. In my thirties and forties, I thought I could run the perfect system also. Gates is not unusual. He just has the money to bet on his to him clever ideas. My idea is that he ask teachers what he can Do for them, what IDEAS they would funded. If he is serious about listening, he wouldn’t need “integration of social media channels and other digital platforms” until he had listened. Obviously, he has something in mind and it is one-tracked.
I think Gates believes his own publicity. He is a business man who lacked the curiosity to obtain a college degree and who knew one was not needed for what he intended to do. But do we know in what way he has furthered his own growth intellectually? Experienced, knowledgeable teachers were aware before he that his ideas had holes in them. How long must one put up with people running the show who are just learning the earth is not flat?
LikeLike
like funded. sorry
LikeLike
“The Gates Foundation has done remarkable work across the globe. How about taking some of your formidable resources and bringing them on home to America’s children and communities?”
Nonono. I have a three step program for the Gateses.
1) Bribe politicians into passing a law that would forbid philanthropy.
2) Bribe politicians into passing a law that would implement progressive taxing with a 90% ceiling instead of the current 35%.
3) Bribe politicians into passing a law that would mandate wealthy dudes and dudesses to spend 90% of their after tax money on gambling, drugs, private jets and yachts. (Definition of wealthy: 90% of their after tax income is enough to buy a 30ft or longer yacht)
The purpose of the first two is clear. The last one would clarify the real purpose of collecting a lot of money.
LikeLike
Agree. Adding, Gates, Broad, DFER stay the h_ll away from students.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on stopcommoncorenys and commented:
Not bloody likely. Too many $ in the eye$ of our kid$.
LikeLike