Governor Bill Haslam of Tennessee signed into law a bill that allows mental health professionals to refuse service to anyone based on their religious beliefs.
The American Counseling Association has announced that it may cancel its annual conference, now scheduled for April 2017, if the law is not repealed.
Governor Haslam will be the keynote speaker at a conference at the Harvard Graduate School of Education on May 17. Perhaps other participants will question him about this legislation. Perhaps Harvard President Drew Faust will chastise him in her introductory remarks for signing legislation that is unacceptable at Harvard or in Massachusetts or in most states. Apparently, other states have adopted similar laws, on the theory that a person with sincere religious beliefs should be legally permitted to refuse service to anyone who offends those beliefs.
Peter Greene commented on the law as permitting discrimination against any group that is different.
Greene wrote:
So Governor Bill Haslam of Tennessee today signed a law that allows mental health counselors to refuse patients based on the therapist’s religion or personal beliefs.
That means that a Christian counselor could refuse to see a Muslim, or an atheist, or a pastafarian. That means a Southern Baptist could refuse to see a Catholic. That means an anti-abortion person could refuse to treat a woman who’s had an abortion. A staunch conservative could refuse to treat someone struggling with infidelity in their marriage. A racist can refuse to see anyone who’s not white. That means a counselor could turn away a woman who’s wearing too short a skirt, or holds down a job outside the home, or who uses birth control. That means a republican therapist could refuse to treat a democrat, or vice versa– and both could refuse to treat a socialist. And of course, anybody can refuse to see an LGBT patient.
I am imagining someone who’s hit a rough patch trying to find a counselor, looking through the yellow pages for a Jewish vegan feminist republican counselor who believes in attachment parenting. Presumably some folks, like the Green Party gay pro-gun Wiccan, would just have to drive to some other state.
One of our Tennessee readers added the following comment:
I wonder what the organizers at Harvard were thinking when they asked BIll Haslam to speak at this ‘illustrious’ summit. His accomplishments in scholarship & policy initiatives are, at best, underwhelming.
Gov.Haslam is the son of TN’s billionaire Jim (“Big Jim”) Haslam family who own Pilot Oil & Flying J Truckstops. His family control of the Republican Party bought him 3 elections – one as Mayor of Knoxville & 2 terms as Gov of TN. The family’s venture philanthropy buys the silence of critics in the local press & in higher education.
The Haslam family business is under FBI investigation for multiple counts of fraud
http://www.knoxnews.com/news/local/fbi-pilot-engaged-in-fraud-haslam-knew-of-scheme-ep-358423015-355934701.html
His legacy as governor is outsourcing public education, privatizing state workers & maintenance operations, privatizing our beautiful state parks, privatizing Dept of Children’s Services, cutting capital gains taxes, cutting the inheritance tax, passing a constitutional amendment prohibiting a state income tax, assuring TN remains the state with the highest number of workers earning minimum wage or below, and no healthcare for the poor.
He gave Tennesseans Kevin Huffman, Candice McQueen, and in a Dept of Ed staffed with TFA. Arne Duncan visited TN regularly to brag on our “progress” in edu-reform.
Thanks to Haslam, Tennesseans can carry guns on campus & in schools, our state book is the bible, we have a state gun, and a new state logo, fracking on the Plateau, cabinet advisors from Americans for Prosperity, the Milton Friedman Foundation, and The Charter School Associations.

Maybe that should be Keyhole Peeker?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Peewee Herman of Harvard education conferences?
LikeLiked by 1 person
SDP,
Now that’s being awful mean to Paul Reubens.
But it reminds me of this clip. How they ever got through making that part is beyond me. I don’t think I could have from dying from laughter:
LikeLike
I must be really old fashioned. I thought that if you got paid to do a job then you did the job. Also, people must be so insecure these days about their own religious beliefs. I am an agnostic, so do I have religious beliefs?
LikeLiked by 1 person
As an agnostic you would have the right to discriminate against gnostics.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like the comment about gnostics. Very funny.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“could refuse to see an atheist who is a pastafarian.”
Where would I go?!?!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pastagardian?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not sure what a Pastagardian is but a Pastafarian worships the FSM-Flying Spaghetti Monster. One may proselytize only while in pirate garb-arrrgghh!
If you are not familiar see: http://www.venganza.org/about/ or for a more esoteric account of how FSM came about (yes it had to do with Kansas) see: The “Flying Spaghetti Monster” was first described in a satirical open letter written by Bobby Henderson in 2005 to protest the Kansas State Board of Education decision to permit teaching intelligent design as an alternative to evolution in public school science classes.[10] In that letter, Henderson satirized creationism by professing his belief that whenever a scientist carbon-dates an object, a supernatural creator that closely resembles spaghetti and meatballs is there “changing the results with His Noodly Appendage”. Henderson argued that his beliefs were just as valid as intelligent design, and called for equal time in science classrooms alongside intelligent design and evolution.[11] After Henderson published the letter on his website, the Flying Spaghetti Monster rapidly became an Internet phenomenon and a symbol of opposition to the teaching of intelligent design in public schools. (from wiki)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t like pasta . .. I stick to rice.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Gonna have to use that as a facebook post as I’ve got a number of friends and relatives who love sharing puns. Gracias
LikeLiked by 1 person
Here in Massachusetts, a woman was allowed to have her license picture taken wearing a colander on her head, as she professes to be an avowed pastafarian.
(Hoping the photo will come through)
/var/folders/hn/j1xzh16976b90xg7frzr8wbr0000gn/T/com.apple.iChat/Messages/Transfers/Lindsay-Miller-Colander-License-jpg.jpg
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry, no photo. Here’s a link, though!
LikeLike
eeerrrr: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/pastafarian-colander-license-photo_us_56498e42e4b08cda34897b27
LikeLiked by 1 person
Getting hard to find a service station with which to do business.
LikeLiked by 1 person
These anti-tolerance laws are allowing people to use religion as an excuse to discriminate. The sad part is that most of the bigotry is coming from presumed Christians. Anyone familiar with the teachings of Jesus should know that he was open minded, tolerant, kind, and he and kept company with “sinners.” Their discriminatory behavior no more represents the teachings of Christianity than terrorism represents the teaching of Islam.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Let me get this straight:
A card-carrying member of the grit and rigor crowd wants to spare the tender feelings of mental health professionals that feel uncomfortable carrying out not just their duties but fulfilling their moral responsibilities to heal the injured?
Please, someone, anyone, get some pearls for Gov. Haslam to clutch and a fainting couch for him to fall back on.
😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
What would Gov. Haslam say about a teacher with a religious or personal belief against testing refusing to administer them?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Love that, Dienne!
About as likely as school choice zealots letting parents choose whether their children should be forced to take those tests
LikeLiked by 1 person
Why don’t the feds enforce the laws already on the books? Then, the states would be less likely to rattle their biased swords. We have seen this perversion of civil rights among states allowing discrimination against a woman’s right to choose and LGBT people. For a country based on separation of church and state, using religion as a shield gets too much attention.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“. . . or personal belief against testing refusing to administer them?”
Don’t know about Haslam but that is what I told our standardized testing coordinator last year in refusing to take part in that malpractice. Fortunately for me she was a guidance counselor, already knew my thoughts about it, and quietly went about finding another teacher and didn’t inform the adminimals. Indeed at times it’s better to be lucky than good!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am filling out a medical form presently. It does not ask my religious preference. So will this be added to medical questionnaires in that state? The only time I have been asked my religious preference on a medical questionaire was when I had a hospital stay.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Why recreate the wheel? Just do what the Nazis did make us wear badges.
Yellow triangle = Jews
Brown triangle = Gypsies and Roman descent
Purple triangle = Jehovah’s Witnesses, Adventists, Baptists, Catholic
priests, and Christian leaders who ran afoul of government
Black triangle = Vagrant
Blue triangle = people who had moved to Germany from other countries (unless they were Jewish)
Red triangle = member of trade union, a Democrat, Freemason or labeled political nonconformist
Pink triangle = homosexuals, and persons suspected of rape or pedophilia
Green triangle = thieves and murderers
LikeLiked by 1 person
As a once proud graduate of HGSE, I am now embarrassed. It once was a vigorous and stimulating forum at which ideas could be tested and challenged. Now I am embarrassed, adding Haslam is an insult to HGSE traditions.
Two questions: how much money will HGSE receive albeit tainted? And where on the agenda are the experienced public school educators? Sad day.
LikeLike
Start-up cost for this display of elite incompetence came from a gift of one million dollars from a couple of graduates of Harvard. The Harvard “brand” in education is tied to money, not to the merit of ideas.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Tennessee is pretty much the ed reform state. Go back and look at how many times Arne Duncan singled out Tennessee as his favorite experiment:
“At multiple stops in Nashville Tuesday, President Barack Obama’s top education official showered Tennessee with praise for “controversial but common-sense decisions” he contends are having a profound effect on achievement.
In doing so, U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan lauded state officials for taking on what he coined a “courage gap” prevalent in public education today, pointing to reforms this state embraced despite fierce pushback.
“There’s so much this room and this state should be collectively proud of,” Duncan said during a panel discussion moderated by Tennessee Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman, an ally, at Brick Church College Prep, a Nashville middle school overseen by the state and operated by a charter school organization”
Tennessee, DC and New Orleans. Over and over and over.
http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/education/2014/05/20/us-education-secretary-arne-duncan-visits-nashville-today/9322449/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Correct. TN was one of the first 3 “winners” of Race to the Top money. Our prize package was Kevin Huffman, Eli Broad & the Milken brothers plan to scale-up edu-reforms. According to them, TN wasn’t moving fast enough:
From 2014:
http://www.milkeninstitute.org/blog/view/619
“Patricia Levesque, CEO of the Foundation for Excellence in Education, cited teacher quality as one of the ways fellow panelist – Tennessee Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman – helped lead his state to the largest growth in history on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (the “Nation’s Report Card”).
Recruiting and retaining high-caliber talent in schools – and creating ways to continually measure it – is all the more important in implementing the Common Core State Standards. The intersection of the standards and adult accountability is “where the rubber meets the road,” Huffman said. Tennessee partnered with NIET on its statewide teacher evaluation system, based on a clear set of best practices for instructional improvement.
While Tennessee is among a number of states that have become hotbeds of innovation, the reforms aren’t getting to scale fast enough.”
LikeLike
With credentials like that, I’m surprised he isn’t running for President!
LikeLike
Choke, gurgle, gurgle…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rumors around TN are that Haslam’s money & connections will buy him a Senate seat or possibly a higher appointment in DC. He & the Republican Party are marketing him as a moderate similar to Alexander & Corker.
Having never shown any backbone standing down the aggressive, regressive Tea Party general assembly, “moderate” is as empty as a dry well. He signed into law every edu-privatizaton bill drafted straight from ALEC. TN’s voter restrictions are as bad as in NC & WI. After Haslam was elected, early voting days were cut, polling sites were shuttered, voter ID restrictions allowing drivers license and a gun permit but not a student ID.
I need to make one correction in my previous post- the bible as the TN state book did not pass in the general assembly.
He does serve his purpose, however. Doing what he is told. He’s always flanked by smarter, slicker advisors who buffer him from press questioning & carefully manage his public appearances.
LikeLike
Technically speaking, I get it. But why in hell would a gay person choose to see a counselor who disagreed w their direction/choices/lifestyle? These arguments begin to get tiresome. We are not using common sense, but just fighting for the sake of fighting.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Because they would expect the counselor to act professionaly regardless of opinions?
BTW, being gay is neither a choice nor a lifestyle.
LikeLike
Yes, you would certainly hope that a counselor – especially a counselor – would act professionally. But I am Irish and if I know that a counselor I’m thinking about going to has feelings against Irish people for whatever reason (for who I am, like a gay person) I will go to somebody else. It’s that simple. If I am in that position, I need help and support – not a fight.
LikeLike
I’m not following this. How would you know whether a counselor doesn’t like Irish people? Is that something that’s listed in the Cigna directory?
LikeLike
I don’t think it’s because Harvard endorses these laws- I think it’s because ed reform is an echo chamber:
“The Volunteer State has been Duncan’s education reform darling since it first won a $500 million Race to the Top grant back in 2010”
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/campaign-k-12/2014/10/sec_duncan_talks_education_pol.html
It’s the same small group of “movement-approved” speakers, over and over and over.
If one reads on the ed reform side, one can reliably predict it down to the school level.
If they’re talking about Cleveland, for example, it will be “Breakthrough Schools” which is a charter company. There are apparently no other functioning schools in Cleveland.
LikeLike
I hope public schools insist on getting the funding for this before they go along, because they’ll be reallocating funding from something else in the real world;
“Leaders of dozens of the nation’s top businesses — from Apple and Facebook to Target, Walmart and AT&T — are calling on Congress to help provide computer science education in all K-12 schools, arguing that the United States needs far more students who are literate in the technologies that are transforming nearly every industry.”
Get the (additional) money first. Ed reformers run away when it’s time to pay for their programs. We all know this by now. What that means is that other priorities will drop off and these companies are setting the agenda for investment priorities.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/top-business-leaders-27-governors-urge-congress-to-boost-computer-science-education/2016/04/25/f161cbde-0ae7-11e6-bfa1-4efa856caf2a_story.html?linkId=23872464
LikeLike
“Harv Ed is Dead”
You know it’s dead
When Harvard ed
Has Campbell moderate
When Haslam speaks
It really wreaks
And seals the Harv Ed fate
LikeLike
I wonder if the Tea Party will now change its name to the Pee Potty to better reflect the scope of its values.
LikeLike
Don’t know about that, but word has it that the Harvard Department of Education employs very strict “Pee-er review” to decide who speaks at conferences.
LikeLike
Here is a update to the 2013 article quoted by Peter Green about the investigations of Jim Haslam
http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/2016/04/29/judge-rejects-jimmy-haslams-bid-avoid-deposition/83705432/
LikeLike