This story is incredible, astonishing, unbelievable.
In 2013, the operators of a Los Angeles charter school were convicted of misappropriating $200,000 from school funds. The school is called Ivy Academia. The founders are in jail.
Recently, the school complained that the district had failed to provide adequate quarters, as it was required to do under the Starr’s very charter-friendly law. The matter went to an arbitrator, who awarded Ivy Academica $7.2 million dollars plus legal fees of $625,000.
The Los Angeles Times reported:
“The Los Angeles Unified School District must pay $7.1 million to a San Fernando Valley charter school for failing to provide the school with rent-free classroom space, a violation of state law.
“School districts are required to share classrooms and other facilities with charter schools but, for three years starting in 2007, Ivy Academia Entrepreneurial Charter did not get enough space for its 1,100 students.
“The district’s approval of the charter required arbitration of legal disputes.
“In his written ruling, arbitrator John Zebrowski said that the district’s failure to comply with the law harmed children attending the charter during those years because it forced the school to use some money intended for educational programs to lease a building. Zebrowski said students were further harmed because the building leased by the charter was inferior to what it would have received from L.A. Unified….
“Ivy Academia spent $3 million on rent and other costs from 2007-10, but the arbitrator said L.A. Unified should be on the hook for more money because he believed the property denied to the charter had a higher value. The district must also pay the charter $650,000 in attorneys’ fees.
“Ivy was forced to cobble together multiple private facilities that were inferior and didn’t have things like playing fields, libraries, permanent science labs, and enough special education space,” Paul Minney, an attorney for the charter school, said in a statement.
“L.A. Unified acknowledged that it did not provide Ivy Academia the space it is entitled to under Proposition 39, which requires districts to offer charters facilities that are reasonably equivalent to those provided to students in traditional public schools.
“David Huff, an attorney representing the school district, said L.A. Unified simply didn’t have the space during the years that it did not comply.
“Huff also pointed to a criminal case that in April 2013 found two of Ivy Academia’s leaders guilty of misuse of public funds.
“According to prosecutors in that case, Yevgeny “Eugene” Selivanov negotiated the 10-year lease of a building for $18,390 a month but then charged the school $43,870 a month to sublease the property.
“It is the district’s theory that had we made a compliant offer of space. . . Ivy would have never accepted because it would have ended their $25,000 a month profit,” Huff said.
“But the arbitrator said the district could not prove that the charter would have rejected such an offer.”
So the charter operators were making a cool $25,000 in profit every month by over gargling the district. And the arbitrator rules that money will be subtracted from the district’s overcrowded schools, which have inadequate repairs and few arts teachers, to further enrich this school, even as its founders sit in jail.
An ally in Los Angeles wonders if the district’s case was sabotaged by a Broadie plant on the inside.
Astonishing.

Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education and commented:
WOW!
LikeLike
Thanks Diane, for featuring this ripoff of public funds in LA.
Even the Ukrainians get in on it…and of course the Turkish Gulen billionaire. I mentioned this yesterday on your Hillary post. So many crooks abound in our community that it has become de riguer for charter operators to cheat us and steal our taxpayer funds, with unabashed legal representation for which We the People pay.
Another example of American Exceptionalism. He who can steal the most is the winner and makes the rules.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Here’s another charter horror story.
How egregious must a charter school’s transgressions,
both legal and ethical, be in order to close that school?
Or in order to trigger a criminal prosecution?
Former L.A. charter school leader fined for conflict of interest
http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-charter-school-conflict-of-interest-20160411-story.html
Former L.A. charter school leader fined for conflict of interest
Here’s a story of a charter operator who …
— uses a shell real estate corporation to profit from
the usual charter school real estate scam; she uses
public funds to pay rent to a real estate company,
a company that she secretly owns… she conceals
this ownership by having her aged mother pose
as the “imposter” owner of the real;
— in what might be the wildest story of extortion
I’ve ever heard in a school setting, the charter operator
has a unique way of getting her brother, a Nigerian
citizen, U.S. citizenship;
She gives an ultimatum to one of her non-tenured
teacher: as a condition of continued employment
— Do this or else your fired) — this teacher must
fly to Nigeria, marry the charter operator’s brother,
then fly back to California with him, then live in a
sham marriage long enough to satisfy immigration
officials.
In this case, the teacher refuses such an unsavory
proposition, and as promised, she is fired for refusing. However,
she files a wrongful termination lawsuit. The charter
operator eventually pays the teacher $ 566,803 in school
funds that were supposed to go the classroom.
— she pays herself $223,615 salary to act as
“Executive Director” of a school with a miniscule
student body
Here’s its “Great Schools’ page:
Wisdom Academy For Young Scientists – Los Angeles, California – CA – School details
http://www.greatschools.org/california/los-angeles/16890-Wisdom-Academy-For-Young-Scientists/details/#Students
Anyway, LAUSD refuses to renew the charter, but that doesn’t close it, as the
charter operator appeals to the L.A. County Board of Ed, who takes over as
authorizer.
However, a year later, the L.A. County Board of Ed has state officials
audit the school, who “concluded that administrators may have funneled
millions in state funds to Okonkwo, her relatives and close associates.”
Undaunted, the charter operator appealed to the State Board of Ed
to take over as authorizer, who almost never refuses to authorize
a charter … and they thankfully refuse.
In repsonse, the charter operator claims that she’s being discriminated
against because of her skin color and African accent:
LA. Times: “In papers filed with the state, Wisdom’s leaders accused auditors and the county office of misconduct and “open hostility … against this African American operated school,” calling it “the culmination of years of unfair treatment and retaliation … because a few [county office] staff members dislike our school’s founder Kendra Okonkwo, her family, the thickness of her accent, and the color of her skin.”
State officials declined to overrule the charter revocation.
———————————-
Mind you, immigration fraud involving sham marriages is felony.
Why is this not being prosecuted?
The very fact that, after all this corruption was uncovered, that this charter operator even thought that she had a chance at authorizing by the State Board of Ed. shows how entitled the charter industry players think they are.
Indeed, the Callifornia Charter School Association supported their appeals to the L.A. County and State Board’s of Education.
LikeLike
To the charters goes all even when convicted of illegal activity and misuse of public funds. This is the monster you created, LAUSD, money grubbing business interests, counties, states. You created this mess, now you need to fix it like public educators have been saying all along. Greed can really make idiots.
LikeLike
This was deliberate on the part of LAUSD and the business interests. They actively want to destroy the public schools.
It’s definitely a mess, but they will fight having to fix it tooth and nail.
LikeLike
Who says crime doesn’t pay….What a racket!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This represents a clear pattern of disjunction and corruption that have been part and parcel of LAUSD’s mode of operation that I have witnessed working for them for 14 years. In this case, the district is hamstrung by the dysfunctional and unjust state laws that the ‘Governator’ Ahhnold ( Schwartznegger) promoted and enacted. The crisis comes about because citizens in this state are misinformed and under the thrall of the reformsters and their oligarch patrons that flood our political system with money tho further their agenda to privatize LAUSD and gain access to billions and billions of federal and state taxpayers ‘ dollars. Members of the school board, as well as key senior administrators are complicit in this and have not been made accountable. The media war fueled by illicit funds donated by oligarchs like Mr. Broad ( whose company, KB homes was investigated for financial improprieties) is directed against veteran teachers through surrogates such as ‘mr. DZ’ and his cronies . It is no surprise to me that veteran teachers are being forced out or are voluntarily retiring prematurely in light of the hostile environment that the school board and administration has promoted. In addition equally unsurprising is the steady torrent of unproven and unsound education practices that are being promulgated and forced upon classroom teachers by these snake oil salesmen .So now the shoe is on the other foot and I’ll assure you that many of the administrators that promoted this war on teachers are only worried about their 6 figure salaries. The students attending LAUSD and their parents are only pawns in the privatizers game.I see this as paralleling the disfunction that has overtaken the Republican Party that was created by the Tea party insurgents, the hubris and irony Engendered by these events is dizzying. I would write further but all of this makes me ill! Good luck School board, LAUSD administrators , may you live in interesting times !
LikeLike
Good analysis, Stephen…and you mention Schwartzenegger whose elevation from hack actor to governor was in itself a story of how crooked this world is, starting with the Kennedy clan who got him elected (despite dozens of women he sexually harassed) by decimating and recalling the sitting governor (with the help of Dick Cheney and of Ken Lay)….to now.
This week, murderer Esteban Nunez, son of a former crooked Speaker of the Ca. Assembly (remember his use of public money while in office, to buy himself $1500 bottles of French wine), was released from prison after serving only six years for stabbing to death a young student, while his partner in crime will rot there for many decades…all due to the special insider favor the Austrian granted to papa Nunez, his bosom buddy. Surely it is who you know, not what you know that counts.
I grew up in a time when statesmen like Earl Warren and Stanley Mosk were revered…boy…have times changed in my Golden (now polluted in every way) State.
LikeLike
Sorry, Ellen, but Earl Warren was no statesman. He maliciously advocated for the forced internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, while he was Secretary of State for California. He argued that all Japanese Americans were disloyal, saying, “A Jap is a Jap.” He also, while governor, fought hard to prevent the return of Japanese Americans to their homes in California. He may have been a later champion of civil rights, but he was certainly NOT a “statesman” during that awful time, and personally, I am not very impressed by him. http://encyclopedia.densho.org/Earl_Warren/#Proponent_of_Exclusion
LikeLike
Threatened, it is easy to judge people from many decades later. I hesitate to do so because who knows how history will judge us fifty years from now, assuming that the world has not been blown up in fifty years. Maybe we will all stand guilty of having eaten other living creatures.
LikeLike
I agree, but Earl Warren never really apologized (except for one line in his autobiography) for what he had done. The internment should never have happened.
You have apologized and worked to right the wrong. Warren never did.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Can’t the charter school find some billionaire looking for a tax credit?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, you would think that the billionaires who are spending so much money trying to push school districts and legislators to decrease money to public schools and shovel money to charter schools, could instead directly spend their money on the charter schools themselves. Instead of trying to destroy public schools.
In fact, wouldn’t it be really great if they started spending their money to improve under-resourced public schools?
I’m afraid that ain’t gonna happen. 😦
LikeLike
Los Angeles continues to be a marvel of billionaire shamelessness. Amazing that they do this in broad daylight there, and it’s even more amazing to me that people allow it to happen, It’s just organized crime at some point. Isn’t there a RICO case somewhere to be found? We need the Preet types to get involved and shut this racketeering down. Public offices can’t just be purchased and repurposed as private entities. Yet it seems like they are, particularly in LA.
LikeLike
Not that it’s any consolation in this disgraceful episode, but elite corruption has historically been the norm, not the exception, in Southern California. The Otis and Chandler families (then-owners and controllers of the LA Times) in the early 20th century were WASP family crime syndicates.
In the early-mid twentieth century, LA was the most segregated, anti-semitic – for example, Jews were for many years excluded from an elite social club they’d founded in the city’s earliest days – anti-labor large city in the country, with a police department known for brutality and bigotry.
Go back to Roman Polanski’s masterpiece, “Chinatown,” loosely-based on the true story of the theft of the Owens River as part of a immense development plan, and you’ll see that, after some recent atypical decades of comparatively progressive governance – even the Chandlers turned liberal, and their paper showed it – LA is now returning to its roots, with Eli Broad – originally a real estate guy, of course – in the current role of Mephistopheles.
LikeLike
I can’t find it but remember reading an article in your blog about a grassroots effort to revoke the CA charter laws. I sent them a donation and talked to them briefly. They say they are getting no support from unions or other groups. I don’t know the details but the idea is very appealing.
LikeLike
Mary, that effort is going forward
The CA charter law was written by charter advocates. The governor was Schwarzenegger, who appointed charter people to a majority of the state board even though (at the time) only 5% of children in the state were in charters
LikeLike
Good thing California figured out how to play the system so well — it set up such an seductive example for Colorado to follow. 😦
LikeLike
Teachers unions in California have been bought just like our politicians. The fix is in and they all, I mean all, take the money.
LikeLike
We have several efforts in California but our governor will veto all of them. He is on the board of two charters that he plans to export to Los Angeles. I can get you links if you like but this is a protracted struggle. Importantly, we need to keep finding honest educators to run for our board who won’t be bowled over by the charters. Schmerelson who won in the last round (or two? I’ve already forgotten) is in fact one of our most honest board members. We need more similarly honest people. But we also need a board that will lobby our legislators to keep supporting our schools and not believing the lies of the deformers. LAUSD also should not have relied on arbitration to settle this. THIS WAS THEIR DOING IT ON THE CHEAP – they will never spend money to defend what should be defended, so they end up paying more. Just 30 years + experience with this district. It’s enough to make you very ill. Our union unfortunately at the moment is only organizing charter teachers, which while noble is not enough.
LikeLike
Schmerelson was elected for the first time at the last election. He is an excellent board memberand a great supporter of public schools, which are currently besieged by the charter lobby.
LikeLike
Just want to pass on this news from NC….. http://www.ncpolicywatch.com/2016/04/13/legislators-advance-controversial-achievement-school-district-proposal/
LikeLike
They don’t have to accept the arbitration award; they can fight it, right? And go to court. Isn’t that the way?
LikeLike
“School districts are required to share classrooms and other facilities with charter schools” – this, alone, is utterly deranged policy! I was unaware. The rest is just… well, a harbinger of the end times, for lack of another way to describe it. Not that I believe in that kind of thing, but I do find myself using the term “apocalyptic” more often these days.
LikeLike
I have ceased to be astonished.
LikeLike
As to Matt Hill being paid by Eli (see the link to the 2009 LA Times article), Hill was, as I recall, one the top Deasy/Broad Academy guys who fouled up MiSiS and was canned last year. If memory is correct, he was rather quickly hired by Glendale at their Supt….and we were all shocked until we saw how many charter school deformers were on their BoE. Correct me if I am wrong, Geronimo.
Broad has a long history of paying an assortment of salaried folks…and he often brings them them to LAUSD as with the music supervisor about two years ago, and of course as he did with disgraced John Deasy, who when forced to resign, immediately segued right back to Broad as his prime henchman to push Vergara lawsuits, partnered with the infamous Ben Austin. So strange that a private person can take charge of a major school district, get/force/bribe the BoE to hire the Supt, and others, and pay their salaries. Do other districts operate with such abandon????
LikeLike
In long letters sent to the banks this week, the two regulatory agencies pointed to the dangers created by the global reach and complexity of the largest banks, which are bigger now than they were before the 2008 crisis.
LikeLike
Lenny Isenberg who has chronicled the abuse in LAUSD for a decade, wrote this to me, when I sent Diane’s Post
Professor, I do not find this astonishing. This kind of behavior is actually part and parcel of what is going on all over LAUSD. I have close to 800 posts covering equally egregious behavior at my bloghttp://www.perdaily.com, CityWatchLA.com, and the L.A. Progressive.
Endless stories about this tend to anesthetize the readers. All who contact me wind up saying the same phrase, “I can’t believe.”
Today I was reviewing a 35 page daily diary I kept regarding similarly criminal behavior within LAUSD, which tends to offer a greater sense of reality, given the scope and known LAUSD administrators involved.
While I am not sure it will work, I do think some crowd funded form of litigation to finally go after these criminals running our public education system is warranted. Given the thousands of senior tenured teachers who have been targeted and removed from their careers, I do think there is at least the highly motivated audience to fund this endeavor.
LAUSD has close to $500,000 to bleed any who object into ultimately walking away. But with the money we could raise and the legal team we could put together, we might just save public education and this country as anything that even remotely resembles a democracy.
Get in touch, if you would like to do something more than preach to the choir by finally making the criminal have to answer for their clearly illegal actions.
http://www.perdaily.com
LikeLike