Parents in an elementary school in Chicago brought cleaning supplies to their children’s school, because of the filthy conditions in the bathrooms. The leadership of Chicago Public Schools, controlled directly by Mayor Rahm Emanuel, privatized custodial services last year, and at that time the principals complained that the schools were getting dirtier by the day because of the loss of their custodians.
Would Mayor Emanuel tolerate these conditions in his own children’s school? Would any member of the Chicago Board of Education? What do you think?
On Saturday, a handful of pre-kindergarten parents packed yellow rubber gloves and spray bottles of vinegar and baking soda solution and headed to Suder Montessori Elementary Magnet School, 2022 W. Washington Blvd., on the Near West Side, where they spent the morning cleaning their children’s washrooms.
The parents felt they didn’t have a choice: Upon entering the bathrooms, they found pools of day-old urine on the floor, feces smeared on the walls and clogged, stinking toilet bowls. In the past few weeks, the school had an E. coli outbreak and more than half of the kindergarten students missed school because of various diseases, including a stomach bug, diarrhea or vomiting, said Michelle Burgess, head of the school’s parent-teacher association.
“These are preschoolers. They go to the bathroom and miss. The boys play in the urinals. And sometimes can’t get to the toilet fast enough. It’s understandable,” said Angela Morales, the parent of two children who attend the school. “But they need to clean. We can’t have our kids be in this filth.”
Parents claim the unsanitary bathroom conditions, overflowing garbage cans and soiled napping cots are the result of inadequate custodial care following the Chicago Board of Education’s decision last spring to award multi-million dollar custodial management contracts to two firms, Aramark and SodexoMAGIC.
The decision to privatize much of the custodial work was made in light of “daunting financial challenges” faced by the district, CPS officials have said. Surveys conducted by principals and parent organizations at the beginning of the school year aired numerous complaints of filthy conditions inside some school buildings after the custodial changes.
Aramark and Chicago Public School officials could not immediately be reached for comment Saturday.
Questions about school cleanliness grew further in early September when district officials announced close to 480 subcontracted custodians who work in CPS buildings would be laid off by Aramark.
CPS officials in March signed a minimum three-year contract worth up to $260 million with Aramark. SodexoMAGIC also received a minimum three-year, up to $80 million contract for facility upkeep earlier this year.
The reduced contracts, Suder parents say, have led to the school operating with two full-time custodians and one part-time custodian as opposed to operating with four full-time custodians as it had in previous years. Parents claim that since the reductions, janitors have done a poor job maintaining regular cleaning duties and, for the past three months, have mopped the floor with water—and nothing else.

The story must be wrong as private enterprise always does the work more efficiently, cost effective and better than government employees.
LikeLike
True… because they are motivated by the right thing: profit!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yup and minus the pension liabilities.
LikeLike
Would have been nice if a local news outlet had come along with them to film the before and after on the local news. Rahm needs to squirm some more. A whole lot more.
LikeLike
Why wait for a news team? Take video from your phone and post it. A team of teacher activists did that in Los Angeles to pressure the district to stop spending construction repair bond funds on testing devices. The pictures that got posted were irrefutable. https://www.facebook.com/Repairs-Not-IPads-228827333958584/?fref=ts
LikeLike
Yes, posting their own video would have been the next best thing. But it’s hard to get an individual video to get the views that a local news station can get. But then, the local news stations are all bought and paid for….
Anyway, speaking of Rahm, this post from Tim Furman is a must-read (just not around meal time): http://www.tbfurman.us/2015/12/were-doomed.html
LikeLike
Temp contract employees do not have an investment in the schools they work in and Custodial staff is at inadequate levels.
LikeLike
The fact that this school had floors mopped with just water is one up from many other CPS floors. My classroom had not been mopped since August (think breakfast spills because breakfast is eaten in the classroom). There is only one floor scrubbing machine to a school and it is too heavy to be carried up a flight of stairs (no elevators) and it can not clean around a toilet.
We can’t blame the janitors. They can’t possibly do a proper cleaning with less help and no cleaning supplies.
LikeLike
In a country as wealthy as ours, it is downright embarrassing that parents must clean the restrooms at their children’s public school. Rham & Co. have siphoned away hundreds of millions of tax dollars from the working-class Chicago neighborhoods to turn the downtown lakefront into a playground for his multimillionaire buddies.
Rahm and the Reephormers are intents on proving public schools are a failure, even to the point of subcontracting out critical work. I have a lot of respect for our custodians; they are part of our school staff, and keep our school safe and clean to the best of their ability, even thought it is ranked in the bottom 5 percent of the state (according to test scores). Rahm & company think publicly-paid custodians are dispensible; he doesn’t give a rat’s @$$ that custodians, too, are stakeholders in our children’s education.
I have for more respect than the custodian than the banker/hedge fund manager.
LikeLike
The new parental involvement – scrubbing toilets. Nice job, Rahm.
LikeLike
This is unacceptable and I hope the person/s responsible for this are held accountable.
LikeLike
Sadly, if anyone is “held accountable” it will be the cleaners themselves and maybe their supervisor. Not that they can do anything since they don’t have proper supplies or support. But if someone’s head has to roll, you know it can’t be the people actually responsible. Accountability is for little people.
LikeLike
Aramark just won the contract to run the concessions in Yosemite National Park. People from all over the world make the long trek (no nearby airports). Will Aramark be up to the task? If not, we’ll give a poor impression to the rest of the world.
LikeLike
Way back in 1969 I spent eight weeks one summer studying in Europe. I remember that in at least one country (Austria I think) when entering a public school you removed your shoes to show respect for the public place and maintain cleanliness. Here we are 46 years later in the United States of America allowing our children to walk in feces.
LikeLike
I do applaud the parents and think that perhaps Rham and the Chicago Public Schools officials should discontinue custodial services in their buildings and have the custodians reassigned to the schools. This situation is dire and apparently a serious health hazzard. Couldn’t the Board of Health shut the schools down until this has been resolved?
LikeLike
I have to say that in Fort Wayne, IN, our public schools privatized custodial services about 5 years ago with SodexoMagic and they have been up to the task. Maybe it was because they hired some of the same people already on the job or because the district kept its own top management to hold Sodexo to their contract. In the FW experience, Sodexo has been a great partner, our buildings are as clean as ever and we are in the middle of major building projects at 10 schools. Sodexo employees have also participated in several fundraising projects for our students. But again, we do have our own people with oversight of services.
LikeLike
I work in Zionsville and we had Sodexo for a while. They did not do a good job at all so the district changed companies. Unfortunately this second company is even worse!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on The Academe Blog and commented:
More wonders of privatization, courtesy Diane Ravitch’s indispensable blog on K-12 education:
LikeLike
Does Emanuel’s children’s school hire ARAMARK? If so, what kind of job do they do there.
LikeLike
Aramark is the food service provider not only for the Lab School, but for the entire University of Chicago and hospitals: http://chicagomaroon.com/2015/10/30/university-seeking-changes-to-dining-as-aramark-contract-ends/
The Lab School likely has its own custodial staff.
LikeLike
This is happening in schools all over – not just in Chicago. Drastic cuts to education have caused schools to try to find savings by turning to privatized custodial services. These services save money by hiring $8/hour temp employees who are not invested in the school in the same way that the previous school system custodians were. While I don’t have much respect for Emanuel – this problem is much bigger than him. Politicians have turned their back on public education and we are starting to see the results. This is just the tip of the iceberg folks. Only you can stop this decline. Vote for candidates who support public education in the U.S.!
LikeLike
Do you know any candidates?
LikeLike
I still believe that the Department of Public Health is remiss not to address this situation. It is unsanitary and pathogenic.The schools should be shut down until they have been sanitized and reinspected. I bet the prisons and jails are in much better shape. This should not be happening.
LikeLike
Have OSHA and Health & Human Services/Department of Public Health (whatever it’s called in the state) complaints been filed? OSHA complaints were the only way some schools in Baltimore City got access to safe, potable water (the lead pipes were not being replaced and fountains couldn’t be used; district had to provide those water cooler things in all the halls and give students water bottles) in the early 00s.
LikeLike