From a reader:
Journalists do not really seem to understand the gravity of what is happening to education in the United States. There is a reason that highly educated parents are opting their children out of standardized tests. It is a scary time to be a teacher and an even scarier time to raise a child.
Since 1997, the testing market in the United States has grown 835%, or roughly 14% annually, from $263 million to over $2.46 billion. That’s nearly double the annual rate of return of the S&P 500. A lot of people have made a lot of money off of the test-based accountability movement and a lot of corporations now have a lot to lose. Corporations and politicians promised us a lot when they seized control of the nation’s education policy and enacted No Child Left Behind in 2002.
Since then, the rate of growth in NAEP scores has declined, SAT scores have declined, ACT scores have remained flat, and PISA scores have declined.
As if that wasn’t enough, politicians and their corporate backers doubled down on the dismantling of public education by withholding funding, taking over school districts, and threatening to close down schools. In Washington D.C., after linking 50% of teacher evaluations to standardized test scores, teacher turnover increased to 82%, schools in communities with high poverty rates showed large or moderate declines in student learning outcomes, and the combined poverty gap expanded by 44 scale-score points causing poor students to fall even further behind their more affluent peers.
Realizing the calamity of these reform efforts, the American Statistical Association, the National Academy of Education, the American Educational Research Association, the Economic Policy Institute, and educators throughout the country issued statements urging policymakers to reconsider the use of high-stakes tests which have robbed teachers of their autonomy and forced hundreds of hours of test prep on our students.
While some states have responded to limit the stakes until more is known about the validity and reliability of the assessments, officials in New York State continue to press forward.
It is long past time to acknowledge that the high-stakes accountability movement has failed our children. We must hold politicians responsible for withholding funding from our public schools and allowing poverty to wreak havoc on our education system. The United States now has its highest level of income inequality since 1928. Yet when you control for poverty, we have the best PISA scores in the world.
Our schools are not failing our children, our politicians are. It takes a real hero to ignore the impact of poverty and threaten to punch teachers in the face. But parents can see right through the lies, the decept, and the corruption. In 2016, opt out rates will double and this grass-roots parent movement will ensure that the American Dream is not permitted to skip a generation.
A “Parent Spring” on its way?
If our politicians are failing the children, it’s actually the public who is failing… because we are the ones putting and keeping these politicians in office.
Do people who take no action to change the situation… share the blame?
My vote for president will go the the candidate who plans to select Diane Ravitch as Secretary of Education. #ravitchforsecretaryofeducation
Let’s get Diane Ravitch to the White House now! Please sign the petition below to bring Diane on board to guide President Obama’s education policies in the last year of his presidency. The time is now! Anre Duncan is leaving. The President just acknowledged mistakes have been made, under his helm, in the aealousness of high-stakes testing. The stars are in alignment! We have only 14 months to change the direction of education before the next president. No approval by congress needed. President Obama just needs to ask her.
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/takeaction/441/312/837/
There is a bipartisan consensus among the Overclass about using high stakes tests as a weapon to redistribute money and power upward to themselves. Those who belong to this insatiable group of know-nothing’s couldn’t care less how it affects students.
Actually, that’s not true; they do care, and quite a lot. However, they only care insofar as they can also use education for social engineering/training purposes. In that sense, forget Common Core, because in fact the tests are the true, stealth curriculum, inculcating and embedding habits of mind – passivity, lack of critical thought and creativity, tolerance for tedium, authoritarianism, meaninglessness (thus the insistence on teaching skills, devoid of context and content), and absurdity.
Under the boot of so-called education reform, the tests are the curriculum, and the more kids “fail” them, the more successful the edu-privateers are.
Well said!
Even if we don’t make assumptions about the desires of the overclass, they are cut off from what happens in schools. They lack knowledge, either by direct experience, statistical inference, or the historical perspective Diane has, from which to get any depth of understanding of schools.
Journalists might not have an overclass perspective, but they are the same in their lack of direct experience, statistical knowledge, or historical perspective.
Also, policy makers and journalists have intense time pressure, which prevents them from getting better understanding. Thus we get educational policy that is justified largely by a single study, the famous Chetty, Friedman, Rockhoff study. Making policy on the basis of a single study is a bad idea, even if it’s a really good study.
Also, as a famous philosopher said, “The ruling ideas are the ideas of the ruling class.”
Reblogged this on karenw95 and commented:
Exactly!
The information in this posted summary should compel congressional hearings.
Our local newspaper today had an article
Believe it or not AND in Indiana;
Headline:
“National Report blasts Charter Schools”
Recently they printed a superlative column by Dr. Tony Lux , which someone put on this blog.
MAYBE; finally some are “getting religion” and seeing the light.
MAYBE!!!
It is way past due obviously but maybe “it is darkest just before dawn”.