Alan Singer reviews some of the many charter school scandals, some of which were reported here. But he has some new ones that you should know about.
Here are some good examples:
While the New York Times seems determined to promote charter schools, other news agencies and educational groups are expressing increased reservations about their lack of performance, excessive expense and political and financial backing. The Center for Media and Democracy (CMD) reports that 2,500 charter schools have failed since 2000. The list includes “ghost” schools that collected public funds but never served any students. These include 25 charter schools in Michigan that were awarded federal grants of between three and four million dollars in 2010-2011 but never opened. CMD estimates that during the last twenty years the charter school industry has received over three billion dollars in federal tax dollars that should have gone to public schools….
A recent study by the National Bureau of Economic Research on North Carolina charter school enrollment and performance from 1999 to 2012 found that “charter schools in North Carolina are increasingly serving the interests of relatively able white students in racially imbalanced schools.” Enabling legislation “explicitly stated that charter schools could not discriminate on the basis of race or ethnicity.” However, the study found the percentage of White students attending North Carolina charter schools is increasing as is the number of schools where White students predominate. In Durham County, “where the rapid growth of charters has not only increased racial segregation,” it has “also has imposed significant financial burdens on the school district.” Their research suggests that charters are systematically recruiting White and academically higher performing minority students to boost school-wide performance on standardized exams and that the trends they observed will continue and accelerate….
Detroit 90/90, a charter school management company that operates Detroit’s largest charter school network is busy fighting efforts by its teachers to join a union. The company is currently challenging a National Labor Relations Board ruling during the summer that Teach for America recruits should be in the same bargaining unit as regular teachers. Maybe they are on to something, but the charter management company claimed TFA recruits were” temporary service workers,” not professional educators, and ineligible to become part of the teachers’ union.
There seems to be a very strong push by hedge fund managers to charterize more and more public schools. Perhaps they are afraid that the public is catching on and time is running out for them. They see that their millions are harming the vast majority of kids, who are in public schools, but they don’t care. They don’t care about results. This is a game for them, a hobby, a better activity than polo. It is about money, power, and greed.

If anyone wants to read a charter school grant to the federal government Ohio finally released the application to the Obama Administration.
Apparently DC and Columbus plan to vastly expand charter schools in this state.
Did any Ohio state lawmakers run on that the last election, you know, informing the general public, not people inside “the movement”? I know President Obama didn’t.
Click to access ohioapp.pdf
LikeLike
“It is expected that by 2021 the state charter sector will total nearly 100,000 seats and have about 400 schools. By leveraging new planning and implementation subgrants through Ohio’s CSP program, the state will generate nearly 25,000 new charter school seats over the next 5 years”
I wonder which Ohio public schools they’re planning on closing. It’d be nice to know ahead of time because obviously no parent wants their child in a public school that DC and Columbus have abandoned and are winding down. Can they maybe give us a head’s up or do we find out when our schools lose funding and support? How is that a “choice”? Obviously the vast majority of people in this state aren’t even aware of the Master Plan.
LikeLike
Ohio’s evaluation system for public schools is rigged to fail many schools in urban districts. That makes the whole district a target for unelected charter operators, many with profit-seeking as the priority. In addition to Youngstown, the following districts are vulnerable to a district-wide takeover with charters becoming the only “choice” and choosing students
Akron City
Canton City
Columbus City
Cleveland Municipal
Cincinnati City
Toledo City
Dayton City
http://reportcard.education.ohio.gov/Pages/District-Report.aspx?DistrictIRN=043752
LikeLike
Well, maybe these fraudsters are more capable of educating “seats,” since they’ve proven themselves incapable of educating children.
LikeLike
When money is the bottom line instead of human needs, this is what one can expect.
Sadly this has become the norm.
LikeLike
One can not express the extreme disappointment I have of this administration in regards to prosecuting crimes. Banks launder drug money for criminal cartels, bankers engage in risky and fraudulent behavior, torture and war crimes – no problem, charter school fraud. Oh well… Cops with guns. I felt threatened. Kid on a corner with some weed. You’re going to jail. Doesn’t seem right. Maybe next time in 2016
LikeLike
Despite rhetoric to the contrary, Obama is a free market corporatist. He constantly talks about the middle class, but does little for them.
LikeLike
Worse than that- he to like W, is also a war criminal.
LikeLike
…And holder of the Nobel Peace Prize! How’s that for irony. I recently read they regret this decision.
LikeLike
While I’m not an Obama fan, it’s untrue that the Nobel committee has expressed regret:
http://www.snopes.com/info/news/nobelprize.asp
LikeLike
For those who said the market would do what public education couldn’t and do it cheaper and faster, were wrong or lying through their teeth when they claimed that the profit motive wouldn’t supercede student well being – students would get taught and people would profit in the pursuit of better education. That presumes that “quality” however you measure it is the primary driver for charter schools, and that parents would “buy” the best schools.
This completely ignores the laws of physics whereby parents need to deliver their students to someone’s door while they go to work in a timely manner. It also ignores that cutting corners, manipulation, and skimming are far better ways to achieve the profit motive than by elevating the quality of learning for all students.
This system whereby ANY student has a mechanism where the school can easily exclude or coerce them, will devolve into a 2 tiered system. Brown v. BOE wru?
LikeLike
M:
For the heavyweights and enforcers and enablers of the self-proclaimed “education reform,” $tudent $ucce$$ isn’t everything but the only thing—
Rheeally! And it is especially enjoyable when pursued in a most Johnsonally fashion…
But in the real world when you impose a worst practices business model on public schools you get precisely the sort of homogenized mediocrity and failure that is the hallmark of rheephorm.
Caveat: said mandated catastrophe only to be applied to the vast majority aka OTHER PEOPLE’S CHILDREN. For THEIR OWN CHILDREN there are gems such as Lakeside School [Bill Gates] and Harpeth Hall [Michelle Rhee] and U of Chicago Lab Schools [Rahm Emanuel and soon Arne Duncan] and Delbarton School [Chris Christie] and the like.
After all, wouldn’t want the hewers of wood and drawers of water to intrude on matters that are best left to the better sort of people, now would we?
😡
LikeLike
As a character in a long-running Japanese police detective tv show is wont to say [from the English subtitles]:
“It is my fault that I obsess over small details.”
I reproduce here from the original piece [HuffPost, 10-1-2015] the sentence fragment I was struck by [see posting and original for full paragraph and context]:
[start]
… the charter management company claimed TFA recruits were” temporary service workers,” not professional educators, and ineligible to become part of the teachers’ union.
[end]
So actual heavyweights or “playas” in the self-proclaimed “education reform” movement characterize their TFA employees as (in public and in a potentially litigious context) “temporary service workers” and not professional educators.
Not shills or trolls for rheephorm. Not a parent whose child is enrolled in a charter or an employee speaking under duress. These are the actual shot callers.
So when some wag coined TFAers “TeachForAwhiles” they were just being a bit more pungent and sharper in their version of what honest-to-goodness charter big shots call them—“temporary service workers.”
Which, according to the “thought leaders” of the “new civil rights movement of our time” (a few of whom post on this blog) means that charters are just like, exactly like, no different from, public schools. Except that they’re better.
😳
When a sock puppet seems to make a sound, if you want to find out where the noise originates from, you look at the person whose hand fills the sock and makes the puppet’s mouth move.
“I reject that mind-set.” [Michelle Rhee]
We knew she would say that. And even though the sound seems to be coming out of her mouth…
‘Nuff said.
😎
LikeLike