Thanks to the reader known as FLERP for finding this terrific article about kindergarten children in Finland.
What matters most: Play!
While our five-year-olds buckle down to show that they have mastered academic skills in math and reading, the children in kindergarten in Finland are playing.
When children play, Osei Ntiamoah continued, they’re developing their language, math, and social-interaction skills. A recent research summary “The Power of Play” supports her findings: “In the short and long term, play benefits cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development…When play is fun and child-directed, children are motivated to engage in opportunities to learn,” the researcher concluded.
Osei Ntiamoah’s colleagues all seemed to share her enthusiasm for play-based learning, as did the school’s director, Maarit Reinikka: “It’s not a natural way for a child to learn when the teacher says, ‘Take this pencil and sit still.’” The school’s kindergarten educators have their students engage in desk work—like handwriting—just one day a week. Reinikka, who directs several preschools in Kuopio, assured me that kindergartners throughout Finland—like the ones at Niirala Preschool—are rarely sitting down to complete traditional paper-and-pencil exercises….
This is scandalous! How can they expect to be global competitors when they don’t buckle down and learn to suffer through stultifying exercises?
And there’s no such thing as a typical day of kindergarten at the preschool, the teachers said. Instead of a daily itinerary, two of them showed me a weekly schedule with no more than several major activities per day: Mondays, for example, are dedicated to field trips, ballgames, and running, while Fridays—the day I visited—are for songs and stations.
Once, Morning Circle—a communal time of songs and chants—wrapped up, the children disbanded and flocked to the station of their choice: There was one involving fort-making with bed sheets, one for arts and crafts, and one where kids could run a pretend ice-cream shop. “I’ll take two scoops of pear and two scoops of strawberry—in a waffle cone,” I told the two kindergarten girls who had positioned themselves at the ice-cream table; I had a (fake) 10€ bill to spend, courtesy of one of the teachers. As one of the girls served me—using blue tack to stick laminated cutouts of scoops together—I handed the money to her classmate.
With a determined expression reminiscent of the boys in the mud with their shovels, the young cashier stared at the price list. After a long pause, one of her teachers—perhaps sensing a good opportunity to step in—helped her calculate the difference between the price of my order and the 10€. Once I received my change (a few plastic coins), the girls giggled as I pretended to lick my ice cream.
Throughout the morning I noticed that the kindergartners played in two different ways: One was spontaneous and free form (like the boys building dams), while the other was more guided and pedagogical (like the girls selling ice cream).
In fact, Finland requires its kindergarten teachers to offer playful learning opportunities—including both kinds of play—to every kindergartner on a regular basis, according to Arja-Sisko Holappa, a counselor for the Finnish National Board of Education. What’s more, Holappa, who also leads the development of the country’s pre-primary core curriculum, said that play is being emphasized more than ever in latest version of that curriculum, which goes into effect in kindergartens next fall.
“Play is a very efficient way of learning for children,” she told me. “And we can use it in a way that children will learn with joy.”
Imagine that! Finland will surely lose the race to the top of global competition if they keep up this play methodology. They should do what we do: drum the kids into silence, require them to march and sit in rows, teach them to keep their eyes on the teachers at all times, and require that they are college-and-career-ready from day one!
Of Course. Children ARE and should be considered CHILDREN and treated thusly commensurate with that philosophy.
Our nation seems to be ruled now by corporate interests and corporate viewpoints that ALL people are widgets to be made peons in their ability to siphon off the nation’s largess.
Gee…look at all those happy, healthy, nurtured little white kids playing in Finland, who all speak the same language in their liberal and unified/socialistic society. In no way do they remind me of the multitude of black and brown kids, and other kids of color, in LA and all over the US, who live in poverty, in barrios, on reservations, and in inner cities where there are few playgrounds, abd they speak dozens of different languages, are not guaranteed even a modicum of health care, and too often do not get enough parental attention.
Our high-needs children are the ones who can benefit MOST from developmentally appropriate practices in their schools. They may not have well equipped, safe environments at home in which to really explore and play, so they need to have these experiences at school.
You’ve highlighted some important differences, can you complete your thoughts? Am I to assume you are against play based learning? More importantly, what do you propose to address the problems you cite?
Knight…I definitely support play based learning for small children. What I take issue with is the constant refrain comparing Finland to the U.S. This is an impossible standard. Rather, it seems more rational and productive to me to compare the homogeneity vs. heterogeneity of the two countries, and how that affects students and society, but using reality based potential solutions .
Having a mutually shared single language, and a quite shared history, and a rather logistically contained and consistent middle class society in a liberal/socialistic nation, makes for a better outcome IMO. That is Finland, not America.
We, here, are the antithesis. We have open borders surrounding us, with all comers from everywhere as residents, speaking hundreds of languages/dialects, and many living in abject poverty…and it is children from these homes who are sent to public schools to be educated.
Of course America’s teachers are challenged far more than Finland’s, and of course these are not kids who can be turned into cookie replicas of a fantasized happy and healthy environment through government edicts like Common Core or even play based learning. These are the children who my professional career has exposed me to over a period of many decades. And our obtuse and often false and destructive government oversight, which is prevalent in our country no matter which party is in office, does not bode well for teachers, students, and most others, especially these days.
I am not a early childhood specialist, but as an educational researcher, I have traveled the country and have observed in endless school districts that are in throes of poverty and which lack appropriate funding, have little to no parental involvement, and where children play in graffiti filled alleys, and where 10 years old kids are selling and using crack in those alleys. Yes, these children need grassy playgrounds, excellent feachers, and better opportunities for learning through play.
Yeah, sure, but wait until they take those high-stakes standardized tests when they’re older and they…
Oops! Got the rheephorm mis-messaging all mixed up…
😱
I guess the rheephormsters got one thing right: there IS something we can learn from Finland!
😎
P.S. FLERP!: you outdid yourself!
The sad thing is that the people in charge KNOW this! The $40,000/year private schools that they send their own children to are almost always far less academic in the early years than public Kindergartens are now supposed to be. And of course, not one of those private schools “opts in” to the common core state tests, despite the fact that private schools are allowed to do so any time they wish.
I’m not quite sure how they get away with the hypocrisy, but perhaps having the major media (both liberal and conservative) seemingly in their pocket helps avoid any questions.
Just one link about Finland’s schools.
http://www.thedailyriff.com/articles/the-finland-phenomenon-inside-the-worlds-most-surprising-school-system-588.php
Thanks Yvonne for this link. Good articles and so pertinent.
What’s really sad is the fact that we’ve known this for many, many years.
Reblogged this on Politicians Are Poody Heads and commented:
Well, but of course. Anyone who has studied child development at all knows that play is vital and necessary. It’s a huge part of how children learn, and, yes, develop.
It’s just too bad that the current “testing above all” environment (and, oh, yes, while we are at it, make sure that the corporations involved in testing and developing “programs” make money) has lost sight of this.
And isn’t it interesting that most of those who have been pushing for the test-and-train-for-the-tests aficianados, send their kids to private schools?
Can we not let children be children, with the age-appropriate guidance? Apparently not. 😦
Diane – I recently shared this piece as well. I’ve left the classroom for to take over academics at Kiddom, which develops a data-driven instructional tool for teachers. Sadly, since taking over, I’ve been getting numerous requests from kindergarten teachers for us to add Kindergarten CCLS to align assessments to.
While I’m obligated to do so, it makes me feel concerned. Kindergarten is supposed to be about striking a balance between play and building social skills. In addition, It’s probably pretty hard as a kindergarten teacher to say “no” to CCLS when our education system is such a national sore spot… you don’t want to be THAT teacher that doesn’t follow CCLS.
Someone please research the ages children enter and remain in K in asian countries, and when they enter first grade, high school and college. More specifically: China, Japan and Taiwan.
Actually, I’m sure many readers wouldn’t need to research, only perhaps to pool knowledge.
“Finland is finished”
Finland is finished
They let their kids play
Their future’s diminished
On PISA they’ll pay
Anyone who has a degree in Elementary Education knows about the power of play. Unfortunately, the creators of Common Core decided to disregard all the child development research when they set the standards. They claim that child psychologists like Piaget were incorrect (who pays attention to that pesky research) and that small children are capable of a more rigorous curriculum based on their own (untested) theories of learning. You know the “I know what’s best for your child” theology.
As the rest of us know – Just because you say it’s so, doesn’t make it so.
“He said, He said”
Piaget said ‘Let them play’
Coleman says “no way”
Duncan says “It’s testing day”
What more is there to say?
Yeah, but do the Finnish control the World? For example, could they start a war any time they wanted to?
“Finnishing what you Start”
Anyone can start a war
Hard part is to end
Finnish may be just a bore
But Finland sets the trend
And in other headline news today: Wild bear shits in the woods!
Or as we used to say as kids in the 60s when someone made an absolutely brilliant everybody knows that statement: No shit Sherlock!
We need to get back to this. A child’s work is play. They learn much more this way. Where has our common sense gone?
Do you ever read the About page?
Yes! Enjoyed the article when you posted it!
Back in the seventies I made a grocery store for my kindergarteners complete with prices and registers, baskets, fake fruit and veggies , cans empty boxes of cereal, egg cartons etc. They loved it so much. As a student teacher I loved creating lessons for those angels, like umbrellas raining numbers, or ice skating to a waltz. I shudder to think of teaching kindergarten today, just shudder.
Julie,
The Finns built their model on research done in American schools and university Ed. Departments. They admit it. So, it isn’t surprising that you would have done similar things.
What is surprising, of course, is that we now would ignore those findings and listen to people like dropout Gates. The Finns have more sense. We no longer accept any evidence that contradicts our National ‘belief of the day’.
The Finns understand the value of science. We don’t. We only understand the value of money.
Well, gates dropped out and he’s a success, which clearly proves that dropping out makes you successful
hence the need for Common Core and tests with high cut scores to ensure a high drop out rate.
It’s all very scientific
“(Common) Corelation mean Causality”
Gates dropped out
Which bred success
There’s no doubt
That dropout’s best
Design the test
So no kids pass
Gates’ success
Is ours at last!
Gates’ success
Is theirs at last!
Kndg teachers in Asheville NC fought for twenty more minutes of play time for students and got it!
Good stuff.
With support from parents, teachers can make changes.
Totally agree, Linda. Teachers, by themselves, now have little, power. It is up to parents to help. We are near the end of the game, and only a teacher-parent coalition has any chance of stopping the juggernaut.
I once had a seven year old Danish student who had not yet started reading in Danish. Usually this is a signal that reading in English may take longer when the student cannot read in L 1. She took to reading in English like a fish to water. She was a thoroughly middle class student with well educated parents; it makes a huge difference.
American kids always did more seatwork in kindergarten than what is described in the Finnish schools, but there used to be plenty of opportunities for free play. I’m sure many of us can remember the toys from our own kindergartens.
Thank goodness I never went to kindergarten! And, my ‘first grade’ was in a school that only had two classrooms. In the lower level, grades 1,2,3 and 4 were taught by one teacher (who also was my first piano teacher). When she had to concentrate on the higher grades, she would send the first-graders out to play. I learned so much outside.
Didn’t hurt me one bit. In fact, made me a more confident and dritical adult.
Play is wonderful but the ensuing peer-interactions are insufficient for low SES kids. They needs lots of adult verbal interactions– two-way wonderings, not one-way directives–and one teacher can’t do it all. Budgets make it so hard for schools to hire verbal parents and retirees just to interact naturally for at least an hour a day with the kids while they play, explore, and read books. I know someone will say to use volunteers, and I’m sure that would work in some poor communities, it just didn’t work in ours.
I was in Kindergarten in 1927 at Rankin school. I was made to sit under the Grand piano with tape, which the teacher licked, over my mouth for talking out of turn. I wonder how it affected me, , affected, affected me ( smile )
Indeed; my kid learned to do multiplication and division in his head from hours upon hours of time spent playing Minecraft and Lego.
Finland this, Finland that. Good grief! How about we try to be a little more critical about this, hmm? Is Scandanavia really a paradise of happy, educated souls? Is Finland in particular? Their suicide rate, their homicide rate, their rate of gun ownership, their endemic alcoholism and laconic, depressed affect suggest that something is, in fact, rotten in Finland. So maybe, just maybe, we shouldn’t swallow this narrative of educational “success” so uncritically. If anyone reading this is unwilling to research the (very real) social problems in Finland, at least check out this tongue-in-cheek article, if only to counteract the Kool Aid you’re drinking every time you read a piece about the Finnish educational miracle:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jan/27/scandinavian-miracle-brutal-truth-denmark-norway-sweden
Skeptic,
I understand your skepticism about all things Finland. Seems too good to be true. I visited Finnish schools. They are wonderful. Arts and physical activity are very important. Wish US schools were more like them, not test-driven. I was interviewed yesterday by Korean public TV crew, and the interviewer says that all Korean education is rote memorization and very dull.