This press release just arrived from Néw York State Allies for Public Education, a coalition of 50 parent and educator groups.
http://www.nysape.org/nysape-pr-ny-parents-have-spoken.html
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: April 23, 2015
More information contact:
Eric Mihelbergel (716) 553-1123; nys.allies@gmail.com
Lisa Rudley (917) 414-9190; nys.allies@gmail.com
NYS Allies for Public Education (NYSAPE) – http://www.nysape.org
NY Parents Have Spoken, Now It’s Time to Fix Cuomo’s Education Budget Debacle & Establish New Leadership for the Board of Regents
For the past two years, New York State Allies for Public Education has warned elected and appointed officials about serious concerns related to excessive high-stakes state testing based on flawed and experimental learning standards, as well as the collection and sharing of private student data.
This past week, the national attention focused on the parent uprising taking place in New York State. Spurred to action by the refusal of both the Governor and the NYS Education Department’s failure to respond to legitimate concerns, thousands of parents fought back to protect their children.
At this time, estimates indicate parents of close to 200,000 students this year have refused New York State’s Common Core testing agenda and the final figures are expected to be even higher.
The educational program of the state is in chaos. Leadership is more important than ever. On Sunday, April 19th the Editorial Board of The Journal News declared, “The stunning success of the test-refusal movement in New York is a vote of no confidence in our state educational leadership” in calling for Chancellor Merryl Tisch to step aside.
New York State Allies for Public Education, a grassroots coalition of over fifty parent and educator advocacy organizations from all corners of the Empire State, stands with the Editorial Board of The Journal News.
Chancellor Tisch must step down. The only way for the Board of Regents, Assembly, and Senate to regain trust of their constituents is to call for the Regents to empower a new leader to fix within its authority, the Cuomo budget legislation fiasco and the misguided Regents Reform Agenda.
“Parents have been left with no choice. We will submit our refusal letters, which is our parental right, on day one of school, next year and every year and if those in power will not listen, we will free our children from a test driven, developmentally inappropriate education,” said Jeanette Deutermann, Nassau County public school parent and Long Island Opt Out founder.
“For the past two years Chancellor Tisch has repeatedly ignored parents at forums throughout the state. She is incapable of leading the state in a new direction because she believes what is happening is just fine and her latest plea for asking for more time is just a distraction from the real issues. Her repeated calls for critics to “calm down” indicates her unwillingness to change course.” said Lisa Rudley, Westchester County public school parent and NYSAPE founding member.
“On Chancellor Tisch’s watch, the work of the State Education Department has been outsourced to a privately funded ‘Regents Fellows’ think tank. It is not surprising that the reforms put forth by this think tank advance the agenda of the wealthy ‘yacht set’ and corporate-linked groups that fund the Regent Fellows: The Robin Hood Foundation, Gates Foundation, and even Chancellor Tisch herself. When you replace a public service with a private organization that advances corporate agendas, New Yorkers know that is corruption,” said Anna Shah, Dutchess County public school parent and Schools of Thought Hudson Valley, NY founder.
“While the Governor has demonstrated blatant disregard for the will of the people by doubling down on the use of high stakes testing, the State Education Department and Chancellor Tisch similarly ignored parent concerns regarding inappropriate test content by forcing children to read passages on last week’s ELA tests that were up to four years above grade level followed by vague and confusing questions,” said Jessica McNair, Oneida County public school parent, Central NY Opt Out co-founder, and educator.
Fred Smith, testing specialist, NYC public schools retired administrative analyst, and Change the Stakes member said, “Instead of transparency and disclosure of complete and timely test data that would open the quality of the ELA and math exams to independent review, Tisch has ruled over an unaccountable testing program that flies at near-zero visibility–in a fog of flawed field testing procedures, age-inappropriate poorly written items, the covert removal of test questions after they have been scored, arbitrarily drawn cut off scores, and the misapplication of the results to reach unsupportable conclusions about students, teachers, and schools.”
“As seen with the budget debacle earlier this month, New Yorkers know when the ‘Albany Fix’ is in,” Eric Mihelbergel, Erie County public school parent and NYSAPE founding member. Mihelbergel went on to say, “We know that the opt out movement will ultimately invalidate the data and render these test scores useless. When some schools have opt outs as high as 70%, we know that any claims that opt out is “random” and that only a small sampling of test scores will yield usable data is illogical.”
To ensure clarity for all, NYSAPE calls for the following from the NYS Legislature & Board of Regents and will release a more comprehensive list in the near future:
1. A dramatic reduction of testing in grades 3rd – 8th, along with reasserting New York State’s authority to determine the education of its children by calling on the US Congress to reduce testing requirements and return to grade span testing. As former President Bill Clinton said we don’t need annual testing, “I think doing one [test] in elementary school, one in the end of middle school and one before the end of high school is quite enough if you do it right.”
2. Chancellor Tisch must immediately step down.
3. An independent review of the NYS career and college ready standards to ensure that standards are research based and appropriate. Establish a taskforce including parents, educators, and stakeholders to study the Common Core Learning Standards and make recommendations to adjust and adopt NYS standards.
4. Adhere to a public and transparent process for selecting a new NYS Commissioner of Education.
5. Fix the Cuomo budget legislation debacle by passing legislation that decouples student test scores and restores local board of education control over teacher evaluations.
6. Pass legislation that REQUIRES parental consent to share ANY identifiable student data beyond school district administrators.
We want to restore our classrooms with a well-rounded education and drive testing compliance factory reforms out of our classrooms forever.
###
– See more at: http://www.nysape.org/nysape-pr-ny-parents-have-spoken.html#sthash.WPxXvbWx.dpuf

Good luck. Not much to lose…but I am not a New Yorker, or a member of the yacht set.
LikeLike
Fabulous statement! Focusing on what’s important, and not shying away from politically difficult calls to action (e.g., fire Tisch).
LikeLike
“. . . not shying away from politically difficult calls to action (e.g., fire Tisch).”
Why is that a “politically difficult call”? It seems a no-brainer to me.
LikeLike
Something the New York state legislature should be aware of: 200,000 students = about 400,000 parents (eligible voters) and even more grandparents, uncles, cousins, etc.
LikeLike
Don’t forget their teachers who can vote… and the teachers’ family and friends, too. Those in elected positions should be mindful that those numbers add up quite quickly.
LikeLike
According to http://teaching.about.com/od/ProfilesInEducation/a/New-York-Education.htm , there are 209,527 public school teachers in the state. That number also grows when we add spouses, family hand friends. I think the Democratic Party in New York State is facing a crises unless they back off from corrupt, narcissist psychopathic freaks like Cuomo and start supporting the public schools over Hedge fund based corporate education reform.
LikeLike
You are exactly correct Lloyd! Isn’t pathetic it has come to the voting booth for our educational leaders & public servants to make healthy education decisions for our students.
LikeLike
Definitely following to see what happens! I wish you all the best of luck.
LikeLike
Brilliant.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on stopcommoncorenys and commented:
Finally!
LikeLike
What about getting Flanagan removed as Senate Education chair? He is another one of the corrupt Albany politicos who is supported by Michelle Rhee’s “Students First” pocketbook. I hope Cuomo is choking on Sandra Lee’s “semi-homemade” vittles over these demands. Get ready for the threats from Albany. If Cuomo does not capitulate and encourage his heavy heart dems in the Assembly to get rid of Tisch, there will be a complete an utter dismantling of Albany, piece by piece. Still think this is being driven by the union Andy? Guess again!
LikeLike
Precisely.
Public-school educated Flanagan (District #6 where his father served as chair in the humanities dept.) should know better!
Flanagan’s number one campaign contributor was none other than Koch-funded, Michelle Rhee.
What a travesty!
He’s getting ready to step down, however, as he’s sold out and set his sights on becoming Suffolk County Executive. So much the worse for Suffolk.
What a shame, John used to behave like a gentleman. Not sure where he went so wrong. Let’s pray he has a change of heart and starts to stand up and do the right thing for the children.
LikeLike
Any bets that the charter sector will soon start marketing itself as a “Common Core Test Free Zone”.
LikeLike
Good point, Duane.
This is an issue that has been discussed – November 2013:
Common Core vs. Charter School Independence
http://www.realclearpolicy.com/articles/2013/11/19/common_core_vs_charter_school_independence_738.html
LikeLike
Great video on the fight in NY. Even a couple funny moments. To often, people invoke Hitler when fighting over ideology, but it seems so apropo in this video. https://youtu.be/OvKVkitKOgk
LikeLike
Cross posted at
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/NY-Leaders-of-Opt-Out-Move-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Demands_Diane-Ravitch_Education_FAILURE-150423-846.html#comment542336
LikeLike
It is clear we took the wrong education reform path. I think this can be likened to driving with one’s husband and getting him to stop to ask for directions. It is really hard for some individuals to admit they are wrong. We should say to the reformers, “It’s o.k. to admit you were wrong. It is entirely human. Now lets begin revisions and get on with it.”
LikeLike
If I may correct your statement:
“I think this can be likened to driving with one’s WIFE and getting HER to TO GO IN THE DIRECTION OF THE DESTINATION INSTEAD OF GOING AROUND HER A** TO GET TO HER ELBOW.
LikeLike
Tsk, tsk, Duane. Mustn’t curse on Diane’s blog.
LikeLike
Over the years I have heard/read many people curse without ever using cuss words.
LikeLike
As many have said. I hope this movement gets traction in ALL the states, especially here in Indiana. [Fat chance of that I fear although there is a movement afoot.]
LikeLike
It starts with one person, Gordon. : D
LikeLike
It would be even BIGGER if Mulgrew ACTUALLY got off his posterior and joined the uprising.
How’s that seat at the table you fool?
LikeLike
But those mighty unions and their supposed “lideres” are. . .
. . . not doing anything other than sucking up to the big boys (sic).
LikeLike
Or is that sucking the big boys?
LikeLike
Parents in Los Angeles have been ‘warned’ that schools will loose funding (especially TITLE 1) if students OPT OUT. Have tried putting this fear into perspective and to bed but there are those who are intimidated and are listening to a principal saying that students should take the test ‘because this year they don’t count anyway’. hmmmm…nice backbone Principal X. Doesn’t it count that we take a stand and refuse to subject our kids to this madness.
LikeLike
Violence, the last resort of bullies.
Refuse to be intimidated.
LikeLike
Once again Lisa and Eric and allow our allies lead the way. I volunteer to be on that review of standards crew,
LikeLike
Sorry.. And all of our allies….
LikeLike
I really admire this group’s organizing work and would love to see it stretch nationwide.
LikeLike
Local School Boards need to say, “We bear the burden of more than fifty percent of the costs of providing NY students an education and we will not have Albany, or Washington, DC impose upon us unreasonable testing regimes.” Over the last two weeks more than a billion dollars in property taxes were squandered as districts spent six days giving flawed tests to about half their students while the other kids were supervised in the café, gym or library reading. Those kids should have been in class benefitting from instruction. Parents have said loudly to Cuomo and Tisch that they, “can go to hell.” It is time now for local school districts to pick up on the courage of parents and say, “NO MORE OF THIS NONSENSE.” Education in NY has devolved into a fiasco under Tusch and Cuomo. They will not be able to bring in a quality Commissioner so Tisch must go immediately! End this fiasco! Phone,email, picket the offices of your legislator!
LikeLike
““We bear the burden of more than fifty percent of the costs of providing NY students an education and we will not have Albany, or Washington, DC impose upon us unreasonable testing regimes.””
“Goddamn Gump you’re a genius*”
That right there Louie is one of the most logical takes on this whole debate that I’ve read/seen.
That’s a 100 font TAGO! in my book.
That’s meant as an independent exclamation, not as a statement about you M. Louie!
LikeLike
I hope that if you are coming to the Windy City this weekend that we get a chance to meet up.
LikeLike
Duane,
I will be there. Say hello.
LikeLike
Will do. I plan on getting there early each morning. Perhaps like in Austin where we said hello early Sunday morning or I’ll just try to meet up with you (and the many others) along the way. I know your time will be in demand.
LikeLike
I think Tisch’s biggest worry is that she looks like she just head-butted a belt-sander!
LikeLike
Totally. I know that if you didn’t think I were attractive, that would be my biggest worry in life.
LikeLike
These should be our demands. those are too vague
We now know that change is coming
:
What might that look like?
1. Ms. Tisch stepping down from the Regents.
2. A moratorium on Math and ELA testing for three years.
3. Suspension of the Common Core Curriculum and the States “Engage NY” agenda, to be replaced by the former NY State Curriculum.
4. Suspension of agreements with Pearson and other
companies producing Common Core Materials and testing.
(This must be done soon, before the Transpacific Partnership Fast Track legislation is approved by Congress, which would hold the States and school districts liable for any possible losses by these companies “into the future”, should these agreements between corporations and governments be suspended.)
LikeLike
Thank-you everyone for a fabulous press release. Some excellent ideas in the comments as well. I am going to pass along to my local school board “Memphis Louie’s” comment about their paying more than 50% and so they get to call the shots. And I agree with “Joseph” on all 4 points. Perhaps together we can do this!
LikeLike
http://www.humansofnewyork.com/post/117200038456/schools-have-really-shifted-their-focus-to
This teacher is spot on and I think part of the reason children give up easily has to do with test prep. One of the “hints” my child received is not to spend too much time on a problem that is too hard and to move on to another problem. That’s great advice for a standardized test, but lousy advice for the rest of life.
I think a HS student learning test taking tricks for the SATs, or an adult taking the bar, etc. knows this type of advice is just for tests, but I worry about 8 year-olds receiving this “advice”.
LikeLike
Informative article about Pearson –
http://libn.com/2015/04/23/uncommon-costs/
LikeLike
At least in NY state, parents can opt their children out of testing. In Illinois, they can ‘t (although parents are refusing to let their students take the tests.)
Illinois Gov. .001 Percent (Bruce Rauner) has now pledged to veto a bill that would allow parents to opt their children out of test. Yes, that Rauner who has a charter school named after him, and whose private foundation is now under federal investigation for the CPS/SUPES scandal. And, lest we forget, who clouted his daughter into the prestigious Walter Payton high school.
SOURCE: Crain’s Chicago Business, April 22, 2015
Headline: Rauner threatens veto of school-testing bill
http://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20150422/BLOGS02/150429903/rauner-threatens-veto-of-school-testing-bill
LikeLike
Breaking News:
Tisch extends “deadline” to enact new teacher evaluation system to September 1st 2016 – what will fill the vacuum? Can she extend it even more come next year?
http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/albany/2015/04/8566665/tischs-evaluation-delay-earns-lawmakers-praise-cuomos-ire
If there’s going to be a Tisch-Cuomo bout I want front row seats…I do wonder to some extent though if this is just political theater.
Cuomo gets to huff and puff about how tough he is on teachers and how things would be perfect if only he had his way. Tisch saves face and stands up to the governor and “for the children” will take this courageous stand. Lawmakers get to stand tough against Cuomo and applaud Tisch. Yay the good guys…win?
I don’t think anyone thought the deadline was realistic. Meanwhile we’ll still have the massive overtesting. And what kind of vetting of this process will be done in the meanwhile? Who, exactly, is responsible for coming up with this brilliantly complex formula covering all educators including the projections for individual students, melding of their “results” against the projections for every single teacher from millions of students? The difficulty of the tests, and the raw score conversions?
This seems like a truly pyrrhic victory (a concept I’m afraid our students won’t learn).
And is Cuomo going to pull a different tough guy act come the budget of next year with other brilliant schemes – perhaps demanding control of the Regents so he can win his battle over Tisch?
I don’t believe for one moment these 2 are opposed on anything – this is to pacify people until they can send another shock into the system.
LikeLike