Chris Hayes interviewed Arne Duncan and Peter Greene reports on what happened.
You can imagine Arne artfully dodging and weaving when Chris asked straightforward questions. Arne insists that Common Core is confused with the unpopular tests (that Arne funded). Arne suggests that politicians are upset by Common Core but Real Parents welcome it.
“Hayes: I want to talk about Common Core for a second. (And he smiles a little smile, like “let’s do this silly thing, I’m going to ask a question, you’re going to sling baloney, it’ll be fun”). Are you surprised by how controversial Common Core (which he characterizes as “kind of an obscure issue in certain ways”) has become?
“Duncan: “It’s actually very simple. The goal’s to have high standards.” So, kids, the whole national consistency issue, the whole being able to compare kids in Idaho and Maine, the whole keeping everyone on the same page so mobile students will never get lost– that’s no longer the point.
“Duncan goes on to display how much he doesn’t understand about how this works. He talks about how, under NCLB, too many states dummied down standards. He says this was “to make politicians look good.” I’d be more inclined to say “to avoid punitive consequences for their schools.” If Arne had reached my conclusion (and really, given that he was in charge of a large school district at the time, it’s kind of amazing that he didn’t reach my conclusion) then perhaps he wouldn’t have figured that the solution was to make the consequences of high stakes testing even more punitive than before.
“Insert story here of how schools lied to students about how ready they were for college. So brave governors decided to stop lying to children. “Let’s have true college and career ready standards for every single child.” As always I wonder why reaching that conclusion leads to a next step where one says, “Let’s hire a couple of guys who have no real education experience, either pedagogical or developmental, and have them whip something up.”
As Greene shows, this is vintage Arne. Adroitly changing the subject, mouthing high-minded platitudes, never accepting that parents have valid reasons to be upset by the administration’s unvarnished support for high-stakes testing, closing schools, and inviting entrepreneurs to cash in on the educationmarket. NCLB went wrong, he admits, but he never acknowledges that Race to the Top was no different philosophically from NCLB and far worse in actuality when judged by the whipping it has given to schools and educators.

When someone willfully lies that is the definition of evil!
LikeLike
It’s hard to call Duncan “adroit” after his comment about the white suburban moms who refuse to believe how stupid their kids are.
LikeLike
Duncan, the artful dodger, tries so hard to not reveal the man behind the curtain. It has taken some time, but the public is catching on to his twists and turns.
LikeLike
Arne’s absurd remarks have been collected on Diane’s blog.
The US Department of Corporate Education must be abolished.
LikeLike
LLC, Be *very* careful about what you wish for…
There are lots of powerful, monied people who would like to abolish the Dept of Education–we could just roll it into the Department of Labor… After all, the idea goes, what is the public education system for but to create future (obedient) workers for the corporate machine…???
LikeLike
Well that would be the point to begin pushing: the underlying philosophy of NCLB was the same as Race to The Top. Exactly. That point needs to be emphasized. The punitive part. Those who care about public school need to echo that. We still have too much tap dancing along to the “get hard on teachers” music.
In my own child’s district leadership is (blindly, smugly, ignorantly, optimistically, stupidly, unfortunately, willfully, trustingly, not sure the adverb here) counting on Race to the Top measures to close the achievement gap in five years.
It makes me nervous.
LikeLike
Duncan is a certifiable liar. CCSS is just plain awful and so are those tests. Arne is given the script from the DEFORMERS and they know he’s a good puppet for the wealthy. He likes the perks, the dark money, and being part of that unholy club. Bet he gets money under the table to foist harm our young and our public school teachers.
Wonder what he’s is on? Oh…the drug is called “power” trip. SIC. The games played in Cingress makes me ill. They are the chosen ones by the 1%-ers to make laws to own every resource in this country. The DEFORMERS would have us pay just to breathe.
So much in this country is about PACKAGING lies.
LikeLike
Duncan: Fixing achievement gaps is the big achievement..
Really? In Denver Colorado, the quintessential reform school district that consistently flies under the radar (appropriate for the flyover time zone I guess ) the achievement or testing gap has INCREASED over ten years 7% in reading to 36%, 20% in math to 34%, and 9% on writing to 36%. I wish someone would ask Secretary Duncan to show me the data. For such data driven business guys that is often the missing element. Without it they can and do say anything. Accountability, Mr. Duncan.
This really says it all if he is citing fixing the achievement gap as the success of ten years of reform. We are in more trouble than we thought!
LikeLike
What they’re not being honest about re: the Common Core testing is how the tests will be used.
My concern is that these tests will be plugged in as a proxy everywhere and in every decision- the tests will devour everything in their path. Despite repeated assertions that it is not “all about the test” it will become “all about the test” because they will rely on these tests for all kinds of decisions. It makes SENSE to rely on the tests for all kinds of decisions, given how they have been sold as the measure of “College and Career Readiness” and given state investment in them. They can’t both sell the tests as an accurate measure of College and Career Readiness and then tell people “well, though, you shouldn’t rely on them for that”. That is not going to happen.
Here’s an example:
“Officials at the Colorado Department of Higher Education and the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) on March 8 announced that Adams State University and Aims Community College will begin using PARCC, the state’s K-12 assessment of college and career readiness, to determine whether entering college freshman are prepared to take college level courses.”
Obviously, they fully intended to use these scores to determine if students needed remediation when they entered college. That’s “high stakes” for students.
They need to be straight with parents on how the tests will be used. These claims that “nuance” will somehow be employed and the tests will be used solely to determine “where your child is” is simply not true.
One of two things is true: they cannot predict how the tests will be used by states OR they have some idea how the tests will be used but they simply aren’t telling parents. They can’t keep spouting this MUSH that is contradicted by what they’re actually doing.
Here’s the question: what will be determined using these scores? High school graduation? Promotion from 3rd to 4th grade? Whether you’re slotted into remediation at a community college? What else? Parents deserve to know this before this thing is set in cement and the whole ed reform chorus drowns out debate.
LikeLike
Of course, it is about the test. How else can they support the claim that public education has failed! The built in failure will give them the justification to take over and close more schools.
LikeLike
It is particularly important to tell the current “cohort” of parents and students how these test scores will be used, what decisions will be made based on them, because the Common Core testing is NEW. That means a whole huge group of kids were somewhere in the middle of their public school progression when these tests were put in. How does this affect them? If I’m in 10th grade, is it fair to start measuring me on standards that did not exist (for me, as a student) until I reached high school?
I mean, come on. That strikes me as brutally unfair. The whole group that is in school now just gets thrown overboard- “good luck with those tests on the brand new standards that will be used to determine all kinds of high stakes decisions! Sorry but you just happened to be a freshman when we were disrupting!”
LikeLike
Sing to the tune used in Canadian hockey games when someone is booted from the game:
“Nah, nah, nah, nah;
Nah, nah, nah, hah,
So long Arne,
Goodbye.”
LikeLike
The second line of the second paragraph of the posting:
“Arne insists that Common Core is confused with the unpopular tests (that Arne funded).”
Dr. Frederick Hess, American Enterprise Institute, winner of the Letting The Cat Out Of The Bag Award 2013:
[start excerpt]
In truth, the idea that the Common Core might be a “game-changer” has little to do with the Common Core standards themselves, and everything to do with stuff attached to them, especially the adoption of common tests that make it possible to readily compare schools, programs, districts, and states (of course, the announcement that one state after another is opting out of the two testing consortia is hollowing out this promise).
But the Common Core will only make a dramatic difference if those test results are used to evaluate schools or hire, pay, or fire teachers; or if the effort serves to alter teacher preparation, revamp instructional materials, or compel teachers to change what students read and do. And, of course, advocates have made clear that this is exactly what they have in mind. When they refer to the “Common Core,” they don’t just mean the words on paper–what they really have in mind is this whole complex of changes.
[end excerpt]
For a link to the original posting of Dr. Hess and crucial contextual info, go to—
Link: https://deutsch29.wordpress.com/2013/12/28/the-american-enterprise-institute-common-core-and-good-cop/
A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
But it’s only wasted when you have one to waste.
Which explains Mr. Duncan’s fascination with a song in THE WIZARD OF OZ that he has posted on the ceiling of his DoE office and which he often looks at, lying on his back and humming away furiously:
“I could while away the hours
Conferrin’ with the flowers
Consultin’ with the rain
And my head, I’d be scratchin’
While my thoughts were busy hatchin’
If I only had a brain”
And that’s just the first two verses.
😎
LikeLike
Pretty thin gruel, but I’m relieved to see MSNBC (at least Hayes and Harris-Perry) are finally beginning to take a look at this issue
LikeLike
Duncanister= PARCC steroid and PEDs that feed Frankenstein in DOE.
LikeLike
“Sympathy For The Duncan”
Please allow me to introduce myself
I’m a man long since disgraced
I’ve been around for a long, long year
Stole many a child’s soul and faith
And I was ’round when Barack O’
Had his moment of doubt and pain
Made damn sure Billy Gates
Washed his hands and sealed his fate
Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game
I stuck around Chicago-land
When I saw it was a time for a change
Killed the schools and the CTU
Parents all screamed in vain
I stacked and yanked
Held a point guard’s rank
Helped the charters rage
Teachers walked the plank
Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name, oh yeah
Ah, what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game, oh yeah
I watched with glee
While young Miss Hell Rhee
Taught for just ten days
Using masking tape
I shouted out,
“Who’s killin’ Public Schools?”
When after all
It is Bill and me
Let me please introduce myself
I’m a man long since disgraced
And I laid traps for Pre-K kids
Taking tests until they screeched go away
Pleased to meet you
Hope you guessed my name, oh yeah
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game, oh yeah, get down, baby
Pleased to meet you
Hope you guessed my name, oh yeah
But what’s confusing you
Is just the nature of my game
And every kid is just a data point
And all us reformers saints
As heads is tails
Just call me Arne-D
Cause I’m in need of some restraint
So if you meet me
Have some courtesy
Have some sympathy, and some taste
Be sure to use my Common Core
Or I’ll lay your schools to waste
Pleased to meet you
Hope you guessed my name, um yeah
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game,
LikeLike
Ha!
LikeLike
To me it is surprising that Arne Duncan would allow himself to be interviewed with an intellect like Chris Hayes. Duncan may be as ignorant about quality journalism as he is about education.
LikeLike
Luckily (in this case), Duncan is as arrogant as he is ignorant. He probably thinks he did a “heckuva job” on that interview.
LikeLike
K Quinn: like many of the “thought leaders” and heavyweights of the self-styled “education reform” movement, Arne Duncan is characterized by a fierce and studied cluelessness.
It’s the same sort of attitude that produced the following remark by the NJ Commissioner of Education:
[start]
What’s astonishing is to read defenders of “reform” finding silver linings or straws to grasp at. Some claim that Cami has plenty of supporters, others say that success is around the corner. Just be patient. Christie’s state commissioner says, “Christie, through a spokesman, declined to comment. According to Christie’s education commissioner:
“It will take time to see the type of progress we all want,” he said. “Whatever we’re doing, we need to double down.”
[end]
See this blog in the following posting for the above—
Link: https://dianeravitch.net/2015/03/04/lyndsey-layton-governor-christie-fails-in-newark/
It’s the kind of stereotyped teenage snark that finds its way onto sitcoms and into bad jokes. Ask rheephormsters what they actually do and want and believe and if they were honest you’d get: “Double down on whatevers.”
But what else to expect? That rigid mindset is typical of the crowd that Arne runs with, always quoting snippets of Marxist orthodoxy to each other:
“I’ve got the brain of a four year old. I’ll bet he was glad to be rid of it.”
And trust me when I say they never consider for even a moment turning their backs on their Groucho.
😎
LikeLike