Juan Gonzalez, the crack investigative reporter for the New York Daily News, has written a stunning expose of the connection between hedge fund money and politicians’ support for privately managed charter schools.
He writes that parents demonstrated outside the Harvard Club, where equity investors were meeting to learn about “Bonds & Blackboards: Investing in Charter Schools.” The conference was sponsored by the Gates Foundation and the Walton Family Foundation.
Inside, the investors were learning about how to use their money to expand the charter sector.
He writes:
Hedge fund executives have unleashed a tsunami of money the past few years aimed at getting New York’s politicians to close more public schools and expand charter schools.
They’ve done it through direct political contributions, through huge donations to a web of pro-charter lobbying groups, and through massive TV and radio commercials.
Since 2000, 570 hedge fund managers have shelled out nearly $40 million in political contributions in New York State, according to a recent report by Hedge Clippers, a union-backed research group.
The single biggest beneficiary has been Andrew Cuomo, who received $4.8 million from them.
Several of the governor’s big hedge fund donors, such as Carl Icahn, of Icahn Enterprises, Julian Robertson of Tiger Management, and Daniel Loeb, of Third Point LLC, are also longtime backers of charter schools.
Loeb is chairman of the board of the Success Academy network run by former City Councilwoman Eva Moskowitz. He’s given $62,000 to Cuomo, while 18 other members of the Success Academy board or their family members have given nearly $600,000 to the governor, according to state campaign records.
Gonzalez documents the showering of millions by hedge fund executives on other groups, such as New Yorkers for a Balanced Albany, Democrats for Education Reform, and Families for Excellent Schools. All of these names are ironic; the people who give to New Yorkers for a Balanced Albany don’t actually want “balance,” they want a corporate-friendly Legislature in which Republicans maintain control of the State Senate. Democrats for Education Reform includes many who are not Democrats, who have contempt for public schools and their teachers, and who are big supporters of charter schools and privatization. My favorite is “Families for Excellent Schools” because it implies that lots of poor and minority families joined together and raised $10 million overnight, when in fact the “families” are the families of billionaires who may never have set foot into a public school, except possibly when they were children, before they became Masters of the Universe on Wall Street.
Gonzalez concludes that all those millions invested in Cuomo’s campaign are paying off in his insistence on opening more charter schools.
It would have been nice if the crack investigative reporter had actually gone inside the building. Who knows, there might have been something to investigate.
More likely than not they wouldn’t have let him in as I’m sure the conference was filled up by those willing to fork out a measly (if I remember correctly the conference) something like $3,000.
I thought it was advertised as free. And press usually get in free to events like this. If they refused to let him in, that itself would be the interesting story.
This reinforces what I’ve stated numerous times here: The biggest problem we have is the extreme distribution of income and wealth in our society. The privatization of public education is a by product of this. With so much money in so few hands we are losing or democracy. Robert Reich stated that power is in the hands of big corporations and the super rich. Everyone else has essentially no effect on government.
“Robert Reich stated that power is in the hands of big corporations and the super rich. Everyone else has essentially no effect on government.”
And that my friends is Fascism.
I am glad to see that parents are actively campaigning against charter expansion in New York. It resulted in “The Daily News” doing a story on the problem. This is free publicity! I am thrilled to see parents making some noise. Their credibility can’t be attacked the way teachers can. More parent protests, please!
Well, about that.
Juan Gonzalez is usually a solid reporter and lord knows that his heart is in the right place, and what this piece reports about the connections between the hedge fund industry and the various advocacy groups is true, but he left out some very important details.
The Alliance for Quality Education isn’t a parent group, it is a “dark money” 501(c)(4) organization funded almost entirely by the UFT (the union for NYC public school teachers) and NYSUT (the union for the rest of the state). The spokesperson quoted in the piece is a paid employee (AQE’s advocacy director for New York City).
Credibility and good journalism demand full transparency and getting the facts right. Gonzalez failed those tests here.
Tim,
The spokesperson for AQE has six children in the NYC public schools.
…and is an employee of a “dark money” organization that exists solely to advance teacher’s union causes. The omission by Gonzalez is inexcusable and you know it.
Dark Money? In the UFT? Puhlease. I just peed myself with laughter. The 1% billionaires use their dark money to create chaos and return on investment for themselves and disenfranchise the rest of us. Dark money. LOL
One problem is that a casual reader of this post (and Gonzales’s article) might not understand that the parents who were protesting may have been paid to be there, i.e., it’s part of their job. Maybe some were unpaid volunteers, and maybe the paid employees are not paid much (I’m sure they aren’t), but that doesn’t mean this isn’t relevant.
“Robbin The Hood”
Robbin the hood
Of public schools
Subbin’ with flood
Of charter tools
Over the Hedge
With his Merry Men
Robbin The Hood
Has struck again
Are you aware that the Robinhood Foundation exists, and it is operating in New York City? It has truly amazing stats on jow investors think about the worth of preschool for low-income families, along with other social services that should not be needed…in the humble opinion of the billionaires. You can see the calculations here. https://www.robinhood.org/sites/default/files/user-uploaded-images/Robin%20Hood%20Metrics%20Equations_BETA_Sept-2014.pdf
yes, that’s where the poem idea originally came from.
truth is indeed stranger than fiction
This is the metrics of poverty. Just because Robin Hood “assigns a value” to various interventions does not mean the numbers are accurate. We both know that people are far more complex than any statistical model some foundation can generate. They are making a lot of assumptions that make their conclusions no better than a statistical crystal ball. It reminds me of VAM.
Most poor people would be better off if we had a better social safety net. The problem is trying to convince the government to pay for it and trying to convince a lot of Americans that punishment, like testing does not lift anyone from poverty.
I think it’s worse than that, because the underlying idea is that really wealthy people and entities will only invest in programs or policies that they support. They put a huge thumb on the scale towards approaches THEY like. They’re driving public policy but there’s no public input and no accountability, because none of them are elected.
I read a long account of a Toledo public high school that Gates experimented on for a decade. He’s gone now-his foundation lost interest or something (the public high school survives) but it is absolutely amazing to me that he was essentially given this public high school and told “do what you want with it”.
He bought that school. You or I would NEVER be given that kind of power unless we got elected, and even then we’d have to deal with the public, negotiate with other elected officials, weigh competing priorities etc.
He doesn’t have to do any of that. He walks in and purchases control.
Chiara
If you find that article about Toledo, please forward.
You make a good point. All of this sense of entitlement comes from the billionaires that believe they count far more than other people. That is why we are becoming an oligarchy with the will of the people dismissed.
“All lives have equal worth”
Every life has equal worth
To businessmen like me:
Consumers all, to death from birth
And workers, for low fee.
FYI. Scary s–t!
Sent from my iPhone
What is completely missing from this piece:
Any evidence whatsoever that the hedge fund investors who politically support charter schools have ever invested in the tax-exempt municipal bonds that were the subject of the “Bonds and Blackboards” conference.
Seems quite likely that there is close to zero overlap. Take Dan Loeb. His hedge fund reportedly makes its money from buying troubled companies, replacing management, and turning them around. This is nothing to do with tax-exempt bonds related to charter schools. Thus, the fact that other unrelated banks invest in tax-exempt bonds has nothing to do with Dan Loeb, and certainly doesn’t count as an “expose” of anything about him.
Well, not at least for now. I don’t think any hedge-fund managers are jerk to allow that situation to happen. Otherwise, they would be in serious trouble.
What’s also missing is any evidence about who this conference was geared toward, who attended it, what the presentations were, what the discussions were, etc. As I said above, it’s a shame that Gonzales chose to just repeat what’s already been reported and insert a couple quotes from AQE rather than doing any original reporting. It would have been an interesting story, and it only would have required Gonzales to walk through the front door of the building (assuming he was personally outside the building in the first place, as the article suggests; he may have just talked to AQE on the phone).
Cross-posted at
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Hedge-fund-execs-money-fo-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Charter-School-Failure_Charter-Schools_Donors_Education-150321-335.html#comment537982
Reblogged this on onewomansjournal and commented:
Oh my goodness. This is a shame. Shame, shame, shame on these 1%ers.