I have decided to break precedent today. This is the only post you will see.
I wish you and your family a happy, healthy New Year. I hope that 2015 is a year of dreams fulfilled, mountains climbed, happiness achieved. I hope all of us are able to meet the inevitable challenges and setbacks with heart and fortitude. I hope we learn and practice the virtues of patient struggle, unflagging endurance, the ability to build alliances, and the willingness to seek common ground with others.
2014 was a rough year for me, physically, and I am glad to bid it farewell. I spent most of the year thinking I would never walk again without a walker or a cane. I’m happy to report that I am walking without either, thanks to the intervention of a wise rehabilitation specialist in Cincinnati who built a rigid (temporary) cast for my bum leg. I have to exercise every single day to keep the scar tissue in my knee supple, but that’s not so awful. I can walk! I can walk! I can’t walk long distances (as I used to do), I can’t sit for too long, I can’t stand for too long, I kick my leg up and down under the dining table. You may occasionally notice a slight limp, but that’s nothing. I can walk, and for that I am grateful.
In terms of the education issues that concern us, we made great headway. Charter studies continue to show that private management has no “secret sauce.” The media in Ohio, Michigan, and Florida woke up and began to expose the hollowness of the charter advocates’ claims of superiority to public schools. Except for the charters that actively seek to help the neediest children, the charter boasting is wearing thin. Even better news: Public and professional confidence in VAM continues to plummet. Common Core testing–with its unrealistic passing marks– is in big trouble. The anti-high-stakes testing movement continues to grow in every state. Parents send their children to school to be educated, not to be sorted, rated, and labeled.
As Peter Greene put it, the greatest win of 2014 was the fact that teachers continued to teach, continued to knock them selves out day after day, despite the attacks on them and on their profession. I can’t resist quoting a small part of Peter’s wonderful post:
In environments ranging from openly hostile to merely unsupportive, teachers went into their classrooms and did their best to meet the needs of their students. Teachers helped millions of young human become smarter, wiser, more capable, more confident, and better educated. Millions of teachers went to school, met students where they were, and helped those students move forward, helped them grasp what it meant to be fully human, to be the most that they could be. Teachers helped millions of students learn to read and write and figure and draw and make music and play games and know history and understand science and a list of things so varied and rich that I have no room here for them all.
When so many groups were slandering us and our own political leaders were giving us a giant middle finger, we squared our shoulders and said, “Well, dammit, I’ve got a job to do, and if even if I’ve got to go in there and do it with my bare hands in a hailstorm, I’m going to do it.” And we did.
Leonie Haimson made her list of the best and worst of 2014. I would add the blow-up of the $1 billion iPad fiasco in Los Angeles as another momentous event, which should make us all warier of throwing money at technology without careful planning.
Not all news was good news. The midterm elections were a disaster for supporters of public education, especially at the state level. Several anti-education governors were re-elected. There is always next time. American history tends to move in cycles, and we must work together to hasten the end of the current cycle of greed and indifference to suffering. We must restore a healthy belief in democracy and ward off the forces of autocracy. We must fight to protect our children’s privacy from data miners. We must do a better job of informing parents and citizens about the peril posed by privatization to their community’s public schools. And we must be relentless in informing the media that the movement to demonize the teaching profession is NOT reform. True reformers seek to improve public schools and to honor the teaching profession, not to close schools, fire teachers, and turn their children over to entrepreneurs.
The Network for Public Education continues to build alliances and to connect activists within and between states. Here is a link to the Top Ten “Why We Will Win” Stories of 2014. Yes, we will persevere in our fight to protect our public schools from hostile takeovers and our efforts to improve them. Our second national conference will be held in Chicago on April 25-26, 2015. I hope you will plan to join us and meet with your friends and colleagues from across the nation.
No question there’s a long road ahead of us. But we must and will persist. This must be our cause and our mission. We are many, they are few. Democracy is on our side, and we are on the side of democracy. Not efficiency; not sorting and labeling children for the workforce; not preparing for global competition; but preparing children to live full and free lives in our society, able to make wise choices for themselves, with every chance to develop their interests, talents, and abilities. We must not rest until every child has equality of educational opportunity.
Thanks for what you do!!
Sent from my iPhone
Happy New Year… and a healthy one
Breaking precedent?
😳
An ed blog that isn’t homogenized, standardized, prepackaged and for sale to the highest bidder? *And not even lexile rated and approved by the BBBC?*
😱
“Diane Ravitch’s blog A site to discuss better education for all.”
😃
A favorite among very Greek guys that love truth and beauty:
“To find yourself, think for yourself.” [Socrates]
Happiness and health in the new year to you and yours.
😎
As always, Krazy TA speaks truth with subtlety. Yes, Diane, you gave us all a place to coalesce and now there are cooperative movements growing nationwide supporting public schools. We in LA could never have pushed forward without your vast blog site….so thank you again.
I am glad you finally found the correct medical professional who could identify and improve your injured leg. Stay well and happy, and I wish you all good things in 2015.
…and of course….a huge Happy New Year also to all colleagues and friends here who have educated and supported me, us, in the battle with LAUSD and the privatizers.
Happy New Year! Thanks for all your hard work!
Go get ’em, Diane, Peter, Leone, and NPE!
A Happy New Year to you all!
Leonie 😉
The results of Diane’s investment in me are reflected in my New Years post:
http://deutsch29.wordpress.com/2015/01/01/happy-new-year/
Thank you, Diane. I appreciate you.
Well, I might go into withdrawal with only one post today, but I guess you deserve it. Happy New Year!
Diane, enjoy your well-deserved (albeit short) break.
Thanks for all you do!
I am happy you can WALK! Personal independence is great! Happy 2015! Thanks for your passionate stance on quality education for ALL!
Best wishes to all for a happy New Year. May 2015 be a year of joy in learning for you and your students. And let us hope that 2015 is a year where district, state, and federal leaders exercise better judgment based in wisdom, evidence, and listening to teachers.
And thank you Diane for your writing and discussion. Best wishes for your continued health and progress with your knee.
Happy New Year and thank you for all you do to support children and educators!
The news of your knee is wonderful! A happy new year to you and your family. Thank you for speaking truth to power, and for giving us all the information we need to do the same.
Thanks for all you do. Especially speaking truth to power/politicians. Too bad Arne Duncan does not learn from your postings.
Diane,
Thank you for your words of encouragement. The highs and lows are very difficult to take. We work very hard and without funding.
Gates has provided a charter school operator with $4M and another charter school will open in Seattle. and I hate having Gates in our backyard. Yet, we await the Supreme Court decision.
Gates and others continue to pour millions of dollars into privatizing our educational system. I’m finding recent events in York City to be very frightening and I fear we’re watching the ghost of the future.
Thanks for your work and I wish you well in the New Year.
Beautifully stated, Diane. Happy New Year to you, too. I am eternally grateful for your work and wish you good health in 2015 and the continued improvement of your knee.
Adding my thanks for ALL you do.
Happy New Year and we all wish the very best for you in the coming year and for all the succeeding ones also.
God bless:
Thank you for continuing to work for public education. Peter Greene was right. Teachers will continue to go in and educate their students despite the attack.
Also grateful for your work and this blog, and for your support of studies in the arts as a vital part of education. Wonderful that you have found a remedy for severe problems with your knee.
When I realized that I wasn’t going to be hopping around like I was when I was 30 or spending two hours in the heavy free weight gym, I slowly adjusted. The main thing is a modicum of good health, family and friends. Being blessed with the acuity to continue the kinds of work we do here and elsewhere is an additional blessing. But it was good to discover “Fashionable Canes” and make sure I had a cool one (or two) to navigate this brave new world. Happy New Year.
With love & admiration: Happy New Year !
It was a pleasure for Bill and I to meet you in Syracuse at your presentation there. We feel honored to have done so and feel so fortunate to be able to receive up to the minute information about the ill effects of Common Core. Our lives have become full of information since reading your book, “Reign of Error,” and listening to many of your presentations. We hope one day in 2015 we will open up our email from the blog and see the heading, Common Core is OVER! We wish so much the North Country (above Syracuse) could hear you and realize what is going on. Thank you for all you are doing for all of us. Best wishes for good health and a very Happy 2015!
~Bill & Debbie Dermady
I wonder if you have any perspectives about the nineties and what might have been going on in urban education. There must have been something….right now we have those who are all aboard for reform that looks suspiciously like a subtle form of resegregation, based more on wealth than race, and those who used to be on that train, until it started dawning on them where the train was headed. I doubt if I can do it…..but I am starting to form the structure of a novel…..the central character is likely to be a person appointed to Missouri’s state board of education in 1991…..he is from silver dollar city and after 23 years, he is still there—as president, and usually the only person quoted by the press. I have a lot of drama and excruciating details from 2004 on….and I am not sure whether anything happened that mattered very much in the 1990’s. There must have been something.
When the fight in me is waning, this is where I come. Thank you, Diane and everyone in this community, for the support, wisdom, excitement, and battle cries. Wishing you all a happy and healthy new year.
God help us all as the whistle blows again in a few days and we jump back into the educational boxing ring. Peter Greene describes perfectly some of the conditions and forces dealt with that comprised being an educator in 2014. When given that giant middle finger though I remember this: “Hold your head high and your middle finger higher!” There are times when it is indeed called for. When expressing sentiments for a Happy New Year I’m not sure which word I would rather place more emphasis on; that it will be happier or that it will signify new and better things to come. I optimistically hope for both during this 2015 school year.
Thank you so much, Diane. Happy New Year to you and your family!! Love from Minneapolis.
Happy New Year to all! If you want a treat, and you really want to see democracy in action, tune into the live stream of the Philadelphia Mummers Day Parade. This is the people’s parade, of by and for the people, without corporate sponsorship, although the broadcast is sponsored by a casino. This parade is a testimony to the power of organization for those with a common goal. Let’s hope this type of energy carries us into the new year. FYI:http://phl17.com/live/
And best wishes to you, Dr. Ravitch. The joy you feel about being able to walk, even in a limited way, I feel about being able to see. In August, I had what I hope is my sixth and final retinal surgery, and I’m very happy with my improving vision. I can see mountains! I can see faces! May it continue long into the future
There is a lot we can say about this year in education. Much of the news is bad, some of it good. I take courage by the specific good work we teachers do in the classroom. I also find hope, when I find it, in the countless students who are unwilling to sit still and tolerate less than the well-rounded education they deserve.
So three cheers for student activists!
Dear Diane,
Happy New Year and best wishes for your continued, growing, good health and happiness. Thank you for your blog.
You have my deepest thanks and gratitude.
And the same to all your readers, fabulous commentators and authors of posts.
I fully believe you ripped this off. It is as beautiful as poetry. A gift to us all for this holiday.
Happy New Year to you too, Diane. Stay healthy!
Happy, healthy, new year to you too, Diane. Thanks for all you do.
Thank you for your efforts and inspiration. May 2015 be a blessed year for you, personally.
Margaret Pierson 1005 Woodmere Ave., Suite 2 Traverse City, MI 49686 231-357-5984
Walking right into 2015 – how wonderful for you. This is my first response ever, but probably my millionth read – thank you for your voice for all children and their learning. I heard you speak at Syracuse this past year and you planted a spark in me and opened the eyes of my supporting husband. I am my students voice and I will keep fighting through the wanna-be reform of public education. Thank you for educating me through this blog along with all the responses from supporters. 2015 will be the YEAR of the STUDENT! I will fight for that everyday! Happy 2015
Debi
One of the wonderful things about Diane’s blog is that it’s a place for EVERYONE to discuss “better education for all” -as opposed to the corporate imposed, top-down edicts that are stomping on true learning in our public schools.
This past week, I’ve been reading Bob Herbert’s book, “Losing Our Way” based on Diane’s recommendation. And it is a great book. Herbert quotes the historian Howard Zinn, who he said once told him, “‘If there is going to be change, real change, it will have to work its way from the bottom up, from the people themselves. That’s how change happens.'” pg. 7.
Yes, there are a lot of huge problems facing us. But I’m buoyed by Bob Herbert, Diane Ravitch and all the other people on here who care so much about our kids. We’re the people who can make real change in 2015. All the best to you.
Thanks so much for everything you do. I’m glad to hear you are walking better, and I hope you continue for a long, long time. I wish you all the best life has to offer!
Happy New Year to you, Professor Ravitch. Add me to the list of grateful educators who appreciate the remarkable work you continue to do. You inspire many of us to take a stand against the corporate takeover of public education. I hope either President Warren or President Sanders appoints you as Secretary of Education.
From your mouth to God’s ears.
Happy New Year, Diane, to you and yours. Thank you for showing us the path to fighting the good fight for public education. Continued best wishes for your health and mobility!
As George Will wrote in his Dec 24 column on Cuba, “U.S. doctrine about legitimacy has been clear since the Declaration of Independence: Governments derive their “just powers” from the consent of the governed.” Applies to education as well.
Happy 2015, Diane! Mahalo for all you do! Blessings…always!
So glad you can walk. health issues drain whatever remains our energy at our age.
YOU are unique.
We need you, and applaud you!
And we pray for you continued health and presence in this complex world.
Here’s a possibility:
Republicans dominated the midterm elections.
Like Arne, Obama and other Democrats, Republicans love all the “reform” ideas.
But…
The media generally hates Republicans.
So maybe NOW the media will take on the terribleness of school reform ideas because it will allow them another opportunity to disparage/criticize/shame/heckle Republicans.
Maybe?
I want to thank you profusely for your untiring advocacy for teachers, students, and for the public school system. You are awesome! May you have a very healthy and prosperous year.
Diane, wishing you a healthier and productive 2015 and glad to hear that you are walking free of a cane or walker. Respectfully, I must disagree with your comments regarding MI “waking up.” Michigan voters voted for more of the same failed education policies this past November 4. Mi Gov Snyder is getting ready to unleash his “portfolio” vision of a privatized Detroit and statewide public schools. Conditions here have never been worse and the only bright spot was stopping the MDE’s deplorable revisions proposed to our MI Administrative Rules for Special Education, albeit possibly temporary and with countless fights ahead. It is dark and ugly in MI for anyone who cares about children, teachers and public education.
Marcie, thank you for your comments. I didn’t say that Michigan was waking up; the re-election of Snyder was awful. What I said was that the media was waking up. I referred to the week-long series in the Detroit Free Press about the charters’ poor results and lack of accountability
Hi, Diane- I knew you were referring to the Free Press series. My comments were strictly focused on the pathetic reality of Michigan voters and term limits, and the fact that voters did not takeaway enough from the Free Press series or the subsequent articles on failing charters, to make a difference on November 4. I might sound like Scrooge, but this January 2015 is not a “Happy” new year for anyone in MI (not enough of us) who cares about children, public education and poverty.
Marcie, agreed. Michigan public schools are in deep trouble. So are those in Ohio, Wisconsin, Tennessee, and North Carolina. To name but a few states where corporate reformers are in control. New York has its own problems, with a governor who is a Democrat but wants to create a more punitive evaluation system for teachers and principals, dislikes the teachers unions (they didn’t endorse him), and wants to expand charters (he received millions in campaign contributions from hedge fund managers who support charters).
Thank you for your endless efforts on behalf of our students. May your health continue to improve and grant you more mobility. Rest assured the old-timers have found their voices and are speaking out against these failed reforms.
Diane- I am thankful every day for the national spotlight that you shine on public education in America. I think about current politics and with frustration know that Democrats need 8 weeks in detox from the corporatizing, charterizing, dismantling of our public schools, but I will continue to push them to find their GPS education-navigator and right this ship, because the Republicans want to end Public Ed and turn America’s children over to 14,000 plus inequitable school districts. Most days I don’t think that you and I will live to see Public Education rejuvenated and meeting the needs of “all” of our children, but I go to sleep every night knowing that there are a growing number of us fighting to our last breath, and final steps.
Marcie, we fight on, we persist, we will not quit. We will prevail because we are motivated by principle, not profit. When the profit is gone, most of the reformers will be gone too.
“We must not rest until every child has equality of educational opportunity.”
And we won’t. But you, our dear Boudicca, are entitled to a respite from time to time. As Susan DuFresne reminded us the other day, self-care comes first. To a healthy and feisty New Year!
Thank you!
.Health is everything.
For all you do, may God bless you. To the others here fighting the good fight, may God bless you. May this year bring us closer to educational equality for all children, better working conditions for public school teachers, and a booming middle class.
Ms. Ravitch,
I found this blog only about a month ago and this is my first response. I would like to be more engaged in 2015.
You mention two things to which I would like to respond.
First, you say that ‘we must work together’. You are right. I am a middle school principal in Pittsburgh, and I am a conservative American. I am independent of any political party but I am conservative as far as the role of government and traditional values. However, I am not an ideologue; I voted for Tom Wolfe for Governor of PA.
Many of my teachers are conservative as well. But whether conservative or liberal, democrat or republican, we are educators who support public schools, and we should stand together. I caution bloggers against pushing a leftist ideology. This fight has to come from the center or it will not be embraced or understood by conservatives outside of education.
To the second point; you say, ‘We must do a better job of informing parents and citizens…’ And ‘informing the media’. I am trying to do that now. I recently published a book titled ‘What the Public Doesn’t Know About Public Schools’. I wrote it to inform the general public about how public schools really work since politicians and the media have done such a poor job of that. It is written from the principal’s perspective and is based on my experiences with many of the topics that have been discussed here, starting with the fallacy of school rankings based on test scores. And I am an administrator who is very supportive of my teachers, as the book reflects.
So I want to ‘inform’ as you say, but being an unknown, it is hard to get the word out that the book exists. I hope it is ok to mention it here.
I am glad I found this blog. Thank you for what you do to support public schools.
Happy New Year!
Dear Mr. Wetmiller,
I have always believed that conservatives should be strong supporters of public education. Conservatives conserve traditional institutions, they don’t seek to blow them up and replace them with entrepreneurial for-profit schemes. Conservatives seek to strengthen their community, not divide it. Public schools have long been a community institution. I believe we are now in a battle between Main Street and Wall Street. Main Street values its community; Wall Street wants to find a way to get a share of public education dollars for investors. Welcome!
looks like I will have to check out your book….My nephew, Matt Grossmann and his wife, Sarah Reckhow, author of Follow the Money, usually have something for me to read….they first alerted me to KIPP and then Diane a few years ago…….this year, as we visited over Christmas, my present was a book “the teacher wars”…..by Dana Goldstein…..it is giving me a better historical perspective…..as well as some things to say to a nauseating mantra of conservatives regarding education….”money has nothing to do with problems in education…we have documentary proof of that”. Dana says otherwise. Just the fact that you address the effects of standardized testing is encouraging….because blind acceptance of its importance is what is being demanded nowadays. I have a feeling, maybe slightly different than yours that education is going to have a huge impact in 2016…….the media has a mantra that Elizabeth Warren, though sincere, informed, and able to communicate…..is not to be taken seriously…..she is not “centrist” enough…….the things ordinary people are concerned about in education are avoided by both parties in the political center……..I am not sure how Jeb Bush-Hillary Clinton will be forced to deal with education issues—-but I believe they will have to. Good luck to you.
Jeb Bush and Hillary won’t have to deal with education any more than Obama and Romney had to because, like the latter two, they are on the same page.
Amazon has two reviews on your book….a five and a four. Not sure how one guy typed his….he said he could not put your book down….steve Jobs got only 3 stars….he was too boring…..http://www.amazon.com/gp/pdp/profile/ASSMS4D9PB7RK/ref=cm_cr_dp_pdp
victorino…..while I agree about the history….I was amused to see…..five minutes after I posted it…..one of Diane’s first posts today…..Jeb Bush is not exactly filing for divorce….but is making some efforts at separation from some of his education shenanigists…..it might not matter too much…..but it is a sign that he is very serious about running….I bet his momma advised him to quit being stupid about education if he was really gonna run.
” I caution bloggers against pushing a leftist ideology.”
Michael, please explain what “pushing a leftist ideology” means to you.
Thanks,
Duane
Yeah, Duane, I need a definition of THAT, and an understanding of how reporting the data and the absolute observable reality of the public school debacle, is ‘pushing”.
Forgive me, too much holiday eggnog to parse such a sentence, even as an English teacher and as a PLAYWRIGHT, which I am… you know, the kind of story-teller that lets BEHAVIOR ‘push” action, and dialogue reveal intentions…. but them…that’s just me!
Moreover, telling the truth by reporting and analyzing the meaning of events and behaviors, is HARDLY THE same as PUSHING an ‘ideology’ — such as the one practiced by the tea-party ideologues who currently govern the GOP.
Their ideology is actually ‘pushed’ by our legislators (pushed by the lobbyists) , as they push false austerity on our nation as it recovers from the shock of being robbed blind by the banks and losing their homes. Krugman describes this so well, as European countries are brought to their knees, and to the brink of financial disaster by austerity pushed by ideologues.
Pushing ever more drastic budget cuts on the states while ‘pushing’ the ideology of small government is pushing ideology not facts.
Starving the government clearly resulted in the end of funding for everything we the people (remember us) consider important like funding so we can enforce environmental regulations, and pay for upgrading schools, building classrooms, and supporting learning with appropriate services.
Equating truth-telling with ideology? Hmmmm.
Moreover… It does NOT bode well for a meaningful discussion from a school administrator, when he insinuates at the get-hp that Diane is pushing an ideology, and then cautioning her!!!!!!
It seems to me, that entering a teacher’s room like this by speaking words of caution to the bloggers here.?. Bloggers? Why, Duane, THAT’S US!
Is he cautioning me?
You see, if this middle school principal believes that his voice resonates here, to a degree where we (who do not know him) would feel ‘cautioned’….????
Methinks, there is a hint of hubris in his early words.
I for one, after corresponding with Diane for a decade, reading what she wrote here for weeks, before my first comment, and following the discussions before giving voice to my analysis of events, and some strong opinions about solutions to the real problem, getting our voices OUT THERE so the people know the truth about what learning looks like and what is needed… This is not some ‘ideology’ and rather than caution, we need to be vigorous in our ‘push’ to have the injustice and corruption ended, and the principals in this lawless assault on Americans exposed at the least, and prosecuted for their malfeasance.
Too much holiday eggnog to understand what Mr. Wetmiller has to say… or maybe, I understand him only too well!
From where may I get your book?
Thank you for providing badly needed leadership. It’s because of you that we have made a lot of headway against the people who are trying to destroy our great public school system. This leadership should have been provided by the unions, but was not.
I’m so glad you’re walking unaided again. God bless you and Happy New Year!
Best Wishes and Happy New Year to you! More Power
Wishing you a healthy, happy and productive New Year, Diane, with tremendous gratitude for all you do.
Godspeed to you and may 2015 be a wonderful year for you and for public education. Thank you for being a great teacher for all of us.
Thank you for all that you do. You are an inspiration to all of us.
In a recent post you asked for ideas how to refer to our movement that opposes “corporate reform.” How about “real education reform” or “equal education reform”.
But do we even need the word “reform” which has been misused, and now carries a lot of negative baggage? Perhaps “real education” movement, “or “equal education for all” or “better education for all”?
May you have a healthy and happy New Year.
Happy New Year to you, Dr. Ravitch; you deserve the best. My New Year started out with a bang; my computer crashed.
Diane,
May you continue the healing process, continue the excellent leadership against the forces attempting to destroy public education, and continue enjoying the life you have chosen!!
Duane
Thank you for your ongoing support and respect for those of us who do a very difficult job under stressful conditions. Happy new year; I hope your walking gets better and better, and is not replaced with any new serious problems!
May you continue to get better in the new year I understand your disabilities well and always live in hope every day for better health around the corner. Good Luck always.