George Joseph reports in “Jacobin” about “widespread corruption” in Gulen charter schools, one of the narion’s largest charter chains. The Gulen schools have different names but all have boards composed of Turkish men and ties to an Islamic cleric who lives in seclusion in Pennsylvania and leads a political movement in Turkey.
Joseph writes:
“Over the summer, FBI agents stormed nineteen charter schools as part of an
ongoing investigation into Concept Charter Schools. They raided the
buildings seeking information about companies the prominent Midwestern
charter operator had contracted with under the federal E-Rate program.
“The federal investigation points to possible corruption at the Gulen
charter network, with which Concept is affiliated and which takes its name
from the Turkish cleric Fetullah Gulen. And a Jacobin investigation found
that malfeasance in the Gulen network, the second largest in the country,
is more widespread than previously thought. Federal contracting documents suggest that the conflict-of-interest transactions occurring at Concept are a routine practice at other Gulen-affiliated charter school operators.
“The Jacobin probe into Gulen-affiliated operators in Texas, Arizona, Utah,
Nevada, and California found that roughly $4 million in E-Rate contract
disbursements and $1.7 million in Department of Education Race to the Top grantee awards were given to what appear to be “related parties.” Awarding contracts to firms headed by related parties would seem to violate the FCC’s requirement that the school’s bidding process be “competitive” as
well as “open and fair.”

What corruption? As long as they’re paying the right people off they’re American as apple pie.
What, me cynical?
LikeLike
Fetullah Gulen nurtures his friendship with Sheldon Andelson, the casino king billionaire…so he has the best teacher/partner leading him in his money grabbing.
Magnolia Schools in LA were supposed to be under investigation by the FBI for internal fraud and mismanagement, but the case seems to have been dropped off the public’s radar. Gulen is one very slippery character who seems to be aided, if not abetted, by our government.
Why is he still allowed to filch American taxpayer money to fund his Turkish charter schools, and to bring endless Middle Eastern men to the US on green cards, ostensibly to run his schools? He claims there are not enough good teachers here to hire so he needs these mainly non-teachers. Why does this pass muster with INS and with each administration since Clinton let him in???
He is getting billions in public funds from all of us, but does not have to operate under the same rules as the rest of us in terms of fair hiring practices. He is under indictment in Turkey but our govt, does not extradite him. How can this Imam who is a strict follower of Sharia Law be given so much freedom to run his own businesses here, but not having to abide by our rules???
LikeLike
The same thing happened with the Gulen school in Utah. It was under investigation for all kinds of shady dealings with taxpayer money, and it was actually closed, but then reopened on appeal. I keep wondering how on earth that happened. With this new study, I’m going to go the rounds with some state legislators to see why on earth taxpayer money is going to these crooks.
LikeLike
We Turks are not “middle eastern” we are considered part of Asia Minor, or Turkic (originally migrated from Central Asia) The Gulen Movement is in more trouble behind the scenes in California than you realize. The biggest issue with closing down the 2 schools was the LAUSD didn’t follow policy and procedure for closure. Getting a “temporary injunction” merely outlined the fact the LAUSD School board needed to formally and in writing, not renewal the school. In their first session back the LAUSD board denied Magnolia #6 and #7. They hired a law firm but in reality they don’t run the show the LAUSD is who controls the purse strings of ADA and other services that the charter schools use.
There are merely in pre phase of trial and have set their scheduling conference. I would be surprised if the Gulencis take this all the way through discovery, interrogatories, etc.,, extensive trial. That is not their style to be exposed and out in the open., Concurrently the state is auditing 4 of their schools, the schools dismiss these off as merely “mistakes” and that it was perfectly find that MERF robbed the schools of millions because now all the sudden the schools are solvent (possible after they got a $6 million grant from the state of California on a school that was DENIED by the Orange School district, they ran to the state for a state charter approval and were rubberstamped.
With the state audit in place this could possible lead to criminal charges with the $200,000 used in H1-b Visa fees for more unqualified teachers and in majority of the cases were not even employees of Magnolia Schools.
They were double dipping from yet another management company the gulencis formed – Accord Institute but the judge ordered the ties to the schools severed. Judge Lavin made it clear he and the Office of the Inspector General take financial mismanagement seriously. With that said he is also a stickler for following protocol and procedures. LAUSD should have had a plan of action in place for those closed schools. No arrangements or transition schools were put in place, had they done this, there would have not been such a backlash. At least in the case of the Gulencis School in Louisiana that was closed the school district had a “recovery school district” in place and ready to step in after a town hall meeting with the parents.
LikeLike
This is truly shocking I don’t understand how it keeps happening. Where is Time Magazine on this one? Investigative reporting it seems has also been bought and sold to the highest bidding billionaire.
LikeLike
Just wondering where the Congress is, the Nation, Mother Jones, the New Republic and various state and local leaders? Just wondering…
LikeLike
Thinking RICO violations.
LikeLike
From a prior post.
USDE needs an inspector general investigation
In October,2014 USDE announced grants to 27 charter organizations in 12 states worth $39.7 million.
For Replication and Expansion. Here is one sure to insult NewYorkers: the fabulous Success Academy Charter Schools, for $2,234,500.
The biggest overall winner is KIPP for $13,789,074 worth of expansion, all in California.
The biggest winner by state is California $26,780,502 followed by Tennessee, $3,112,402
Here is the GULAN piece: For Planning, Program Design, and Implementation Grants, the biggest winner at $308,270 is the Chesapeake Lighthouse Foundation, operator of Gulen charters with issues with scandal documented at .http://charterschoolscandals.blogspot.com/2010/07/chesapeake-science-point-charter-school.html
The big winner by state for start-ups is Washington, with four new charters funded at $1,122,606, about $250.000 per school.
LikeLike
Thanks for this information.
LikeLike
Oh, don’t worry Laura. DC will HEAVILY regulate their huge charter school building program.
They’re regulate it about as well as they’ve regulated for-profit colleges, which is not at all.
They’re going to plunk these schools down in every state no matter the effect on kids in existing public schools, and regulate them from Washington.
LikeLike
I’m not sure that calling California a “winner” is appropriate in this situation. More like the biggest loser.
LikeLike
Diane
THANK YOU for this post! HORRORS is ALL I can say.
LikeLike
Magnolia Charter Schools in LAUSD, again.
LikeLike
Read more and the blatant crossing the line of Gulen’s Political lobbying machine Pacifica Institute, who tried to con the parents their building was the Turkish Cultural Center. They sent a busload of their students there to “Learn” about Turkish culture. The class was taught by Ozgur Yildiz who is President of the West Turkic Alliance (another political arm of Gulencis which also sponsors trips to Turkey for politicians, media and academia) Many of these “NGOs” which are really political lobbyist at one time shared an office with MERF/ACCORD. Can you figure out where they get the money to pay for all of this lobbying for Gulen and Turkey? http://www.magnoliascienceacademy.blogspot.com
LikeLike
In May a report from the Center for Democracy in Education and Integrity in Education reported on over a billion dollars in waste of public money from charters in fifteen states.
http://integrityineducation.org/charter-fraud/
LikeLike
Ed reformers are celebrating last night’s big wins:
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/charterschoice/2014/11/qa_how_school_choice_fared_in_the_elections.html
As usual, not a word about how existing public schools will fare under the ed reform governors, because really, who cares?
More charters and vouchers! Hooray! So what if 90% of the kids in public schools get completely screwed by their lawmakers? Ed reformers won!
LikeLike
As politically connected as this charter chain is, I find it hard to believe there will ever be a prosecution.
Has there been a single federal prosecution for charter fraud? One? They all get federal money and there have been state and local prosecutions.
The FBI raided the Pennsylvania rip off for profit chain and I never heard another word about it. It was 2 years ago. They were passing bags of cash in a Pizza Hut parking lot. Doesn’t seem like it’d be hard for convict them of something.
LikeLike
Or, when the Cincinnati Enquirer has a direct quote from a charter school official saying, his comfort zone is recruiting Turkish citizens.
The prohibition against discrimination based on national origin, is another law, that won’t be enforced, because it doesn’t benefit
the Washington club.
LikeLike
So what is the government doing about it? Nothing. What are the states in which these schools thieve doing about it? Nothing. All that money flowing into Turkey? Do nothing. All those male “teachers” who can’t speak English coming here on visas? Nothing. Rinse, repeat. Do evil, get ahead. The USA is protecting this man while he lives in the Poconos, and we freely give him our tax dollars. I don’t get it. Its worse than giving our monies to Pearson, a UK company, rather than keeping our tax dollars here in America.
LikeLike
Pearson, a U.K. company, whose 3rd largest shareholder is the government of Libya, according to Mother Jones.
LikeLike