Nevada is soon to vote on whether to tax big business to raise more money for public schools. The state’s public schools are among the worst funded systems in the nation. Big business is pulling out all the stops to kill the Initiative. They warn that it will kill the economy and jobs.
Columnist Steve Sebelius here explores why the state’s business community is so frightened by the Initiative, why they are trying so hard to block it.
He writes:
“There may be a good reason the elites of the Nevada business community are so vehemently campaigning against The Education Initiative.
“But it’s not what you think.
“There’s certainly a reason you’re seeing billboards, TV ads, mail pieces and spokespeople endlessly parroting the line that The Education Initiative is a “deeply flawed,” “job-killing” tax that will cost the state business.
“But what if it’s not the shortcomings of the tax that’s behind the anti-tax campaign?
“What if there’s another reason the Las Vegas Chamber of Commerce, the Nevada Resort Association, the Nevada Mining Association and their allies of convenience in organized labor fear and hate this tax?
“What if they hate it not because of its flaws (and there are a few) but because of its successes?
“The Nevada State Education Association actually succeeded in writing a tax that the corporate elite of Nevada tried and failed to stop in court.
“The teachers union had the unmitigated gall to succeed in gathering more than the required number of signatures in the various congressional districts of Nevada. And they went on to boldly champion the measure in the Legislature as lawmakers (especially Democrats) uncomfortably squirmed in their seats.
“And now, having survived court challenges, legislative indifference and a campaign of more than $2 million spent against it, the voters are about to have their say on Question 3.
“Could that be what Nevada’s corporate elite despises about The Education Initiative most of all?
“The Nevada Legislature was long ago captured by the commercial interests that run the state — first mining, then railroads, then gambling, land development and general business. The cumbersome, Balkanized legislative process makes it easy to kill bills, especially with a majority of friendly lawmakers from both parties on your side.
“The courts are a less certain prospect (after all, judges failed to stop the petition from going forward). But Nevada’s courts are generally quite friendly to business.
“The executive branch? Gov. Brian Sandoval — who now pledges an earnest effort to reform the state’s tax system in 2015, predicting success where his predecessors have failed — is not exactly an independent. He’s come out squarely against The Education Initiative from the start.
“But direct democracy? The people themselves? Well, that’s a frightening prospect for Nevada’s corporate elite, because the people are, at the very least, unpredictable.”
Imagine that! Business elites bought every elected official, but they haven’t figured out yet how to buy the public. Let’s see if all that advertising and TV manages to persuade the public to vote against the interests of their own children.

So – Business is arguing that they need a good environment to do well. To the business elites in this case means tax breaks, but it also means other structural factors. Perhaps unsafe neighborhoods, or poor roads, or a need for a good source of water to name just a few. In other words, according to business elites, the environment in which a business exists impacts a business, which goes beyond the business itself. Another way to put it is that these business folks are saying that their businesses cannot really be successful without outside structural factors that go beyond the walls of the business.
Isn’t this what Diane and others are saying when it comes to structural factors such as poverty etc. that impact education performance – and which is beyond the control of teachers and schools?
Is this hypocrisy or obfuscation? Help out here all you corporate reformers, and in particular Mr. Gates!
Tom
LikeLiked by 1 person
The same type of scare tactics are used in red states against the EPA, raising the minimum wage, and Obamacare, by asserting these are “job killers.” I would think every state would benefit from having a well educated population. The people running these ads are not patriots, and they fail to see the bigger picture. Their only interest is in making a profit today.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This can’t possibly be true, Diane. Everyone knows business and industry support public education!
Everything they do is entirely selfless and intended only to promote the Common Good. Only conspiracy theorists believe otherwise.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Texas Education.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We need something like this in Illinois where a progressive income tax is unconstitutional.
LikeLike
But I thought business and the elite have said education is the key to a better future and a solution to the growing wealth ineqality that threatens our Nation? Did they misplace their money were the mouth resides?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Steve Sebelius is right. The plutocrats, who score near the bottom on every measure of trust, planned the assault on a well-respected group, the professionals we trust with our children. The Chamber is very frightened that we will turn on their members instead of, their target.
Buy the app that lists the political activities of the oligarch-owned businesses and stop buying the products and services they peddle. I eliminated box stores that fund the subversion of our democracy. It narrowed my choices, simplified my life and makes me feel like a person who cares about future generations of Americans.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Linda, what is the name of the app? Sounds interesting.
As for the Education Initiative here in Nevada, lots of us in education support it, of course, but we (all Nevadans) are being slammed with negative advertising, and of course our local paper rails against it almost every day, with Sebelius’s column a rare exception. I heard three commercials against it on the drive home today, and I’ve received endless fliers. The “pro” side just doesn’t have the money to compete with this, but I still have my fingers crossed.
The ad I heard on the radio today said it will kill jobs, which I think is ironic considering just yesterday on the radio, on NPR I believe, I heard about a state’s experiment with cutting business taxes (I want to say Kansas?), and it did NOT help the economy at all. Several business owners were quoted as saying they just got to take home more of the profits, but it didn’t mean they needed to hire more people because business remained about the same. The state budget suffered immensely, with education taking a huge hit.
I am so tired of businesses and corporations not accepting their social responsibilities. Businesses hesitate to come here because their employees want a better public school system. Ironic, right?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Regina,
Everything you’ve said is correct and well-stated. The app can be found at Buycott.com.
Regards,
LikeLike
When I learned that the Kohler heirs support Scott Walker and I concluded that Home Depot and Menards support Darwinian economics, I went on-line. I found an American made kitchen faucet, by a small company, Wolverine, that sells through a local small plumber. The faucet was competitively priced and it works great. It took a little extra effort to buy from someone other than a multinational corp. but, it was well worth the good feeling and bragging rights. They even sent some candy with the faucet!
LikeLike