Education advocates blasted Governor Andrew Cuomo for vowing to “bust the public school monopoly” by creating more privately managed charters.
Will he bust the “police monopoly” or the “firefighters” monopoly? Will he privatize other essential public services as he now threatens to privatize our public schools?
The Alliance for Quality Education and other groups said:
ALBANY (October 28, 2014) – AQE, local school superintendents and leaders of the state’s major community organizations issued the following statement in response to Gov. Cuomo’s vow to break the public schools “public monopolies” and replace them with more privately-run charter schools.
“Gov. Cuomo has laid clear plans to expand his frontal assault on our public schools through high stakes testing, starving our public schools and privatization,” said Billy Easton, executive director of the Alliance for Quality Education. “It’s not that shocking when you look at the enormous pile of cash he has raked in from the Wall Street billionaires who are investing in charter schools. He is rewarding his financial backers at a devastating cost to our children.”
“Governor Cuomo’s public school bashing hurts students and families, especially in low-income immigrant communities hardest hit by the inequality that has grown under his tenure. Instead of addressing overcrowding, the loss of vital resources, high dropout rates among Latinos, or record-high inequality between school districts, he’s stuck on tired talking points that are divisive and benefit a small few,” said Javier H. Valdés, co-executive director of Make the Road Action Fund.
“New York State’s graduation rates for black and Latinos ranks at the bottom of all states nationally. It has also been established that NYS clearly discriminates against those same children when it comes to equal distribution state education aid. If you are white and/or rich in New York, you get the best of all state aid worlds. If you are poor and/or black or Latino, you get the short end of the education aid stick,” said Kenneth Eastwood, Superintendent of Schools of the Middletown Enlarged City School District. “So lets redirect the real issue of education in New York State to the evaluation of teachers using data from a failed common core test that the Governor admits is so bad that the same data should not be used to evaluate students for the next five years. Political hyperbole at the expense of fair funding and opportunities for all students in New York State only results in greater sales of smoke and mirrors and larger numbers of disenfranchised poor and minority students in New York. Stop running for President and do what’s right for New York’s poor and minority students.”
“The Governor’s words demonstrate that he really doesn’t understand the important role of public education in the continuing re-tooling and development of the American economy,” said Robert Libby, the Cohoes City School District’s Superintendent of Schools.
“It is outrageous that Mr. Cuomo calls our public school system a ‘monopoly.’ While the governor calls for school competition, what he’s really pushing is a ‘survival of the fittest’ charter school model,” said Jonathan Westin, executive director of New York Communities for Change.“What the governor should be doing is complying with the Campaign for Fiscal Equity’s decision to fully fund our schools and pay the $2.5 billion New York City public schools are owed. Every child in New York City should have access to good schools and we will be in Albany next year to make sure this happens.”
“New York’s leaders need to stop blaming everyone else and instead address the real problem with our education system: the state’s chronic under-funding of schools,” said Karen Scharff, executive director with Citizen Action of New York. “Declaring war on teachers is just an excuse for the budget cuts that are undermining our kids’ opportunity for success.”
“The Governor’s assertion that competition is an adequate substitute for equity should be an affront to New Yorker’s sensibilities,” Schenectady City School District’s Superintendent of Schools Laurence Spring said.

I think it’s time for New Yorkers to pull a Wisconsin style occupation on the capitol.
LikeLike
The Governor should resign immediately.
LikeLike
Maybe he should step down if he can only respond to public education with bias and prejudice. He is not representing all of New York with such a bad attitude. Teachers are taxpayers too!
LikeLike
Politicians don’t need the votes of public school parents anymore, I guess.
I think it’s great they’re now boldly announcing they plan on opposing public schools.
Someone on his staff should remind him that 95% of kids in that state attend the public schools he has now declared to be enemy territory.
Go get ’em, tiger. Launch an attack on your own state’s public school system. Idiot.
LikeLike
I cannot wait to see what happens with election results Tuesday here in NC so we can know what new fights we are gearing up for.
You are right in your mindset about him. But lately I am startled by what people buy into. But maybe this guy’s blatant style will finally bring it on home. Something’s gotta.
LikeLike
These are the rants of a vindictive madman, not a public servant. Such brazen threats make him an outright bully and should disqualify him for public office.
Still waiting to hear from our union leaders on this . . . .
LikeLike
What kind of Democrat is he. He is a SELLOUT! He needs to be recalled.
LikeLike
I have to say, I enjoyed listening to the health care professionals take Mr. Christie and Mr. Cuomo to task on their idiotic, politically motivated response to ebola.
Teachers could learn something from that. The bully twins back down pretty quick when you call them out and humiliate them.
They know about as much about public health as they do about public education, turns out,
LikeLike
Time to quarantine Cuomo. Permanently. He clearly is a very sick man.
LikeLike
Article XI, Sec. 1 of the Constitution of the State of NY reads:
EDUCATION
[Common schools]
Section 1. The legislature shall provide for the maintenance and support of a system of free common schools, wherein all the children of this state may be educated.
Andrew Cuomo, as Governor, took an oath of office to uphold this statement.
Draw your own conclusions about his fitness for this office.
LikeLike
I agree. I think ed reform politicians have to work on behalf of public schools despite their obvious disdain and ideological bias against our schools..
If they aren’t, they’re not doing the job. Sorry. Presumably they realized most children attend the public schools they hope to “bust up” when they took these positions. Maybe he should consider doing his job? I know public schools aren’t fashionable, but I’m sure he’ll be able to hold his nose and soldier thru it.
LikeLike
The problem is that free common does not require the schools to be public. I would argue that charters without certified teachers is not offering the same level of service.
LikeLike
I have a question. Why did the Working Families Party endorse Cuomo? Seems like a no-brainer not to.
LikeLike
They endorsed him in the hopes of getting some beneficial political concessions from him that would help their causes: better schools, better government, better jobs.
If they fail to get 50,000 votes the WFP must be dissolved. They still offer some hope in combatting Cuomo’s outrageous right-wing, plutocratic policies. If they fail to get their votes, it will be one less watchdog trying to keep him reasonably honest. Cuomo intentionally formed the WEP (Women’s Equality Party) to siphon votes away fro the WFP next Tuesday. The one letter difference is no accident (WFP v. WEP). He is a ruthless man.
LikeLike
As an outsider looking in I just can’t believe this guy is related to Mario. Or maybe I was mistaken about him too.
LikeLike
Mario remains silent for good reason. If you have nothing good to say, its best to say nothing at all.
LikeLike
Karen . . . ? Michael . . . ?
Your silence is getting deafening. Hopefully you are crafting a harsh but measured rebuttal to this dictatorial buffoon. Please step up to the plate on this or you will lose what little credibility you have left with your members.
LikeLike
NY T, I’ll assume you are speaking of Magee who has called the governors comments an “unfortunate distraction”.
http://perdidostreetschool.blogspot.com/2014/10/cuomos-attack-against-teachers-public.html
LikeLike
Threatening the livelihoods, careers, and due process rights of 500,000 teachers is a “distraction”? My God what is she thinking?
This pathetic, mealy-mouthed response is about what I expected.
LikeLike
It’s fascinating in a way. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a politician run against his own state’s public schools.
Many of them ARE anti-public schools, but actually adopting this stance as announced policy strikes me as new ground in the ed reform “movement” 🙂
Will he stand by this when he visits public schools in the state? That should be interesting for the students: ” I OPPOSE Lincoln Elementary!”
Wacko-ville.
LikeLike
He’s playing what he perceives to be the ‘demagogue card’. A gamble he knows he can’t lose – for now (as his election is an unfortunate lock). But it just may backfire on him down the line. We can only hope.
LikeLike
If he loses, he’ll probably become a lobbyist for charters. The usually the road for loser politicians, if not charters, then drug companies.
LikeLike
I get that he’s a shoe-in, but they won’t be able to thread this needle forever. They can’t continue to claim they’re only talking about those OTHER public schools, where those OTHER peoples’ kids go.
At some point they have to face people who actually support local public schools. There are quite a few of us! 🙂
The national “public schools suck!” narrative is one thing, but I think it’s a different story when you’re actually in a specific community as governor.
They’ve been able to do it thus far because they’re “pro charter” not anti-public, or they are “agnostics” who want “great schools”.
This is flat-out “I reject this state’s public schools”
I don’t know if political actors can do that. The schools were there long before he arrived and they’ll be there long after he loses his bid for the presidency. We live in these places. We’re not just here for a term or two 🙂
LikeLike
Now all you good NYers who care about PUBLIC EDUCATION can spend some time complaining before you go to the polls and support “the lesser of two evils.”
By doing so, you will embolden more Democratic politicians to put Wall Street silver over public schools.
I urge everyone to vote for the greater of the two evils and send a schlock wave across the country. Both parties have turned their backs on public education AND WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO unless their political lives are put at risk.
Vote for Astorino, it may be the Democratic party’s best hop for the future!!!!
LikeLike
Tough getting odd. 🙂
LikeLike
When you put people that have led privileged lives in office, they often neither understand or respect public education. Their friends, hedge fund managers, bankers and corporate lawyers, are not your friends. A governor should represent all the people and support all public services.
LikeLike
I love the utter disconnect. Parents are complaining about too much testing, so the US Department of Education links to some Pearson crap.
I don’t know: are they actually ON the Pearson payroll? Are they allowed to have two employers at the same time in DC now?
It’s just shameless. It goes beyond ignoring constituents to outright shilling.
http://blog.pearson.com/the-10-things-that-make-a-great-21st-century-teacher/?hootPostID=9ce0631a644adeb9d41e75e5913ab612
LikeLike
I also can’t figure out why anyone would work hard on Common Core in a public school. They’re all but telling us the goal is to get rid of our schools.
“Oh, and by the way. Put in this giant new complex program while we’re attacking your very existence!” Maybe I’m a “traditionalist” but that sounds like a very cynical betrayal to me. 6 months ago they were all selling this program. Now they’re throwing in the towel on the whole system. So much for that, I guess.
LikeLike
Yep. It’s hard to feel like there is any straight, accountable talk about schools right now within the system. I spent a day at training for how we submit our evidence of growth in students for the arts for our VAM in NC. But nobody really knows if it will actually come to pass. Or when. Rules change every so often; then switch back.
I never imagined leadership like this. Reading the documents Mercedes linked to about CCSS now and the Hunt Institute’s involvement in early planning—it all embarrasses me and just makes me so sad.
What happened? How did we get here?
LikeLike
The average school district in New York State spends $20,000 per student. New York State residents have by far the highest combined federal, state, and local tax burden in the nation.
There is a reason why Cuomo’s popularity didn’t suffer one iota from signing the “destructive” tax levy cap into law, and why his message resonates with non 1%-ers, even those who have kids in public schools. The rhetoric about starving schools of resources has no basis in reality here.
LikeLike
But he didn’t say anything about funding, not in the quote anyway.
He said he wanted to “bust the public monopoly”.
He’s like Teddy Roosevelt, but in reverse!
It’s an interesting approach, I’ll give him that. Public entities are the REAL villains here!
He’s right about one thing. Public schools are the last universal public system in the US. That can be his legacy. He privatized the only public universal system in the US.
LikeLike
Some variation of “Money isn’t the problem with New York schools” is a standard line in virtually every stump speech he delivers. Has been for years now.
Cuomo is pursuing this course because the middle-class people who pay $10,000+ in property taxes to operate $20,000+ per student schools are sick and goddamn tired of the ‘sky is falling’ rhetoric about school funding in New York. He is transmitting this message not as a prelude to some sort of sneak attack against the will of the people, but because he knows that it is exactly what a lot of voters want to hear.
LikeLike
Competition as a reform strategy pits people against one another in pursuit of personal advantage, rather than joining together for improvement for all. Public education is not a monopoly. It’s community responsibility. http://www.arthurcamins.com/?p=255
LikeLike
I think it’s going to be very difficult to tax people for public education when it’s no longer publicly-owned. I don’t really want to pay into a system where I’m not an owner, but am instead buying a service from a contractor.
It’s a profound difference, and they’re kidding themselves if they think it won’t radically change how people view public schools.
LikeLike
So many people are educators or married to an educator or involved in public education I think he just lost thousands of votes. I hope it’s enough to can him and bring in someone with a heart and some sense.
LikeLike
There’s a good response from Karen Magee of NYSUT to Como’s biased comment.http://www.nysut.org/news/2014/october/nysut-public-schools-not-a-monopoly-but-a-centerpiece-of-democracy
LikeLike