Frank Breslin, retired high school teacher, considers the current obsession with standardized testing in reading and mathematics and laments the neglect of history, foreign languages, science, and everything else that is not tested.
He writes:
“Reading and math, indeed, must be taught, but much more besides — literature, history, science, world languages, music, art, and, in an age of childhood obesity, physical education. But, thanks to this mandate, they no longer are because they no longer are tested.
“Even the restorative elixir of play and recess so vital to children is often omitted, so frantic are teachers at not having enough time to cover the testable material of reading and math. The result is an alarming narrowing both of curriculum and of children’s minds by this relentless barrage of testing and test preparation.
“But this has also had an overlooked, though no less pernicious, effect on students, not just by the little that is now being taught, but also by the many subjects now being omitted because there is no time to teach them.
“And it is this that is so very chilling about this educational “reform,” which is not about reform at all, but something very ominous — control of the mind.
“How better undermine education than by crippling thought; how better discourage critical inquiry than by stressing rote learning; how better weaken democracy than by subverting its schools!
“Teachers are deeply disturbed by what is now going on in the classroom. Only someone ignorant of what a school is about, who likens the classroom to an assembly line for the making of widgets, could be blind to the intangible dimension of what should be going on between teacher and students, but no longer is — the opening of vistas, introducing new worlds, the inducing of wonder, pushing back the unknown.
“Gone are those wondrous “teachable moments” that all of us recall from our own childhood years when a teacher would transfix us for a few rapturous moments when time stood still, as he or she took us into the very heart of what it means to be human, thrilling lessons that would remain with us for the rest of our lives. Such old-fashioned teaching is a thing of the past….
“Dickens skewered such “education” in his grotesque portrayals of Victorian schools in Hard Times, Nicholas Nickleby, and David Copperfield, where gargoyle schoolmasters like Gradgrind, Squeers, and Creakle are let loose upon children to their irreparable harm.
“The interminable mantra of “facts” heaped upon “facts,” the dogmatic insistence that only what can be measured, quantified, counted, and weighed is real and important, objective and useful, that all else is humbug — this pestiferous doctrine was unmasked for all times as tragically destructive to children. Such was the national fury and outrage at what innocent children were being made to endure in such schools that they were swept away overnight.”
Only those who know nothing of the love of learning could impose so soulless and deadening a regime on the nation’s children. Unfortunately Washington, D.C. and our state legislatures are overrun with people who resemble Mr. Gradgrind.

It was the Test of times, it was the StudentsFirst of times, it was the age of Gates, it was the age of Common Core, it was the epoch of Rheeform, it was the epoch of VAMs, it was the season of Charters, it was the season of Dollar$, it was the spring of dope, it was the winter of despair, we had every con-artist scheme before us, we had nothing before us, we were all entering the Gates of Hell, we were all going direct without passing Go – in short, the period was so far like the Gilded age, that some of its noisiest authorities (Gates, Duncan, Rhee, Coleman) insisted on its being received, for bad or for evil, in the superlative only. (How Dickens might have seen ed reform in the US today)
LikeLike
TAGO!
(Channeling your inner Dickens…)
😎
LikeLike
I just watched this 20 minute video featuring James Heckman… The first 15 minutes describe the importance of early intervention but the last 5 minutes describe the misuse and abuse of achievement testing and germane to this post… I am going to be on the lookout for the book referenced in this discussion and expect you and your readers will be as well…
http://ineteconomics.org/new-economic-thinking/james-heckman-early-interventions-lead-higher-iqs
LikeLike
Wonderful. Have you seen this Grassroots movie
https://vimeo.com/4199476
here is how and why all the things you described disappeared in NYC, the larger school system in the country, and the first one where they used THE Process to end the voice of the professional teacher as the judge of how to reach the minds of emergent learners, instead of teachers like I was doing what you describe.
.
http://www.opednews.com/author/author40790.html
LikeLike
Dickens is not the only one who skewered this sort of cheating “education,” that doesn’t open children’s minds, or broaden their horizons. There is another very resonant passage in the fourth and fifth chapters of George Orwell’s A Clergyman’s Daughter (https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/o/orwell/george/o79c/chapter4.html); I remember reading it while I tried to do test-prep enough so my 8th graders would bring their CST scores up enough to get the school into the NCLB safe zone one year.
LikeLike
Nature, God, whatever you wish to identify with has given homo sapiens two halves of its brains. One scientific, the other – for want of a better term here – the spiritual aspects of life. To use only one half is to become half wits.
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Sorry that does not hold up. Even wiki tells the layman, “Short of having undergone a hemispherectomy (removal of a cerebral hemisphere), no one is a “left-brain only” or “right-brain only” person.” Lazy thinking is what characterizes the lateral-brained person.
LikeLike
Frank, I agree that NCLB and CCSS are leading to grim conditions in the classroom. But you perpetuate a common myth when you characterize the modern classroom as “facts, facts, facts”. In fact, there’s a dearth of facts. What we have instead is “process, process, process” –make inferences, use context clues, gather supporting evidence. I was at a conference this weekend where the presenter characterized the NCLB regime as “rote memorizaiton”; Common Core, as “higher-order thinking”. Huh? Where was the rote memorization going on? Not in my district. ELA test prep shoved all fact-learning off the stage; it was joyless processing of crappy fiction –daily mental weightlifting that left very little residue of facts in the brain. In fact NCLB/CCSS can be seen as the equally hideous ANTITHESIS of Gradgrindism. In some ways our anti-fact approach to education is worse than Gradgrindism —at least kids took something away from Gradgrind’s classroom. Our kids emerge stultified AND empty-headed.
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx You are so right. Hence, CCLS-ELA reduces the content of MLK’s ‘Ltr from Birm. Jail’ to a survey of how the author used which type of verbiage to what sort of effect.
LikeLike