Allie Gross arrived to teach in Detroit as a Teach for America recruit. Her three years in a charter school opened her eyes. She saw classrooms without supplies, children promoted who were not ready and did not get the intervention they needed, she saw feckless leadership promoted to larger roles. And she saw the growth of an industry. In this article, she describes what she learned about “the charter school profiteers.”
Here is a sample of a fascinating and disturbing portrait of what is happening in Detroit:
“In charter-heavy Detroit, permissive regulations have created an environment ripe for mismanagement.
“According to the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, Detroit ranks number two nationally for charter enrollment. The city is right behind New Orleans, with over half of its school-aged students attending a charter school in the 2012-2013 school year. That number will no doubt rise now that Michigan has lifted its cap on charter schools. Even more pernicious, the majority of them are run by for-profit education management organizations (EMOs). According to a report by the National Education Policy Center, Michigan has the highest proportion of for-profit EMOS running their charter schools — 79 percent of the total.
“Privatization and limited oversight have conspired to produce a new figure: the education entrepreneur. In the chaos of the Detroit school system, education entrepreneurs see an opportunity for experimentation, innovation, and venture capital. And the decentralized nature of charter schools works to their advantage. With little coherence across schools, the issue of serial education entrepreneurs emerges. Those with limited track records of success are able to wedge their ways into school after school, with nobody checking up on past performance.”

http://www.ctpost.com/local/article/McKinney-vows-to-scrap-Common-Core-if-elected-5667923.php?cmpid=twitter
~Thank you, Joe Jacobs
Sent from my iPhone. Please excuse any brevity and/or grammatical errors.
LikeLike
No, no excuses Joe!!
LikeLike
Excellent article! Thank you.
LikeLike
As I have pointed out before, the ultimate goal of the profiteers is to run public education on the Defense Industry Model (DIM).
LikeLike
I’ve been making the same argument for the last ten years. I can’t seem to get it to penetrate the haze of “Failing schools! Bad teachers! Corrupt unions!” that surrounds most peoples’ brains.
Even when cases of charter school fraud, cheating on tests, etc., make the news, it’s as if they are rare exceptions to an otherwise excellent industry.
LikeLike
Jon Awbrey: much appreciate your comments on this blog, but I have a bit of a different perspective on what you term the DIM.
Please bear with me.
Recall that the state of public education aka “schooling for the vast majority”—or as edupreneurs, educrats and edubullies and edufrauds would put it, “OTHER PEOPLE’S CHILDREN”—poses an existential threat to the USofA.
😧
Literally. Not figuratively. Economically. Politically. Indubitably! Most certainly!
😱
Yet when it comes to the “Defense” Industry there is no limit to the amount of money that is thrown at the putative solutions to manufactured crises and problems, e.g., the invasion and occupation of Iraq [don’t forget that Saddam Hussein was behind 9/11!] and the continuing morass in the former as well as in Afghanistan. When it comes to the public side of the “Education” Industry, however, there is a droning hue and cry about how “just throwing money at a problem won’t solve it”—but the money tap is always open for predictable fiascoes like irresponsible wars or saving banks and corporations that are “too big to fail” and such.
No, the solution for the self-styled “education reformers” is to starve and smother and beat down public schools so that anything else looks halfway good by comparison. And they can’t even get most of their reform solutions like charters and vouchers to even match pubic schools when it comes to their misleading data measure of standardized test scores.
😕
So I say, with the war that the charterites/privatizers have declared on public education, let’s spend WHATEVER IT TAKES for public education. On the other hand, for the proven rheephorm failures, let them hold bake sales.
Fiscal responsibility, that’s the ticket. An end to edupreneur entitlement and the dance of the educrat lemons. Transparency in all matters, including and perhaps especially, when it comes to funding and spending.
Just my dos centavitos worth…
😎
LikeLike
Just to be clear, the Defense Industry Model maximizes the distribution of profits to private corporations, maximizes the distribution of costs, risks, and the ultimate price to the public and the troops (read “teachers” here), and minimizes democratic control over its operations by shifting Corporate Owned Governments (COGs) into the highest possible gears.
LikeLike
Jon Awbrey: thank you for the clarification.
I’ve just heard it under other labels: “welfare for the rich” and “socialism for the wealthy” and “private profit/public risk” and “too big to fail.”
Keep writing. I’ll keep reading.
😎
LikeLike
Great piece.
Compare it to this:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/preston-smith-/monopolies-dont-build-dem_1_b_5641484.html
It’s from a Rocketship founder. The subtitle seems to be “disrupting public education status quo” (I am not making that up)
It’s like a list of ed reform marketing phrases connected with “and” and “or”.
This is odd:
“It’s time to put the needs of kids, families and communities before the needs of adults.”
I have adults in my family and community. Don’t most people? Are there families and communities that are composed of just “kids”? Are adults in families and communities somehow opposed to the children in those same communities?
He throws in “democracy” at the end. Got it in right under the wire 🙂
LikeLike
To add to absurdity, Act Blue, an organization with the goal, “to empower small-dollar donors”, has a website page for fund-raising for DFER. Act Blue must not have received the memo, that DFER was asked by the California Democratic Party, to stop using the name Democrat. Ironically, Act Blue also has a page for the Chicago Teachers Union Solidarity Fund. The two organizations are diametrically opposed and have funders at the extreme ends of the economic spectrum.
Political differences are one thing, this is another thing entirely.
LikeLike
So a lousy teacher or administrator or “entrepreneur” can go from school to school without anyone noticing, and teacher “tenure” is the problem?????
LikeLike
In many cases like this one, tenure is the least of people’s worries….well one would hope that to be the case. But when it comes to a for-profit charter school, ill bet that tenure is the last thing they care about when it comes to buy-ins and hiring new teachers.
i just don’t understand how for-profit charters have this long in our nation without someone saying something, or rather i feel that a lot has been said, but nothing has been done. It calls into question the difference between “The pen is mightier then the sword.” and “Actions speak louder than words.”
When a pen is put to paper it has the ability to rally the masses. But when one of those masses stands up and takes the lead and rallies the masses into action will true differences be made. So the threads have been woven, it is only a matter of time.
LikeLike
Three days after the article was published, Flint Community Schools announced they have chosen Jessie E. Kilgore as their new assistant superintendent. With a salary over $100K a year, he will oversee the district’s curriculum.
http://www.mlive.com/news/flint/index.ssf/2014/07/flint_schools_hires_assistant.html
“With little coherence across schools, the issue of serial education entrepreneurs emerges. Those with limited track records of success are able to wedge their ways into school after school, with nobody checking up on past performance.”
LikeLike
The only thing worse is Detroit Public Schools, a cesspool of corruption and waste.
LikeLike
Troll
LikeLike
yep.
LikeLike
“She saw classrooms without supplies, children promoted who were not ready and did not get the intervention they needed, she saw feckless leadership promoted to larger roles” I saw this in urban school districts ran by idiots, too. No charter schools in town, when it happened.
LikeLike