Bob Braun has written one of the most moving, powerful critiques I have ever read of the heartless destruction of neighborhood public schools. What is it all about? To quote Braun: “money and power and greed.”
He writes:
“Sad. There’s a word rarely heard in the context of the state’s war on Newark’s neighborhood public schools. Sad. Yet the story of how a cruelly tone-deaf state bureaucrat named Cami Anderson is singlehandedly destroying a community’s neighborhood schools is just that. Sad. And nothing more illustrates that sadness than the brave but probably futile effort of one successful neighborhood school to remain alive despite Anderson’s promise to give it to privatized educational entrepreneurs who include former business partners of the recently resigned state education commissioner.”
Hawthorne Avenue School is not a failing school. It ranks well in the city and state. It has string parent involvement. But Cami has promised it to her friends at KIPP.
To get ready for the transfer, she has devastated the school:
“Anderson’s treatment of Hawthorne—and similar schools throughout the state’s largest district—has been a nightmare. A sad nightmare. She stripped the school of its librarians, its counselors, its attendance personnel. She has ignored constant pleas to repair crumbling walls and leaking ceilings—promising repair money only after she gave the building to TEAM Academy, the local name for KIPP charters, and the Brick schools. The head of TEAM Academy, Tim Cardin, is a former business partner of Christopher Cerf, the recently-resigned education commissioner. All three–Cardin, Cerf, and Anderson–worked for the New York City schools.”
Cami Anderson has no sense of shame.
Crony capitalism at the expense of kids.
OMG!!! I love this blog!!! AWESOME!!!!
Absolutely disgusting. I guess KIPP is set to receive more corporate welfare.
“Just as reforms involving choice, assessment and teacher effectiveness are showing promise in upping student achievement, resistance is growing. Certain localities are pulling back on the spread of charter schools and Common Core State Standards reforms have become politicized, and their implementation criticized. Holding teachers accountable for students’ academic achievement has succeeded in pilot programs in many states, but hasn’t caught on in large urban settings, where it is most needed. Federally required state testing in grades 3 through 11 has illuminated the achievement gap and raised scores in some jurisdictions. Yet testing opponents are encouraging parents to have their children “opt out” of state and district examinations. Are the K-12 reforms of the last two decades moving forward or faltering? Is public confidence in reform dipping, or are parents demanding continued progress? This panel of philanthropists, educators and reform advocates will make sense of the mixed bag of education news and propose strategies for business leaders to influence the debate.”
They got a really diverse of views to discuss every public school in the country, as you can see from the guest list. It’s the same set of people:
Russlynn Ali, Chair, Emerson Education Fund; Former Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, U.S. Department of Education
Kevin Huffman, Commissioner, Tennessee Department of Education
Patricia Levesque, CEO, Foundation for Excellence in Education
Lowell Milken, Co-Founder, Knowledge Universe Education; Founder, National Institute for Excellence in Teaching (NIET)
Bruce Reed, President, The Eli and Edythe Broad Foundation
What do you think these 5 national ed reformers will decide about the parents of public school children? Is our “confidence in reform dipping” or are we “demanding continued progress”?
These 5 people will soon tell us what we think, so stay tuned!
http://www.milkeninstitute.org/events/gcprogram.taf?function=detail&eventid=GC14&EvID=5026
I read the Wikipedia entry for Lowell Milken, brother of the convicted, Michael Milken.
A comedic roast, in absentia, for the “deformers”, would be entertaining.
Or, an exercise in writing epithets for their tombstones, could provide gallows humor for the extremely dire threat to our democracy.
All the attention has been focused on Camden and Newark and the ridiculous travesty that is taking place in Asbury Park. The district has been in the process of trying to appoint a new superintendent of schools for well over a year. The fact is the Asbury Park BOE has completed their process and have appointed their candidate but the political machine of the DOE refused to approve the appointment. There appears to be a secret list of approved candidates and if you are not on that secret list you will not be successful. The boards candidate of choice has the support of several grass roots organization, Asbury Chapter of the National Action Network, NAACP, and a large number of religious leaders.
May I email you? I am interested in getting in touch with Asbury Park educators regarding representation on the MCEA LAT. The team needs your voice! I’m on yahoo by the name of womanofx.
That is, if you are an educator…if not can you please steer us in the right direction? Thanks!
Schools are such an emotional anchor for families and children. They keep our memories, allow us to visit and relive our fondest memories, look for our favorite teachers even though we’ve all aged.
Treating schools as another Walmart store, or Kmart…here today & gone tomorrow. No one pines for their favorite big box store. Impersonal, no favorite workers to share memories. No friends. No stories to share with families.
I am terribly sad for the children and families who have no connections, no expectations for future generations. How does one kick-start lost roots of institutions such as favorite schools?
I am sure that Gates’, Duncan’s and Obama’s kids will contribute to their schools, attend reunions and keep in touch with their friends and teachers for generations.
None of that for OTHER PEOPLES’ CHILDREN.
WIPED OUT!
We appear to be shocked when people become disconnected from everything and suddenly snap and commit evil acts. When nothing matters and people have less control over their lives, our entire society suffers over time.
Just too sad and maddening!
H.A. Hurley
I love your post! These people seem to be heartless!
Very good way of putting it. These notions have been lost in the education debate. Sort of like appealing to and involving the senses in learning, rather than just decoding and bubbling.
I think most public schools are trying so hard to still offer good learning experiences for children in public schools. But you are right, a connection to something is vital. Alas, I suspect the drive towards upping that apart started long ago. As sung in a song made famous by EmmyLou Harris in The Hotse Whisperer, “There is a way, subtle changes come up stay, barely noticed, hardly known. One day you’ll say my situation’s locked away, but by tomorrow you’re all alone. It seems so sudden, but it’s not it’s only grown. From a seed that long ago was left forgotten in the snow. And has a way of slow surprises all its own.”
Slow surprise. I think that’s the name of the song.
A KIPP enthusiast in Tennessee tells me that because so many students were finishing high school there with poor grammar and spelling, and that because it is unfair to the children of Tennessee to not have access to superior academics, these moves are necessary.
They simply do not see it in the context that those who are sad (including me) to see this era come to pass do. Their script is different, their priorities are different, and all the while there are some (“reformer” supporters) who have a hint of doubt that corporate philanthropy and charity are a dis-service, and yet were they to pull their support they think they would be leaving the children (of Tennessee and NJ) out to fend for themselves against this group of teachers who has emerged over the last few decades who lack the pedigree KIPP can attract, and who are certain they will ensure proper spelling and grammar will become the norm.
In short, I don’t see this freight train being stopped, but I hope it can be and furthermore wish someone on it would see the destruction in its path.
They truly think they are bettering the chances for schooling quality.
This didn’t need to happen.
A hint of doubt meaning they sort of know better, but they go along anyway (peer pressure, charity lunches??). Who knows why.
I would say that’s where Duane Swacker will find his GAGAers.
If the parents of the school children in Newark really want to save neighborhood public schools they would teach their children a civics lesson by forming strike committees of parents and children and setting up a rolling picket line. Keeping their kids out of the KIPP schools would destroy the schools. People have learned to be helpless. They have more power than they know, but perhaps the majority are not really that upset about the privatization of their schools. Perhaps they really don’t care as much as the people who are posting comments here.
Perhaps they don’t wish to use their children as pawns in a political struggle. Same reason more parents don’t boycott testing. The reformers have no such compunction.
Allowing for the abuse of so many children, and their children after them, in the name of protecting your own child, makes no sense to me. Children learn from the example set by their parents. Giving in and giving up is not what I taught my children. In fact my children traveled with me to walk on picket lines all across the state of PA when they were growing up. Children are resilient. You are their parent. It is your responsibility to teach them well.
As a child of a picketing teacher in PA well over two decades ago, I salute you for your efforts. Pennsylvania teachers have fought for a very long time. Here in NJ, people don’t know what’s it’s like to stand up like that. Here’s hoping there is solidarity on the part of parents and teachers alike.
I do agree that it’s a bold move to include children in the fight. What would happen if every parent kept their children home for a week or so? Probably not feasible for those with work schedules, but it would send a message.
I’m the parent from Hawthorne ave school that Bob Braun wrote about. We have done so much but Cami Anderson will not meet with us. Please go read Bob Braun’s ledger.
Grace – I’m so sorry you are in this situation. Is there nothing that can be done to go around Anderson? Newark citizens fund the schools, yet have no voice in how their money is spent. Are you looking for a way to make a legal challenge?
Of course Cami won’t meet with you. That is a given.
What is your next step?
Do you just give up?
Your children, and your grandchildren are depending on you.
Hi Christine,
Newark Public Schools are primarily funded by the State. If there is a way to go around Cami Anderson, no one has figured it out yet. The challenge is coming up with a way to get around Christie. Anybody have any suggestions?
I have a meeting with the board members today. They agreed to meet with me to see what we can do. I’ve also been contacted by many that are going to try and help. Our fight is not over till Cami resigns
Keep the faith, Grace.
Can an injunction not be filed? Cami doesn’t play by the rules and it’s time she had some consequences hit her upside the (metaphorical) head!
So technically we could say Cami is completely failing in her duties? What is her VAM score? If the students/teachers and schools are failing (her words) then she is, also, failing to provide a safe and educationally enriching environment for all students to learn in. She is in charge of keeping up the learning environment…clearly she is not doing her job or is shifting the blame, to everyone else, and dismantling the school system her real job? I know my school’s superintendent does everything he can to make our school a better and safer learning environment every year, thank goodness there are more of him then her!
“I know my school’s superintendent does everything he can to make our school a better and safer learning environment every year, thank goodness there are more of him then her!”
Is that true in urban districts? Doesn’t seem to be the case as far as I can tell.