A new poll from Siena College of voters in New York State produced some unsettling news for Governor Andrew Cuomo, who has presidential ambitions. While most see him as “effective,” only about 50% say they expect to vote for him in the fall election.
When matched against his Republican challenger Rob Astorino, Cuomo has a lead of 58-28%.
But when a third-party challenger from the left is added to the choice–an unnamed candidate from the Working Families Party–Cuomo’s lead drops to 39%, and Astorino and the anonymous representative of the WFP are tied at 24%.
What this shows is that Cuomo has lost the liberal base of the Democratic Party. His assiduous courting of Wall Street has paid off in campaign contributions. He last reported some $33 million, enough to scare away challengers. But the liberal base would prefer “anyone but Cuomo” on the WFP line.
As for Common Core, 27% say they are “very familiar” with the new standards, and another 46% say they are “somewhat familiar” with them.
However, only 23% say the standards are “just right,” with the majority saying they are to hard, too easy, or don’t know. That suggests very shallow support.
When asked whether the Common Core standards will make students more college-and-career-ready, only 9% feel “very confident” with this statement, while another 29% feel “somewhat confident.”
When asked whether New York–given the changes of the past three years– is headed in the right direction on education, only 26% say yes. Another 28% say the state is headed in the wrong direction, and 43% say the changes have had little impact at all.
Bottom line: Cuomo does not have a commanding lead, The liberal base of the Democratic party doesn’t like him, and his record on education is a weak spot for him.

I’ve never voted for a Republican Governor in 35 years. That changes this year. Astorino for Gov.
LikeLike
Astorino is against Common Core, but for standardized testing and charters. Probably also supports vouchers and dissolving unions.
LikeLike
My family voted for Cuomo when he ran for governor. This time we will vote “against” him as all conscientious New Yorkers should do.
He has been nothing short of a disgrace to the people of this great state.
It’s time to give another candidate the chance to do the right thing by our citizens. The first thing, standing up for all of the people of our state, against the corporate interests whose money Cuomo’s fingerprints are all over.
Mr Cuomo…you definitely are beatable. More and more New Yorkers are getting to see what you really are…a shill for the one percent. Your platform should be as the representative and lobbyist for the corporatists, not the children that you have sold out. You insult the people of New York.
And we believe that it is time for you to step down at a minimum, and be held accountable for the malpractice you have brought to our state.
We will prove this to you come November.
LikeLike
Cuomo will not be getting my vote, nor will Astorino. I’m disgusted with Astorino’s games concerning the Westchester County housing settlement. I will be voting for a third party candidate.
LikeLike
3rd party is the ONLY way to vote. I wish the Democrats and Republicans would join together under the Neoliberal party. Why let guns and abortions stop you from raking it in?
LikeLike
Daniel,
Sure wish people in this country would just THINK about the long-term consequences of the unholy two-party system of OLIGARCHS.
LikeLike
I am working on a doctoral research project inspired by Diane’s book, Death and Life of the Great American School System (2011). If the public school system–as many of us knew it, at least–is dead or near death, it would stand to reason that public school teachers who remember the system as it was prior to No Child Left Behind (2002) have experienced loss and grief. If you remember what it was like to teach prior to No Child Left Behind, if you feel as if teaching completely changed when No Child Left Behind was implemented, or if you ever felt saddened by some of the changes that resulted from educational reform, then you may be interested in taking my survey.
Professional Loss and Grief in Teachers (a survey)
https://ndstate.co1.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_5nCLnPAFadWZX93
LikeLike
It’s interesting to me, the one thing that the common core authors forgot all about were the parents who have to watch their kids suffer and hate school They are a powerful force to reckon with and it’s my hope they will all eventually take down the common core in all states.
LikeLike
Thank you Julie…my wife and I are two of those parents that have seen the horrors of Common Core.
Our children repeatedly tell us, when they try to complete their homework, that our way of doing math homework makes more sense, than the nonsensical faux methodology they have been subjected to.
Thus, our children reject Common Core…which shouldn’t be surprising.
Obama, Duncan, and Gates children would hate it too…perhaps that is why they have not been subjected to it. Corporatist salespeople not even trying to sell an inferior product, but resorting to forcing it upon others.
I guess that makes me a special interest person…we like to refer to ourselves as the following…
…parents.
LikeLike
Governor Cuomo has lost supporters from the conservatives. In a talk show he told us that we are not welcomed and that we should leave the state. He lost the votes of people who are fighting the Common Core. Anyone who has a background in philosophy of education, learning theories, early childhood education, in child psychology, development disabilities, a strong background in math and language arts, as most of our teachers, can not vote for Cuomo. He apparently has no background in education and yet makes devastating decisions adversely affecting children, parents and teachers. How can anyone who is truly concerned about children’s education ever support the Common Core – unless they are listening to others who are not informed and have not done their research but only “shoot from the hips”?! How can anyone take money away from school systems that need the money for teachers and kindergarten only to turn around and implement pre-k accompanied by its direct teaching along with its paper- pencil activities and to do so without consulting the early childhood experts?!
Rob Astorino is our hope of getting rid of the Common Core along with its aligned high stakes testing. Rob Astorino is our hope who respects life and won’t ask conservatives to leave the state. Astorino is out hope of appropriating money wisely and efficiently.
LikeLike
We need to form an organization called something like: “Former Cuomo Supporters Who Will No Longer Vote For Him Under Any Circumstances Because Of His Positions On Tying Test Data To Teacher Evaluations (even though he invalidated said test results for students), Charter Schools, the CC and All Testing in General. Has a snappy sound to it, no?
LikeLike
As one who has struggled in the past to pull any lever but one designated for a democratic candidate, I will NOT vote for Cuomo in the next election. His arrogance and constant courting of business interests at the mercy of our state’s students is appalling. Astorino is looking better every day.
LikeLike
I will be voting for the Working Families Party candidate, WHOEVER it is. WFP is very well organized and a 24 percent showing for an unnamed WFP candidate right now could transform into a named candidate that could beat Cuomo this fall, despite Cuomo’s $33-million hedge-funded campaign war chest. WFP can get VOLUNTEER boots on the ground, so they just don’t need the same level of money.
There is widespread dissatisfaction for “Governor One Percent,” who shelved the anti-corruption Moreland Commission, passed meaningless campaign financing changes, gave away NYC schools to charters, refused to let NYC increase its minimum wage, still hasn’t given adequate funding to schools even as he grants a tax cut to corporations. He will gain practically no moderate Republicans with these actions, he will lose many moderate Democrats, all progressive democrats, and he lost the conservative vote with his two (and his only two) “liberal” actions: legislation on gun control and gay marriage.
His support of Common Core and its testing enforcement stick is the final nail in the coffin. At least 33,000 kids opted out of testing for NYS ELA. you can bet their parents feel strongly about this issue and you can bet they will not be voting for Gov. Cuomo this fall.
Common Core and the high stakes nature of teaching Common Core is hurting my kids learning.
Just this month, my youngest child was given ridiculously (needlessly) confusing Common-Core aligned lessons in fractions (problem sets with multiple choice answers, of course). It jumped more than a year ahead of where the class left off last year in fractions, introduced too many concepts in one lesson, and the questions themselves seemed more designed to make sure you were parsing the question rather than understanding the concepts. This kid is “mathy” and he felt confused and disheartened. I guess he should develop some grit and learn how to cope when lesson is not at the appropriate level for him. To make him feel better, today, I pulled out an old math book for his grade level from some years ago, showed him the fractions lessons there. He got it and felt confident. He could do math at his grade level. (At the same level that I was at for that grade, which allowed me to somehow finish high school math and be ready to take calculus and advanced math courses in college.) At the end, he told me he got it, but he doesn’t think he likes math anymore. Congrats Common Core!
My oldest kid’s high school is following Common Core and teachers even had to cite to Common Core standards at a fairly detailed level in their syllabi for courses. He had an essay assignment to analyze a poem, purely by looking at poet’s literary devices, to discuss only poem author’s intended meaning, and with an absolute prohibition on including anything on the student’s perspective of the poem. (Remember, Common Core architect David Coleman’s guiding principle: Preparing kids for the world of work, where “nobody gives a $#I& what you think.”)
Really? Studying literature is about divining the author’s one true meaning? Don’t readers need to engage and react to a piece of literature? Don’t readers make their own meaning? I feel like the writers of the Common Core know nothing about what motivates young writers and readers and, apparently, haven’t kept up with the last 30+ years of literary analysis. Author’s intent, mechanics of the piece just two parts of literary analysis. Art is MEANT to cause a reaction.
Common Core seems meant to teach children they are stupid, their opinions don’t matter, they better buckle down, and they better follow the directions closely. Someone they don’t even know has created the standards and the measures to judge them , which they need to accept without question, and they better measure up. Perfect for worker drones.
LikeLike
Love your post.
I’m afraid that too many of the No Votes are based on Cuomo’s gun laws and not on the education issues.
If there are enough of us crying foul to CC and the current testing environment, then maybe, at a politically expedient moment, King will get the boot. Especially if suburban parents who didn’t opt out their children get another set of low scores prior to the election (although, if King is smart, he’ll change those cut scores to show miraculous growth “due to the common core curriculum”.)
King fired – that’s a small victory I’m looking forward to, hopefully in the not so distant future.
LikeLike
Fingers crossed on that firing. I believe you are right and he will adjust the cut scores down this year so more kids are passing. Let’s make sure people are aware of how much that cut scores goes up and down each year!
LikeLike
AMEN, NY Parent. AGREE totally.
LikeLike
Cuomo’s numbers are falling. That is really good news. He can be beaten in November! Time to turn up the heat and talk to more people. It is up to us to keep talking to and educating anyone who is willing to listen. This bully of a governor, and his wealthy benefactors, need to lose in a big way. Thanks for the report Diane.
LikeLike
Cuomo for president?? Do you think if Hillary runs? I don’t think so.
LikeLike
Always have voted for Democrats, but not this year. I have a feeling Cuomo and others are going to be very surprised by the high number of voters who have had it with politicians who ignore the voices of educators, parents, and citizens. Obama may have fooled me with words of hope and change, but hope doesn’t do it for me anymore. I’m looking at what candidates do these days. Actions or lack of actions speak much louder than words.
LikeLike
Working Families Party is looking for feedback: take their survey and tell them you’d like them to support a 3rd party candidate and not Cuomo:
http://action.workingfamiliesparty.org/p/dia/action3/common/public/?action_KEY=9732
LikeLike
If the WFP can’t get it together, the Green Party is also fielding a candidate on the ballot. Excerpted here is his recent education statement:
“…[Howie] Hawkins chose to announce in front of the NYC Board of Education to highlight his call for adequate funding for public schools and an end to high-stakes testing. Hawkins said, “High-stakes tests are designed to define the children, teachers, and schools of disadvantaged communities as failures in order to privatize their schools as charters for profit-seeking investors. Public schools are not for sale. It’s time to stop the corporate privatization agenda.”
…
“Hawkins had harsh criticisms for Cuomo’s education agenda for shortchanging funding for public education, pushing high-stakes testing linked to the Common Core Standards to evaluate schools and teachers, undermining teachers’ professional autonomy, and favoring private charter schools over public schools. Hawkins would replace Common Core and high-stakes testing with common standards and diagnostic tests written by teachers, not corporate contractors. He opposes Cuomo’s push to take away community control of schools and give it to Mayors.
“Cuomo and his Republican allies in the Senate have defied the courts’ orders to fully fund the constitutionally required sound basic education. The cumulative shortfall on Foundation Aid to meet this constitutional requirement is now over $9 billion. The state is being sued for this failure. Cuomo’s underfunding of education is forcing school districts, particularly those in inner cities and rural areas, to hike regressive property taxes, cut staffing and programs, and many will go broke,” said Hawkins.
Hawkins said that Cuomo’s hostility to public school teachers and their unions and his support for charter schools must be understood in light of his large campaign contributions from wealthy hedge fund managers who profit from the favorable tax treatment of investments in charter schools and who like the fact that most charters are non-union.
“The roots of low achievement for some schools and students lie in concentrated poverty, segregation by race and class, and underfunding,” Hawkins said. “Cuomo’s high-stakes testing regime is designed to fail the underfunded schools and teachers of low-income children in order to privatize the schools and de-unionize and downgrade the teaching profession. It won’t better educate disadvantaged students. It just punishes them for being disadvantaged,” said Hawkins.
Hawkins views education as a basic human right. He has called for expanding public education from early childhood through college. He supports statewide universal full day Pre-K and Kindergarten with certified and unionized educators. For public higher education, he supports free tuition at CUNY, SUNY, and community colleges. He pointed out that City residents had voted to make CUNY tuition free, a decision that was overruled by the corporate and political elite as part of deal to rescue the city from bankruptcy. He supports the Dream Act, viewing its recent rejection by the State Senate as an immoral assault on the values of America as the land of opportunity and a nation of immigrants. He supports access to college by prison inmates.”
http://www.howiehawkins.org/howie_hawkins_nyc_on_education_mass_transit
LikeLike
I will be voting third party in NY. Didn’t vote for mainstream candidate last time because neither candidate was appropriate. Cuomo has devastated New York not only by his love of all things corporate and charter and VAM and CCSS, but by the tax cap on rural schools, which is rapidly destroying them. And that referendum on technology in schools? Vote it down. It is only to supply computers for online testing while school budgets suffer.
LikeLike
I agree that Cuomo’s proposed $2 billion education bond act will undoubtedly going to go for tech for testing, perhaps for our very own state-sponsored inBloom style data collection. Our own I-pads for testing Deasy-style boondoggle. I agree it should be opposed. Even if we wanted education funding, why go into debt? Cuomo could generate this money for schools just by eliminating his NYS corporate tax cut.
LikeLike
Cuomo is the enemy within. He spends two years eviscerating school budgets, is directly responsible for the layoff of 15,000 teachers, legislates a tax cap that to further punish public schools, legislates APPR calling it his crowning achievement, and then conveniently cancels his corruption probe just before taking $800,000 from Success Academy after which he legislates a give-away of public school money and space to charters. He should be impeached, The man is a criminal.
LikeLike
The Common [sic] Core [sic] State [sic] Standards [sic] were created because some educational publishing monopolists and would-be monopolists wanted a single national bullet list to tag their software and assessments to. These “standards” never were about better education. They were an essential prerequisite to the implementation of a particular business plan. See Mercedes Schneider’s recap of who paid for them and why, here:
LikeLike
The NYS election might serve as a litmus test for a national third party run… and those who came of age in the 1970s recall that NYS has already had a successful third party candidate: James L. Buckley who won as a Conservative in 1970 with 38% of the vote. The key: he garnered votes from the middle and held on to the hard core conservatives. BTW, I did a quick Wikipedia check (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_L._Buckley) and learned he was the legislator who introduced FERPA… and also the first individual to successfully challenge spending limits for campaigns… Oh, and my Wikipedia research (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_Families_Party) reveals one achilles heel for WFP, it seems that ACORN was in on the creation of the part in 1998… I can see Rupert Murdoch rubbing his hands with glee on THAT little tidbit ;-).
All of that said, it seems like the State AG Eric Schneiderman might be a strong candidate for WFP to consider: he’s got name recognition, he sued Trump for starting a “university”, he’s one of the few State AGs who wanted to aggressively pursue mortgage fraud, and I gotta believe he is appalled at the decision to abandon the Moreland Commission…
LikeLike
It’s hard to believe that THIS guy is the son of Mario Cuomo. Maybe it’s the difference between growing up in humble circumstances as the son of two Italian immigrants who ran a small grocery store in South Jamaica, Queens, as opposed to having a father who was a major lawyer and elected official.
It’s stunning, really, the contrast between these two. To best illustrate it, listen and/or read the words of the father, Mario Cuomo, a truly good and gifted man with a genuine compassion for others of lesser means.
Please take the time to really listen. I remember this speech, almost exactly 30 years ago and it is as moving now as it was that evening. (I remember thinking, and I wasn’t alone, that THIS should be our nominee, not the well-meaning, but quite ineffective, Walter Mondale.)
and in print:
http://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/mariocuomo1984dnc.htm
LikeLike
Thank you PSP. And best of luck standing up to Arne Duncan and the plutocracy he represents. Take him all the way to the Supreme Court.
LikeLike