Julie Vassilatos, a Chicago parent, blogs about school issues.
In one of her latest posts, she realized she could no longer use the term “education reform” because it was a complete phony and misrepresentation of reality.
She writes:
Something in me snapped today and I realized that I am finished using the phrase “education reform.”
That’s how folks refer to the constellation of ideas firmly entrenched in the White House right now, upheld by almost every governor of every state, red and blue, and most mayors, notably our own. It includes the tenets that privatizing our schools will improve them, that the Common Core State Standards are the fix for all that ails our failing schools, and that testing our students more and more will raise test scores.
But this, truly, is not “reform.” Some of these are ideas that have been implemented for 25 years all over the country to little effect.
This is the status quo.
So I’m not going to call it reform anymore.
I’m going to call it what it is. Corporate control of education.
I want you to read her whole post so I hate to print too much of it. But it is so on-target, so clear-headed, so obvious that I am going to have to give you even more to think about, then go open the link and read how this Chicago mom went straight to the heart of the beast:
In every instance, every plank in the platform, every element of this effort can be traced back to cash–flowing into the coffers of very rich corporate entities and individuals.
Like Pearson, one of the testing companies that is creating the tests and the test prep materials, all new and improved and Common Core aligned, and who lobbies Congress to mandate more tests.
Like Reed Hastings, Netflix CEO, a huge proponent of charters and innovative uses of technology in schools. What kind of technology does he advocate as the best fix for students today? In Learning Lab modules at his Rocketship Charters kids sit at a computer monitor, streaming video content for 100 minutes per day.
Or Rupert Murdoch. He is a cheerleader for what he calls a $500 billion industry of education technology including content and assessment.
Or Bill Gates. His push for the Common Core, the inBloom initiative to harness students’ big data, and his vision for the classrooms of the future, which will be heavily dependent on his own technologies.
The proponents of this snake oil have managed to control the rhetoric for so long that we don’t even blink when they say that their education plan is “the civil rights issue of our time.” They say this a lot.
So if we wish to stand up against the corporate control model we are not only anti-reform but anti-civil rights.
They say they want “excellent teachers,” and by this they mean they want to get rid of union teachers and replace them with uncertified, pensionless staff handling up to 50 kids at once who receive their education from handheld devices or monitors.
They say they want “school choice,” which usually means less choice: families can’t choose their neighborhood schools that the city has underfunded to the point of death throes, pouring its available money instead into privately supported charters.
I don’t know Julie, but I know this: She has seen through the sham rhetoric and the phony claims. She has seen through the facade to the internal workings of a machine that hurts children, closes community schools, and will ultimately do grievous harm to our democracy.
She writes:
Enough little bits of reality have popped out that folks are starting to notice. The stranglehold grip on the narrative held by the corporate education controllers is beginning to weaken. Because we can all see with our own eyes that it isn’t actually civil rights for kids to have their school closed or subjected to a turnaround. It isn’t actually higher order critical thinking to bubble in bubbles. And it isn’t education and it isn’t reform to work toward the dismantling of public schools in our city and our country.
It’s stale old rhetoric that is losing its power. And it can no longer conceal the naked emperor, nor the naked greed of the corporate power grabbers.
Thanks, Julie, for seeing through the PR baloney.
I am so tired of the media accepting the corporate bosses’ claim that they are “reformers.” Listen up, reporters. They are NOT reformers. Their program is the corporate control of education.
Excellent essay! I will forward it to my Congressional delegation. I continue to be amazed at how many of my colleagues are in denial about the real reform agenda. Years ago, Bill Gates claimed that the traditional high school had become obsolete; he is doing everything in his power to prove himself right.
Speaking of congressional delegations, I’ve just gotten two replies to my letters.
First, from Elizabeth Warren. You should sit down if you’re prone to feeling like a lead weight has hit you in the stomach when somebody betrays your trust.
“Thank you contacting me with your concerns about Common Core school standards.
“The Common Core State Standards are a set of education standards developed by the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers. Common Core attempts to establish a single set of educational goals and expectations for students across the country. The standards have been adopted by 44 states, including Massachusetts.
“I support efforts to set high standards for all students. I also believe that states and local education agencies should have the flexibility they need to provide their students with a great education. I recently cosponsored the Strengthening America’s Schools Act, which would make much-needed changes to give children a fair shot at success while also preserving for states the flexibility to set standards for academic content.
“Because the ultimate decision of whether to adopt Common Core standards is left to the states, I recommend that you contact your State Representative, your State Senator, and the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education with your concerns.
“I appreciate your reaching out to me on this important matter, and I will keep your thoughts in mind as I continue to work to improve our nation’s education system.”
omerta
This is very similar to what California Senator Diane Feinstein wrote me which I posted a few days ago. But Diane, whose billionaire husband, Richard Bloom (or Blum) sits on the U. of California Board of Regents, and prospers hugely from all things warlike, and reformy, and like the Kochs, many things used widely industry, Diane was definitely in favor of CC. Maybe they have investments in charter schools too.
“I’m going to call it what it is. Corporate control of education.”
It’s not CC but CCOE.
“U.S. Secretary of Commerce Penny Pritzker will discuss how the public and private sectors can work together to best equip workers for the jobs of the future in a “keynote interview” at the 2014 ASU+GSV Education Innovation Summit on Wednesday, April 23, 2014. Forbes Publisher Rich Karlgaard will conduct the interview, which will take place at the Phoenician Resort in Scottsdale, Arizona.”
Speakers list is a like an ed reformer roll call; Jeb Bush, Chris Cerf, Cami Anderson, Reed Hastings, Margaret Spelling…
“Tom Vander Ark is author of Getting Smart: How Digital Learning is Changing the World and CEO of Getting Smart, a education advocacy firm. Tom advocates for innovations that customize and motivate learning and extend access. Tom is also a partner in Learn Capital, an education venture capital firm investing in EdTech startups. Previously he served as President of the X PRIZE Foundation and was the first Executive Director of Education for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.”
I’m weirdly comforted that there don’t seem to be any public school people who aren’t “rockstars” on the list.
Maybe ordinary public school administrators are busy administering the Common Core tests 🙂
http://edinnovation.gsvadvisors.com/2014-speakers/
Pritzker got a major payoff for her support of Obama…first on the Chicago School Board, and now a Cabint position. All you need to do this is billions to grease all the palms in DC.
Thought this was interesting. It’s a Toledo Blade op ed on Common Core. It’s supportive of Common Core, but the tone is much more respectful and less dismissive of dissenters than the national political/media theme. They actually (partly) address the objections to the CC without resorting to calling people who object to this union thugs (“on the Left”) or paranoid (“on the Right”).
Also, this:
“Testing needs to return to its original purpose: as a diagnostic tool, not an excuse for cutting off someone’s funding.”
I think this change where they’re actually questioning standardized testing is due solely to the opt-outers and other public ed activists and advocates. Ohio newspapers have basically rubber-stamped every “ed reform” in this state for the last 15 years.
Politicians read local media coverage because they have to get elected locally. David Brooks has only one vote, and it’s not in Ohio. Hopefully this will trickle up to the thought leaders 🙂
Read more at http://www.toledoblade.com/DavidKushma/2014/04/20/Make-Common-Core-better-in-Ohio-don-t-scrap-it.html#fg5PFLdLBftOuhCH.99
Chiara, did you see the youtube clip from the Connecticut GOP gubernatorial primary from over the weekend? I forwarded it to the Fitzgerald campaign with some of my thoughts. Maybe you can do the same with yours (surely more powerful/persuasive than mine).
I think you’re vastly overestimating my persuasive powers 🙂
I haven’t seen it and would like to, so link if you can.
FitzGerald came out here months ago campaigning and I did talk to him about public ed. I went up to him after his speech. He seemed open to talking about it and I know he’s campaigning on Kasich public ed funding cuts generally. If you’ll link the video I’ll send it to him too.
I’d be happy to join any big push on public ed with FitzGerald. I think it’s worth a shot. Maybe ask to meet w/him on just that issue?
Certainly. This link should work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7k2yWJuHv8
Great points! There is a large NYC contingency who refer to “ed reform” as ed deform! Myself… I still like to put the corporate BS in quotes and use the actual term they throw out at the public. Each time I hit the shit key to add the quotes, I am reminded of all the words and phrases THEY TWIST… I become ultra sensitive to the constant SPIN of the phrase “ed reform” this hideous movement is so found of. It is like a childhood game where everything you say…”is the opposite”! Non profit, rigorous, differentiation, highly qualified, and I regrettably could go on and on as the list grows by day!
I am going to plug what I believe is a great grassroots movement to express how “we the people” feel nowadays (especially since the McCutcheon decision). An organization out of Burlington VT (started by Ben Cohen of Ben and Jerry’s) is selling stamps with logos like “stamp money out of politics” for ordinary citizens to put on dollar bills. Apparently it is legal because the money is not destroyed and nothing is ironically being commercially sold! Maybe since something “snapped” with the author… she could take out her frustration by stamping! Check it out:
http://www.stampstampede.org/
LOVE the stamp! Will be ordering some, to give to friends as well.
Woops I meant to say “each time I hit the shift key”!
We were just informed today, at a teacher inservice, that we should no longer use the names Common Core State Standards or CCSS, here in Illinois. They are now the Illinois Learning Standards…new name same thing. http://www.isbe.state.il.us/ILS/
I’m sure if I took the time to go through them (though I’m very tired of wasting to my time keeping track of all their spin) they would be almost exactly the same. Do they think we don’t read? We’re teachers, it’s our job to read and comprehend. In fact we teach others to do the same thing, can the creators of the CCSS say the same thing?
The confusion and disorientation I felt when I opened the link to find a Los Angeles Citywatch header dissolved as I read Julie’s piece. A Chicago blogger got highlighted in Los Angeles!
Right on! Let’s start a conversation about the lack of civil rights for non-“chartered” public school students, like the handicapped ones that Success Academy will displace next fall in nyc. Let’s start another one to dislodge all elected officials who support charter schools, starting with Governor Cuomo of New York State. Force in unity!
Here is the data-driven Corporate Control of Education act Elizabeth Warren co-sponsored.
HELP Chairman Tom Harkin Introduces the “Strengthening America’s Schools Act of 2013”
Bill Summary
Sustain current state reform efforts and provide them the flexibility they need to improve their schools
If a state has an accountability system approved by the Secretary, it can continue to use the approved accountability system. If not, a state will adopt an accountability system that is equally ambitious and holds all students to high expectations of student achievement.
All accountability systems will include student academic achievement and growth, English language proficiency and, for high schools, graduation rates for all students; systems will also include accountability for all subgroups. This accountability system asks states to identify and support –
o Priority schools – The lowest-achieving 5 percent of each Title I elementary schools and Title I secondary schools, and secondary schools with a graduation rate lower than 60 percent.
o Focus Schools – Ten percent of Title I schools with the greatest achievement gaps and secondary schools with the greatest graduation rate gaps between subgroups.
o For all other schools, districts will identify schools experiencing achievement gaps across subgroups and will develop and implement a locally-designed intervention for that school based on input from the community.
Support great teachers and principals and ensure that all children receive the best instruction.
Help ensure there are great teachers and principals in every school by supporting evaluations that will inform professional development to help promote school success.
chemtchr
Its like one of those movies where there is a sudden realization that the people you thought were on your side, are on the other.