The New York State Senate has written a budget bill that opens the public coffers to charter schools and guts mayoral control in New York City. If the Republican-controlled Senate has its way, the charters will get more money, will not pay rent, will get new slots for pre-K, and will be protected against any effort by Mayor de Blasio to reverse decisions made by the lame-duck Bloomberg administration.
In the past, Mayor Bloomberg gave the charter operators whatever they wanted. He was also a major funder of Republicans in the State Senate. The very sizable campaign contributions by hedge fund managers (Democrats for Education Reform) to New York politicians are paying off for the charter operators, which enroll 3% of children in New York State and 6% in New York City.
According to the report in the New York Daily News,
“The Senate’s budget proposal expected to be unveiled later in the day would bar Mayor de Blasio from rescinding co-location agreements with charters, boost per pupil funding for charter school students, and prohibit school districts from charging rent to charters that co-locate in an existing public school building, the Daily News has learned.
“The measures are part of a comprehensive seven-point charter school plan expected to be put forward in a one-house budget resolution by the Senate Republicans and five dissident Democrats who control the chamber together, sources briefed on the plan say.
“De Blasio recently rescinded co-location agreements with three charter schools operated by former City Councilwoman Eva Moskowitz. The Senate plan put together by Senate GOP Leader Dean Skelos and his members along with the Independent Democratic Conference led by Sen. Jeffrey Klein would reverse that, sources said.
“Under the proposal, the sources said, any charter school that was approved to co-locate in a public school building prior to Jan. 1, 2014 would be protected. The measure will state that any significant change in school building utilization relating to co-location shall not be authorized without the consent of the charter school.
“Charter schools in New York City receive nearly 30% less in public funding per pupil than traditional public schools. The Senate plan would boost the basic tuition amount the city would transfer per pupil to the charters.
“Charter schools for the first time would also be eligible to receive separate state building aid funding after de Blasio cut $210 million in city capital money earmarked for the charters that build in private locations.
“The plan would also pressure the city to provide public space for charters by creating an additional cost to the city if they don’t. Under the plan, sources said, the city would be required to pay an additional 25% on top of the per pupil money it gives out to charter schools so a charter can go into a private space.
“And in hopes of protecting charter schools from future problems with the city, the Senate would allow them to apply to the SUNY Charter Institute or the state board of Regents to oversee and supervise them, rather than the city.
“The Senate would also authorize charters to provide full-day prekindergarten programs, something Gov. Cuomo has said he would also push.”

Who has the power? The plutocrats have the power. Witness them override the popular will of NYC’s citizens.
LikeLike
The Senate Majority is poised to pass a budget resolution which includes: –Giving tax credits to wealthy donors via a back-door voucher scheme — the intent is to use public funds to finance the costs of a non-public school education;
–Increasing per-pupil funding for charter schools which comes directly out of public school coffers; and
–Providing NEW facilities funding for charters and forcing co-locations of charter schools – displacing public school students – and directly benefitting Success Academy C.E.O. Eva Moskowitz
CALL YOUR SENATOR NOW – 1-877-255-9417. Press 2 to speak with your New York State Senator.
I called two minutes ago and spoke to an aid of my state senator. It is not a done deal from what I gather. Make a call now. Actions speak louder than words.
LikeLike
If Eva’s charter schools are so great, why aren’t state legislators signing up to secure a seat for their children and grandchildren at Success Academy?
Who’s behind the curtain writing the script for Eva’s Morning Joe propaganda? I’m curious about why the “scholars” were used as chess playing props with Mika as head cheerleader. Joe and Mika are clearly in the pockets of Eva’s backers. Open records requests need to be filed on every pro charter legislator in NY and on Cuomo’s aides.
de Blasio must stand strong! Can’t compromise with greedy Wall Street hedge fund managers or their puppet Cuomo who want it all for their pet billion dollar tax funded financial projects.
LikeLike
Speechless. It used to be that NY public teachers and their mandatory master’s degrees were valued in NY and definitely in other states. Apparently NY teachers, public school students, parents, and administrators are less than dung. Apparently, we have become NYtucky or NYenessee. And our degrees and knowledge have become devalued. Whatever we are is a shadow of the proud tradition we once were, back in the days when we were bolstered by elected officials who valued the public good. Follow the money for the “new” NY.
LikeLike
Apparently Tennessee has more sense than NY
http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2014/03/tennessee-legislators-halt.html
LikeLike
How do they white wash this? Does Eva need the money? How do you justify MORE money for charter school students, when part of it goes back into private pockets, they’re already better funded than public schools through both public and private funds, and they are now going to take even more away from the public schools to give to private charters.
The mayoral control was great when the mayor and the governor agreed. Rescinding all agreements prior to Jan 1st does nothing else but rescind the decisions from before de blasio took office – quite literally. The second he does anything these people don’t agree with, they fight with a vengeance.
How can we compete with this as voters? We get to make a decision once every 4 years from a limited pool. The plutocrats get a vote every time they write a check. How is this allowable? Aren’t there conflicts of interest?
LikeLike
PS – I can’t imagine a better piggy bank for millionaires than education. Government collected taxes, that local people have very little say over how it’s controlled once it’s put in private hands, that will flow forever, and they can always cut back on the personnel and pupil expenditures to open up their profit margins.
When other sectors are flailing and you don’t know how to start a successful business in this globalized economy that doesn’t have a high risk of failure or being rapidly made worthless by technology – education is the ultimate risk-free money maker – at the cost of the children. As teachers I know used to say before I became one…they can’t outsource teaching.
Some people are paying attention to that.
LikeLike
For the children who attend public schools, de Blasio must call out the Success Academy profiteers by name and not back down. de Blasio needs a coalition of parents like TAMSA armed with speakers who present facts at churches, libraries, schools, etc. TAMSA defeated Perry and Kress using these methods – so NY parents will defeat Cuomo and the hedge fund profiteers if they organize.
LikeLike
I am speechless….It is okay to take away space for the other 94% of the students in NYC…special education students being taught in bathrooms or closets, the teachers moving from one class to another with a cart of the day’s lesson and materials, and many other atrocities while so many charter schools are taking away space from the public schools. I recently retired as a special education teacher in an elementary school. Many of the students I worked with had auditory disabilities, learning disabilities, ADHD, etc. many of whom would not have received any services in a charter school, let alone be accepted. I had to share a classroom with 3 other special needs teachers. This was a horrible situation for our students who had a great deal of difficulty focusing on tasks. It was next to impossible for the children to learn. I had to share this room because another school was placed in our building and we had to give up rooms. There is no reason why charter schools cannot build their own schools, utilize buildings that are empty….There must be a better way for the have-nots!
LikeLike
This has the unmistakable stench of DFER, Moskowitz and a whole host of unelected cronies and profiteers all over it. Their motto, like so many others who are morally and ethically bankrupt is “If you can’t earn it, steal it.”
LikeLike
Sure sounds a lot like what Glenda Ritz faced in her efforts to stand against corporate reform moneyed power.
LikeLike
This is what we’re here for: to write, speak, fact-check and expose their naked power grab.
I don’t think deBlasio is going to back down.
LikeLike
Their “naked power” has long been exposed. Time to create problems for them. There is now nothing for deBlasio to back down from. How long did you think a Republican controlled state senate would allow anyone, especially a popular new mayor, to try and stop one of their own, Moskovitz?
LikeLike
Back down from what? He’s already caved.
LikeLike
de Blasio has no more say in what’s about to happen or not happen than you or I do. He’s pissed off the wrong people, and God help us this is all in the hands of the NYS Assembly, a wretched hive of scum and villainy.
LikeLike
Using similar media/lobbying tactics as Eva/DFER, de Blasio will prevail. His voice is weak, but his message is strong. Battles are lost before the war is won. Parents need to file an avalanche of open records requests on Cuomo’s aides – then post the paperwork on the web.
LikeLike
Someone should take a poll of how many legislators who endorse this idea have children attending charters. I’m thinking it’s a par-for-the-course low number.
LikeLike
msnbc has not been very helpful…..morning joe and mika have bought the whole line of bs…..so badly that it hurts their overall credibility. Ed had a great interview today, with on site interviews of parents of special needs children being displaced……
LikeLike
Did you find them credible before this?
LikeLike
Tyranny on display! Perhaps eminent domain could be used to condemn the charter locations forcing them to build their own. Maybe they can be forced to take all comers and operate under the public rules for their public money. Isn’t this a variation on taxation without representation?
LikeLike
Cuomo will never be president. de Blasio will be New York’s next governor. DFER profiteers are fearful of the future and are actively using Eva and her “scholars” as financial props with Morning Joe as a stage.
LikeLike
Revolting.
LikeLike
I think politicians forget is there is no power like the power of angry parents.
So far, the anger has been suppressed. But it’s boiling to the surface more and more. And when it becomes fully evident that “we’re mad as hell and not going to put up with abusive testing or profit-grabs under the guise of “charters”” then politicians will quickly abandon these policies.
Until then, pity the students who will suffer from ill-conceived intervention. (And I liked Cuomo’s father…but what’s with Andrew?)
LikeLike
A problem (one of many) is that it’s easy to attack NYC students because the majority are poor – it’s a pretty proven fact that poor urban parents have less influence, and less time to devote to political machinations than more educated, affluent, suburban parents with more time. That is not based on racism or classism – I believe that’s a pretty reasonable assertion based on education and available time and energy.
How many angry protests did we have over the Bloomberg co-locations and it never stopped a single one? How many suburban protests did it take to get the state legislature to look at inBloom and the Common Core again?
You’d think given that the charter issue is smaller than the state-wide issues, that it’d be easier to make a dent in that – but we saw the opposite.
LikeLike
It is racism. This is how institutional racism works.
LikeLike
Excellent points.
LikeLike
How dare they? Where is democracy? There ought to be sit ins in these besieged public schools.
LikeLike
Time for some traffic problems in New York City.
LikeLike
Well, if all the activist parents in the leafy suburbs were looking for a moment to show their solidarity with New York City public school parents, here it is. Contact your own assemblyman / state senator (especially if you live in one of the nice burbs represented by Valesky or Klein) and tell them how you feel.
Talk about being disenfranchised: New Yorkers don’t have a democratically elected school board, and yet under this legislation we won’t really have mayoral control, either. If the state wants to amend what kind of funding they’ll provide to charters, fine. But to penalize the children who attend traditional NYC DOE schools if the DOE doesn’t give charters all the free space they want? And giving charters the power to refuse a change in utilization? That stuff is way beyond the pale.
So what will it be, suburbs?
LikeLike
Tim, you comment is potentially divisive but sobering and truthful.
Thank you for pointhing this out.
We must all be concerned for every child’s education, although we see in creasingly suburbs in which the populations are becoming more and more diverse and are morphing into suburbs with “inner city populations”. This is a growing phenomenon, and many such suburbs do fight for those who are disadvantaged.
Still, the disconnect you speak of is still too much of a prominent trait of many LEAs in NY State (I am fortunate in that I work in an LEA that is very connected to all of its students).
I think one of the lessons here to be learned is that not even affluent, soldily middle or upper middle class districts are not immunes to the predatory privatizing tactics that have now engulfed our unknowing and often too ignorant but innocent lower income urban populations.
Charterization will only further stratify our society and let our tax-paid government off the hook for its social responsibilities (and remember that we all ARE still the government) by pawning them off to some profiteers who don’t really care or know much about children, the cognitive sciences, and pedagogy.
If parents in the suburbs really care about what Cuomo intends to do, they – and the rest of us – will have to show it through our acitvism, our boycotts, and ultimately, our vote . . . . .
LikeLike
Correction (that’s what I get for writing in a rush so late at night after a 10 hour workday . . . ):
The paragraph should have read:
“I think one of the lessons here to be learned is that not even affluent, soldily middle or upper middle class districts are immune to the predatory privatizing tactics that have now engulfed our unknowing but innocent lower income urban populations.”
LikeLike
Tim–the truth is parents have done more for public ed than my own union. Parents in Florida fought and won the proposed Parent Trigger Law and now they are fighting against vouchers. Parents in Texas and in other states started the opt-out movement and have had victories regarding the over-testing of children. If you look at what’s happening with the backlash against Common Core you can thank a parent.
Yesterday Cuomo announced that the test was flawed and wouldn’t go on student record cards, but he held teachers were still accountable for the scores and VAM will apply. Haven’t heard one peep from Randi or Mulgrew. In their minds if you turn all schools into charters, they will find a way to unionize them and keep their powerful jobs.
Well Robert….These are my COPE contributions in action. First the NYS Democrats vote in the incumbent Regents including the woman who was put on the ballot last minutes and won. And on top of that a spiritual weigh-loss advisor when she isn’t a judge. And the candidates with education backgrounds lost all because they objected to the implementation of Common Core.
Randi supported almost everything Rhee did, and look where it’s got us. You want activism? But it’s okay that our own union remains silent as all this is going on.
I think all schools should be charters because they won’t be able to cherry pick or counsel out students. Then every problem the public schools face, they will too. Watch investors jump ship and all the little perks disappear.
LikeLike
Schoolgal,
I have never contributed to COPE and will not because of the tenor of the union.
I have always said to my colleagues that it will primarily – by a landslide – the PARENTS who will turn this whole thing around if ever there is a chance. The parent voice is more powerful then the union and educator’s voice . . . . . Just look at the angry bear moms of Texas as one of hundreds of examples.
But the alignment between parents and educators is also growing . . . . .
I agree with all your points and can understand any of your “I told you so” tone, which I accept.
I am not in disagreement with any of your truths at ALL, but I don’t always agree with your political strategies . . .
I can’t not get Randi Weingarten out of office fast enough, but ho wdoes one unseat her so readily, so rapidly?
We are working on it, Schoolgal, Believe me . . . . You and I are not alone in both our semtiment and actions . . . . .
LikeLike
Robert, My point to you that I have tried to make over and over again is that Randi finally changing her mind comes way too late. Even if you don’t contribute to COPE, that money is STILL being used to support Cuomo as will soon be made evident by the NYSUT elections.
Again, it’s always been what she does, or in this case doesn’t do, rather than what she says. so your enthusiasm for her so-called turn around will only land you more disappointment. Cuomo’s eval system was supported by Mulgrew. Pearson taking over certification was supported by Mulgrew. VAM and Common Core was supported by Mulgrew, and Mulgrew putting up his puppet for NYSUT president who contributed to Cuomo, came with Randi’s blessing. The same Randi that backed Klein, Gates and Duncan and whether you want to believe it or not, still does. She is playing politics with your emotions.
I have no idea what you mean by my kind of activism vs your kind.
If anything now is the time to rally all the delegates so the next AFT convention will be an interesting one and may also, God willing, give us a new leader. The point of an Iannuzzi win will be more harmful to politicians, especially Cuomo, because the union will be coming from strength not weakness. We can rally the parents and the votes because we won’t be anyone’s puppet.
LikeLike
I can’t imagine the Assembly will sign on to these building utilization rules.
LikeLike
Who the hell knows? Albany is like Thunderdome right now.
LikeLike
“Who run Bartertown?”
LikeLike
The shame of this totally expected move is that it is supported by our nominally “liberal” Governor.
LikeLike
Time to bus the other 93% to Albany for a rally and bring along the NY Daily News, Salon etc. and your own film crews, to assure news coverage. Time for a traffic jam on the route to Albany.
LikeLike
In light of the Assembly’s budget, which included de Blasio’s “millionaire’s tax,” the Senate’s move was expected and totally unsurprising. The real shame is that it is supported by our Democratic and nominally liberal Governor.
LikeLike
Outrageous!
When Bloomberg was Mayor, I highly doubt that Albany and the Governor would have undercut him the way they’re whittling away at Mayor deBlasio.
I’m not in favor of mayoral control of the public schools ( we do have a Chancellor, after all), but since Mayor deBlasio has been elected, it appears that our own State government is doing everything it can to undermine him and what he hopes to achieve for public education in the city.
The only thing I’m getting out of all this- money talks. Let the public be damned. If deBlasio doesn’t fight back with all of his power, the real losers will be all of those students attending public schools in NYC.
Obviously, our politicians up in Albany care more about their own careers and lining their own pockets than the constituencies they claim to serve.
Time to start a massive letter writing campaign to let our so called “representatives” know how we feel.
LikeLike
Scary part of this in NY is bad enough, bit I also wonder if this is one version of ALEC’s strategy complete with the model legislation to ram-rod through in multiple states. I have not checked this out but it has the stench of ALEC.
Second problem in many states and communities is the absence of excellent candidates for public office who will fight for public schools, regardless of party. Neither Democrats or Republicans can be trusted.
Public indifference is also a major problem, aging population, selfie millennial, higher education also under attack.
Critically informed teacher education is being gutted in about 24 states by the new gatekeeping test from Pearson (called edTPA) for this generation of teachers. It was developed by Stanford University and endorsed by a bunch of teacher associations before the reliability and validity of the test has been established.
Need more activists who can take the risks associate with stopping this devastation.
LikeLike
Hi everyone. I want to share a talk I just gave to the School Board of Palm Beach County, FL.
VAM: The Scarlet Letter
http://youtu.be/dfMymU86Bjo
LikeLike
It really is time for a call for true equity in public education. Bus all the rest of the kids in the state to Albany on a school day under the banner “Same Rules for All Public Schools.”
Don’t concede to this Right/Right Lite two party system!
See: “The Left Has Left the Building” http://www.truthdig.com/eartotheground/item/adolph_reed_jr_the_left_has_left_the_building_20140312
LikeLike
Correction: one party system
US politicians, so in love with “choice”, really give us a selection of just “…two neoliberal parties, one of which distinguishes itself by being actively in favor of multiculturalism and diversity and the other of which distinguishes itself as being actively opposed to multiculturalism and diversity. But on 80 percent of the issues on which 80 percent of the population is concerned 80 percent of the time there is no real difference between them.”
And, the Right Lite’s commitment to multiculturalism and diversity applies only if “it doesn’t negatively affect upper-class economic interests. Democratic liberalism has used such anti-discriminatory displays as a veil to cover a general disregard for economic justice.”
LikeLike
It’s been a tough week, for NYS and the rest of the USA. Getting weary, and wish more parents would stop being so complacent and trust that their neighborhood schools are insulated. Cosmic Tinker has it right. Time to rally again in Albany, yet we’ll do it on a Saturday not a school day.
LikeLike
What will a rally do? In the next election – who do I vote for?
The republican candidate who would be in league with the Senate republicans endorsing this? Or Cuomo? Why should he listen to voter sentiment when in a blue state like NY, he likely will win, and knows if he doesn’t, he will have backed monied interests to support him in other political ventures – and then the neo-lib republicans win and where are we then?
It seems virtually the only way to make a change now is to co-opt the Senate too since we’re not going to likely have the governor’s office for close to another decade with someone who will support public education.
LikeLike
Time to have sit ins in the schools which Eva and Co. Are trying to colonize.
LikeLike
Excellent point, make it local and vote.
LikeLike