Cami Anderson, the state-appointed superintendent of Newark public schools, has grown increasingly high-handed in recent weeks. In driving through her so-called “One Newark” plan, she suspended principals who dissented, she stormed out of a meeting of the elected advisory board, and now she has announced she will no longer meet with the board. Read Politico’s account here.
Randi Weingarten sent the following letter to Governor Chris Christie, calling for an end to two decades of state control of New Jersey’s largest city.
“Letter from Randi Weingarten to New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie on the school crisis in Newark”
February 26, 2014
The Honorable Chris Christie
Governor of New Jersey
PO Box 001
Trenton, NJ 08625
Dear Governor Christie:
There is a crisis in Newark. And that crisis was made worse by your schools Superintendent Cami Anderson opting not to attend last night’s School Advisory Board meeting to hear the concerns and desires of parents, educators, students and the people of Newark.
Governor, you have complete and total control over the schools—the way they are managed, the way they are funded. The Newark community has met state requirements to regain local control twice now, in 2011 and 2013. But your administration kept changing the bar, and the state remains in control.
At the very least, then, your superintendent has the obligation to listen to the people of Newark—the people who send their children to our schools, and the people who spend their working lives trying to make a difference in children’s lives.
So we’re clear, please know I don’t condone disrespectful behavior, be it at a school board meeting or when, in my opinion, you bullied teachers. However, the potential that some at a school board meeting could be boisterous does not justify the superintendent skipping it entirely.
The people of Newark want their schools back. They don’t want the One Newark plan, and they have lost faith in the way Superintendent Anderson has managed the city’s public schools.
Let me explain. Superintendent Anderson dismantled the Global Village—a smart, community-driven effort to provide children with much-needed wraparound services. She ended the Newcomer program, which provided support for English language learners. Her “renew” schools efforts have yielded poor results. She quickly spent the sizable donation from Facebook. She suspended several administrators who disagreed with her, and she made backroom deals with charter operators. She is forcing through her One Newark plan despite public outcry. And now, under the guise of so-called budget problems, the superintendent has asked out-going state Education Commissioner Chris Cerf to allow her to waive our contract and state law, and wants to replace experienced teachers with new Teach for America recruits, who have never stepped into a classroom and have no qualifications to teach in the Newark schools.
We worked on that contract together. We agreed that it put into place policies that would be good for students and for teachers. You said yourself that it would “improve the quality of education across the City of Newark.” This is a failure of management, a failure of fiscal stewardship and a failure of instructional leadership.
Rather than deal with the fact that Newark students are suffering, school buildings are crumbling and staggering inequities persist, Superintendent Anderson would instead blame and mass fire the people who have devoted their lives to helping Newark’s children.
Instead of driving deeper divisions and distrust in Newark, we need to be focused on solutions that work—early childhood education, wraparound services, project-based learning, professional development and more. We need to make Newark schools places where kids can build trusting relationships with each other and with adults, where they can learn the critical-thinking skills they need to compete in the 21st century, and where they develop the persistence and grit they’ll need to deal with adversity.
Governor, the Newark community has made it known: They don’t want mass closings, mass firings or mass privatization. They want to regain local control of the district. They want to reclaim the promise of public education in Newark.
I ask you to listen. Give the people of Newark their schools and their future back.
Sincerely,
Randi Weingarten
cc:
Newark Superintendent Cami Anderson
Education Commissioner Chris Cerf
Newark Teachers Union President Joesph Del Grosso
AFT-New Jersey President Donna Chiera
State Senator Ronald Rice
State Senator M. Teresa Ruiz
State Senate President Steve Sweeney
State Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto
Educators are educators.
Edictators are edictators.
Ne’er the twain shall meet.
Very clever!
a letter is something, I guess…. where are the union feet in the street protesting? ACTIONS speak louder than (written) words….
Newark Education Workers Caucus is having a mass rally on 3/18 at 4PM at the corner of Market and Broad. It will protest the next School Board business meeting (which Cami will not be attending).
…and Christie’s response is…….when pigs fly.
I love Randi’s commitment to wrap-around services and early childhood educ. I hope discussion at NPE remains civil w re to CCSS.
There is no “civility” in CC$$.
TRU DAT!
TFA New Jersey seems to be tap-dancing around their involvement in One Newark. In response to an article contending that TFA is working with Cami Anderson (a former TFA teacher herself) to greatly increase TFA’s presence in Newark, TFA announced that they currently have 48 first year and 17 second year TFA teachers in Newark Public Schools — and totally dodged the fact that there are additional TFA teachers working in charter schools in Newark, and that some teachers who started as first year teachers in NPS last year are now teaching in charter schools!
TFA should clear the air: how many first and second year TFA teachers are currently working in Newark charter schools? What were the number of 1st and 2nd year TFA teachers in both NPS and Newark charters last year, and what are the numbers projected to be over the next two years?
Cami Anderson will not survive as Superintendent, the groundswell building against her is too strong. TFA needs to get out in front of this mess or TFA NJ is going to face the public backlash as well.
FTFA!
How many TFA scabs can dance on the head of a pin?
The TFA NJ website describes Cami this way: “Cami Anderson (Los Angeles Corps ‘93)”. But elsewhere I’ve read that she is also a former TFA executive! Why would they promote her TFA teaching experience without noting her other experience with TFA? It seems they want to promote the image that the network of TFA alumni are informed and motivated solely by what they learned in the classroom, and not by the ideology or interests of TFA itself.
This blog post by Owen Davis, another former TFA teacher, says that he examined an internal TFA database and found that 114 TFA teachers were placed in Newark charter schools over the last 2 years, and 73 were placed in district schools.
This is well worth a read to get all the details:
http://commonal.tumblr.com/post/78003721842/tfa-in-newark-act-as-if-the-facts-matter
good letter, but the list of grievances against Anderson in this letter is also a list of Christie’s goals
But, again, a great letter.
Letter rings hollow; she’s writing to a politician who plays God. Bridgegate.
It is just a letter, more action is certainly needed, but it’s a good letter. I hope it is on the front page of NJ and NY newspapers.
Yeah, sure, Randi…
Coming from one of so-called education reform’s chief enablers, the half-life of these well-spoken but empty words will expire in 3 … 2 … 1 …
We worked on that contract together. We agreed that it put into place policies that would be good for students and for teachers. You said yourself that it would “improve the quality of education across the City of Newark.”
Chris Christie reneged on a contract? Now there’s a shocker.
They want to get rid of teachers unions. The best way to do that is to make the contract worthless. They won’t even have to change the law like they did in Wisconsin. All they have to do is show members that belonging to a labor union offers no additional protections or benefits.
He never intended to comply with this contract. For his political purposes, it was much better to negotiate it, get all that free media and then waive it. I can guarantee you his breaking the contract won’t get nearly the media that his “good faith” negotiations did.
Folks might find today’s Dilbert relevant to Weingarten’s remarks about “changing the bar”.
http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2014-02-27/
http://www.ed.gov/news/speeches/technology-education-privacy-and-progress
You guys really have to start reading Duncan’s speeches. He does not give a speech where he doesn’t promote a specific charter school and the only districts he ever mentions are those run by a tiny group of national celebrity ed reformers.
He’s added Newark to the (very short) list of reformer-approved public schools. We now have two cities and one state in this country; DC, Newark and Tennessee. I’ve read “DC and Tennessee” so many times I just wait for it. It’s ALWAYS there. This is the Michelle Rhee Department of Education. Complete and utter capture.
It is lock-step adherence to reform dogma. There is NO alternative view presented, ever. He actually IS worse than former President Bush’s appointees, as far as fealty to this tiny group of “reformers”. That is not an exaggeration.
I honestly do not know if public schools will survive this full-court privatization marketing press. If they do, they are one hell of a resilient public institution.
Duncan is to DoEd what Dick Cheney was to the Vice Presidency. They both know how to manipulate regulations and position personnel deep inside govt agencies to advance their nefarious agendas. Little tweeks and sneaks behind the scenes all buried in the regulations and enforced by acolytes. Has there ever been a more dishonest Sec of education than Duncan? I used to think it was Bill Bennett but I’ve come to think Duncan is much worse and for more destructive.
Here’s Curmudgucation on the latest Duncanspeak pitching his latest “50 state plan”. Duncan wants to give the Office of Civil Rights Authority over teachers.
http://curmudgucation.blogspot.com/2014/02/duncan-civil-rights-highly-qualified.html
Actual quote:
“Privacy rules may well be the seatbelts of this generation. I’d like to see vigorous self-policing by the commercial players. Frankly, it’s in their interest to do so— and I’m glad to see the conversation starting here.”
Duncan attended one of America’s finest universities. Is he really not aware that the auto industry fought safety requirements tooth and nail, up to and including illegally wiretapping consumer safety advocates and trying to destroy their reputations? They did everything but mark them for a “hit”. They were worried whether they’d SURVIVE to enact seat belt laws.
The auto industry didn’t comply with safety regulations voluntarily, because regulators met with them at “summits” and asked them nicely. It was a freaking 20 year brutal, bare-knuckle battle.
Good Lord. “Self-policing”. And using seat belts as an example! What the heck are they teaching at Harvard? 🙂
I know it won’t matter, but if I were a parent in Newark I’d be really wary of a leader who violates a contract. A contract is a promise. If she’ll break a promise she made to teachers, one that was negotiated with great fanfare and trumpeted on the Morning Joe program and other national media, that probably tells you something about what her word is worth.
I’d say “get it in writing” but even that doesn’t seem to be worth anything.
Everytime I read about NJ, I feel like I’m reading a medieval novel about a tyrant lord and his minions…we will take your children and do as we like with them. Now pay your taxes and shut your mouths, your lives are not your own. Where did the America I know go and why aren’t more people fighting back?
When is Randi Weingarten going to write the letter that disavows her support of the Common Core?
Weingarten co-wrote a piece with Vicki Phillips of the Gates Foundation about why American public education is in dire need of the Common Core.
Phillips and Weingarten opined that it was critical for American public education to “align teacher development and evaluation to the Common Core state standards.”
Phillips and Weingarten made the preposterous claim that it was absolutely essential that the “mission” of public schooling “must evolve from an outmoded model of education that exists in too many places to a new paradigm that will prepare students for life, college, and career.”
The Common Core is predicated on the notion that “rigorous” standards (and the testing of them) are needed – are imperative – to prepare students (and the nation) “to compete successfully in the global economy.” Nothing could be further from the truth.
The U.S already is economically competitive. When it drops in the World Economic Forum competitiveness rankings – as it has done over the last several years – it’s because of really stupid economic policy choices it’s made, policies that have been pushed aggressively by many of those who now insist that schools and teachers must the ones to remedy their economic fallout. Very sad. And very cowardly.
Achieve was one of the instigators of Common Core. (along with the ACT and the College Board). It just so happens that Achieve is funded by groups like Battelle (which argues for STEM when there is no STEM shortage), the Gates Foundation, Prudential and State Farm and Travelers, Boeing, GE, JPMorgan Chase, Intel, IBM, the Helmsley Foundation, DuPont, Cisco, Chevron, Microsoft….many of these companies pay little or no taxes.
In supporting Common Core, Randi Weingarten is siding with them.
When Weingarten rescinds her support, and apologizes for it, that will be news worthy of noting.
While Ms. Weingarten sends out letters and press releases in which she poses as a supporter of Newark’s parents and public school teachers, work continues on Teacher’s Village in Newark, a $150 million real estate – never forget that so-called education reform is also a real estate play – development that will house three charter schools (to be staffed by guess who?). NTU President Joel Del Grosso, who not long ago joined Randi and Cami in a public smooch-fest over a contract for Newark teachers that will usher them out of the profession, is also an enthusiastic supporter of Teacher’s Village.
Teacher’s Village is being developed by Ron Beit, who is on the Board of TFA-Newark.
While TFA’s official involvement in Newark’s Teacher’s Village is of the quasi-stealth sort, it is explicitly involved in similar projects in Baltimore, Philadelphia (where the public school system is being rapidly dismantled, which Cami Anderson’s One Newark plan is likewise intended to do) and Baltimore.
Lest people outside of major cities feel jealous of having their tax dollars used to subsidize the teaching of their children by 22 year-old temps, there is also a Teacher’s Village in McDowall County, West Virginia.
Teacher’s Village in Newark is being financed primarily with public money, with some of the remaining private funding coming from Goldman Sachs (still doing “God’s Work,” along with Wendy Kopp), Prudential and TD Bank.
As reported by Jersey Jazzman and NJ.com, Teach For America Village was approved for a New Markets Tax Credit – a vehicle for charter school construction – by the AFL-CIO, on whose Executive Board Ms. Weingarten sits and upon which she is reported to exert much influence.
While it was the construction trades that were the prime labor lobbyists for the project, you’d think Randi would have made efforts to dissuade them from pushing a project that is intended to house privately-run charters that divert money from the public schools, and which is intended to house teachers from a notorious anti-union employment agency.
So you’d think, but you’d be wrong, for this is the Great Collaborator we’re talking about.
So, not only is Ms. Weingarten going along with having teacher’s tax money used to displace them and gentrify Newark, but she is also using their dues money to do it.
Randi Weingarten is an extremely intelligent, hardworking woman. The question for teachers is, whom is she working for?
http://www.nj.com/business/index.ssf/2012/02/newark_to_break_ground_on_long.html
jerseyjazzman.blogspot.com/2013/06/who-will-live-in-teachers.html
So now Randi is using my pension funds to house TFAs!!! Newark is already in the process of laying real teachers off and putting TFA in their place. Why are my pension funds being invested in construction in the first place when so many pension funds are going belly up. Teachers do not need to have housing….they need a good salary so they can choose where they wish to live. I wonder how many TFA housing developments around the country were constructed with my pension dollars!!!
Has Weingartner ever taught K-12?
She worked as a substitute for a few years while being groomed to take over the UFT, then a had a cup of coffee in a high school classroom.
The woman’s references to herself as a teacher are like everything else about her: fraudulent.
“Dear Randi” From a Newark Teacher | Ed Notes Online
Dear Ms. Weingarten,
You are to be commended for writing a letter to Governor Christie. It is your visionary leadership and the historic contract you were instrumental in negotiating that have brought Newark teachers to the “top of the mountain.” Moreover, your generosity in donating AFT funds to the Teacher Village being built to house Teach for America novices in Newark could not have come at a better time. It is inconceivable that you could have had prior knowledge that record numbers of Newark teachers were to be laid off and replaced with Teach for America scabs. Your brilliant strategy of advocacy for weaker tenure protections, subjective evaluations and complicity with those who wish to turn teachers into Walmart employees has played nicely into the hands of your coconspirators Bill Gates and the Walton Foundation. I am grateful to you for your wise stewardship of the AFT and your particular interest in advancing the interests of Newark schoolchildren by having them taught by a revolving door of unqualified teacher impostors. Send my regards to Cami next time you speak to her.
In gratitude,
A Newark Teacher
Yep. Weingarten surely did support the TFA-friendly Teacher Village:
“‘Reconnecting McDowell made new housing a key piece of its plan to revitalize the county. A Teacher Village will attract and retain teachers, provide good jobs and encourage more economic development,’ said AFT President Randi Weingarten. ‘We are helping this proud community reclaim the promise of great schools and access to the services and programs they need to thrive'”
http://www.aft.org/newspubs/press/2013/121713.cfm
The developer for Teachers Village is on the TFA Newark advisory board:
http://jerseyjazzman.blogspot.com/2013/06/who-will-live-in-newarks-teachers.html
The “exciting private-public partnership” that was the NJ contract:
I can understand why many Newark teachers voted for the contract (actually, only a slight majority of city teachers even voted and 62% of them voted yes). They have been forced to work without any contract these past two years, under the state takeover of their schools, and now will receive some retroactive pay. They were also given some input into the design of their own evaluations which are still based largely on student test scores along with peer evaluation, and which will determine whether they receive “merit pay” from now on. So the argument could be made that this was the best they could get. Of course, that’s not what Weingarten and Christie are saying.
Teacher pay is now also dependent upon the largesse of billionaires Eli Broad and know-nothing power philanthropist Mark Zuckerberg who can pull the plug on his $100 million gift at any time — for example, if Christie or Newark mayor Corey Booker were to be defeated in the next election. This is the same kind of top-down manipulation and leveraging of Gates and Broad grant money that Michelle Rhee and former Mayor Fenty pulled off in D.C. before voters gave them the boot. Newark schools have been turned into beggars operating largely on private funding to circumvent public decision-making. A Tea Party dream come true.
Teachers are no longer guaranteed pay step and lane increases based on credentials. They can win bonuses for teaching in low-performing schools (not a bad idea in and of itself). Teachers who are deemed “ineffective” based on a test-based, value-added formula, can elect to be rated by an independent “peer validator.” That review will be considered before determining their final ratings or whether they should be fired or “mentored.” However, Newark School Superintendent Cami Anderson will have the final say if an agreement on a teacher’s competence can’t be reached. What? Where’s the union grievance procedure in all this?
http://michaelklonsky.blogspot.com/
Enough of the “letters” to Obama, Christie, Duncan, and Cuomo. THEY DO NOT CARE.
And Randi “Weathervane”, you are a bit late but since you now see the winds blowing up a storm, go hide somewhere. Real Leadership is forming and you are not needed.
Go join some other parade as it forms…
“Real Leadership is forming…”
Perhaps. But meanwhile, the “leaders” in the AFT and NEA can – and likely will – do lots of damage.
As I’ve asked before, are these people (Weingarten, Van Roekel, etc.) utterly clueless? Or are they merely sycophants?
I don’t know anything about Dennis Van Roekel, but I can tell you from many years observation and experience that Randi is neither clueless (except insofar as she thinks she is actually accepted as a peer by the so-called reformers she enables) nor sycophantic.
She is, or thinks she is, one of Them, though she is likely to find out otherwise, once she has outlived her usefulness.
How else to explain her accepting money from Gates, allowing herself to be described by The Broad Foundation as an “investment” – their words, not mine – allowing teacher pension money to flow to real estate deals designed to undermine the public schools and her very own members? The list goes on endlessly.
Edushyster brings home the NJ situation in this post:
http://edushyster.com/?p=4369
Where in the world has she been for the last four years? Where was she the first time Christie and Cerf ( another fake educator, making the money and now he is with Klein )wouldn’t even entertainment the thought of giving the schools back to Newark when they were on an uphill swing.It was Mr. Rice, the school system, parents, communities trying to get the school system back under Newark’s control? Now that the public school situation is on the brink of total destruction she writes a letter. Maybe I am being harsh but where has she been since the takeover began? I do remember the photo of her and Christie looked like good friends to me along with photos of Mayor Bloomberg and anyone else in political office who is set to destroy public education. now the saying goes it is just politics. Well it isn’t when it comes to public education it is a death sentence for all of our kids unless we realize that some of our talking heads for public education are just that talking heads and we start being very selective on who leads the charge.
Arabella, be glad you have allies. Better late than never.