Imagine this weird scenario: a state that has more Nationally Board Certified Teachers than any other state in the nation; a state where 96% of the teachers are rated proficient; a state where the legislature is coming up with every trick in the book to demoralize and harass their excellent teachers.
That is North Carolina.
As Yevonne Brannan, chairman of Public Schools First NC, explains it, North Carolina once ranked 21st in the nation in teacher pay, but is now 46th. The legislature ignores the fact that more than half the children in the state live in poverty and blames the teachers. So the legislature enacts law after law to drive teachers away, losing many great teachers in the meanwhile.
To make sure that any bad teacher could be immediately fired, the legislature abolished tenure, putting every teacher on a year-to-year contract. The legislature eliminated extra pay for additional degrees, thus letting teachers know how little the legislators care for education itself (imagine a teacher wanting to learn more!). The legislature instituted merit pay, assuming that the promise of a bonus would improve student test scores; the fact that merit pay has never worked anywhere was no problem for this legislature, which seems to know nothing about education or teaching or children or 21st century psychology (quick, give the legislators a copy of Daniel Pink’s “Drive,” which explains what motivate people).
The good news is that the public in North Carolina does not agree with their elected officials. Brannon writes: Thankfully, N.C. residents overwhelmingly support teachers getting a pay increase for completing a master’s degree (83 percent). Moreover, 76 percent of North Carolinians agree that public school teachers are paid too little, and 71 percent agree we cannot keep the best and most qualified teachers with the current pay scale.
Now it is time for parent, grandparents, neighbors, civic leaders, business leaders, and everyone who cares about the future of North Carolina to let their legislators know that they must respect and honor their hard-working teachers and take action to retain them.

I have faith that NC is going to come back around to sanity both politically and educationally. They once had some of the best schools in the country, along with Wisconsin and certainly some of the best in the South. Georgia used a special education curriculum from both of those states. They still have a lot of citizens who are not backwards, especially in the Eastern part. The people are getting fed up with their politicians’ antics and I don’t think they wlll lay down.
LikeLike
I am sorry to say that I don’t have that faith. It will take many, many years. So much so that I continue to encourage my daughter to change her major (elementary ed) or move to a different state!
LikeLike
First of all, I am a teacher in North Carolina, and I’m not so sure they’re going to come around soon enough to help the students we have now. I fear it will take several years for them to realize their mistakes, and, by then, NC will have already lost many valuable teachers and too many students will have “fallen through the cracks” that should never have fallen through the cracks. Secondly, taking into consideration that my family and I are from the western part of the state, I don’t appreciate you referring to people not in the eastern part of the state as “backwards”.
LikeLike
Education in North Carolina is at an all time low. The teachers can no longer be creative and teach anymore. They are told how and when to do it. Why not put robots in the mix and forget teachers all together?Someones cousin that has no knowledge about education must have been put in charge to make all these changes. The twentyfirst century learning is just another bandwagon that North Carolina has jumped on and will try something else in a few years!!!! A teacher can only work with what she is given. She can’t pour the knowledge in their brains.
LikeLike
Deborah of NC,
You just stumbled onto the “reformers'” plan.
They want to replace teachers with computers (you call them robots).
LikeLike
…didn’t say people who are not in the eastern part of the state are backwards. Emphasis was placed on the eastern part of the state. There are MANY citizens of NC who are supporters are public education.
LikeLike
sounds like a good plan to me. All the things they are complaining about I support.
LikeLike
Didn’t the good people of North Carolina elect the legislators who are now trying to dismantle the educational system? Why do people elect these politicians, then complain about what said politician is doing? Are they lying to get elected, or are we not informed enough?
LikeLike
If thing in North Carolina work the way they do in Idaho, the people of NC elect such legislators, in part, because the legislators promise to prevent socialist atheist illegal immigrants from forcing North Carolinians to gay marry each other in state-funded abortion clinics.
LikeLike
Hey, some Missourians resembles that remark!
LikeLike
I can’t speak for the rest of the state, but the redistricting that followed the most recent census redrew voting districts to practically guarantee republican majorities in previously balanced or democratic areas. Buncombe County, the democratic stronghold where I live, was split and gerrymandered to put our voters in with faraway towns like Gastonia, which are populous and tend to vote republican. If you mess with enough districts like that you seriously distort the outcome of elections.
LikeLike
First, yes, what Kevin Wilson said. Also, I’m guessing that few of those legislators ran on a platform of teacher bashing and public school privatizing. Politicians of all stripes say whatever people want to hear, while keeping their real agenda discreetly hidden until they’re elected. People are still too caught up in what politicians say (and the socialist, atheist, gay illegal immigrant thing) to notice what they do.
LikeLike
I live in North Carolina, am not affiliated with any political party, and did not vote for most of these people, but many who did vote for them believed in their promises of focusing like a laser on jobs, jobs, jobs. (I have yet to see this happen.) Also, the current Governor ran under a platform of being a moderate, which attracted a number of voters who did not like the previous Governor.
LikeLike
Unfortunately….Everyone believed in the New Governor..
Turns Out…he speaks out of both sides of his mouth…
Now…everyone is waiting for the 2016 elections..
He will be one term!!
LikeLike
Oh, not everyone! Some of us saw this disaster coming from a mile away.
LikeLike
Our governor has no spine: no beliefs to which he is true. He is a prevailing-winds kind of person, a popularity seeker, who seemed fairly moderate when he was mayor of Charlotte (look at the prevailing winds) and in with with the Art Pope crowd now that he is governor, after a gerrymandered election. Think we ought to trust a person without a true compass and a spine?
LikeLike
I will remind you that the current mistreatment of teachers began years ago, long before the Republican majority. My wife has only had a single 1% increase in the last six years, and *that* was immediately consumed by a simultaneous increase in health insurance premiums. Six years ago we had a Democratic House, a Democratic Senate, and a Democratic governor. The Republicans may have accelerated the process, but it was Democrats who started the decline.
LikeLike
People really need to forget who is voted in, they are only puppets to sots who wield the cash. If none of us voted some twit would still get elected.
LikeLike
Not everyone believed in him, enough to get him elected, but there were plenty of us who could see the writing on the wall.
LikeLike
North Carolina is an extremely gerrymandered state, so that even though the majority of North Carolina citizens voted for one party, the other party is in control of both houses in the state legislature.
LikeLike
Some politicians run for office on one platform, then once elected has a completely different agenda! We will not make this mistake next election year!!
It makes me sad to think we are taking time to point fingers when it is the children who suffer! Regardless how NC got here, let’s turn around this Shame Train!
LikeLike
To Hensonblog: Also, I believe Mr. Art Pope invested $10 million in North Carolina politics prior to the elections of the current NC legislature.
LikeLike
I think it is both – but more that the people who complain DON’T go out and vote! The legislators know that they can do what they like, because…they will get voted back in next time!
LikeLike
http://www.wiredacademic.com/2013/08/exclusive-amplify-chief-joel-kleins-vision-all-tablets-no-textbooks/
Well, North Carolina may not have teachers, but they have… Amplify! Ignore what reformers people say about “great teachers” and pay attention to what they spend money on.
It isn’t teachers. Never, ever.
In fact, it is nearly anything BUT teachers.
LikeLike
You have Hit the Nail on the Head!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LikeLike
Check the Rhinoceros Times’ recent reporting about how those Amplify devices were acquired and how they perform in Guilford county.
LikeLike
It’s clear that McRory has never spent time in a room with thirty children and 45 internet-capable devices.
LikeLike
If tenure is abolished, then don’t teachers become free agents? The best will go where the money is.
LikeLike
Not true. Teachers will forsake the “big raise” for respect and autonomy. We don’t pursue our passion for a few extra bucks.
Teachers are not valued and respected in our nation and when you treat us like crap you don’t respect children either.
You can’t put children first when you put teachers last despite the BS from the Edushysters: Duncan, Rhee, Obama, Gates, Broad, the list is endless.
LikeLike
“The best (N.C. teachers) will go
where the money is.”
Yeah… to almost any state OTHER
THAN North Carolina.
(I said “almost” because N.C is now
46th in teacher salaries… meaning
there are now just 4 other states that
pay their teachers less than they
do in North Carolina, and 45 states
that pay teachers more.)
LikeLike
Great point!
LikeLike
News flash…teachers aren’t in it for the money. Would we like more pay, sure. Wouldn’t anyone? However, as a teacher I am more concerned with the decisions being made that affect the children we are serving. When you have time, energy and love invested in your school and students, you don’t just pick up and move where you get paid more. My family’s financials suffer because I know my students here in NC need excellent teachers and I choose to stay.
LikeLike
“That is NC.” Well, yes, but unfortunately nobody is really talking about it yet. We got the following letter today and I feel as though we are in a holding pattern right now. Until we can vote somebody out, or until real pains are felt by families, it’s just the same old lip service about “I think teaching is the hardest job ever,”-and- I- send -my- kids- to -private -school-and-really -I’m- just- glad- I’m- not- a- teacher-let’s-go-watch-football, type thinking. I have met very few people in the business community who strike me as really giving a rat’s a— about what is going on in public school (or who even realize what is going on). But anyway, here’s the letter and I’ve gotten so used to reading the preparatory propaganda that at this point I’m void of emotion and just waiting to see how others respond because I can’t change anything myself (although I am trying). I’ve been riled up for a year, and usually it just comes off as a personal obsession. The letter:
Dear Teachers:
Parents consider teachers one of the most trusted sources for information regarding what is going on in the school and how it may impact their children. As such, we want to make sure you are up to speed regarding the release of the latest student assessments results.
The State Board of Education is expected to approve student and school performance under the 2012-13 READY Accountability model at its Thursday, November 7, meeting. Because the assessments are more rigorous and difficult than in previous years and, the bar for reaching grade-level proficiency has been raised, we anticipate that student scores will be lower.
In communicating with parents, we encourage you to make sure they realize that last year was a transitional year. Accountability results will not affect their students’ grades or current placement nor will the school receive any label or designation. You may want to be prepared to discuss with parents what you are doing to help students who may have come to you less than proficient and how you are preparing these students to be successful this year under the new standards.
One point on which we all can agree is that we want our students to not only succeed at the next grade level or high school course, but to graduate from high school career and college ready. Raising standards is important in ensuring that students remain competitive in an ever-changing global economy. We have an obligation to expect more from students and we know – as past performance has shown us – that they will rise to the challenge.
If parents would like more information, you can direct them to the READY Accountability Background Brief, which is available on the Department of Public Instruction’s website at http://www.ncpublicschools.org under Highlights.
June Atkinson
State Superintendent
LikeLike
As an NC parent, the only reason why I care about the results is because of the possible management reactions. I worry my school will be forced to do more test prep, etc. I am extremely happy with my child’s school and teachers. I think my school is handling the CC well.
This year my school won’t receive a label, but I believe next year schools will receive an A-F grade. Do you have the formula they are going to use? I was told it is 80% on school performance and 20% on student growth. I asked if it it was based 100% on test scores, I was told no, but I can’t find the formula they are using. I assume a large chunk is based on test scores.
I wish the “official statements” I read would question the validity of the tests. It seems to me that in order to accept these statements, the assumption has to be made that there are no issues with the test itself. I could be wrong because I attended elementary school back in the 1970’s so my reading comprehension is most likely not up to today’s standards.
I think they made a big mistake waiting so long to release the results.
LikeLike
Per it being a mistake, the benefit I see is the reactions in New York having happened, giving time to get folks ready for the results (party line or not).
I don’t know what that ratio is, but I will ask at my faculty meeting Thursday. I will respond on this blog when I know (I will come back to this post).
LikeLike
Good points about management reactions. If I am told music has to support testing more, that will be my cue to move on. If music is seen as a balance for the children (as I see it), I will stay on. Then again I could try to do both. Heaven only knows. And I do pray about it.
A good Episcopal school will be what I go looking for when I can no longer take the pressure or bear the game. Both for me and my son. I am an Episopalian, so it makes sense for us. But I believe in public school. But not the CcSs VAM model.
LikeLike
Here’s the HS “model” for the “grading”…
(300) points (100 ea.) from: Bio, Alg I, and English 2 % proficient
Graduation co-hort %
ACT student % scoring 17 or higher
Workkeys Test %. proficient
% of students who pass Alg or Math III before graduating
IF a school scores an 80% or higher overall then growth does not factor into the calculation for the rating.
HOWEVER if the school is below an 80%, then thr state will do their % x .80 + growth x .20 = the % to be used for the rating to calculate the A-F
Did you get all of that?
No one knows how growth is actually calculated…and I have the above info memorized because I have heard it numerous times this year… Along with “teach to the test”.
It’s also important to note that the state BOE saw the scores, then voted to “up” the bar of what it means to be passing…too many kids “passed”… Most categories saw a 20+ point DROP after the NC BOE VOTED AFTER seeing the results to change what it meant to pass…yep.
Good luck!
LikeLike
“They” waited so long to release the results because Wake County just voted on an $810 million bond. If the results aren’t out yet, the bond is pretty much safe. Had results been out, nobody would have voted for the bond. smh
LikeLike
Let’s get this straight. The new CC$$ assessments are more difficult for students to pass, yes. However, they in no way “raise the bar.”
LikeLike
That’s her story and she’s sticking to it.
It is frustrating to be told what your kids will need in the future with such righteous indignation such as her letter (and all communication from her) puts forth. I did go to college. Who is she to tell my husband and me (and all other parents) what our kids need in a top down manner?? I don’t understand why more parents are not having a visceral reaction to that.
LikeLike
June taught school how many years ago?
What did she teach?
When is the next superintendent election?
This letter is the biggest bunch of wordy bull that I have read in quite awhile..
“One point on which we all can agree is that we want our students to not only succeed at the next grade level or high school course, but to graduate from high school career and college ready. ”
June. You have a ‘One Size Fits All Curriculum” and have thrown this CC$$ on the walls to see what sticks….The children of NC have suffered greatly during the RTTT Reform which was implemented for the Politicians and not the welfare of the children of the State of NC
LikeLike
June Atkinson is working within a lot of constraints, given that the legislature holds the purse strings and is making many of the decisions that affect teachers (no pay for advanced pay, eliminating tenure, etc.) She has been a fairly vocal critic of a number of things, including lack of salary increases and increased reliance on testing, and if she had her way, those things would not have happened. And she can’t exactly write a letter that says the state raised the cut scores so the new tests look like they are more rigorous when all we have done is made sure we have an even distribution, meaning 50% of students will be below the 50th percentile.
LikeLike
Sorry, but June Atkinson is not a threat to education in NC. I heard her speak, and she doesn’t support high-stakes testing anymore than any of us do. She’s being handed the Common Core, and she’s making the best out of it.
LikeLike
I do not think that ANY CHILDREN have been considered in any of their shenanigans!!
LikeLike
Note she never mentions the thousands of Tests that are given to the children of NC…
Accountability = TESTS in NC…P-E-R-I-O-D
Find the right Private School…You will love it!!
LikeLike
I asked this question before, how do people afford private schools?
There are many private schools in my town – the least expensive one I would consider is the Catholic school which is just over $8,000 per year The rest are over $12,000. We have an above-average income, but to pay for private schools, we would have to stop funding our retirement and college savings.There isn’t anywhere other than our savings we could cut to come up with the money.
So how do people pay for private schools? Are they ignoring their retirement? What is the long term social costs when these people are old and have no savings? Savings they could have if they didn’t pay for 12 years of private school for their children? Will their private school educated children take care of them?
These comments are starting to depress me. A bunch of people write about how lousy public schools are because of the CCSS (not that I’ve seen that at my child’s school). A bunch of comments insists a quality education is only possible at a private school. What both of these say to me is that there are a bunch of people who think public school children are getting a worthless education.
LikeLike
Joanna, sheesh, she’s got hutzpah. Here’s a thought: direct all parent questions to HER office. After all, this is her thing so she can jolly well own it. You have enough work to do & she basically wants you to do her job for her. Let her answer to parents & explain her decision about supporting this policy. That’s her job.
LikeLike
The rich send their kids to private schools. The people who actually have money and power don’t give a damn what happens to the poor (or what is left of the middle class) in the public schools. It’s not hard to see that. Let the masses spend all their time playing sports and watching “American Idol”, whatever. The rich are just angry that they have to pay property taxes to pay for kids who generally don’t care about education. That is just a fact. That is why Oprah Winfrey built a school in Africa and not in Chicago. The kids in Chicago (like all over America) generally had no interest in education. They just want shoes, cell phones, bling, etc. Oprah talked about this in some detail. In Africa, you have kids walking 30 miles to study deteriorating books in a collapsing classroom. They have the correct values and deserve the education. In America you have kids in state of the art classrooms trying to text under their desks and talking back to their teachers. Think about it. It is ridiculous. Our culture is a broken mess, and schools alone can’t change that. Most of our kids don’t deserve public education. Maybe the answer is to privatize the whole thing and make them pay for it or not. Maybe then kids would value education more. As public school teachers you have 1-2 kids in every class who really care about what you are teaching, or are passionate about learning. Wouldn’t it better to teach a class of 20 private school kids who actually care? Let the other kids be warehoused somewhere where they could text in peace. Most of the public school students just want to check Facebook or text anyways.
LikeLike
You are confusing adolescence in a developed country with apathy.
I am sorry but I am not as jaded as you are about the big picture.
I teach K-5 and they are eager to learn. It is the opposite of what you describe. That is why I will hang on as long as I can.
The holding pattern is the hardest part.
Reminds me of a good Carly Simon song.
LikeLike
Looking for NC rankings the last 20 years.. to see when the trend downward started.. From reading the story and comments one would think a R has been in office for years, but the 1st R in NC was voted in when?
Look at Common Core.. what NC is following.. teaching the kids ZERO but as long as they follow Common Core the more $$ the schools get..
LikeLike
Tough but true!
LikeLike
I am not a teacher. I am not in North Carolina. I do however, have a 5 year-old grandson, in WIlmington, that just started Kindergarten. (A Teacher referred me to this site) I am concerned about the references here to “CC.” What is “CC?” Are we talking “Common Core” and all that it entails? I suspect so. “CC,” is one reason I will become very involved, even from a distance, in my grandsons’ education. As I have seen and read, The “Common Core” program is simply another “latest and greatest” teaching methodology, forced down, (rather hurriedly,) from heaven (Washington) upon The States. Looking at a few of these comments, I see teacher concerns about “CC.” and the new accountability demands placed upon them. I am not an educator, but…I am a businessman. I smell opportunity, and it’s NOT for the Teachers, the students, or the children!
I believe in the old axiom, “Follow the Money!” “CC,” did not come about due to a huge, thoughtful, scientific process, built by education professionals. I suspect, a FEW at the very top, are poised to make huge profits by implementing this program and force feeding what I see, as Socialist indoctrination of our children, to be enforced without question, by our teachers. There are actual human beings, behind this agenda. Who are they? Who stands to make monetary gains from this questionable endeavor? A cursory look, (3 minutes,) and I found some surprising answers: (Ain’t The Internet a wonder?)
…”Schoolteacher Chasidy Miroff notes the corrupt part about Common Core, “The creators of the Common Core standards have now taken jobs with testing companies which stand to make millions of dollars developing tests based on the standards they created.” Your State took money, (Grants,) on condition that they implement “CC.” Federal money, brings top down, Federal control. We know what this ALWAYS brings: Failure for the students, and demoralization of teachers. (No Child left behind?) Let’s forget this mess, and OPT out!
We start with accepting universal truths about Education that have stood the test of time. Heard of The Lao-Tzu? (6th century, Chinese philosopher) Some attribute him as saying: “When the Student is ready, the Teacher will appear.” Brilliant. This described ME in High School. C’s, D’s, sprinkled with a couple of A’s, and more than a few F’s! In College, (yes, they took my money) I actually made Honor Role, and Deans’ list!!! Did I miraculously jump about 30 IQ points between HS and Freshman year? Hardly. I, was the one, who traded MY hard earned money…for MY college experience! Motivation, folks!
One size does NOT fit all. Never has, and Never will. “CC’, or “No Child,” or “The New Math” for us old folks, was NOT the salvation claimed. Neither will be Common Core. Stop the Federal Control. Give ’em back their money, and take back YOUR schools!
LikeLike
Once a teacher moves to NC and applies for state licensure, it takes 45 days for a response. I have a master’s in educational psychology from Indiana University– recently ranked #11 of the best teacher training institutions in the country. According to NC, my masters doesn’t meet standards to be listed on their licensure documents. I have to wait 45 days to see if my Florida licensure qualifies me to teach in NC. I was considered “highly qualified” in Florida. I have to wait 45 days before I can apply for a job in NC. Oh, and earn less. I’m likely to be one of those former teachers who decides it’s no longer worth it.
LikeLike
John, you are either teaching in a bad school or analyzing one. I teach in a mostly rural school with great kids and staff. Privatizing will not help – public schools offer many kids the opportunity to be educated – private schools don’t – they just kick them out and there is no hope. An uneducated populace, without a diploma, means more crime, more in jail, and more despair.
LikeLike
Yes! However, the many always suffer because of the few…teachers do not have time to teach manners AND show growth! Choices must be made and the ‘legal’ do’s and don’ts cause these children to get away with not learning and the teachers get blamed for it! Public schools just need to stick to their ‘rules’ and kick kids out that do not wish to ‘to their job’ – as in any field!
LikeLike
“We have an obligation to expect more from students and we know – as past performance has shown us – that they will rise to the challenge.”
PERFORMANCE ON A TEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LikeLike
The above comment was taken from the posted letter..
LikeLike
by a state supe, no less
LikeLike
Sounds exactly like Oklahoma where the winds come sweeping down the plains and our state superintendent is a dentist….an ignorant one at that! Our governor was just quoted in our state newspaper saying that if we didn’t stop complaining about our ludicrous A-F grading system, which had been changed 11 times in the last two weeks, she’d put a hold on our “extra” funding. With enemies like ours, who needs friends? Ugh!
LikeLike
5 year Old…”I need to go to the bathroom
Teacher: ….”You must wait until after we finish this test”
5 Year Old..”Why Ms Apple?
Teacher…..” You will have to take the test again if you go to the bathroom”
5 Year Old…What is a test?
LikeLike
This is horrible! Fix the communities, then the schools will fall back into pace. Communities need help everywhere!!! This is bullying the teachers. Where are the bullying laws protecting them??????
LikeLike
Thank you for addressing the travesty that is occurring in North Carolina. Wonderful educators are being asked to choose between their passion of educating children and a living wage. Is it right that educators and their families should have reached the point where their children now qualify for free and reduced lunch because the state is paying them so little? Is it right that the people who embrace 70, 80, 90, or 100+ children as their own are being vilified to the general public. North Carolina has systematically removed all rewards and safeguards for educators in this state. We need the support of the public so that we can continue to educate for the public good. It is time for our state and our nation to realize that the BIG problems belong to us all.
LikeLike
Here in Iredell County just Charlotte we are losing students and money to charters. We have our state senator, David Curtis, attending grand openings, saying he just can’t understand how charters do so much better with less money. This group of NC legislators are on a mission to destroy traditional public schools, teacher by teacher and school by school. Parents are organizing and Iredell Statesville Schools will be fighting back. Most of our schools have great scores but this era of hyper-viiglant parents thinking their kids deserve better than others are flocking to these publically-funded private schools we called charters. An elementary school located in a VERY high socioeconomic area and was pretty much like a private school because of its location lost teachers because so many kids enrolled in Langtree Charter which is run by a private company.
Write letters people, get involved, this is a fight we have to win!
LikeLike
Lisa, it’s called FREEDOM of CHOICE. Perhaps you would find better job satisfaction, attempting to secure employment at one of the Private schools, or at a Charter School. Blaming the parents for your laments about lack of public school support, is akin to blaming a new salesman who lost a sale, and blames the would be buyer. He could simply be a poor salesman.Perhaps Public Schools NEED to be “destroyed!” There are now many more options to the traditional models of primary education. Parents whom you describe as “hyper-vigilant,” are simply becoming more aware of the problems of a “one size fits all,” public school system. (i.e. “Common Core.”) I, as a grandparent, WILL NOT close my eyes and watch my most precious asset, be destroyed by indoctrination from a National Education system that appears to have a goal of “Control,” not of education. Call me “hyper-vigilant,” if you will. I gladly accept that as a compliment when it comes to describing me love for my grandson.
You can “write letters, get involved, etc.” I will remove my grandson from your school. I AM…the boss! I AM the consumer. You have competition. Better focus more on serving the customer. (ME)
LikeLike
Some private / charter schools are better than some public, but a lot are not – check it out! Also, if you are going to compare, do so fairly. Are the free /reduced lunch ratios the same, or is the charter / private school excluding the more difficult to educate children? As a public school high school teacher, I KNOW for a fact that many private school students who transfer into my classes are way behind my public school students!
LikeLike
Part of the reason NC has so many nationally board certified teachers is because NC paid the fee for getting certified while other states did not,
LikeLike
I am a teacher in NC. I am demoralized, dejected and fed up! Nobody has mentioned Read to Achieve…wait until parents get wind of this! I am convinced that nobody has even considered the child when coming up with these ludicrous and ridiculous “measures” of achievement! The insanity must stop…it is the children that are suffering because of the idiots in Raleigh. Does anybody in Raleigh read the research on developmentally appropriate curriculum and standards for children in elementary school?
LikeLike
Is this the plan to retain every third grader who fails the reading test? I guess there are going to be some huge 3rd grade classroom next year
LikeLike
Yes- it is mind boggling. Basically, they are legislating every student to be average or above by 3rd grade. And the only intervention is a summer camp after you fail then retaking the test in several ways at several times. Last resort is a 3/4 combo class with a couple of more times to retake the class. If you can’t pass it, you do not pass “Go”. My “favorite” parts is they legislate mandatory retention – the one intervention correlated with harming student’s learning potential and increasing the likelihood of dropping out exponentially. But the formative assessments ( the only good part- DIBELS with TRC) only have a .60 correlation with the #rd grade EOC’s. So when the formative and summative assessments have only a moderate match we cannot predict who is having the correct reading problems to remediate or intervene ahead of time. This is crazy with icing 🙂
https://eboard.eboardsolutions.com/Meetings/Attachment.aspx?S=10399&AID=12267&MID=804
LikeLike
That is a big concern and it just shows how much is going on in NC that this issue isn’t being discussed more. How in the world will a mid-year promotion work? That will be hard on everyone – all students (not just those who were retained, although I know it will be toughest on the one semi-held back – how will they catch up on everything??) and the teachers.
I was wondering how all the assessments match up with the EOGs.
LikeLike
Thank you for taking time to write articles like this and to speak up for us. This is my 15th year in education, and I have never felt so overwhelmed by an ever-increasing workload and unrealistic expectations while at the same time feeling completely demoralized in my profession. We have taken a beating – and not just financially. Each year, it seems I have more stress but less time and money for my own family. Articles like this and the supportive comments that follow are like cheerleaders encouraging us to stay in the game.
LikeLike
Thank you Ms. Ravitch! I am so glad people are beginning to speak out so when I apply for a job in another state, they will understand why I am leaving North Carolina. While I may have considered staying here permanently , it wasn’t worth the risk. Thank goodness every state has wonderful children.
LikeLike
Murray Middle School wrote a petition. One hundred percent of our teachers and support staff signed it and we took it to our school board last night. We are opting out of the teacher selection process. We don’t want the money, the competition, or the division this legislation will bring. Schools promote unity and involvement within communities. Public education is vital to our towns, states and country! More schools, parents and community members need to join in! It’s great to talk but we need to take action! We need to be heard!
LikeLike
Were you heard?
LikeLike
I applaud the Murray Middle School teachers and several other schools in the area have followed their lead. I also hope those of us who are parents in NC opt out of the EOG/EOC’s since their only purpose is to grade teachers and schools. Since the validity of the EVAAS tests is non-existent we need to quit playing the game. I applaud the Murray teaches for their petition and I hope the rest of us can support them. The southeastern community of educators is very proud of you all!
LikeLike
Totally agree that parents need to opt their children out of the web of standardized tests. I would have done it for my children but never knew it was an option.
LikeLike
Janna,
How do you opt out? I do not want my children taking it.
LikeLike
Just write a letter to you prinicpal requesting that your children not be given the EOC/EOG’s. A sample letter is at: http://unitedoptout.com/state-by-state-opt-out/north-carolina/
LikeLike
Amen!
LikeLike
Poem by Lucas McLawhorn, (Middle School Spanish teacher) presented at the New Hanover County Board of Education meeting last night, about the current plight of teachers:
Teachers are clad in red across the Old North State
Red is the color we wear to reflect our passion to educate
Red is the color we wear to show our anger with those that legislate
Red is the color we wear to represent our salary – which yet again has failed to inflate
Red is the color we wear because we bleed for our peers who had to vacate
Most importantly, red is our color for the students we try to reach and motivate
Red is passion. I love my job. I didn’t always though. I was on the verge of quitting after my second year.
I was inexperienced, intimidated, and on the brink of tears
But my confidence grew with the support of my peers
They pulled me from those depths to reach new heights
Don’t put a lamp on the floor, a table is where you put the light
So it can illuminate more
Greatness is shared not packed up and stored
Which brings me back to the color red that represents our anger
It’s directed at those who write the laws
Yet have no idea what goes on in our halls
Only rewarding the top 25% will lead us to separate
A divisive plan that intends to isolate
the best from those that need a helping hand
just as I did when I first began
Love thy neighbor, is our Father’s command
Who wants to do that, if it keeps you from a cool grand
That brings me to point three
Red equals negative financially
Everything costs more- that’s the nature of inflation
I guess our salary doesn’t matter in the field of education
It’s still frozen- Can someone tell us how to get a promotion?
Do we need outside experience, or a title change to become golden?
It’s become elusive- that Benjamin
maybe we should move like the Mexican
Red numero cuatro
We wear rojo. This goes out to all my hermanos
That left the game for many reasons
Teachers hurt, specially round the Christmas season
Feliz Navidad- Yeah…only if you teach across the river
Brunswick county beckons come hither
A thousand dollar bonus proves they have local support
With free dental, soon teachers will be our number one export
Board members and commissioners
I hope y’all are good listeners
Because your fleet grows weary
We need a boost clearly
Have you considered this county’s businesses?
We can’t be blind- We are all eyewitnesses
What entrepreneur would bring their company
To a spot where teachers starve hungrily?
Don’t get me wrong, we’re not to that point yet
But the writing’s on the wall, and I begin to fret
We used to be the beacon of the Southeast
But our light grows dim to say the least
It’s not all bad news though
The last red embodies the will to grow
like a flame that starts small
and ignites into a fireball
We take kids that trickle in and leave a waterfall
The ability to motivate is a God given talent
And no legislation will ever unsettle the balance
A skilled teacher demonstrates as they juggle their student’s needs with those that call the shots
Please keep your eye on the rock
Not us teachers, or scandals, but the kids instead
They deserve the best, so we stand as ONE in RED.
Lucas McLawhorn
LikeLike
To Concerned Mom and anyone else interested:
Talk on public radio again this morning about the release of scores today, and the caveat about the higher standards and that in NY less than 50% passed.
I got a copy of the legislation from my principal this morning about the school report card; it mentions only student scores in determining the school grade. From what I am reading everything centers around 3rd grade also (and 8th), whereby they also get a grade (or a factor in the grade) based on how many 3rd graders do not “pass.” The grade for the school revolves around how many third graders were retained (because they did not pass the Reach to Achieve standards) and the test scores in general. No percentages are listed, however there is an amendment to this Section 7A.3.a that is not included in the copy she gave me (maybe it is online).
When I was in 8th grade, there was a state writing test and in 10th a state chemistry test. NC has used this type of state-wide thing for a long time (as you may well know). I suppose the notion of giving the school a grade associated with those scores is the new part.
I feel that NC is trying its best to continue as it has (ABCs type accountability), but cloaked in the new CCSS and Essential Standards so that they could get the federal money. The tap dance is that the only thing that is different is the bar is higher and we have a little more competition. Some see that as a good thing. . .it keeps teachers from being complacent (that’s what my principal thinks and also she likes CCSS). But you know, I think we’d be better off with technical training for some students, as specialized as our computerized world is becoming. CCSS might have unintended consequences we have not even considered. Career and college ready is a presumptuous justification for a one-size fits all approach to schooling.
But knowing everything I do about the sweeping federal changes that are tied to agendas including the Christian right, those wishing to profit off charters, those enjoying the “racket” as it were (Pearson, etc), I can no longer read our education legislation just for what it says on the page. NC is, in my opinion, trying to have its cake and eat it too and as even the leadership paid to enforce CCSS and the MClass and assessments will attest, we now just have to see how it plays out.
The holding pattern continues.
LikeLike
Joanna,
Thanks for the update and your willing to fill us in with your reporting from the field!
LikeLike
willingness…
LikeLike
I’m a high school English teacher, and our schools are also “graded” on the average score all of our juniors make on the ACT. Why in the world is the state of NC PAYING for EVERY JUNIOR to take this test?? I’ll let you all figure that one out, but it sure doesn’t have anything to do with helping kids. The last time I checked, tests like the ACT and SAT were OPTIONAL and paid for by individual students interested in attending college. If CCSS is all about “college AND career readiness,” then we need to put back all the technical programs and courses that have been taken away. College isn’t for everyone. And those who believe that a four-year degree is the only way to happiness and success or being a contributing member of society are frighteningly misguided. WAKE UP, NC!!
LikeLike
The ACT is required now in the RTTT grant won by NC. It is not longer optional. ACT got a lot of $$ for the test and the WorkKeys program/tests. Look up NCDPI for the full RTTT Gradnt and ACT links.
http://www.ncpublicschools.org/rttt/
http://www.ncpublicschools.org/accountability/act/
I agree we lost sight of what school is all about.
LikeLike
We did fine on NAEP- but still waiting to get the other tests.
http://www.newsobserver.com/2013/11/07/3348703/state-student-performance-on-national.html
LikeLike
Welcome to the real world,guys! Governments and business has been doing this to skilled trades for years and I suppose its the same way they have chosen to look at ya’ll now.Cut your throats and sling you in the ditch to bleed out.
LikeLike
I am one of those highly qualified, exceceptional teachers. Due to life circumstances I wound up in another state and guess what? They are chomping at the bit to pick up NC teachers. They know how well trained Nc teachers are. The smartest thing ncdpi ever did was allow school’s to get rid of basal textbooks and begin to teach instead of blindly assign worksheets. The place where I am now has an easier demographic than my former nc school but my nc kids were easily a full year ahead of my current student population. The amount of content and craft knowledge my nc colleagues have is about five years ahead of my current colleagues. The NC legislature is sending my beautiful home state into a horrible downward spiral! Stay mad people and speak with your vote!
LikeLike
Keep in mind that the current budget dictating teacher pay was left over from the previous administration. Pay dropped about $5000 under those years. The current legislature did vote to gid rid of tenure but also increased education spending. If teacher pay is not greater in 2-3 years, then the current governor and legislature should be blamed.
LikeLike
This is my 35th year teaching in NC. This isn’t the first time our salaries have been frozen. I remember my first time protesting in Raleigh. At that time, we did not receive raises because they were tied to an increased tax on tobacco products. And Lord knows, tobacco was the golden child at that time so…no teacher raises. I went through six years of NC’s Career Development program with the promise of an increase in salary at the conclusion. You guessed it…the program was thrown out at the end of my sixth year so…no salary increase. Oh, and bonuses for meeting ABC expectations? ….Gone with the wind..Teachers who transferred into my Title 1 school were given big bonuses. Those of us who were already fighting against rough neighborhoods and poverty? We received nothing.
Why am I still teaching? I retired 3 years ago, stayed out the required 6 months and then returned…Teaching really is my passion. My advice to young teachers entering the profession in NC? Run…run as fast as you can. This will be my last year. I will be taking my experience, my National Board certification (and re-certification) and my Masters’ elsewhere.
My two sons received an excellent education in our public schools but I fear the future for others.
LikeLike