I have been more than thrilled by the response to my new book. Today it is #10 on the New York Times best seller list, next week it will be #15. My guess is that as more educators and parents read it, they will recommend it to others. I hope they will form study groups to discuss the issues it raises. My hope was to provide indisputable facts about where we are, and research-based evidence about what we need to do to improve our schools and our society–not one first, then the other, but both.
As you might expect, the book is controversial because it disputes the popular narrative that our schools are failing and broken, that we must do all sorts of things that have never been done before, must test more often, more than any other nation in the world, must fire teachers and principals, lay off guidance counselors, social workers and librarians, eliminate the arts to make more time for testing, and close schools. And if we do all these things, someday, all schools will be great!
Humbug, I say. A hoax, I say.
Speaking plainly, however, is dangerous, if you are a woman. When men speak plainly and mince no words, they are direct and forceful. When women speak plainly and mince no words, they are abrasive, harsh, and just plain–well–rude. The same people who object to my tone waste no time denouncing me in abusive language. I will not deign to notice them. Nor will they intimidate me by their swagger.
So, to pay tribute to those who want me to be quiet and deferential, here is a video for them. Enjoy.

Love it!
Here’s a warning to the boys:
EDUFRAUDS: Know YOUR limits…the tide is turning. You are NOT in charge.
TEACHERS: Subvert, they don’t control our minds or our classrooms.
LikeLike
Watched you on TV last night. It was a replay of Philly Free Public Library and the tone I heard was even, measured, thoughtful, detailed, clear and compelling.
No harshness detected, even though the plutocrats presently plundering Philadelphia’s free public schools deserve a poke in their pirate pockets, large enough to return a responsible revenue stream back to deliberately impoverished classrooms.
LikeLike
Wow! You are beautiful, intelligent, and witty that = priceless! I guess that’s what has them so ruffled, you can’t be bought!
LikeLike
I think George Carlin covered some of what affects your male critics:
LikeLike
GREAT post and rright on, too.
LikeLike
reality-based educator and Yvonne Siu-Runyan: as a member of the, er, male persuasion, I think this video, the one Diane posted above, and the one Detroiter posted below, have made this blog, among the thousands that have appeared on this website—
UNFORGETTABLE!
At times I couldn’t decide—nay, refused to decide!—between laughing and almost crying.
Thank you all from the bottom of my heart.
🙂
LikeLike
Diane
The difference in your words and the words of your critics is that you
“Practice what you Preach”
Thanks..You put yourself in the battle…
Your critics are simply watching from afar and filling their wallets with the Green from the big companies..
They are hurt……..The Truth hurts …but in their case..It hurts their $iggy $anks!!
LikeLike
Dr. Ravitch:
You are indeed “wild & dangerous!” Please don’t change.
LikeLike
Your book is perfectly complemented by Naomi Klein’s SHOCK DOCTRINE, for the corporate right has applied SHOCK DOCTRINE remedies to the manufactured perception that something is wrong with public schools, the remedies of which are all geared toward the fun and profit of Wall Street, and NOT children, despite the incessant claims to the contrary… Michelle Rhee’s STUDENTSFIRST is a prime example, for they are funded by the corporate right to serve the corporate right and do virtually NOTHING on behalf of students… actually they do LESS than nothing for what they DO do is to harm the interests of students they claim to serve…
I believe that few accolades are greater in this nation that to be deemed ‘a great American’, as in the words of the late great journalist SARAH MCCLENDON as she shouted to Watergate era special prosecutor ARCHIBALD COX after the press conference in the wake of his Friday night massacre firing by Richard Nixon…
“You’re a great American, sir!” she proclaimed to Cox as he left the podium….
Dr. Ravitch, YOU TOO are a GREAT AMERICAN!
LikeLike
We only limit ourselves by not standing up and speaking out … With our expertise, passion and purposeful determination to decompose this myth of corporate reform we are pushing the limits together.
Thank you Diane, for leading the way and giving our cause your all, each and every day.
Limitless is our motto as move forward, together, for our kids and our teaching profession.
LikeLike
Speaking of know-nothing education policy, here is the way Kevin Huffman’s DoEd is reporting student test scores in TN. It’s a statistical alphabet soup.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/10/05/1244499/-Why-isn-t-my-kid-in-Honors
LikeLike
…..and I doubt that will ever be said of Michelle Rhee….
LikeLike
Good for YOU, Diane. When people are running scared, they blame the messenger of truth. That is ALL they have.
LikeLike
HA! I’ve seen that clip before, but it’s still funny. Nice one.
LikeLike
Is it just me, or do others believe that Rheeformocrats find it easier to promulgate a narrative that disparages teaching professionals because so many of us are women? Just saying….
LikeLike
BWAHAHAHAHA! As always, intelligence, integrity, and wit…. thank you Diane!
LikeLike
Here is a Leslie Gore classic:
LikeLike
I seem to recall posts by PL Thomas, if I remember correctly, about people in power using the “tone” reprimand to keep others in submissive roles. I was recently called down at work for my body language and tone when I was in a meeting where my point of view wasn’t being acknowledged. As my 22 year old stated, so wisely, that it is usually people who are frustrated that they can’t control you, who use this as a way of putting you in your place, so they can remain in a power role. She gives me hope that the next generation is not as ignorant as the Ed Deformers would have us think.
LikeLike
I love British humor, always have. Too bad they had to follow that clip with a statement that it was satire. And playing it in the US would require flashing warnings before, during and after, probably only managing to reach 10% of the viewing audience and perhaps 0.1% of the male viewers.
LikeLike
You nailed it. Except that for Latinas, all we’re supposed to say is,”I clean house, ok?” Thanks for coming to Denver.
LikeLike
Have you considered creating a mini-course for parents? Something that could be delivered in a night or two? Or are there other resources you could recommend? I am president of my child’s school’s parents group and would love to find a way to start educating parents on the corrosive effects of high stakes testing. I am also a member of coalition of public schools in Philly and will be speaking with them about the possibility of a city-wide “opt out” movement next week. I will do my best to distill what I know – but if you could offer any resources I would appreciate it.
thanks you for all you do!
LikeLike
Please get in touch with Peggy Robertson of United Opt Out.
You can reach her at writepeg@juno.com
Her blog is Peg with a Pen. Here is a sample: http://www.pegwithpen.com/2013/08/my-opt-outrefusal-letter-for-2013-2014.html
Organize. Opt out. The only way to stop this mad machine is to keep your children home from testing. Deny them the data to label your child and close your school.
LikeLike
It may be harsher for women who dispute the conventional wisdom but it is no picnic for men either. In my long career in government auditing we always told each other to speak the truth to power…and duck.
LikeLike
Teachers in Chicago are already forming study groups around “Reign of Error…” But The New York Times Book Review objects. If you read closely the blurb in today’s Times at the entry for “Reign of Error…” we are informed that the “education scholar denounces what she claims…” are the efforts by foundations, billionaires and hedge funders to destroy American public education. While in a way it’s a dubious honor to be sharing the “Non-Fiction” best seller listing for hard cover books with two books by the celebrities from “Duck Dynasty,” this is, after all, the 21st Century in the USA. But neither of the DD best sellers is caveated like “Reign of Error…”
The BBC You Tube is a hoot. Highly recommended. I’m not sure that The Times would have been nicer if “Reign…” had been more deferential to the erroneous who are exposed down to their skivvies in “Reign…” but I’m glad that deference to plutocrats and preening pundits is not part of the book.
LikeLike
I can relate, any published author knows exactly where you are coming from. Ignore your critics, be true to your ideas and convictions, and the always restive rabble of nay-sayers will fade away. Congrats on the success of your new book!
LikeLike
Congrats on your book and to the haters, well they will hate. Regardless, talking about these issues actually improve the dialogue, dispels myths and provides parents with much needed information. Unobstructed by hyperbole.
LikeLike
Inbloom dashboard for the big boys….we must keep assessing until they improve.
LikeLike
I love that you used the word humbug.
LikeLike
For all you fans of Data Driven Decision Making who wonder if the shrill and strident voices of critics of your beloved education establishment are undermining $tudent $ucce$$, I offer the following—
Amazon accessed between 11:17 & 11:22 AM, 10-6-13, PST:
Diane Ravitch, REIGN OF ERROR (hardcover, 2013):
Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #83 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
#1 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Children’s Studies
#1 in Books > Education & Reference > Schools & Teaching > Education Theory > Reform & Policy
#3 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > Public Affairs & Policy
Michelle Rhee, RADICAL (hardcover, 2013):
Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #117,276 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
#82 in Books > Biographies & Memoirs > Professionals & Academics > Educators
Dr. Steve Perry, PUSH HAS COME TO SHOVE: GETTING OUR KIDS THE EDUCATION THEY DESERVE — EVEN IF IT MEANS PICKING A FIGHT (hardcover, 2011):
Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #367,962 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Ron Paul, THE SCHOOL REVOLUTION: A NEW ANSWER FOR OUR BROKEN EDUCATION SYSTEM (hardcover, 2013):
Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #1,299 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
#1 in Books > Education & Reference > Schools & Teaching > Education Theory > Administration
#7 in Books > Education & Reference > Schools & Teaching > Education Theory > Reform & Policy
#8 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > Specific Topics > Commentary & Opinion
What oh what are we to make of these numbers? Well, we are left with no other recourse than to turn to “America’s Most Trusted Educator” (it has to be true, it is taken right from the heading on Dr. Steve Perry’s website, and letters don’t lie!).
And neither does the math:
“Men lie and women lie but numbers don’t.”
I never thought the day would come when I would say this, but Dr. Steve Perry—
When it comes to the above numbers on Amazon, you are so so right!
🙂
LikeLike
Diane, I just ran across a blog post titled “When You Preach To The Choir, Your Back Is To The Rest Of Us.” It’s a review of your talk at Occidental College, and it’s another misreading of your critique of “reform.” The author professes respect, but she objects to what she calls a “holy war jeremiad” containing “amped-up rhetoric” and “overheated metaphors.” She calls your “central narrative” a conspiracy theory. She does end up agreeing with the solutions you proposed in the talk. Still, the piece is front-loaded with distortions and complaints about “tone.”
The author has worked as a professional writer and recently taught English in a Los
Angeles charter school. It doesn’t sound like she has read your new book. Here’s the link: http://gatsbyinla.wordpress.com/2013/10/03/when-you-preach-to-the-choir-your-back-is-to-the-rest-of-us/
LikeLike
I loved the video. It made me laugh. Some might like us to go back to the time when women weren’t recognized as having much of a brain. Thankfully, we are past that. I truly believe “Reign of Error…” is one of the most important books of our time.
LikeLike
Tsk, Tsk, Tsk, when are you gals going to listen to this (especially the first line) timely and timeless advice: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U48VjCJkowE
LikeLike
Hey Dwayne, whatever happened to rerun.
LikeLike
“rerun”?? You got me on that one. Someone help me out!
LikeLike
A legend in the sitcom annals.
LikeLike
From “What’s Happening”?
LikeLike
The video is extremely entertaining. I’ve posted it with your comments above, “So, to pay tribute to those who want me to be quiet and deferential, here is a video for them. Enjoy”. to my facebook wall, and will share them on from there too.
LikeLike
Thank you for speaking clearly and directly. You are doing more good for schools right now than anyone I know of.
LikeLike
In an intellectual debate, charges of sexism or racism are always a sign these days that someone doesn’t want to engage in serious discussion that challenges her opinions. This effort to stifle debate from the author of a book called “The Language Police.”
LikeLike
“Someone” is engaging in serious discussion all across the country and back again. Reporters in the cities she visits are challenging her in interviews, with the arguments of the corporate reformers. She answers them lucidly and directly, citing evidence.
At the same time, nobody with a microphone challenges Arne Duncan or Bill Gates. They choose not to answer the arguments the people make against their destructive policies, and repeatedly dismiss their determined opponents with the sexist label “shrill”. That might work, if people weren’t able to see and hear us for themselves.
Rodgers, your accusation is that by defending herself against false characterizations, Diane is evading debate. Do you really think baseless assertions like “are always a sign these days” qualifies as intellectual debate? Who is stifling you?
LikeLike
Are you serious Rodgers12? At this point anyone who is calling Diane’s work, “opinions”, reminds me of the people who still want to debate climate change! This is really happening. Diane has engaged often here and on the road. The administrators in my building don’t reply to emails anymore so that nothing in writing can be held against them. That is a better example of what you are accusing.
LikeLike
Rodgers, when I lecture, I answer all questions. I don’t ask people to write them down on little pieces of paper and screen them (although the sponsors did that at Berkeley because they said that people tend to give speeches there). I have been interviewed endlessly by reporters who challenge what I say. I have no problem with engaging in serious intellectual discussion of any issue related to education. What I was writing about here are the critics who don’t like my “tone,” who say I am “shrill,” or “harsh,” who use other adjectives to propose that I speak in a quiet, deferential manner. Someone told me that I had hurt Bill Gates’ feelings; well, I say he has cost a lot of teachers’ their livelihood based on false metrics, and I think that is serious indeed. I think you should have seen the video at the end of this post. It is a spoof. Get that? A spoof. I laugh at those who tell me to lower my voice and change my demeanor. I suggest you laugh too.
LikeLike
wonderful, wonderful reponse
LikeLike
The groupies are out in force. Both genders have equal opportunity to be shrill, as Ann Coulter, Rush Limbaugh, and Sean Hannity, among many others, prove all the time. Allegations of racism and sexism are most often preemptive strikes to try to intimidate opponents into silence. It works all the time in academia and in the mainstream media, but since I’m outside those fields, it doesn’t work against me.
Whatever you think about her politics, Margaret Thatcher never cried sexism, even when her male opponents were actually being sexist. She just overwhelmed them with force of intelligence: a sterling example for women everywhere.
LikeLike
For some reason, I am unable to follow your logic and reasoning. I don’t know what your point is…am I a groupie?
LikeLike
Thank you, Diane, for speaking out about the truth of public education today – not in a shrill or harsh tone – but in a strong, articulate and vibrant voice- for those of us who have devoted our lives to education because of our commitment to students – ALL students!
With your dedication and voice to what is TRUE, the tide is turning toward restoration of democracy inherent in public education.
LikeLike
chemtchr: I guess I am getting slow in my old age, or perhaps I just don’t read so well anymore, but I thought the title of this website was “Diane Ravitch’s blog A site to discuss better education for all.”
Before today I have found myself in the [to me] surprising position of occasionally reminding some of the posters on this website that this is an online forum about a “better education for all.” However, I am genuinely puzzled that someone can’t read the first two words since they are proper nouns that begin with capital letters.
As astounding as this may seem, the owner of this blog has very occasionally posted poems and songs, and even gotten so personal as to have a blog posting about Mitzi (short for “Mittens”) her dog. She went so far as to talk about her previous dogs, and her current cat. Honest, I am not making this up.
Link: https://dianeravitch.net/2013/04/05/i-cannot-live-without/
It’s her blog. Her online living room. She is entitled to express her own opinions on her own blog, to deviate every so often from the officially stated purpose of the blog when she feels like it.
Us? We’re the guests. She gives us wide latitude to express our opinions but if we don’t like the way this blog is run, we can start our own.
I think we need to follow that old Marxist dictum: “A child of five would understand this. Send someone to fetch a child of five.”
No need to ask—Groucho.
🙂
LikeLike
Yes, KrazyTA, you’re getting fuzzy in your old age. I can’t fathom what you’re going on about.
LikeLike
Thank you, Professor Ravitch, for your wisdom and courage and good humor in the face of the predictable outpouring of invective from the deformers. Here’s one interesting thing about muckraking, which is a lot of what you have been doing: The truth, once known, cannot be unknown. That’s why, in the end, you will win this battle you are engaged in. Here’s the big question: How long will it take? How many kids will the standards-and-testing and privatization juggernauts roll over before enough of the public becomes aware of what is happening and the politicians have to stop being wind-up toys for the corporate masters pushing these deforms? One would have thought that the utter disaster that was NCLB would have been enough to bring this nonsense to an end. Alas, no. Our leaders have looked at a failed policy and said, “Well. Gosh. I guess we didn’t do enough of that.” But as the history of ugly educational “reforms” in the U.S. tells us, when this nasty episode plays itself out, there will be thousands of former “reformers” falling all over themselves to explain how they weren’t really supporters of this nonsense to begin with. A grateful nation, however, will remember that it was you who called them out.
LikeLike
Dear Diane,
Keep doing what you are doing. People ARE listening. I teach in one of the largest school districts in Texas. I was delighted tis morning to see our superintendent quoting you in the district’s weekly employee newsletter:
Click to access 10-7-13.pdf
LikeLike