Steven Cohen is superintendent of the Shoreham-Wading River
Central School district on Long Island in Néw York. At a time when
others quietly acquiesce, Superintendent Cohen spoke out in
“Newsday.”
He wrote that the schools are being swamped by a
tsunami of untested “reforms,” at the same time that their budgets
are restricted by Governor Cuomo’s 2% tax cap, which voters may
override only by winning 60% of the local vote. Costs don’t stop
rising, so many district will be forced to cut teachers and
essential services to students. He bravely calls out the state
Regents for forcing a “reform agenda” on public schools that may
yet hurt children.
For his courage, insight, and willingness to
speak against an unjust status quo, Steven Cohen is a hero of
public education.
“By Steven Cohen Shoreham-Wading River Central
School District
“Shoreham-Wading River’s greatest challenges in the
2013-14 school year are the same as those of sister districts
throughout Long Island and the rest of NYS. Will we find ways to
preserve, and where possible improve, valued educational programs
without having sufficient resources to cover increasing costs? Will
NYSED’s demands to implement untested — and very controversial —
changes in curriculum standards and assessment, called for in the
Regents Reform Agenda, help or hurt children?
“We do not control increasing pension costs. We have little control over increases in
the cost of medical benefits. We have little control over costs
associated with state mandates. We are bound by the new tax levy
limit. What we do control is the size of our teaching and support
staffs. So if we do not get help to meet increases in pension
costs, health costs and mandate costs, either we must ask our
communities to provide greater resources by a supermajority vote
(while the economy continues to sputter), or we must increase class
size, eliminate valuable programs, or do both. And while we
confront these difficult fiscal problems, we are required to train
new teachers and retrain veteran teachers to instruct students
according to new, untested, curriculum standards, and assess both
students and teachers by methods whose reliability is highly
uncertain.
“Our public schools are being told to do things that no
private schools are forced to do. Private schools have not embraced
the so-called benefits of the Regents Reform Agenda (why not?). An
entire generation of children is being put at risk of receiving a
defective — and perhaps damaging — education should these
untested “reforms” prove to be what many of us fear: false gods.
Will the Regents, many of whom send their own children to private
schools that are not hobbled by insufficient resources, or subject
to their own “reforms,” insist that all children — whether they
learn in public, private or parochial schools — be forced to
benefit from their recommended improvements? “These are the
challenges we face in 2013-14.”

Its time to TAKE BACK OUR SCHOOLS!
LikeLike
I have a friend who is a very talented elementary school teacher. This is a second career for her. She went back and studied education and history after having had a very successful career as a marketing executive. Here’s what she says:
“Never in my life have I had such a job. I thought that in marketing there were always others who thought they knew how to do the job better than you–you know, the production manager or boss who is suddenly an expert on layout or writing ad copy. But that was NOTHING compared to teaching. Every idiot thinks that he or she knows how to do the job better than you do, and every idiot thinks that he or she has the right to micromanage what you do. This year, they’ve handed us scripts, for crying out loud, for a lot of our lessons. And every few months, it seems, the geniuses in the state department decide that this is now how we’re supposed to teach writing or reading or whatever. And it’s always the same half-thought-through crap. I suppose that all that keeps them employed–cooking up the latest, greatest answer to everything.”
The presumption of the politicians, plutocrats, pundits, hedge fund managers, educrats, psychometricians, and others who meddle continually in education and who have foisted these gawdawful “reforms” on the nation is, truly, astonishing. They believe that they have the expertise to overrule every teacher, curriculum coordinator, and curriculum designer in the country. They create incredibly uninformed, AMATEURISH work like the new Common Core [sic] State [sic] Standards [sic] in ELA and then pretend that junk is holy writ that they’ve carried down from the mountain.
Don Marquis ends his lovely poem “The Old Trouper” with this line: “Come, my dear, both of our professions are being ruined by amateurs.” I think of this line often when I look at the junk being foisted on the nation by the reform crowd.
How wonderful that a few professionals are starting to stand up to this crap. God knows that the teacher’s unions aren’t.
LikeLike
“They’ve handed us scripts…;” That is how I personally feel about Pearson’s Scott Foresman Common Core version of Reading Street.
It is so scripted that I really think that Pearson’s believes that s long as their script is followed, a caveman could teach my first graders and have everyone reading and college and career ready. I am ready for Pearson to somehow go bankrupt.
LikeLike
I hear that the teachers unions are backing the new standards [sic] in ELA and I think to myself, “Have they actually read these things? And if they have and don’t think that they are amateurish and boneheaded, where the heck did these people study English or English education?”
LikeLike
You need to hear about our new superintendent in Lee County, North Carolina – Dr. Andy Bryan. He and our school board are speaking out about these types of issues in our state and working hard to protect our classrooms despite some very desperate conditions in NC. I’m glad to hear about other leaders, too. I think teachers in districts that are not as fortunate with their leadership need to know about these people and have hope that we can fight this mess overtaking our schools.
LikeLike
Thank you Superintendent Cohen!
LikeLike
So happy to see more LI super’s standing up and rather than be self-serving, putting their students/teacher’s needs before their own motivations! Bravo Dr. Cohen! I hope you received a pair of green laces from “Lace to the Top.”
LikeLike
I think this is all back door reform to eventually force conversion of public education to a charter system to save the State money. The system is unsustainable as is and instead of working with unions, Washington is trying to force public education to go belly up. It is horrible that it falls on the backs of our children.
LikeLike
It is so refreshing to see another Long Island super speak out!!
Please note: Long Island is not a city, it is an island. One cannot be “in”
it, but can be “on” it. It is “in” the United States, “in” NYS. Pet peeve that many non-long islander’s do. :). Thanks for bringing this article to the forefront- I would have missed it otherwise.
LikeLike
Long Islander,
I live “On” Long Island, so I should know better.
LikeLike