Governor Tom Corbett’s poll numbers have been sinking, and based on his latest budget, he doesn’t deserve another term as governor. His budget abandons the desperate Philadelphia public school system, which has been under state control for a decade.
The governor has no trouble building new prisons or cutting corporate taxes, but his message to Philadelphia is simple: Tough luck!
As Daniel Denvir reports:
“Gov. Tom Corbett’s proposed public school “rescue package,” currently making its way through the legislature, is a destructive joke with troubling long-term implications. The $140 million, pledged just before the governor signed the state budget last night, falls far short of both the $304 million budget gap and the $180 million the School Reform Commission requested from city and state government.
“It’s also a shell game, so make sure to watch closely: the plan shifts the burden for funding city schools onto those who can least afford it. Much of the funding comes from optimistic projections of increased collections from city tax delinquents, and from an extension of the city’s “temporary” 1-percent sales tax hike. The latter is simply the state giving the city the power to further tax its own disproportionately low-income population. This is patently regressive taxation, meaning that it takes disproportionately from the poor — in a city that already has a regressive wage tax, and in a state that has one of the most regressive tax structures in the nation.
“There is only $47 million in new state funding for city schools (less than half of what adds up to just $127 million in new funding, according to this Notebook/NewsWorks analysis, since $13 million Corbett had proposed previously was already included in the school district budget). Critically, $45 million of that is a one-time-only expenditure — and it actually comes not from Corbett but from the Obama administration.”
Denvir writes that Corbett’s “brave new formula requires Philadelphians and teachers to pay more than we can afford while wealthy businesses and nonprofits contribute basically nothing to solve the crisis. This is supported by Corbett, the SRC, Superintendent William Hite, business leaders, “reform” advocacy groups and, apparently, city leaders.”
Let it be remembered and recorded by historians that Governor Corbett, the state legislature, the state-controlled School Reform Commission, the Broad-trained superintendent, the city’s foundations and its business leaders decided to walk away from their responsibility to the children and public schools of Philadelphia. They knowingly, consciously, callously turned their backs on the children. Remember their names.

Pennsylvania is one of 5 states in which the courts have held that equitable funding is not to be determined in the courts but in the legislature. How is this real and who is pulling the strings. How can this not be something to be heard in the courts? I thought that is what courts are for. Something really perverse in Pennsylvania.
LikeLike
What if the courts had said it was not up to them to decide a contested election (a la 2000)?
I had figured the courts was all there was.
I think a lot of this is over my head. Or at least I need to keep hitting the books to understand everything.
LikeLike
History does make fools of those who turn their backs on the marginalized, so I like the way you frame that.
Meanwhile I wonder if Philly will be like Haiti where it is up to main line churches to make sure the poor have schools.
In Haiti I learned two things: vote for Democrats, support my church (the Episcopal church, of which I am a member) does a lot for outreach in Haiti. It is hard to believe I am trying to understand a city in the United States in the context of Haiti, but it sounds pretty dire. Also, support for Democrats so far does not seem to have helped education.
This is a sad song.
LikeLike
You have to hand it to republicans, they have an agenda and they grind at it forever, until they are in power and then anything progressive is torn down posthaste. The democrats mostly forestall (not very often, in the case of education) , they don’t currently have an agenda. Regardless, what you suggest is at least a plan.
LikeLike
Is the School Reform Commission legit or representative of the “Reform” movement (trying to understand this).
LikeLike
The “School Reform Commission” in Philly has nothing to do with reform. It represents the business community and supposedly imposed fiscal discipline.
LikeLike
The School Reform Commission is the body established when the state took over the Philadelphia public schools system in December, 2001.
Three members are appointed by the Governor and two by the Mayor. Since our Mayor Nutter is on board with corporate education reform, being an outspoken promoter of charts, the SRC represents the corporate and banking interests.
One of the first actions of the SRC was to try to turn over 64 Philadelphia schools to Edison Schools. When this failed, they developed a long range plan which, in 2008 Superintendent Ackerman, introduced as a five year plan called Imagine 2014. This is what is now coming to fruition.
Most of Philadelphia’s Superintendents appointed by the SRC since the takeover have been people from outside the district with connections to corporate education reform.
See this article for a detailed breakdown of this history:
The 2013-14 “Doomsday Budget” of the School District of Philadelphia: How Did It Come to This?
http://tinyurl.com/mwkclqr
LikeLike
What is happening in Philly is happening throughout the country. The defunding of public education and other public services is a disgrace. There is absolutely no reason for the lack of tax funding. We keep giving tax breaks to corporations with the idea that they will create jobs. It is not happening. If jobs are created, they are very low paying.
Yet we also find city governments financing multi million dollar projects such as stadiums for NFL and NBA.
I have determined that greed is a systemic disease affecting the 1%ers.
LikeLike
There is a lot to be said for education. Recently Pennsylvania is one of the states trying to back out of Common Core. YEAH for that fact. But it seems there has not been a better system put in place.
Lets look at this from a different perspective if you will.
When going through a crisis in any home or city or other situation or environment, there is a way to adjust to the new circumstances. Now don’t take this the wrong way but it looks like people are wanting Philadelphia to be viewed as the “woe is me”city. Who wants that pity? I thought Philadelphia was the city of brotherly love. Philadelphia needs to pick up their boot straps and not wait on the state to make things better for them. Use the resources they have to put students back in the desk. Great innovative teachers don’t need the latest tech devices to get kids to learn. Great used books are abound in this country. Teachers have the amazing world around them to encourage kids to learn. The term of getting back to the basics comes into play here. Its time for the schools of Philadelphia to regroup and see what resources they have around them to get moving again. Kids don’t need the latest in everything to be successful. Great minds and able bodies can get kids going to great places. Encourage your teachers to teach to their god given abilities to reach children’s minds and do it without the handcuffs placed on them through the federal government.
Get back to the basics of learning and band together to get the city moving again. Use the ideas of the citizens of Philadelphia to put the city back on the map. The federal government will not and should not be the hero in this. The people are the hero’s. Come on Philadelphia, get moving!
LikeLike