Readers may recall that outgoing Indiana State Superintendent Tony Bennett left behind a videoconferencing system that cost $1.7 million and was utterly useless because it was incompatible with the department’s existing technology. The expensive technology was purchased from Cisco Systems, which by happy coincidence employs Bennett’s former chief of staff Todd Huston.
Karen Francisco of the Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette notes that the useless videoconferencing system is symptomatic of Bennett’s most important legacy: a full-bore assault on Indiana’s public school system.
She asks:
“Is the spin that is used to justify the questionable $1.7 million deal any different from the claims he used to expand charter schools, to shift tax dollars to private schools through voucher payments, to strip collective bargaining rights for teachers or require third-graders to pass a standardized reading test before moving on to fourth grade?
“Aside from his former chief of staff’s job with Cisco, Bennett’s ties to corporate interests have become increasingly clear. A nonprofit group in January released thousands of emails revealing the Foundation for Excellence in Education’s efforts in working with state officials, including Bennett, in writing education laws to benefit the foundation’s corporate supporters. The foundation, started by former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, has received financial support from for-profit companies like McGraw Hill, Pearson and K12 and the nonprofit College Board, Huston’s current employer.
“The complex web of ties between corporate influences, Bennett’s administration and the raft of legislation should give lawmakers every reason to halt the continuing tide of education bills, including several sponsored by Huston. Demanding research-based evidence of the effectiveness of laws already passed and simply giving schools time to implement and evaluate them could save legislators some embarrassment later.”

Tony Bennett claimed this purchase was to facilitate communication among school officials, citing the long drive to Indianapolis from the far corners of the state. But everyone knows that Tony had no intention of communicating with anyone in education. His ears were only for the corporations that were backing him and of course Jeb Bush. Another article by Matthew Tulley of the Indianapolis Star (http://www.indystar.com/article/20130413/NEWS08/304120048/Matthew-Tully-What-Glenda-Ritz-got-from-Tony-Bennett-1-7-million-boondoggle) explains this mess in more detail. But the most interesting part of Mr. Tulley’s article is the comments. When the article first appeared there were many comments from Jo Blaketor, a Mitch Daniels appointed member of the Indiana State Board of Education. Ms. Blaketor made a comment that Glenda Ritz needed to “quit whining” about the equipment mentioned in the article and learn how to use it. Amazingly Ms. Blaketor’s comments have disappeared from the comment section of the article. Sadly this all illustrates the disgusting mindset of the reformers. It is all about money.
LikeLike
I am increasingly struck by how the whole movment has the same MO as the Bush administration: The high noble rhetoric justifying actions with horrific consequence on “other people” and no actual hard work and research in exploring their actual effects, the “trust us” disclaimers when questioned, the web of influence peddling, self-dealing, and profiteering and ultimately the incompetence. It’s all there.
LikeLike
Michael,
You summed up the privatization movement admirably well.
The high-flown rhetoric, detached from reality; the influence peddling; the policies enacted without evidence; all for “other people’s children,” who are trained for jobs that were outsourced.
LikeLike
We are all getting a clear picture of the corporate influence peddling. Now, the question is about government corruption: Michelle Rhee did some creative accounting to justify firing hundreds of D.C. teachers. Mitch Daniels also “lost” millions of public education dollars in Indiana, causing extreme cutbacks for school districts. They both then “found” the missing money. Is this part of the ed reform scheme? Other states seem to have experienced the same pattern of events.
LikeLike
I am reminded of ancient Athens at the end of its Golden Age: destructive, unnecessary wars to benefit the upper class, demagoguery without substance, Socrates put to death for teaching critical thinking, and other intellectuals leaving in disgust.
LikeLike
Michael,
You are so right on. Love your comment.
LikeLike
If I may correct your statement: “I am increasingly struck by how the whole movment has the same MO as BOTH the Bush and OBAMA (god I actually didn’t use obomber this time) administration. . . ”
Some of us have seen through the rhetoric of both administrations from the gitgo.
LikeLike
And now we are saddled with Mr. Bennett here in Florida, where Jeb Bush still controls education legislation despite having left office and being replaced by 2 different governors. Florida’s public schools have been on the endangered species list since Bush was in office and I imagine that Bennett will hasten their demise. The only way to get rid of him here is to vote Governor Scott out of office (which shouldn’t be too hard, with his amazingly low approval ratings) but we are still stuck with gerrymandered districts and state GOP legislators who would sell their souls to the highest corporate bidder no matter the results. There are a few GOP legislators who listen to their constituents but the state party has a target on their backs as well. Doom and despair.
LikeLike
Chris,
No time for doom and despair. Time to organize and build a counter-movement.
LikeLike
Florida teachers are amazingly naive and woefully uninformed. There is an “oh well” attitude here of submissiveness and helplessness.
My counter-movement is I quit.
LikeLike
Diane, I have been working to build a countermovement for the past decade without much success. My colleagues believe they will somehow weather the storm and that this will all just go away. My school is one of 8 in my district that is now under state monitoring due to last year’s FCAT results. We just hired a new Broad-trained superintendent with no teaching experience who is starting to swing the ax in every direction while he deals with a huge budget deficit lest by his predecessor.
The FEA has been pretty toothless in this fight and has had little success in stemming the tide of reform and exercising political clout since this a right to work state.
I guess my concern now is what do I do while I’m waiting to lose my teaching certificate over the VAM scores of children I’ve never taught, see my school converted to a privately-run charter school by the new parent trigger law that will inevitably be passed this year, and most likely when I will have no income, no insurance, and no safety net at all? Because of the extremely low salaries paid to teachers here in Florida I am in a mood of doom and despair — I have nothing to fall back on and no one to turn to for help and I am not alone. Many of my colleagues are in the same boat.
I am at the age that switching careers will be extraordinarily difficult if it is possible at all. I’m all for fighting back but I also need to pay my bills and have a little bit of something to hold onto while I fight. Where is that support? Not coming from the FEA, the NEA, the AFT, or any other groups down here.
Sorry if I sound too negative or fatalistic but the reality of this mess has been bearing down on us for many years now and it is taking its toll.
LikeLike
I certainly hope you can build a movement that will be able to rid Florida of your governor and Tony Bennett. It may seem to be doom and despair, but we managed to do it here in Indiana. We are finding that there is a lot more that has to change beyond just getting rid of Tony Bennett but it can be done.
LikeLike
Chris
Indiana threw Bennett to the curb with a “grassroots” movement. Call me an eternal optimist but “we the people” CAN make a difference. Also, bombing email to GOP legislators, calling them out may be something they can’t ignore in any election year. The time to organize is now.
LikeLike
It is nearly impossible to exaggerate how important it was to the survival of public education in Indiana that steady Republican voters switched their ballot on the position of Superintendent. Now, the question remains, will these same Republican voters next election realize that simply voting against the Republican Superintendent does not fix the problem?
Look at the detrimental, even punitive, policies of the Republican controlled super-majority in both the state house and senate. The same voters who cast ballots for Ritz must realize, next election, they will have to vote for state democratic representatives to undo the harm perpetuated on public education by Republicans. If they do not, all may be for naught.
As Martin Luther KIng reminded us, “We are likely to find that the problem of housing and education, instead of preceding the elimination of poverty, will themselves be affected if poverty is first abolished.” Remember that former governor Mitch Daniels supposedly ran a supposed two billion dollar surplus, thus providing the ability for tax breaks, while sharply cutting education programs.
Our public schools in Indiana have, on the whole, done remarkable work, especially when one considers nearly 25% of Hoosier children live below the poverty line. But, they cannot continue to operate at this rate and survive, especially when,state representatives continue to bleed support away and then blame public education for its woes.
If parents and educators want to foster public education in Indiana once again, they will have to start educating more than just the children. They will have to educate Hoosiers voters as well.
LikeLike
That’s what my dad used to refer to as a “brother-in-law job.” And now Tony is bringing his brother-in-law to Florida. Great. I only hope we can get rid of him when we vote Rick Scott out of his job. I only fear that the big corporations who backed Scott can be overcome by unhappy voters.
LikeLike
Francisco nails it again.
LikeLike
When you can literally buy people and their influence and votes so cheaply why not? To them it is just a consideration of the cost of doing business and in education the buy in is so cheap they cannot hardly figure out the percentage of gains for expenditures for the cost of getting that business and profits and power.
LikeLike
Alan nailed it. Read your history. All the answers are there. There are no new moves. Our ancestors were way slicker than we are so if you read the best of all cultures and their political maneuvers these low level scamers are easy to spot along with their simplistic methodologies. Aren’t teachers supposed to know history, Alan obviously is a student. Thank You Alan for waking me up to that one. Just reread Plato’s Republic. No wonder Western Culture is so messed up since we follow that model or so they say.
LikeLike