With a favorable rightwing privatizing climate in Texas and bipartisan support in Washington, a group of charters have proposed a bold plan to take over one fourth of all the students in San Antonio. The time is right for privatization on a grand scle.

“The best CMOs give students about 4 extra years worth of education by the time they finish high school as compared to traditional public schools…. Essentially, these organizations are providing most of their students about 1.5 years worth of learning in every school year. Until recently, this was thought to be impossible because traditional public schools couldn’t do it. It turns out not to be impossible, just really, really hard. Great organizations do great things, including in education.”
I would love to where this data comes from! They are selling a pig in a poke. And people continue fall for this.
LikeLike
P.T. Barnum is right even for today. We sure think we’re sophisticated. I would love to see the peer review on the data too. How do they define a year of education? If this is so great how come their vaunted test scores either don’t match the public schools, or they are not subjected to the tests in terms of accountability?
LikeLike
I teach public high school (16 years) in San Antonio. Already I have received several emails from a teacher in the same subject at a KIPP school, asking for my advice on curriculum and text books. It gives me the impression that charter teachers don’t exactly know what they are doing. And then there’s this guy:
http://trib.it/VO5GOe
Is the public so easily snowed by this illusion of choice?
LikeLike