The movement to slow down or stop or reverse high-stakes testing is moving forward at a rapid pace. This past week, the Houston Independent School Board endorsed a resolution opposing the overuse and misuse of standardized tests (http://blog.chron.com/k12zone/2012/05/hisd-joins-anti-testing-movement/). The resolution has now been endorsed by about 450 school boards in Texas, representing nearly half the state’s students.
The Texas resolution picked up steam after Robert Scott, the state commissioner of education, blasted the misuse of tests earlier this year. He said that testing had grown into the “be-all, end-all” of education and had become “the heart of the vampire.”(http://goo.gl/Az246)
Scott stepped down recently but it turns out that he spoke for vast numbers of Texans who are sick and tired of the tests that now control education and children’s lives.
Parents in Florida are now on board the anti-testing train, as are parents in New York.(http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303505504577406603829668714.html?mod=WSJ_hp)
New parent organizations opposed to high-stakes testing seem to be forming in many cities and states.
I recently posed a question on Twitter that is relevant to this development. I asked, what happens in your district if children vomit while taking the test? I got many answers from teachers about the policy in their district. In some, the test must be placed in a plastic baggie and preserved. In others, the child must immediately retake the test. There were all sorts of variations on what to do when test anxiety causes a child to lose his or her breakfast.
Test anxiety is only part of the problem. Pineapplegate opened a national discussion about the quality of the tests and why they are used to decide the fate of children and their teachers.
Diane
I wonder how we can get this started in Ohio? As we get more and more pressure from our government. Our new teacher evaluation system, which will be in effect in 2013, requires that 50% of our teacher evaluations come from value-added data. . .it keeps getting worse and worse!
It’s heartening to see a backlash building against the lunacy of standardized tests. Here in Australia a group of educators and academics have formed a group against NAPLAN, our nation wide test. ‘Say No to NAPLAN’ have engaged a campaign informing parents that the test is not compulsory and encouraging them to withdraw their children. The Federal government have created a website which rates schools based on these tests.
[…] in other states are leaps ahead of Oklahoma on this issue. Diane Ravitch had a great column on this on her blog a few weeks ago. The idea is not that standardized tests need to go away. Rather it is the […]
Their are two reasons for these tests…one is to keep Pearson Rich…they get about $25 Billion to make the tests, then turn around and train the teachers and sell workbooks designed to beat the test.
Reason number two…all the meetings that Pearson pays for that have teachers going to Austin and validating the tests, at Pearson’s expense….keep the Austin economy booming. I see from the comments this isn’t only a Texas problem…but hopefully it will find a solution.
I ask you…if you have to pass Reading, English and Mathematics to move up at grades 5 and 6, but not science and social studies….Why are we giving the tests???
That should have been 5 and 8. If you are a principal where will you hire a tutor…for math, reading and English or science and social studies?
Diane, is it true that Pearson is taking money from companies for product placement within the tests? (ie: legos mentioned by name and payment to Pearson from Lego company?).
http://murrieta.patch.com/articles/u-s-news-ranks-murrieta-high-schools-among-the-best
If anyone is interested in the response in So Cal-here is a link to an online article & the responses to my comment. I would love any support I can get.