Retired teacher Nancy Flanagan writes about Michigan’s decision to provide a free lunch to all students. She explains why it’s a good thing and also wonders why some people do not. Open the link and read the entire article.
She writes:
So—Michigan just adopted a policy of offering free breakfast and lunch to all K-12 public school kids. Charter school kids, too– and intermediate school districts (which often educate students with significant disabilities). More than half of Michigan students were already eligible for free-reduced lunch, which says a lot about why free at-school meals are critical to supporting students and their families. Why not streamline the system?
Schools have to sign up for the federal funding that undergirds the program, and still need income data from parents to determine how much they get from the feds. Nine states now have universal breakfast-lunch programs, and another 24 are debating the idea, which—in Michigan anyway—is estimated will save parents who participate about $850 year. That’s a lot of square pizza, applesauce and cartons of milk. Not to mention reducing stress, on mornings when everyone’s running late for the bus and work.
Cue the right-wing outrage.
Headline in The New Republic: Republicans Declare Banning Universal Free School Meals a 2024 Priority. Because? “Community Eligibility Provision, or CEP, allows certain schools to provide free school lunches regardless of the individual eligibility of each student.”
It’s hard to figure out precisely what they’re so honked off about: Poor kids getting something—say, essential nutrition– for nothing? Kids whose parents can well afford lunch mingling with their lower-income classmates over free morning granola bars and fruit? No way to clearly identify a free lunch kid in the 6th grade social hierarchy? The kiosks at the HS, where kids can grab something to give them a little fuel for their morning academics?
Open the link and keep reading.

It is OBSCENE that this isn’t nationwide.
Kudos to legislators of the state of Michigan!
LikeLike
I admit that this was something that I at first was not in favor of (my thinking there was why should we supplement families that CAN afford to pay for lunch). That said, I saw how small the amout of budget in Minnesota (who was an earlier state that did free meals for all) would be impacted by moving to meals for all that changed my mind
LikeLike
My grandson in Texas must live in a school district that meets community eligibility requirements. He receives free lunch, and my daughter does not fill out any forms. In New York where I taught, I spent a good deal of time before and after school helping ELL parents at the beginning of the school year fill out the applications for my students, almost all of whom were eligible to receive free or reduced breakfast and lunch.
LikeLike
Here’s what I know…waaaay back in the day, I noticed a student stumbling across the room. Now, my first inclination was to think, “Is she drunk?” The reason being is we had students “experimenting” and putting vodka in Gatorade along with a host of other things. I asked, “Are you okay? I sent her to see the nurse. The result: she hadn’t eaten for a couple of days. For me, I learned every day. Also, I noticed in elementary kids got two recesses and “snack.” Once they reached middle school for whatever reason, snack was taken away and the kids needed to ride it out from 8 a.m. till a tad after 12. And, at the high school they got “brunch back.” I didn’t understand that “middle school concept.” So, as typical, I starting noticing patterns. First, it was all the garbage stuffed under the tables. This continued for a while. I noticed it happened about 10:30 a.m. Young kids need to eat nearly all the time. I put garbage cans in four corners of my room and told them, “Look what we do in here, stays in here, but I can’t have you getting dizzy and “the shakes” from not eating (food was NOT ALLOWED). I cleaned my room nearly all the time because if something was left out (like a brand new stack of books) the janitor would throw it out. GEEZ. You can bring healthy food and eat during class. But, the minute the garbage is not in the cans, it’s over. Got it?” Never had a problem again. Kids brought carrots, sandwiches and whatnot. Good healthy snacks to get them through the day. As the years passed, I starting making sure I had plenty of snacks in the room. Of course, this got expensive, but something to take the “growls” away. I had Cheezits and water. It definitely helped. Small water bottles kept kids from always wanting to leave to get water. It’s what I could do. At another location, I walked the students to the lunch room. One student told me, “I don’t have money and I didn’t fill out the forms.” I talked to the head of the cafeteria and she said, “You tell her to come here and we will make sure she has something to eat.” I also collected any items the kids were told they had to take, but almost always threw in the garbage. I collected those items and had it in a “snack box.” Our school district was really good at providing food services. We all know if you don’t eat, your brain doesn’t function well. I can’t believe in this day and age, there are so many children who go to school hungry; Jeff Bridges reminds me.
LikeLike
Thanks for posting, Diane.
One of the schools where I volunteer has had free breakfast and lunch for years. Because 80%+ of the kids were already on free-reduced lunch, it was actually cheaper (not to mention skipping a whole lot of intrusive paperwork) to feed everyone breakfast and lunch. Plus there was less waste, as extras could be set out for everyone to grab. A significant percentage of the kids live on the Grand Traverse Band Reservation. Offering breakfast and lunch was another way to encourage regular attendance. Because there is little internet access across the district, during the pandemic, teachers stood out in front of school with boxes of food and packets for their students.
I’ve been there frequently at the beginning of the day–it’s a very casual atmosphere, all the kids eating breakfast together, the littles slurping up cereal and milk, the older kids grabbing an apple or banana for later, and sitting down to french toast sticks. The older kids sometimes roam around and chat with elementary students. Food gets put in backpacks, too, and that’s OK.
LikeLike
Thank you for the post, Nancy. So important, this.
LikeLike
And thank you for being one of the good humans who cares about matters like this.
LikeLike
“Long-term, there is evidence that free, in-school breakfast and lunch improve learning and focus.”
“Improve learning and focus”??? If it doesn’t raise test scores what good is it?
LikeLike
Snorting…
LikeLiked by 2 people
Some Paterson, NJ teachers would bring in bagels & orange juice the mornings of the 8th grade test week so their students would have a good breakfast those days. Another instance that never gets reported in local newspapers.
LikeLike
!!!!
LikeLike
Can you say bribery or extortion?
LikeLike
NJ Senator Menendez was just indicted on bribery; $480,000 in cash plus gold bullion at his home. Breakfast for students in a high-poverty school isn’t on the radar screen.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey, Republicans: How about free lunch for K-12 nationwide, some actual family values?
No, Trump kicked a lot of kids OFF the free and reduced lunch program. Because he’s a pig.
LikeLike