Texas journalist Jason Stanford says it is time to recognize one of the heroes of the Education Spring: former Texas Commissioner Robert Scott, who bluntly said that high-stakes testing had grown too powerful and who warned that Common Core was intended to create a national curriculum and testing system. He came under a lot of criticism at the time and had to step down, but he has been proven right. The movement against high-stakes testing continues to escalate, and the number of states dropping out of Common Core seems likely to increase.
“Scott announced his resignation as Texas Education Commissioner in May 2012, but his public career effectively ended that January when he said that standardized testing had become a “perversion of its original intent.” Testing was wagging the dog, and Scott placed the blame on testing companies and lobbyists that have “become not only a cottage industry but a military-industrial complex.”
“You’ve reached a point now of having this one thing that the entire system is dependent upon. It is the heart of the vampire, so to speak,” said Scott, who stood by his remarks even as others failed to do the same for him.”
Texas was the heart of the testing movement, and a vast majority of local school boards passed resolutions opposing the misuse of testing. Even the Legislature took a stand against high-stakes testing. Much of that momentum can be credited to Robert Scott, who had the courage to speak out when it was unpopular. He is a hero of American education.

Thanks David. It’s on Pacifica Radio not NPR. I hope the Seattle station carries it. love,Marek
LikeLike
some people will tell you don’t read anything from the Pioneer Institute (in Boston)
but this publication was 2013 and Robert Scott is cited extensively. Use your critical judgement when reading all their conclusions (for example, Pioneer pushes charters as “choice”) but they did give early press to Robert Scott when everyone else was jumping on the Duncan bandwagon with the Race to the Top to get fund$$$. I have also written here before that Governor Patrick signed off on goals that were unachievable in order to get fund$$$$…
title: go to Pioneer Institute and download the PDF.
A Republic of Republics: How Common Core Undermines State and Local Autonomy over K-12 Education
Download 5.81 MB | 1273 downloads
LikeLike
Robert Scott is one of the “good guys” whose integrity and courage enabled him to speak up on behalf of the Texas school children that he served. Unfortunately, current TEA Commissioner Michael Williams has no experience in education and appears too enmeshed with his own political interests and lobbyists to have the welfare of Texas school children as a priority.
The deficit of leadership by Commissioner Williams and conflict of interests for Bill Hammond has regressed Texas education back to the dark ages…causing many angry parents across the state to think it is time for… torches…. pitchforks…tar…feathers!!
Thank you Jason for another insightful article! Posted on Texas Parents Opt Out.
LikeLike
So where is Robert Scott now? That others would bale on him is not unexpected. I hope that some of them at least had the decency to help him land on his feet. Is it any wonder that teachers fear speaking out?
LikeLike
Diane..have you checked Robertâs client list lately???Billy
Billy R. Reagan
Unlimited Access Educational Systems, Inc.
713.795.9696
713.795.9697 FAX
LikeLike
http://www.texastribune.org/2013/03/04/tribunefest-ex-commissioners-confidential/
Robert Scott and other former commissioners interviewed on Texas policy , accountability etc.
this is the dialogue that took place at Rice with the former commissioners. If someone has the patience to listen through to the latter section I would love to have the policy decisions around special education explained to me… it was one of the “sticking points” when Ted Kennedy compromised on the NCLB and i still don’t really know what happened. (I’m not being disingenuous just want to think about the intricacies) The video is quite long — but in my opinion is worth the time.
jeanhaverhill@aol.com
LikeLike
Billy: TribuneFest: Ex-Commissioners Confidential
by Evan Smith March 4, 2013 (a dialogue that was held at Rice)
Robert Scott is in this video and the former commissioners address the “high stakes” issue and the charter school/choice issue. As someone who doesn’t live in Texas this was enlightening for me (with the aside that Richardson’s laugh is uncanny).
Scott represents a viewpoint that I could support here (in this video) and the forensics as to how we got to this point, from the various commissioners, was helpful for me to understand Texas viewpoints and how we got into this “over the top” assessment. This kind of conversation is needed no matter where any of them are working or retired. There is levity in the dialogue and not the personal attacks that often cheapen the debate.
LikeLike