There are people who hate public education and don’t care much about any kind of education. Some are legislators. Some have positions of influence in states like Georgia.
Here Maureen Downey writes about the latest legislative assault, which started as an attack on Common Core and grew into something far worse.
As one who has been critical of Common Core in its current form, I want to disassociate myself from this extremism. I think the Common Core should be revised by every state’s best teachers and improved. I think the early grades must be made developmentally appropriate. I don’t believe any set of standards is beyond improvement. I also hope they will be decoupled from high-stakes testing. What is happening in Georgia is legislative meddling at its worst.
Downey writes:
“In capitulating to extremists who consider Common Core the work of the devil and/or Barack Obama, the state Senate passed a bill last week that isolates Georgia from the rest of the nation, sets our students up for failure and reverses the progress schools have made over the last eight years.
“The main intent of Senate Bill 167 bill was to ban the Common Core State Standards in Georgia.
“It no longer does that, which is good considering Georgia has already invested years into putting the standards into practice, training teachers and rewriting curriculum. In a compromise with the governor who didn’t want a Common Core battle in an election year, the bill was changed so it doesn’t ban Common Core, but sets up a review of the standards.
“That compromise explains why the bill passed the Senate so easily last week and with little debate. But senators should have read the 18-page bill a little more closely as it still contains plenty of bad stuff, including a prohibition on embracing any new content or tests that even smack of national standards. Let’s hope that wiser minds prevail in the House and put the brakes on this bill, either killing it completely or rewriting it to get rid of all the mandates.
“The bill still states: On and after the effective date of this Code section, the state shall not adopt any federally prescribed content standards or any national content standards established by a consortium of states or a third party, including, but not limited to, the Next Generation Science Standards, the National Curriculum for Social Studies, the National Health Education Standards, or the National Sexuality Standards.”
“Imagine telling Georgia doctors they couldn’t use any cancer treatments developed by medical teams or labs outside the state. Patients would riot in the streets. So should parents over this piece of legislation.”

I say, “Bravo, Georgia”! Perhaps the folks doing this have the wrong motives, but they seem to have the necessary instinct to smell a rat. Somehow, I don’t think banning Common Core will put GA on the path to educational nirvana, but it’s a start.
LikeLike
GA…You are the ones to lead the way!
NC received the RTTT money and we are thinking they have spent just about every cent on two things
1. Tests, Tests, Tests, Tests…..etc..forever..
2. Decode-Workshops….
LikeLike
Not sure this is an entirely bad move by Georgia, actually. I think banning the formal adoption of CCSS does not equate to banning the informal adoption of any parts of a future incarnation of CCSS that might actually be beneficial to students (not holding my breath on that, but admitting that it might be a possibility in the future).
LikeLike
Good for Georgia! Just because a state has spent a lot of time and money going down the wrong road (implementing and training for the Common Core) doesn’t mean it should just keep going. Enough journalists, educators and parents have pulled away the curtain on the mighty Oz to see him pulling levers and pushing buttons to make his voice big and loud and impressive when it turns out it is actually just Bill Gates….the rich sociopath who thinks he can buy everyone in order to end public education. More states should pass such legislation banning the intrusion of “any federally prescribed content standards or any national content standards established by a consortium of states or a third party, including, but not limited to, the Next Generation Science Standards, the National Curriculum for Social Studies, the National Health Education Standards, or the National Sexuality Standards.” People have no idea what kind of curriculum the National Sexuality Standards actually calls for subjecting our very young children to or there would be a stampede for the passage of identical legislation as Georgia has passed. Check it out. Be amazed.
LikeLike
Is this woman serious? If so, we can expect to hear the loud moaning from the core deprived hoards across the nation. Heaven forbid that these hastily written standards be subjected to a thorough review by teachers. Can you imagine that?
LikeLike
I’m really finding it impossible to get too upset about this. There is no way to save Common Core. It was designed to be implemented with high-stakes testing, and there are fundamental problems with it through and through. Kill it and let’s start over.
LikeLike
I am having a really hard time getting upset about this. Common Core was designed to be implemented with high-stakes testing, so tweaking it doesn’t seem feasible to me. These legislators are doing the best they can under the circumstances to at least limit the damage; kudos to them for standing up to the business community and taking the tough votes. Killing this beast has got to start somewhere – maybe this will encourage action in other states.
LikeLike