Florida, under Ron DeSantis, is determined to defund its public schools.
The first charter law in Florida was passed in 1996, when Democrat Lawton Chiles was governor. The 1996 law said there could be no more than two charter schools in each district, and only local school boards could authorize them. When Chiles left office, the state had 17 charter schools.
From 1999-2007, Republican Governor Jeb Bush removed the caps on charters and encouraged their growth. By the end of his tenure, there were more than 300 charter schools.
Republican Charlie Crist vetoed aggressive charter legislation, but charters increased to more than 300 during his tenure in office (2007-2011).
Republican Rick Scott (2011-2019) strongly promoted school choice, reduced regulation, and the number of charters increased to about 650.
Far-right DeSantis is a cheerleader for charters and vouchers. Elected in 2019, DeSantis has aggressively expanded charters as well as vouchers, while reducing accountability.
Half of Florida’s charter schools operate for-profit. Over the years, nearly 500 charter schools have closed, due to maladministration, low enrollment, finances, or scandal.
Today, Florida has about 730 charter schools, which enroll 13.8% of the state’s students, about 400,000. The cost of charters is about $2.5-4 billion annually that should have gone to public schools.
The state’s Republican-controlled governor and legislature are dedicated to expanding private alternatives to public schools. In 2023, it removed income limits from vouchers, so that all private school students are now eligible to get a state subsidy. The number of students receiving vouchers doubled, from 250,000 to 524,000.
Before and since the voucher expansion of 2023, 70% of the voucher recipients were already enrolled in voucher schools. so Florida offers a subsidy to all students enrolled in private and religious schools regardless of family income.
Florida spends about $4 billion on vouchers each year, subsidizing mostly families who can pay for schooling without state aid.
Thus, between charters and vouchers, Florida is spending at least $6 billion annually on school choice.
Now, Florida has given charter operators another boon, allowing them to co-locate inside public schools. This alleviates their need for facilities funding.
Many Republican legislators have financial ties to the charter industry.
Kate Payne of the Associated Press wrote this story, which appeared in the Orlando Sentinel.
TALLAHASSEE (AP) — Florida’s board of education signed off Wednesday on a major expansion of charter schools in the state, clearing the way for the privately run schools to “co-locate” inside traditional public schools.
It’s the latest push by Florida officials to expand school choice in a state that has long been a national model for conservative education policy.
The move comes as some public schools are closing their doors as they grapple with declining enrollments, aging facilities and post-pandemic student struggles.The new regulations approved by the state board build on a bill signed into law by Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis this year to allow operators to open more “schools of hope,” charter schools that are meant to serve students from persistently low-performing schools.
Lawmakers created the schools of hope program in 2017 to encourage more publicly funded, privately run schools to open in areas where traditional public schools had been failing for years, giving students and families in those neighborhoods a way to bail out of a struggling school.
This year’s law loosens restrictions on where schools of hope can operate, allowing them to set up operations within the walls of a public school — even a high-performing one — if the campus has underused or vacant facilities.
The board’s new regulations require public school districts to provide the same facilities-related services to the charter schools as they do their own campuses, including custodial work, maintenance, school safety, food service, nursing and student transportation — “without limitation.
”School districts must allow schools of hope to use “all or part of an educational facility at no cost”, including classrooms and administrative offices, the rules read.
“All common indoor and outdoor space at a facility such as cafeterias, gymnasiums, recreation areas, parking lots, storage spaces and auditoriums, without limitation, must be shared proportionately based on total full-time equivalent student enrollment,” the rules continue.
Public school advocates urged the board to vote down the proposal at Wednesday’s meeting. One such advocate, India Miller, argued that schools of hope are designed to be “parasitic” to public schools.
“To me, it would be like asking Home Depot to give Lowe’s space in their store and pay all of their infrastructure costs. It just does not make sense to me,” Miller said.
Board members, who are appointed by DeSantis, defended the new rules and dismissed concerns that the charter expansion could pull critical funding away from traditional public schools.
“Schools of hope wouldn’t be necessary if our public school system had done its job along the way,” said board Vice Chair Esther Byrd.
Associated Press writer Kimberlee Kruesi contributed reporting from Providence, Rhode Island. Payne is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.

We know from science it is never a great idea to place a parasite next to a host as it makes it easier for the parasite to attack while in this case it further blurs the lines between public and private, but that is likely part of devious DeSantis’ public school demolition plan. Collocation caused a great deal of animosity in New York City when it was implemented since charter schools often received preferential treatment as well as outside funding that made public students feel like second class citizens. What we know from the The Civil Rights era is that separate is never equal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
If the regular public schools in Florida are well-regarded by parents, the charters won’t succeed in enrolling very many students. You favor choice in aborting fetuses until the 10th centimeter of dilation – why are you 100% anti-choice regarding education when you sent your own kids to private schools? Why are you so classist, wanting to trap poor kids in schools you would never have sent your own kids to?
LikeLike
If Walmart is well-regarded by the public, Amazon won’t succeed when the government allows it to open a store-within-a-store at Walmart against its will at no cost to Amazon. [eye roll]
What Ravitch and the article didn’t mention is that the list of “struggling schools” that would qualify for disruption through this program was vastly expanded to include schools that have performed well in the state “accountability” system. They also don’t mention the campaign contributions of Ken Griffin, the billionaire hedge fund manager, who lobbied along with Success Academy for this legislation that could pave the way for the cherrypicking NYC charter chain to open shop in Florida.
https://jasongarcia.substack.com/p/lobbyists-for-a-billionaire-and-a
If charter and private schools want to compete, play by the same rules. When every minute of the school day is controlled by the state in traditional pubic schools yet charter and private schools have all this freedom to actually innovate, you’re setting up public schools to fail by design.
There was a small district in Florida whose virtual school during COVID became very popular beyond its borders. Instead of the state saying, “This is what we mean when we say that school choice forces public schools to be better.” What did they do? They put a cap on the number of out-of-county(district) students who could enroll.
https://www.politico.com/news/2021/06/24/florida-virtual-schools-495963
LikeLiked by 1 person
Becky Maganz is one twisted troll.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve never understood why people have long held Florida with regard and have high expectations for that state, when that was one of the Confederate states that fought for slavery and vehemently enforced Jim Crow segregation laws after the Civil War.
I spent a lot of time in FL in the 50s and 60s (and even attended schools there) and I can vividly recall the segregated public buses and waiting areas in bus and train stations, as well as in airports, separate bathrooms, water fountains, balcony only seating for them in theaters, restricted restaurants, separate schools etc. I also remember how black entertainers such as Sammy Davis Jr. were permitted to perform in big hotels like the Fontainbleu in Miami Beach but not allowed to stay at them (and famously when his friend Frank Sinatra was vocally very pissed off about it).
Many charter schools feel free to treat children of color (and disabled students) differently from how public schools are allowed to treat ALL kids, so I think it’s sad but should come as no surprise when that state goes all in for charters today.
LikeLike
Florida is viewed differently from the rest of the South because the southern culture, at least from Central to South Florida, has been overshadowed by the influx of northerners and immigrants from the Caribbean over the decades. However, though I won’t recommend ordering sweet tea at most restaurants here, you still get traditional southern politics.
LikeLiked by 1 person
FL, Thanks for the info! That makes sense, though all the Northerners who I’ve known that moved there, like my grandparents, other relatives and friends’ parents, really hated their politics. I guess there were also a lot of people who moved there that didn’t mind or agreed with traditional southern politics –like the malignant narcissist.
LikeLike
When DeSantis became the poster boy for keeping everything open during Covid, a lot more right wing extremists from the Midwest and North moved in. I don’t know if this is true for the rest of the state, but it is true in the panhandle where I live. There are about 5.5 million registered republicans to 4.1 million democrats now. When I moved to Florida, it was purple state.
LikeLiked by 1 person
retired teacher, I appreciate your input! Glad to learn about the pan-handle, even though the data is rather depressing.
All the northerners who I knew that moved to FL settled in the Miami/Fort Lauderdale/Boca Raton areas along the east coast, and in the Sarasota, St. Pete/Tampa areas on the west coast (where I had family and attended schools). Most were Reform Jews, who tend to be progressive Democrats, though there were not a lot of them on the west coast then. (I was recently told by someone who travels there often that there aren’t many there now either.)
LikeLike
BTW, During Jim Crow, they made some exceptions in FL for the black servants of white people. For example, sometimes we went to Miami Beach with my mom’s best friend (whose father was a wealthy hotelier) and she brought along her black nanny to take care of the kids. So when we four little white girls got on buses with the black nanny, we were all allowed to get on and sit in front with her. She could eat with us at restaurants and stay on a roll-away bed in our hotel rooms, too, but there were limits. For example, the nanny was not permitted to swim in the pools with us, even at a hotel owned by my mom’s friend’s father –due to FL law!
LikeLike