Media critic Dan Froomkin wrote the headline above and attached it to a blistering article about major media’s supine knee-bending to Trump. He does outrageous things, and mainstream media treats his power-hungry or unhinged actions as normal. Trump’s actions and pronouncements are not normal. The media should say so.
Froomkin writes:
The top story of the moment is the one story that our most influential newsrooms won’t touch: That the United State has become an authoritarian state.
At some point, the evidence becomes overwhelming — and we have reached that point. The frog in the metaphorical pot of water has boiled to death.
Armed soldiers patrol the streets of the nation’s capital, with more cities apparently to come. Immigrants who have done nobody any harm are abducted and disappeared by masked agents. The state is seizing stakes of national companies. Election integrity is under attack. Political opponents are targeted with criminal probes. Federal judges’ orders are ignored. Educational institutions are extorted into obedience. Key functions of the government are politicized and degraded. Expertise and science are devalued. Trump speaks of serving an unconstitutional third term. Media organizations are paying tribute to the ruler.
Most significantly, perhaps, there are no guardrails anymore. No one inside the executive branch will tell Trump no. No one in in the ruling party in Congress will tell him no. The right-wing majority of the Supreme Court won’t tell him no.
And our dominant media institutions won’t call him out.
Rather, they obscure reality under a haze of incremental stories, each one presented as if what is going on is fairly normal. As if it’s just politics.
Every outrage is just one more thing Trump has done, rather than the ever-mounting evidence of a corrupt dictatorship.
The coverage is a play-by-play as the burners click upward, rather than a check to see if the frog is still alive, which it is not.
The closest the New York Times newsroom will come to telling readers the truth, for instance, is to say that Trump is “promoting an aura of authoritarian nationalism,” or that certain actions “increasingly remind scholars of the way authoritarian leaders in other countries” behave.
The Washington Post will quote critics accusing Trump of “authoritarian overreach,” and protesters calling him “fascist,” but leaves even the most obvious conclusions to the readers to make themselves.
The Associated Press sometimes levels with its audience. It has published some exemplary articles recently, including “Trump moves to use the levers of presidential power to help his party in the 2026 midterms” and “Trump ran on a promise of revenge. He’s making good on it.” But the day-to-day coverage gives no indication of the breakdown of democracy.
Outside these newsrooms, the cries of “authoritarian” and “fascist” have been numerous, some dating back to 2016. But now the chorus of voices is growing louder and more mainstream.
Historian Garrett Graff called it… He wrote in his “Doomsday Scenario” newsletter:
The United States, just months before its 250th birthday as the world’s leading democracy, has tipped over the edge into authoritarianism and fascism. In the end, faster than I imagined possible, it did happen here. The precise moment when and where in recent weeks America crossed that invisible line from democracy into authoritarianism can and will be debated by future historians, but it’s clear that the line itself has been crossed.….
Everything else from here on out is just a matter of degree and wondering how bad it will get and how far it will go? Do we end up “merely” like Hungary or do we go all the way toward an “American Reich”? So far, after years of studying World War II, I fear that America’s trajectory feels more like Berlin circa 1933 than it does Budapest circa 2015.
MSNBC host Rachel Maddow called it on August 4:
We have crossed a line. We are in a place we did not want to be, but we are there. The thing we were all warning about for the last few years is not coming. It is here. We are in it…
We have a consolidating dictatorship in our country. And it sounds melodramatic to say it, I know, but just go with that for a minute, right? Think — think in melodramatic terms. Think in cinematic terms. Imagine the cartoon level caricature of what you think a dictatorship looks like.
I mean, it’s secret police, right? A massive anonymous unbadged, literally masked, totally unaccountable internal police force ….
You would expect, right, that you’d have a scapegoated minority group blamed for all things, in our case, immigrants, right?….
In a cartoon caricature of an authoritarian country, displays of military might are not just for the country’s external enemies. They’re for the country’s own people, right? Because in an authoritarian country, you turn military force inward toward the people of that country.
She had much more to say. It’s worth watching.
MSNBC’s Ali Velshi called it on Sunday, opening his show with a powerful monologue about the collapse of democracy:
Each new abuse is justified as temporary, necessary, even an emergency. Until one day it’s not temporary at all. Until one day the justifications stop altogether because once power is absolute it no longer feels the need to explain itself. At best, each assault may seem like an outlier until the day you wake up and realize the system itself has become unrecognizable. Well that’s where we are — right now. It’s not where we’re headed. It’s where we are
The tragedy of what’s unfolding and the danger of what’s ahead will be compounded if American citizens an masse – all of us – do not recognize this moment for what it is.
Here’s a transcript.
The question is when — if ever – our newsroom leaders will reach their tipping point.
For now, they will say that it’s not their job to be the opposition – that’s the job of the opposing party. And therefore, if leading Democrats aren’t calling it authoritarianism, then they certainly won’t.
But that excuse is becoming moot. Top Democrats are in fact becoming increasingly blunt – including the Democratic National Committee chair this morning, at the DNC’s summer meeting in Minneapolis. “This is not politics as usual. This is authoritarianism. It’s fascism dressed in a red tie,” Ken Martin said. He also called Trump the “dictator-in-chief.”
It is past time for our most consequential news organizations to recognize that Trump is leading an authoritarian regime.
The article continues. Open the link to finish it.

Even PBS News seems to have wimped out lately
LikeLike
Jon, I think PBS wants to prove it is impartial. And they no longer receive any federal funding.
LikeLike
The unspoken question: Will an authoritarian nation lead to more prosperity for “most” Americans… the German nation supported Hitler, enthusiastically fought for the German nation in WW2 … we’re heading down the road ..
LikeLike
Instead, might the unspoken question be: Will an authoritarian nation lead to more prosperity for “me” and not for “them”?
If so, then give “me” authoritarianism, and democracy be damned.
LikeLike
The latest job numbers don’t look like prosperity is trickling down. The number of billionaires is growing, now over 1,300.
Things are great if you are on the get side of the wealth divide.
The great singer Sophie Tucker memorably said, “I’ve been rich and I’ve been poor. Rich is definitely better.”
LikeLike
There are wonderful Sophie Tucker quotes …
LikeLike
I would say that news organizations are controlled by money. It is not the first time. This used to be the way the country was. Throughout the early history of the country, native Americans were depicted as savage threats to civilization. The age of white supremacy was ushered in by journalists who wrote of “Negro depredations.” Some folks thought they were free. They just thought so, however.
When the American civil rights push gained momentum, its “independent “ judiciary led by j Edgar Hoover sought to curtail the rights of citizens by surveillance and rumor mongering. People were murdered for registering to vote.
Until we repent of our long history of demonizing the other, we will always risk totalitarianism.
LikeLike
Roy,
What you write is the kind of heretical speech that Trump wants to ban. How dare you write the truth!
LikeLike
The owners of the major news organizations are afraid they will lose their licensing via the FCC if they speak out against the Fascist Leader and his henchmen. Everything to lose and nothing to gain in their eyes.
LikeLike
Russia RepubliQans have long relied on restricting the vote to usurp power. In the post-bellum period it was poll taxes, literacy tests and Grandfather clauses that undermined the constitutional enlargement of suffrage under the 15th amendment. Today its cumbersome ID requirements, paper ballots, FOX propaganda and gerrymandering that aids the Guardians of Pedophiles cult in their stealing of elections. These aren’t Christians folks, they’re anti-science fascists who broadcast lies, hate and intolerance to abet our enemies. MAGA’s a scam like everything Mr. Bocankles touches and we are all his unwitting victims.
LikeLike