David Wallace-Wells, a regular contributor to the New York Times, is confounded by the lack of preparation for Hurricane Helene. The weather reports warned that it would be a deadly storm, yet many people thought they could ride it out, and they paid with their lives. Extreme weather events are becoming more frequent, and the public is not adequately prepared. Have they been lulled by the politicians who claim that climate change is a hoax? Climate change denial claims lives.
Wallace-Wells writes:
Last week, warning about the imminent arrival of Hurricane Helene, the National Weather Service in Tallahassee, Fla., used the word “unsurvivable.”
And yet the storm seemed to take much of the country by surprise. You might have thought, not that long ago, that the arrival of extreme weather could wake us up, belatedly, from climate complacency. But the dull drumbeat of disaster seems almost to be putting us to sleep instead. Even the imminent arrival of a cataclysm like Helene, a Category 4 storm that spanned more than 400 miles across the Gulf Coast and threatened communities as far north as Appalachia, was not enough to generate all that much attention ahead of time, when more might have been done to limit the devastation. The storm has so far produced at least 100 deaths and perhaps $160 billion in damages (according to early estimates).
In Florida’s Big Bend region, Helene was the third hurricane to make landfall in barely a year, flattening beach towns and barrier islands and sending water into the attics of homes as far away as Tampa Bay. In several states to the north, locals from dozens of communities hundreds of miles from one another were calling the storm “our Katrina,” some of them watching whole homes or shiny caskets carried downstream, others clinging to tree branches for hours on end waiting for the floodwaters to recede or help to arrive. In Tennessee, there was no emergency declared before hospital patients were evacuated from a rooftop by helicopter, and as of Saturday, across western North Carolina, hundreds of vulnerable power substations were still down, along with the infrastructure and power lines meant to actually deliver electricity and the vast majority of the world’s supply of high purity quartz, a necessary input for the production of semiconductors. Dozens of coal ash ponds holding billions of tons of toxic coal ash have likely been flooded, as well. Cars and trucks “were tossed around like toys.”
Forty trillion gallons of rain fell in total, the equivalent of one-third of the total volume of Lake Erie, enough to cover the entire state of Massachusetts in 23 feet of water. The intense rainfall was made, over the last week, perhaps 50 percent more intense over parts of Georgia and the Carolinas by global warming. (Other rapid assessments suggested it was perhaps only 20 percent more intense.) Entire towns appear to have been turned into flotsam or pulverized into splinters, and few of those living in the hardest-hit areas even carried flood insurance. In Asheville, N.C., which sits hundreds of miles from the coastline and thousands of feet above sea level and is now the drowned ground zero of the storm, the National Flood Insurance Program coverage rate was under 1 percent. Across the country, as many as six million more homes are at severe risk of flooding than are even included on the federal government’s flood risk maps, Michael Thomas pointed out in the aftermath of the storm. Across Asheville’s Buncombe County, 17 times as many homes had been judged at risk in a 100-year flood event as carried insurance against that risk; Helene was called a “thousand-year” flood for certain parts of the Southeast, though those terms grow less meaningful almost by the day. Another ostensible thousand-year storm had hit the coastal Carolinas just one week before. “Sometimes ‘worst case’ scenarios really do come to pass,” the climate scientist Daniel Swain wrote over the weekend on Sunday, “and I think we often lack the collective imagination to fully envision what that looks like.”
Former President Trump was the first politician to arrive, and he indulged his impulse to politicize the disaster. He asserted, falsely, that President Biden refused to take calls from Georgia Governor Brian Kemp, though Kemp said that he had talked to Biden, who sent the help he asked for. Trump also claimed that Biden wasn’t sending help to states with Republican leaders (every state but North Carolina), but that wasn’t true either.
Trump never learned that natural disasters are times when people help people, regardless of party.

When Trump opens his mouth, he LIES!
LikeLike
After reading the whole article, it seems to lack a point. What exactly should have been done is quite unclear.
Personally, I’d think maybe we’d finally get serious about the things causing climate change, like war and devotion to fossil fuels, but since those are major constituencies of the party currently in power, no more is going to be done to prevent climate change than Republicans do to prevent gun violence (and since it apparently always needs to be said, no, I’m not saying Republicans would be any better on climate change – that’s why we need to reject **both** parties).
LikeLike
Yes, it is absolutely true that there is not one iota of difference between the two parties when it comes to climate change, and AOC and Bernie are lying to all of us, but this poster who told us Putin massively bombed Ukraine and destroyed entire families to “fight Nazis” should be trusted as she always tells the truth.
Our country has made good progressive changes in the last century but not one of them has been “perfect” from the start. The people who said it didn’t matter if they empowered the right wing Supreme Court in 2016 are now whining that the Dems haven’t done enough to overcome all the obstacles put in their way.
Trust AOC and Bernie. Not the folks who lie about Putin.
They understand the difference between democracy and authoritarianism and the difference between Dems and Republicans when it comes to climate change. They can criticize the Dems and they do, but they don’t resort to LIES. Telling the truth used to matter in this country. It’s sad to see folks here embrace the JD Vance/Trump/Putin belief that lying is fine as long as you hate the Dems.
LikeLike
So not only can you not address anything I said, you have to distort it. Again. So typical and so tiring.
LikeLike
Name one credible person who wants to end gun violence who believes the Republicans have done anything at all.
I can name multiple environmental advocates who understand that the Democrats are working to address this issue, even if slowly and imperfectly and having to do so in a political climate that makes it very difficult. You no longer even trust AOC not to “lie” to you.
Your false equivalency is typical.
Most people who care about the future of this country are scared for trans people, for immigrants who aren’t white, are scared for those who believe in dissent. While others here defend Putin and keep promoting the insane falsehood that having total Republican rule would be no more worse (for them, of course) than having total Democratic rule.
I don’t know if you actually care whether all the climate activists are silenced by a repressive Republican government or you are as naive as the supposedly “good” Germans who were sure that the hate preached by the Nazis would never affect their lives.
There is probably a reason why you think that Republican efforts to “drill baby drill” and end those pesky environmental regulations aren’t any worse than Democrats, but that’s not the view of the people who actually care about the environment and have devoted their time and life to it.
There is nothing wrong with criticizing the Dems for not being good enough, but to lie and equate that with the Republican positive on gun control is just as problematic as when you posted here defending Putin and telling us it was an absolute fact that Putin invaded Ukraine to fight Nazis. You have not yet admitted you lied about that, just like your false equivalency is a lie that climate change advocates actually believe.
Please cite the credible people with a history of fighting for environmental issues who say it doesn’t matter whether Trump or Harris wins the election. They can be critical of the Dems without pushing a totally false narrative that Trump will be no worse for the environment than the Dems. I will be waiting….
LikeLike
You cannot pretend that Democrats are doing beans about the environment when they constantly raise the military budget, rattle WWIII sabers at Russia, China, Iran, and every other country that refuses to bend the knee to U. S hegemony. When they issue more drilling permits in more protected lands and brag about fracking. When they refuse to do a thing to remediate the disasters in Flint, Jackson, East Palestine, Lahaina and now Atlanta. When they think lithium-based electric vehicles are somehow better than gas-based instead of doing a thing to improve public transportation. When they constantly act like their hands are tied against Republicans while they move heaven and earth to satisfy their corporate and billionaire donors. Bernie and AOC support all of this – they are frauds. Democrats, including and especially the so-called progressives, exist to block progress.
And I didn’t say Republicans are better. I explicitly said they’re not. Both parties are hell bent on profit over planet, which again, if you care one whit about your public school kids (or any kids) means they all needs to go. Fifty years I’ve watched this country get worse regardless of who was in office. What’s the definition of insanity again? We don’t have another 50 years to keep doing the same thing. Radical change is coming. The only question is if we will survive it (as a country or as a planet). With either Rs or Ds the answer is a guaranteed no. With leftist leadership, the answer is at least maybe.
LikeLike
Your concern for Russia, Iran, and China is touching. Why did you leave out North Korea? We have been very mean to them!
How would you like to be LGBT in Russia or Iran? I never heard you protest Iran’s brutal treatment of women. If you lived in Iran, would you cover your head? Would you risk imprisonment by taking it off? Did you feel bad when North Korea sent home young Otto Warbier as a tortured and brutalized animal who died soon after returning? He wantonly stole a poster in the hotel hallway; he deserved it, right?
And your love of Putin and Russia is touching. Good thing you don’t have to live there.
LikeLike
The U.S. has invaded, regime changed, drone bombed, couped and outright destroyed dozens of countries, slaughtered millions of civilians, tortured people, abetted genocide and has nearly the highest domestic incarceration and homeless rates, yet you still think that Russia, China, Iran and North Korea are the enemies. Typical American ignorance and hubris.
LikeLike
I just wanted to say that I appreciate these exchanges of views.
LikeLike
My grandmother used to say, “You catch more flies with honey.” We should all try to live up to that. I wonder how different things would be if we offered these “enemies” around the world hope and aid. Thinking of this tonight as a second hurricane bears down upon us, even as homes have the debris of the occupants’ lives piled upon their lawns.
LikeLike
Some context: U.S. CO2 emissions have been falling since the mid-2000s, in large part because of fracking, which has sped the adoption of natural gas in place of coal as an electricity source. Emissions aren’t falling fast enough, but that’s partly because emissions have been increasing in countries like China and India.
LikeLike
Using fracking to reduce CO2 emissions is akin to using beheading to reduce brain tumors. https://environmentamerica.org/articles/fracking-is-an-environmental-disaster/
Further, in order to say that the U.S. has reduced emissions, you have to completely overlook the U.S. military which is the single biggest emitter of greenhouse gases (not to mention the single biggest polluter otherwise).
LikeLike
Is there a source for the assertion that U.S. carbon emissions have not decreased when the U.S. military is included?
LikeLike
Sorry, technical difficulties – posted too soon. I know that the U.S. military is the single biggest emitter of greenhouse gases (https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2022/10/pentagon-climate-change-neta-crawford-book/) and that military activity has greatly increased since 2022, so I would strongly doubt that U.S. emissions have decreased if the military is included.
LikeLike
Thanks, I’ll see if I can find out the answer
LikeLike
“I’m not saying Republicans would be any better on climate change – that’s why we need to reject both parties).”
I am not saying Re[publicans would be any better on climate change – I, and the people who actually care about climate change – say that Republicans would be WORSE. A lot worse. And the authoritarian nature of their goals means that it will be easy to silence dissent.
Rejecting both parties signals someone using climate change as a talking point – they care about climate change as much as they care about democracy.
LikeLike
Overall, Democratic leadership is far more fair and reasoned than the leadership of GOP extremists. Even when states that vilify the federal government have a catastrophic weather event, Democratic leadership helps all the people of this country. GOP governors have no problem immediately declaring a state state of emergency in a weather crisis so they may receive socialized assistance from FEMA. Right wing extremists only support socialized services when it benefits them directly. Among themselves they bash and lie about Democratic leadership.
I live about an hour and a half west of Tallahassee, but I was on the better side of the storm. We were very fortunate. All we had were winds of about 50 mph.
LikeLike
Extremist leaders also slap their names all over federal benefits that are delivered to states. In today’s paper it reads “DeSantis delivers broadband to rural Florida communities.” However, broadband expansion is the result of the federal government. https://broadbandusa.ntia.doc.gov/resources/federal/federal-funding
LikeLike
Those who didn’t leave, get their news from FOX and QAnon.
There is another way to look at this. The more MAGA and/or QAnon followers that become collateral damage caused by climate change, the fewer votes Vile Vance and Trashy Traitor Trump get.
LikeLike
My g-d, your arrogance is astounding.
LikeLike
Tennessee came late to its declaration as an emergency area because it’s extremist Governor did not, as other states did, request such a designation. He. Hose instead to suggest a day of “prayer and fasting”, only asking for the emergency designation a day later.
Tennessee experienced the flood as run-off from the deep valleys of the Toe and Piegon rivers, which drain water eastward on this side of the eastern continental divide. Also the Doe, Wautauga, and New Rivers carried catastrophic flooding to the western slope of the highest ridge of the Appalachian Mountains, which form the North Carolina/Tennessee border.
LikeLike
A day of “prayer and fasting”….OMG! Of course there’s gonna be some “fasting”, especially if your house flooded and your refrigerator lost all it’s contents and your pantry contents floated down the street. I’m sorry, but that is just a hilarious comment coming from a political leader.
LikeLike
bitterly hilarious, I should say. The irony of the matter is that East Tennessee is solidly Republican, and has made the state politics swing that way since the Civil War. Any place else, his behavior would ruin his party’s chances in the next election cycle. Not in East Tennessee.
LikeLike
I grew up in a home where faith was important, but that faith was paired with a belief in practicality, and listening to experts in science and medicine. When I or onr of my siblings was sick, we didn’t fast and pray. Mom called the doctor.
It’s frustrating that the voters of Tennessee voted for a man who is willfully ignorant.
LikeLike
Trump can only think about himself and how he can benefit and politicize the situation to his best advantage using, of course, his many lies. Trump is totally disgusting at all levels. He’s the most reprehensible person ever…and works for Putin.
He care NOT a wit for anyone except himself. He surrounds himself with other sycophants who are like him and thus they enable his sick and wicked ways.
LikeLike
Trump also said that there was no money for hurricane relief because Harris and Biden had spent it all on migrants. He just lies. Makes shit up. And the press dutifully reports it.
LikeLike
Friends have been working around the clock doing disaster relief and cleanup. Many homes and businesses destroyed here. Having to rip our dry wall in the homes that survived. And we have another storm, Milton, right behind it. It’s bad.
LikeLike
I hope it stays under a category 4, and it has less rain than Helene.
LikeLike
It will, according to projections. We in St. Pete are supposed to get 8-12 inches of rain. So, with high tide, there will be flooding.
LikeLike
Ft Myers TV showing the potential for Milton to make landfall north of Tampa as a cat 3 on Wednesday. Best to all in its path
LikeLike
it45 complaining about a Biden non-response to Helene? (Lying again much?) Here’s a little memory jogger: Maria, Puerto Rico, ca. 2017:
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/trump-defends-thrown-paper-towels-hurricane-survivors-puerto-rico-n808861
(lf this link doesn’t work, put “T Throwing Paper Towels/Puerto Rico 2017” in your search engine.)
Degrading, insulting & of no help.
LikeLike
REPEATED HURRICANES and their growing intensity are causing people to permanently leave Florida and Gulf Coast states because insurance companies know that this is only going to get more and more worse year after year, and so the companies are refusing to sell house insurance.
And yet, as the Naples, Florida, newspaper NAPLES TIMES reports, the Republican Party’s Project 2025 plan for the first year of Trump’s next presidency (if he’s elected) calls for ENDING THE FREE FEDERAL WEATHER AGENCY that tracks hurricanes to give people a chance to prepare.
On Page 674 of their Project 2025 plan, the Republicans complain that free news and tracking information from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) about approaching hurricanes causes “alarm” and is “harmful” to business. The Republicans prefer that people not know where a hurricane is headed because that’s bad for business in those areas. What’s good for We the People isn’t important.
FEMA is underfunded to provide for victims of disasters because ONLY the House of Representatives can approve the money — but the House is controlled by Republicans who don’t “believe” in the reality of climate change, so they won’t fully fund FEMA…and the result of that Republican belief is that ordinary Americans suffer.
And, while Dolly Parton went to the disaster areas and donated $1,000,000 in aid, not a single one of the megachurch (MAGAchurch) “pastors” has done anything.
Oh, yes — in their Project 2025 plan, the Republicans want people to PAY for hurricane information that would be sold at a profit by private businesses.
https://www.naplesnews.com/story/news/politics/elections/2024/07/31/project-2025-nws-weather-service-forecasts-hurricance-center/74598814007/?fbclid=IwY2xjawFoRNtleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHasLGqDthFdKnoizrXu0jB2X30jb9ece4RKmI6jjxR4QLpuNnyfSVfrzgg_aem_zhYT1ntPcVwly1n4oSh9fQ
LikeLike