Jess Piper lives in rural Missouri. She is a fearless progressive and a fighter. She has repeatedly called on the Democratic Party to contest every seat, even in rural areas, where voters usually have no choice. She will be a featured speaker at the next convening of the Network for Public Education in April 2025 in Columbus, Ohio.
“You don’t like it? Move.”
This sort of advice is often given to me in online spaces when I say something truthful about Missouri that irritates folks on the right. When I talk about abortion bans, I should move to California. When I talk about funding schools, I should move to New York. When I speak out against harmful policies, I’m just an out of place, out of touch, liberal.
I’ve been told to move to California or New York many times, and while I have visited both states, and appreciate the CA beaches and the NY atmosphere, I wouldn’t move to either state for two very important reasons: 1) This is where my children and grandchildren live. 2) This is my state too.
Here’s something that may interest you; I hear the same rhetoric, although presented in a much more caring way, from progressives in states with better representation. My blue state friends have given me the “just move” advice on several occasions. They fear that I am in danger or that specific policies will hurt my family. They are justified in thinking I should move, but what they don’t realize is that moving will eventually harm them. If all of the like-minded congregate in progressive states, we will all eventually be overwhelmed by the regressive states.
If we don’t contest and protest in every GOP-dominated state, the bad policies will leach into all the states.
I will preface this essay by saying that I understand that not all folks have the privilege I have to stay and fight. Those with trans children, those impacted by our state healthcare failings and childcare issues, those dealing with things I can’t even begin to understand have every reason to flee states like Missouri. I make absolutely no judgment on those who choose to leave. I am in solidarity with them.
If you’ve done the reading, you know that our country is slowly being swallowed up by right-wing billionaire rhetoric and policies. You likely know the long-game for this takeover was hashed out decades ago, and the way the extremists were able to do this was by taking over state legislatures and positions like the Secretary of State and the Attorney General. They have bankrolled the campaigns of State Reps and Senators, and even dip their toes into school board races.
In my state, the evolution is complete. Missouri went from a bellwether state to a radical state bent on stripping the rights of over 1/2 of the population and passing policies meant only for the wealthy. But, my leaving this state would be detrimental to other states and here’s how: GOP-dominated states create the policies that would overcome the country if left unchecked and uncontested.
None of us is safe so long as there are folks living in states that are unsafe. They will roll over us first, and you next.
The billionaires are using my state AG and other regressive state AGs to file suit to dismantle public schools. They sue to ban abortion and the medicine for self-managed abortions. They sue to stop college loan forgiveness. They sue to overturn civil rights and anti-discrimination policies. My former AG, Eric Schmitt, even sued Missouri public schools to make them stop masking procedures during a global pandemic. The worst part? He was then elected as our Senator.
If we can’t stop these extremists in our states, they often go on to win higher office and harm the entire country.
The billionaires are also using GOP-dominated states to appoint Secretaries of States who will throw voting rights into the toilet. These SOSs have the ability to impact the nation and create the chaos we saw in the 2020 Presidential election with some states allowing fake electors that would have given the office to Trump.
And there’s this: On January 2, 2021, during an hour-long conference call, then-President Trump pressured Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to change the state’s election results from the 2020 presidential election. The country is lucky the GA Republican Secretary of State did not fold, but we may not always be so lucky.
Progressives fighting back in regressive states are fighting for all of us. They represent the tipping point for the nation. They contest seats, they protest human rights violations, and they show up to keep the red from leaching into the blue.
The real fight for democracy is at the state level. Activists in GOP-dominated states can’t just move…there is nowhere to go.
If we can’t stop the slow churn toward fascism in our states, there is little hope we can stop it nationwide. So, we stay. We stand up and talk back. We link arms and fight the local corrupt policies to stop national corrupt policies.
Just move? No. I can’t. I won’t.
This is my state too.
~Jess
While reading this, I thought about Beto O’Rourke. He is a man of vision and liberal ideals, but he cannot get too far in Texas politics because he is a democrat. In many other states he would be a governor or senator by now. I admire his tenacity and loyalty to Texas and democracy, but I wish Texas would appreciate what he has to offer the state and give him the chance to show them something other than cruel, authoritarian leadership.
She is exactly right. We must involve ourselves in resisting the March to the Right that threatens our basic liberty. Go Piper!
If only this country had direct popular voting for the presidential election instead of the electoral college.
Amen to that, it should have happened eons ago. The Electoral College is a relic that needs to go. Any chance of it ever being dropped in the lifetime of a 2024 embryo………nah, it’s not even being discussed. The GOP would block such an effort and no Democrats are even talking about getting rid of it.
The League of Women Voters is nonpartisan, but supports direct popular vote.
This is from the Saint Louis LWV. website:
Direct election of the President could be accomplished a couple of ways:
@ Frances– Yup. As of this month, the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact has 17 states + DC onboard, representing 209 [77%] of the 270 electoral votes needed to accomplish this.
I would settle for any tweaking of the system that makes my vote worth something. For a majority of elections in which I have voted, my vote has been meaningless. A system that does not allow moderate voters—I have been accused of being so moderate it is sickening— a voice of some kind degenerates into tyranny.
Presidential elections are generally characterized by pictures of candidates visiting other states. Organization of the Democratic Party in red Tennessee is pretty much restricted to urban centers. If my vote for president meant something, grassroots party organization would spring up.
Well, MAGA . . . follow Trump so that you can take up his unstated slogan for yourself:
If you cannot win fairly, cheat. CBK