The incredible Mike Miles started the year boasting that he had no teaching vacancies. Nonetheless, teachers who dislike Miles’ lockstep “New Education System” are quitting. In one high-perfuming school, students in advanced physics lost their teacher and are now teaching other students.
Sam Gonzalez Kelly wrote in The Houston Chronicle:
Juniors and seniors at Houston ISD’s DeBakey High School for Health Professions walked into their AP Physics classes at the beginning of the school year and asked one question: “Where’s our teacher?”
About 150 students at the top-ranked high school signed up for the advanced science courses, many with the hope of earning college credit, but found themselves without a qualified teacher. Given the complex nature of the material, substitute teachers brought in were unable to do much more than supervise the classroom.
The teens spent the first seven weeks of the year trying to teach themselves sophisticated concepts, including electric circuitry and thermodynamics. In some cases, seniors in AP Physics II were pulled out of classes to teach juniors in AP Physics I. Students were told by administration that their hands were tied — a hiring freeze at Houston ISD had left them unable to fill the vacancy, they were told, which was created when a teacher went on leave to start the year.
“It’s just aggravating,” said senior Zain Kundi. “It’s money on the line, because these classes in college are thousands of dollars and if you get it out of the way now, you can save quite a bit of money. And if our grades start falling, colleges will see that early in the admissions process and be like ‘what the heck…’ Especially now with college applications, we have so much on our plates already.”
Kundi says the AP Physics position was left vacant because the school’s administration tried to saddle a standard physics teacher with the role just before the start of the school year, causing the teacher to use accumulated leave days in protest. The senior made it clear he does not blame the teacher nor HISD for the vacancy, arguing that DeBakey’s administration had a whole summer to find someone for the role. Now, student GPAs, AP scores and college prospects may be affected as a result, he says.
DeBakey Principal Jesus Herrera did not respond to multiple requests for comment. A district spokesman said last week that schools “have been asked to limit outside hiring” until staffing audits are complete in the 85 schools in or aligned with Miles’ New Education System, where enrollment was less than forecast to start the year.
“This will give existing HISD teachers whose positions are eliminated in NES and NES-A campuses the first opportunity to apply for other positions available in non-NES schools. Exceptions can and have been made for specialized instructors like AP teachers,” the district said in a statement.
Miles said Thursday evening that the audit was near completion and that the pause would be lifted quickly.
“We had some excess teachers, and we’re moving some teachers around, and that should be completed soon,” Miles said last week. Teachers who move from an NES or NES-A campus will keep their $10,000 stipends, but in the case of the former, will not retain the higher salaries they received for teaching in an NES school, he said.
Meanwhile, DeBakey students presented a petition with dozens of signatures to administrators at a PTO meeting in late September, demanding answers and a solution to the problem.
“Our current management of these courses is not working to benefit our students or our teachers, and it is time for answers,” the petition reads, noting that having senior students teach advanced physics to juniors is “extra work for the seniors and suboptimal instruction for the juniors…”
The situation is not just affecting DeBakey. Though Miles said he started the year with zero teaching vacancies, uncommon in a district like HISD, teachers and administrators at other schools say that they had to get creative to fulfill responsibilities of teachers who have left the district since the school year started.
One geography teacher at Sharpstown High School said he had to take over U.S. history classes after its teacher left over a month into the school year, and that the school has had to reshuffle classes and teachers to avoid hiring as more and more teachers leave. An administrator at one non-NES elementary school said that they were unable to hire a long-term substitute, as they normally would have in years past, after one teacher resigned a few weeks into the year because they were told by district officials that there was a hiring freeze for any positions beside special education and bilingual teachers…
At DeBakey, the PTO has attempted to address the issue on its own by pooling its money to pay stipends to two college professors and two former AP Physics teachers for virtual lessons and tutoring sessions. But not every school in HISD has the resources for such a response, which Ake acknowledged is a “Band-Aid solution until the school and the district can lift the freeze.”

Good morning Diane and everyone,
Now that’s teamwork, determination, dedication and taking responsibility for your education!! 🙂
LikeLike
Mamie, I have to disagree with you. There’s a whole lot wrong here.
First, these juniors and seniors can never regain what’s been lost in terms of their instruction. There’s no do-over.
Second, every student deserves a certified professional to teach every class.
Third, destroying the careers of those trained teachers and disrupting their school systems so as to destroy them is the goal of people like Miles – and he’s having great success.
Are the kids responding in a phenomal way – most certainly! But there’s no need for them to do so. Texas has a $33 billion budget surplus that Abbott is sitting on, refusing to spend because he wants vouchers. His goals and Miles’ are in alignment.
LikeLike
Of course.
LikeLike
However, why wait for others to do for you when you can do for yourself? These kids could have waited and whined about the world but they actually DID something to help themselves.
LikeLike
There’s no reason a “standard” physics teacher shouldn’t be able to teach AP Physics. Either there’s more to the story or those students should be blaming that teacher.
LikeLike
Depends. Certifications for teaching (at least in Michigan) can be very general or specific. One can get a general science certification which means they can be asked to teach any science course but the teacher may not have a specialization.
I have taught multiple AP courses in my career and I can flat out tell you that there’s a huge difference between a generalist and a specialist in teaching classes that demand as much as AP. I’m not suited to teach AP Econ but I’m very well-positioned to teach AP Comparative Government.
Without knowing the background and expertise of the teacher, it’s errant to make a judgment.
LikeLike
Government and Econ are two different subjects/knowledge areas. Physics is not. A teacher capable of teaching physics should have the knowledge to teach AP physics or I question whetherthey should be teaching physics at all.. If some kind of certification is needed, get it.
LikeLike
And btw, Dienne, in most states (all of them?), a person with a degree in Social Science education can teach any of the Social Sciences subjects, including American and World History, Government or Civics, Economics, Sociology, Geography, and Political Science. In some states, such a person can even teach Psychology!!!
Knowledge gap?
This is almost as bad as asking Donald Trump to teach Quantum Electrodynamics or Fluid Dynamics. This is how backward we still are in education in America.
LikeLike
AP is a different animal though. AP requires a depth of knowledge that may not be present. I’m certified in history but I would never want to teach AP US History. If students had me for that class, I would be tremendously subpar.
Additionally, if that teacher has no experience or training in AP, that’s complicated.
When I first got hired, I was asked to teach AP European History (and two other courses) one week before the school year began. By week four, I was drowning. I told my students that I couldn’t keep up. Fortunately, my students did what the students in the article are doing. They simply took me along while I figured it out.
LikeLike
Again, as gtaperuo said, in most states, in most states a person with a degree in Science Education can teach any of the high-school science courses, and such a degree will definitely NOT prepare a person to teach AP Physics or Chemistry. Ofc, it SHOULD BE the case that a person who teaches high-school physics or biology or chemistry or whatever should be an expert in that area, but it’s not. And it won’t be until we pay teachers a lot more and require a lot more specialized training of them if they are to teach in these areas.
I’ve seen a LOT of high-school computer teachers who were basically clueless, who wouldn’t know HTML from the Gates of Hell.
LikeLike
Education should put students first, not politics. Abbott’s takeover of Houston is mostly politically motivated. Placing the schools in the hands of a military dictator is a mistake. In demand teachers with the ability to work elsewhere will do so. Math, science, special education and bilingual teachers are difficult to replace. In a threatening, authoritarian climate, they can leave and find less oppressive positions where they can enjoy academic freedom.
LikeLike
Miles is not improving the Houston schools. He is undermining them.
LikeLike
Miles is in pursuit of higher test scores. The NES is just a system of intensified test prep without being direct test prep. This is done to give the impression of learning. Really, it’s just designed to score well on tests.
This was the general strategy of schools that struggled with test scores. This has been a common charter school approach as well.
This style of prescriptive education is very low level. Besides, at this point, I think we all realize that test scores aren’t particularly good measures of student ability or achievement. Especially as students get older and come to the realization that the standardized test scores mean nothing for them. The incentive for good scores is only for the schools and districts. Not the students.
LikeLike
Let’s repeat that gem, and I’ll
put it in all caps and bold: THE INCENTIVE FOR GOOD SCORES IS ONLY FOR THE SCHOOLS AND DISTRICTS. NOT THE STUDENTS.
LikeLike
The parents of the AP calculus should should meet with Miles and tell him to find a qualified teacher ASAP. If he is unable to do so, they should sue the state for its failure to provide an equivalent education to that which the school district would have been able to offer. There has to be some parent lawyer that will fight back against this politically motivated takeover whose main goal is disruption. Students’ education should not suffer the consequences of Abbott’s war on the Houston schools.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are correct, retired teacher. A lawsuit would certainly help Miles focus.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I recall the departure of a calculus teacher in my high school experience. The guy who came in was incompetent, so we were left to try it on our own. Several of the other students were brilliant and willing to help the teacher try to understand the material, which he did not know, but it did no good. The class was pretty much a bust.
A friend told me her old high school has three open math positions. Open positions exist in almost every school in our county. Why will voters not hold political leaders responsible for their failure?
LikeLike