The Republican debates, starting tonight, will attack President Biden relentlessly. Thom Hartmann has compiled a list of Biden’s accomplishments to counter the lies and exaggerations of Republican contenders for the nomination.
He writes:
The first Republican debate of the 2024 election cycle is tonight, and while all the drama seems focused on whether or not anybody beyond Chris Christie will take a serious swing at Trump, odds are most of the evening’s time will be devoted to trashing President Joe Biden.
So, to help keep you sane through all the lies and BS — and the fog you may be in by the end of the debate if your drinking game involved the word “woke” — here’s a quick summary* of the things that Biden has accomplished (with a little help from Democrats in Congress) in his first two-and-a-half years in office.
First of all, Joe Biden has restored trust, confidence, and faith in the honesty, credibility, and integrity of America. He doesn’t suck up to dictators like Trump did, and doesn’t lie to Americans or our allies. He’s restored independence to the Department of Justice and funding and support to regulatory agencies like the EPA.
Over united Republican opposition, the Biden administration has succeeded in lowering most Americans’ cost of living. The Inflation Reduction Act has reduced inflation to a full point lower than it was when Reagan was running his “Morning in America” ads in 1984 (unemployment is several points lower, too!).
Because of that law, for the first time, Medicare is able to negotiate the price of certain high-cost drugs: a month’s supply of insulin for seniors is capped at $35, Medicare beneficiaries pay $0 out of pocket for recommended adult vaccines, and seniors’ out of pocket expenses at the pharmacy will be capped at $2,000 a year.
America has just completed the strongest two years of job growth in the history of our country. Nearly 11 million jobs have been created since President Biden took office — including 750,000 manufacturing jobs. The unemployment rate is at a 50-year low, and a record number of small businesses have started since Biden took office. Black Americans and Hispanic Americans have near record low unemployment rates and people with disabilities are experiencing record low unemployment.
We’re experiencing a boom in manufacturing and the construction of manufacturing facilities like we haven’t seen since before the Reagan Revolution began offshoring American factories and jobs. Companies have invested more than $300 billion in good jobs, many of them unionized, as America’s technical capabilities sharpen along with this job growth.
Biden has expanded services available to our veterans (after Trump cut them), including 31 new clinical sites and a comprehensive program to help the estimated 5 million veterans who, like President Biden’s son Beau, have been exposed to toxic chemicals as a result of their service to our country.
President Biden brought together Democrats and Republicans to pass the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, the first major piece of gun safety legislation in three decades. The law will save lives by:
— requiring young people ages 18 to 21 to undergo enhanced background checks;
—narrowing the “boyfriend loophole” to keep guns out of the hands of convicted dating partners;
— funding crisis interventions, including extreme risk protection orders (“red flag”) laws;
— making significant investments to address the mental health crisis in America, including in our schools;
— clarifying who needs to register as a federally licensed gun dealer and run background checks before selling a single weapon;
— and making gun trafficking and straw purchases distinct federal crimes.
Over ten years ago, President Biden announced his support for marriage equality, becoming the highest-ranking U.S. government official to do so. Building on his longstanding support and generations of civil rights advocacy, President Biden signed historic bipartisan legislation protecting marriage for same-sex and interracial couples.
And the President took historic steps to advance full equality for LGBTQI+ Americans, including reversing the discriminatory ban on transgender servicemembers in the military, strengthening non-discrimination protections in health care, housing, education, and employment, and ensuring that transgender Americans can access government support and services.
Biden has put a more diverse group of people on the federal judiciary than any president in history. Sixty-six percent of his nominees have been women and 65 percent were people of color, including the Supreme Court’s first Black woman justice, Ketanji Brown Jackson.
After Putin declared war on democracy and launched a terrorist invasion of Ukraine, targeting civilians and using rape as a weapon of war, President Biden has brought the world together to stand up to a fascist autocracy and defend Europe’s largest democracy.
Following Trump’s humiliating groveling before Putin and attacks on NATO, the European Union, and our democratic allies around the world, President Biden has rebuilt the American alliances that have, in some cases, stood for over two centuries. Sweden and Finland have joined NATO, and China appears to be re-thinking their belligerent attitude toward Taiwan after last week’s meeting and agreements between the leaders of the US, South Korea, and Japan.
After Trump unilaterally closed all but one of our air bases in Afghanistan to maliciously make his successor’s job more difficult, the Biden administration ended the war in Afghanistan that George W. Bush and Dick Cheney had lied us into. He’s also decapitated the leadership of ISIS and El Qaeda.
Ever since six Republicans on the Supreme Court gutted American women’s right to abortion (and multiple Republicans are now trying to ban birth control), President Biden has stood up for women’s healthcare rights. He’s signed several Executive Orders to protect access to reproductive healthcare (including for our military). When 19 Republican state attorneys general demanded the healthcare records of women who’ve sought abortions in more than thirty states, Biden signed an Executive Order strengthening patient privacy.
The Biden administration rolled out a plan to cut as much as $20,000 from the debt carried by America’s student borrowers (student debt of these proportions, the direct result of the Reagan Revolution, does not exist in any other nation on Earth). When a Republican lawsuit before the Supreme Court blocked his efforts, he announced a plan to provide millions of borrowers with more affordable monthly student loan payments through changes to income-driven repayment plans.
While Red states still put people in prison for years for possessing a single marijuana cigarette, President Biden pardoned allAmericans who’ve ever been convicted of a federal pot offense. He’s more recently initiated a multi-agency review of the drug’s Schedule 1 status, with an eye to decriminalizing it nationwide.
After centuries of police violence against Black people and other minorities, Biden signed a landmark executive order on safe, effective, and accountable policing that mandated federal reforms such as banning chokeholds, restricting no-knock entries, creating a national police accountability database, and restricting the transfer of military equipment to local police departments.
Through over a hundred executive actions and the Inflation Reduction Act, President Biden has finally put America on course to cut our emissions in half by 2030 and to get to net-zero by 2050. He also protected more lands and waters in his first year than any President since John F. Kennedy.
While Republicans continue to strip people off Red state Medicaid rolls in their pursuit of cruelty, Biden expanded the Affordable Care Act. Millions can now find healthcare for $10 a month or less, and most Americans will see an Obamacare saving of an average of $800 a year.
Since he took office, there has been a combined 50 percent increase in enrollment in states that use HealthCare.gov and the nation’s uninsured rate is historically low at 8 percent. Over 16 million Americans signed up for quality, affordable health coverage, the highest number ever produced in an Obamacare open enrollment period.
Perhaps the most important accomplishment of President Biden has been re-aligning the Democratic Party with its progressive base. Biden worked hand-in-hand with Senate Budget Committee Chair Bernie Sanders to put forward a sweeping progressive agenda involving an investment of over $5 trillion in America and American working people.
Although united opposition from Republicans and a handful of sellout Democrats (including Manchin, Sinema, and the “corporate problem solvers”) forced him to cut the program back, it is still revolutionary given the past 40 years of bipartisan embrace of neoliberalism.
Reversing the anti-organized-labor trend started by Reagan that continued through the Bush, Clinton, Bush, Obama, and Trump administrations, President Biden has aggressively promoted unions and unionization as essential to the future of working people in America.
President Biden also worked with and helped Nancy Pelosi pass through the House the For The People Act, which would have rolled back much of Citizens United and ended most Republican voter suppression by asserting Americans’ absolute right to vote. Had he not been betrayed by Manchin and Sinema, it would now be law.
The Congressional Progressive Caucus (founded by Bernie) has gone from the handful of members (fewer than 10) it was when I did fundraisers for them more than a decade ago to being one of the strongest and largest in Congress (104 members right now). While this isn’t Biden’s doing and much credit goes to its members, Biden is the first Democratic president since LBJ to fully embrace progressives in Congress and fast-track their legislation.
Biden has also:
— Set new policies to reduce super pollutants like HFCs and methane to protect communities and reduce emissions fueling climate change
— Advanced cutting-edge research on cancer and other diseases through the ARPA-H initiative
— Signed legislation to put more cops on the beat and invest in community policing
— Signed the Electoral Count Act, which takes long overdue steps to protect the integrity of our elections
— Lowered the cost of hearing aids by making them available over the counter
— Created more manufacturing jobs in 2022 than in any single year in nearly 30 years
— Signed an Executive Order to encourage competition across industries
— Took action to lower energy costs for families
— Lowered seniors’ health care expenses, including by capping out of pocket expenses on prescription drugs for seniors at $2,000 per year, ensuring that people enrolled in Medicare will not pay more than $35 for a month’s supply of insulin, and recipients will receive free vaccines
— Accelerated adoption of electric vehicles by reducing costs for families, jumpstarted the first national EV charging network, and made historic investments into EV batteries and materials
— Rejoined the Paris Agreement on day one to reassert the United States’ global leadership to combat the climate crisis
— Jumpstarted the American offshore wind industry and convened the nation’s first federal-state offshore wind partnership
— Set new policies to reduce super pollutants like HFCs and methane to protect communities and reduce emissions fueling climate change
— Lowered the deficit with the single largest annual reduction in American history
— Secured commitments from 20 leading internet providers to increase speeds and cut prices
— Signed legislation to reauthorize and strengthen the Violence Against Women Act
— Awarded the most ever federal contracting dollars to small businesses and disadvantaged small businesses
— Reignited the Cancer Moonshot with the goal of cutting the cancer death rate by at least half over the next 25 years
— Appointed a record number of women and people of color to serve in his Administration
— Hosted the first White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health in over 50 years and released a National Strategy to end hunger and reduce diet-related diseases and disparities by 2030
— Awarded more than $1 billion to initiate cleanup and clear the backlog of 49 previously unfunded Superfund sites, over $250 million to clean up hundreds of contaminated brownfield sites, and $725 million for abandoned mine lands
— Restored protections for Bears Ears, Grand Staircase-Escalante, and Northeast Canyons and Seamounts National Monuments and designated Camp Hale-Continental Divide National Monument to conserve our lands and waters, honor our nation’s veterans, protect Tribal cultural resources, and support jobs and America’s outdoor recreation economy
— Signed an Executive Order on Improving Public Safety and Criminal Justice for Native Americans and Addressing the Crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous People
— Invested historic funding for Tribal governments and Native communities, and
— Mailed over 740 million free COVID-19 tests directly to tens of millions of Americans
Below are a set of handy memes you can copy and paste into social media if any of these accomplishments resonate with you or you want to back up claims you’re making online. Just right-click and choose to save, copy, or download them: they’re copyright free.
Here’s to a fascinating (and, no doubt, infuriating) debate!
OPEN THE LINK TO SEE HARTMANN’S MEMES.

Must be nice being privileged enough to think that Biden has lowered the cost of living for Americans. Tell me you haven’t set foot in a grocery store without saying you haven’t set foot in a grocery store. You haven’t bought gas. You haven’t paid a utility bill. You haven’t renewed your license plates or paid your car insurance. Your rent hasn’t doubled or, if you own, your insurance hasn’t skyrocketed. You haven’t tried to send a child to college.
Yes, the inflation rate has gone down, but that doesn’t mean prices have decreased. If you gain 20 pounds one month, 10 the next and 5 the next, you don’t get to brag about losing weight. Your rate of gain may have gone down, but you’re still 35 pounds heavier than you were and you’re still gaining.
Trying to tell Americans how great they have it when they’re either living in the streets or stepping over the ones already there attempting to avoid being there themselves is not a winning strategy.
LikeLike
Well since you challenged someone to say it, I will.
Shopping at the market, or ordering online to have food supplies delivered, I’m spending less than I was before the pandemic and Traitor Trump left office.
My electric bill is lower than at any time in the last several decades and I’m using my HVAC longer.
My water bill is down.
My alarm bill went up about $5 a month
My internet connection costs a few dollars more a month.
My gasoline bill is a fraction of what it was before the pandemic.
The cost of eating out has gone up but I’m spending a lot less eating out because I don’t eat out as much as I used to. Instead of four or five times a week, I’m eating out maybe once a month.
In fact, if it wasn’t for dental bills that are not covered by any insurance, I’d be saving a lot more money than I have in the past. And those dental bills are the same amount they were before the pandemic.
I could go on and add more to this list.
Just because you may have noticed your spending more, doesn’t mean everyone is spending more.
LikeLike
That’s pretty weird, Lloyd, if you look at price indices and commodities markets, groceries are definitely not cheaper now than they were before the pandemic. Stick with your grocer, it’s doing something wrong and it’s working out well for you!
LikeLike
“ Tell me you haven’t set foot in a grocery store without saying you haven’t set foot in a grocery store. You haven’t bought gas. You haven’t paid a utility bill. You haven’t renewed your license plates or paid your car insurance. Your rent hasn’t doubled or, if you own, your insurance hasn’t skyrocketed. You haven’t tried to send a child to college.”
If you are trying to blame all this on Joe Biden — and it sure looks like you are — then you clearly have not been paying attention.
LikeLike
Oh, no, of course not. Every sensible person knows that every problem in this country’s history and its future is Trump’s fault.
LikeLike
democracy, you NEVER said every problem is Trump’s fault and I haven’t seen any person here who wrote that “every problem in this country’s history and its future is Trump’s fault.”
If that isn’t putting words in your mouth, then I have no idea why this person would even write such a thing that no one here has ever said. Is she putting words in the mouth of “every sensible person”??
democracy asked a good question of how any sensible person would blame inflation on Joe Biden. Bernie Sanders and AOC don’t blame Joe Biden, and they are very sensible.
Instead of engaging, she said “Every sensible person knows that every problem in this country’s history and its future is Trump’s fault.”
Given that democracy never even mentioned Trump, the defensiveness of that reply to democracy is very revealing.
Why not engage with the content of democracy’s comment instead of attacking “sensible people” and lying about how they all blame all problems on Trump.
LikeLike
There was no content. Just a ridiculous assertion thar inflation can’t be blamed on Biden when it started in 2022. Who else was in office in 2022? But according to practically every post on this blog, Biden is one step from godhood, while you all are still railing about Trump, Trump, Trump every day even though he’s been out of office for over two and a half years. So obviously everything is Trump’s fault, right?
LikeLike
“according to practically every post on this blog, Biden is one step from godhood…”
Again this commenter is putting words in people’s mouths.
No one here said that Biden is one step from godhood. I cannot believe this person again is putting words in people’s mouths instead of engaging in conversation with someone who rightly questioned why this commenter who keeps putting words in other people’s mouths was so angry at Biden for inflation, especially when neither Bernie Sanders or AOC – who both endorsed Biden’s re-election – believe the myth that inflation is something Biden is CAUSING, instead of fighting to mitigate.
True progressives understand this, and they also understand that blaming Biden instead of the right wing Republican party and the two so-called Dems (Manchin and Sinema) who always side with Republicans is simply wrong.
LikeLike
Biden is far from going down in history as one of our greatest presidents, but I’m not so sure it matters for the 2024 election. Yes, voters, when they’re struggling to make ends meet, tend to reject incumbents, but it’s not a hard and fast rule. Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Reagan all screwed Americans for four years before being elected for eight. Two other things also give me confidence that the resident of the White House in 2025 will not be a registered Republican.
First, Biden’s campaign style in 2020 was effective, and I predict he will repeat it. His campaign was based on saying next to nothing. He campaigned very little. That works when your opponent is bombastic. It’s entirely possible to argue too much. O.J. Simpson would likely have been found guilty if the bumbling prosecution hadn’t introduced the glove that didn’t fit. They said too much. My dad used to regale me with stories at the dinner table about court cases he had won by sitting back and letting the opposing attorney say too much in his or her argumentative enthusiasm. Biden is good at that. He just sits back and lets Trump put his foot in his mouth.
The second reason is that any Democrat in the United States not named Hillary can wipe the floor with Donald Trump in an election. Same goes for Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley, and any other right-of-sanity candidate. I’m sorry to mention Hillary again, and I don’t mean to open a can of worms, but she was the only person in the United States more widely despised than Trump in 2016.
Mum’s the word, Democrats. Sit back and enjoy watching your candidate walk in velvet slippers to reelection.
LikeLike
Thank you, Mr. Hartman. Biden has been a far, far better president than I expected him to be. So impressed by his many accomplishments!!!
LikeLike
Bob,
I join you in believing that Biden should take a victory lap, then let Democrats pick a successor in the primaries or even at the convention. He has been a great President in the FDR-LBJ mold, but without their huge majorities in Congress. His record is even more impressive when you consider his razor-thin majorities for the first two years, and his slim majority only in the Senate in the last year. With Manchin and Sinema ready to go rogue at any moment.
LikeLike
He has done an amazing job. A real statesperson in a time when real statespersons are not recognized as such.
LikeLike
BTW, no, you don’t get to claim 11 million jobs re-opening after a global pandemic (which is still going on and Biden has “conquered” it the same way liberals laughed at Trump for saying – by not testing) as “creating” new jobs.
LikeLike
Yes, Biden’s administration has done good work…….BUT……what has his administration done to rein in the big Banks, Wall Street, and the Tech Industry that have done much of the damage in decimating the middle class? If American’s can’t see change within their personal wallets/pocketbooks, then it’s just “talk is cheap” as usual. I hate to be a Debbie Downer here but we have to look at the bigger picture and look at who gets to keep their expensive toys and legal tax loopholes at the expense of the Common Good.
LikeLike
LisaM,
We also have to consider what the Republicans will do to reward the big banks, Wall Street, and the Tech industry? Biden proposed raising taxes on the richest. Republicans plus Manchin and Sinema shot it down. If any Republican is elected, what will they do to rein in the 1%? Trump’s biggest accomplishment was to cut their taxes (and his). Expect more of the same.
LikeLike
Then I guess we’re screwed! Bernie was the last hope we had and the DNC shut him out because he would have hurt their bottom line by reigning in the banks/wall st/hedge funds/tech. And don’t say that the Southern states and the black vote made that decision ….it did…. BUT they were fed the usual narrative by the DNC, which kept HRC (the DNC’s preferred candidate) in the running.
Nothing will change. It will be this continuous cycle of whose “side” wins. It will continue to be a war of sides and a Power before People mentality from the elected officials at the top. Sorry….not feeling very optimistic today.
LikeLike
LisaM,
I assume that you see no difference between Trump and Biden. I do.
LikeLike
I didn’t say there was no difference between Biden and Trump. That’s you making false assumptions. I’m just saying that Biden (and the rest of the stupid politicians) won’t bite the hands that feed them……banks/wall st/hedge funds/tech will never get slapped down for the messes that they have made.
Now, I’m off to the grocery store to spend probably $40-$50 more than I would have a couple years ago for less items (and generics to boot) in my cart. I guess I should feel lucky that I at least have that extra $40-$50 dollars to spend?
LikeLike
“Bernie was the last hope we had…..”
LisaM, your “last hope” endorsed Biden’s re-election. I don’t understand praising a politician and then dismissing his endorsements as simply an untrustworthy politician who would throw working and middle class people under the bus for their own political gain.
LisaM, when Bernie Sanders and AOC and Diane Ravitch all believe that Biden has done a decent job working under difficult circumstances, why do you continue to bash Biden? Whose anti-Biden opinion is it that you trust more than Bernie and AOC that provides you with your certainty that higher food prices and every other inflationary problem is Biden’s fault instead of being less of a problem that it would be if Biden wasn’t president?
Do you not realize that the progressive ideas that Bernie stands for will always cause some inflation? That’s what Bernie and AOC understand. And they also understand that Biden is pushing for policies (blocked by the right) that would ease the pain of inflation for poor and middle class folks.
Trust Bernie. Or don’t trust him and keep bashing Biden. But it’s mystifying to hear you praising the guy who you think is lying to you about Biden because Bernie is a “politician” whose would lie and Bernie would throw working and middle class Americans under the bus to help Biden win. I don’t believe that. Do you?
LikeLike
Given the makeup of Congress, how — exactly — would Joe Biden accomplish what you suggest??
LikeLike
I don’t know? I don’t get paid the big $$$$ to enact laws that affect regular folks. Maybe those that are enacting laws should live among ‘the commons” so that they know how we really survive. All I do know is that over the years (mainly since Clinton), Banks/Wall St/Hedge funds/tech have made bank because of laws and loopholes afforded to them by politicians. Our politicians won’t bite the hands that feed them….it’s such a symbiotic relationship.
Yep, we vote for Change/Hope (slogans!)…… and it never gets much better.
LikeLike
All I know is that both Bernie Sanders and AOC endorsed Biden for re-election. I don’t understand the people who say they would have voted for Bernie Sanders but then don’t trust Bernie’s judgement.
Both Bernie and AOC endorsed Biden’s re-election. Which means that Biden may be old, but anyone who blames Biden for the struggles of the middle and working class is dead wrong. Or they believe neither Bernie nor AOC should be trusted.
LikeLike
Yes, Biden’s domestic accomplishments have been tremendous, ranking him–in my opinion–just behind FDR & LBJ for building America in a good direction. However, his foreign policy is more a continuation of Bush policies of confrontation around the world. There is a lot of opposition on his left–which I share–to his escalation in Ukraine and his challenges to China, etc. Whether you agree with the progressives on this or not, expect serious defections and challenges which, while not likely to deny him a re-nomination, may cost him the election. For this blog, it is also notable that he is, as have been so many Democratic national leaders, a product of private schools and not a strong leader on public education. When you add in the questions that arise from is age, his re-election seems to me a longer shot than it should be, especially against a “moderate” Republican. If he draws Trump as an opponent, that will be his best shot, in my view.
LikeLike
Jack,
Who is a “moderate Republican”?
LikeLike
Tim Scott seems to be the “moderate Republican” in the lineup.
LikeLike
Tim Scott said he would back “the most conservative” national abortion ban that came to his desk if he were elected–i.e. 15 weeks or even shorter.
Not very moderate.
LikeLike
The South Carolina Supreme Court just uphel a six-week ban on abortion, which is akin to a total ban since women don’t know they are pregnant until at least the eighth week. The SC Constitution guarantees a right to privacy but the all-make court decided that the fetus’ right to life outweighs the woman’s right to privacy.
LikeLike
Christie is probably the closest thing to a “moderate” in the Republican field. And his fortunes will probably suggest Republican voters aren’t very interested in a moderate.
LikeLike
Despite the accomplishments listed in Hartmann’s article, it is inconceivable that Biden remains tied in the polls with slimeball Trump. This may be true in part from some of his inabilities to make life better for most of the working class as Lisa points out, but I also think Biden has an image problem.
Listening to Biden’s well-intentioned Maui speech, I have some constructive criticism that Democrats need to help Biden with in preparation for debates. While Biden no longer has a stuttering problem, he continues to have problems with articulation. He needs a good speech therapist as I think he has lazy tongue syndrome or dysarthria. I know a lot about articulation from my linguistic studies, and Biden’s communication issues can be easily and quickly addressed. It is difficult for Biden to make a positive impression on voters if he sounds like he has had too much to drink much of the time. He also needs someone to coach him on using a more authoritative delivery of his main points through more effective intonation patterns and well placed pauses. Biden has never learned these delivery techniques that many politicians often skillfully employ so voters will remember their message. The Democrats need to help Biden on these matters before it is too late. Biden is old, but not feeble or stupid. He is an old dog that needs to learn new tricks before it is too late. Image projection matters to voters. Sometimes voters make a decision based on a simple impression of the candidate. Biden needs help.
LikeLike
I don’t think it has much to do with any particular candidate’s image. I’ve seen polls of various non-Biden candidates against Trump, and they’re all pretty close to a dead heat, just like the polling shows Biden v. Trump. Point being, I don’t think the issue is Biden’s image, it’s Democrats’ image.
LikeLike
Maybe it’s both.
LikeLike
Gavin Newsom was one of the hypothetical candidates who was running in a dead heat against Trump in one of the polls I saw.
LikeLike
Polling at this stage is irrelevant. The dial will reveal itself through the societal and economic conditions that exist in the summer of 2024. However, what you reveal accurately in this comment is that voters in a democratic society are too focused on the shiny object of charisma vs. the heavy lifting of competent governance. We have seen examples of both with the last two administrations yet the reporting continues to skew to style over substance. I keep hoping the American people will realize this, but history tells me that this will not be the case.
LikeLike
I agree. HRC was an incredibly popular Secretary of State until the right wing smear machine got done with her. (They managed to smear her as a left wing Marxist fem-nazi when she was first lady and then smeared her as a tool of Wall Street when she ran for president.)
Having seen every single Democrat since 1980 get smeared by the right wing propaganda machine, I don’t understand how anyone still blames the candidate, as if they have some power to stop folks who should know better from legitimizing this. That machine destroyed both Carter and Dukakis – with help from people like me who got totally fooled by the mischaracterizations of Jimmy Carter as the evil neo-liberal out to destroy every good thing progressives had achieved. I turned policy disagreements with Jimmy Carter — he adamantly refused to support universal healthcare and is probably the single reason our country didn’t have universal healthcare in the late 1970s — into deciding Carter had taken that policy position because he was a tool of the right wing and Jimmy Carter was an untrustworthy, cruel and evil man who would throw poor people under the bus to please his Wall Street/corporate bosses.
That machine destroyed Al Gore and Kerry and HRC.
That machine was ready to destroy Bernie or Elizabeth Warren and is ready to destroy Gavin Newsom. Or any other Dem who seems popular.
That right wing machine only has power when those who know better help them turn policy differences with a Democrat into something evil and corrupt and untrustworthy. It’s so fun to join in to amplify whatever belittling, nasty joke the right wing is making to help change people’s image of the candidate as an untrustworthy, scary candidate who isn’t worth voting for. When the majority of right thinking people marginalize the folks whose clear goal is to defeat the Democrat and not defeat the right wing Republican, the Democrat wins. Whether the folks who want to defeat the Democrats are racist, xenophobic, anti-LBGTQ folks or describe themselves as progressives who don’t trust the endorsements of Bernie Sanders and AOC, they share the same goal — defeating the Democrat candidate who would stand up to the neo-fascist takeover of this country.
LikeLike
Thank goodness Joe Biden is potus and married to Jill.
LikeLike
Thom Hartmann must spend every waking hour compiling Biden accomplishments.
It’s a wonder he has time with everything else he does.
LikeLike
Of maybe he uses DemocratGPT
LikeLike
Good point, Diane. There are no popular, seemingly electable “moderates” among the GOP candidates. But the foreign policy concerns are real. I can see the GOP playing on that. It will encourage a stronger Green showing. It will hinder volunteer recruitment, etc. Bush II was totally not equal to Gore in knowledge or experience, but he managed to get the election close enough to steal. I could imagine Haley fooling enough people to get close–especially if there’s a major Biden fumble or further escalation of tensions with Russia or China. Peace is needed. I wish Biden would heed Kennedy’s words and work to “make the world safe for diversity,” not try to run it.
LikeLike
The GOP has become an extremist party, where half-baked ideas are debated. Three candidates last night said the way to fix education is to ban teachers unions. Name a non-union state with high academic performance. You can’t. On NAEP, the highest performing states have strong teachers’ unions. I wonder if Tim Scott was thinking of South Carolina as a model when he bashed teachers unions. Had the issue been put to a vote last night, I believe all the candidates would have agreed on abolishing teachers unions.
LikeLike
Even half baked would be an improvement over the current Republican sushi menu.
LikeLike
I’m surprised Republicans don’t come right out and say all tteachers should be eliminated and replaced with ChatGOP” because that is really what they believe
And lots of Democrats believe the same, but would never admit it in public.
LikeLike
Although the Democrats like Bill Gates, Arne Duncan and Barack Obama would want to replace the teachers with ChatDNC
LikeLike
One of my great frustrations with contemporary punditry is that most from the New York Times to the Wall Street Journal seem clueless about the economic circumstances most of us face in the US and abroad. While Democrats brag about their legislative accomplishments, and they are significant, Republicans continue to convince enough Americans that our economy is bad. How does this happen? We live in an economic environment where it is too expensive to be in the middle class. From Education to health care to housing, our incomes are swallowed up before we can think about food or even leisure. Hell, even pet care has gotten out of hand. For the underprivileged, there are simply few resources that pretend to promote any real opportunity toward social mobility. The top 10% in our country represent about 33 million people. The top 2% hold 37% of all wealth. The privileged have access to an economy by themselves that would be second only to the US economy. 59% of Americans cannot afford a $400 emergency (That’s almost 200 million Americans by the way). The focus on macro economic circumstances by our data driven media sphere misses the point. Most Americans perpetually worry about the next recession, or even next week, because we are in debt or lack resources to get by when it comes. The bipartisan bill for infrastructure sounds great, but for most of us it is an abstract occurrence. We face a constant advertising barrage that shows us what we are missing. Republicans exploit this reality while democrats don’t get it. Yes, the Biden Administration has done a lot, but most of us have trouble seeing the benefit. Economic policy should focus on bottom up opportunity, not the drip drip of supply side fantasy.
LikeLike
You are right.
The clowns…I mean “journalists at the NY Thymes* and Wall Street Urinal don’t have a clue.
*and parsley , sage and rosemary
LikeLike