Thanks to reader Kathyirwin1 for bringing this article to my attention. Egged on by Governor Gregg Abbott and legislator Matt Krause (who circulated a list of 850 books that should be removed from public school libraries, most because they deal with race, sexuality or inequality), critics are now targeting the books in the public libraries.
The public library in Llano County closed for three days while librarians reviewed their holdings. Libraries in other counties saw challenges to books that conservatives want removed from shelves.
Local public libraries in Texas, including those in Victoria, Irving and Tyler, are fielding a flurry of book challenges from local residents. While book challenges are nothing new, there has been a growing number of complaints about books for libraries in recent months. And the fact that the numbers are rising after questions are being raised about school library content seems more than coincidental, according to the Texas Library Association.
“I think it definitely ramped it up,” said Wendy Woodland, the TLA’s director of advocacy and communication, of the late October investigation into school library reading materials launched by state Rep. Matt Krause in his role as chair of the House Committee on General Investigating.
In response to Krause’s inquiry, Gov. Greg Abbott tapped the Texas Education Agency to investigate the availability of “pornographic books” in schools. In the weeks since, school districts across the state have launched reviews of their book collections, and state officials have begun investigating student access to inappropriate content…
In Victoria, about 100 miles southeast of San Antonio, Dayna Williams-Capone says the number of complaints about books is the most she’s seen in her nearly 13 years working at the Victoria Public Library.
In August, Williams-Capone, the director of library services in Victoria, said her office received about 40 formal requests for review of books, primarily books for children and young adults that touch on topics of same-sex relationships, sexuality and race.
After Williams-Capone and her staff reviewed the requests, they decided to keep the books in the library. Residents who filed the complaints pushed forward, appealing the decision to the library’s advisory board for about half of the books, Williams-Capone said.
Last Wednesday, the library’s board voted not to remove the books from library shelves.
Most of the complaints are directed at books that feature same-sex relationships.
Wendy Woodland of the Texas Library Association said that:
“These efforts to mute or censor diverse voices in books is part of the just overall extreme divisiveness in our country that was really just exacerbated by the pandemic, [and] the actions taken by Rep. Krause and others have added fuel to that,” Woodland said.
She understands there will be those who may not like all of the books in a library. That’s not the point of a public library, she said.
“No book is right for everyone, but one book can make a big difference in one person’s life,” she said. “That’s what libraries are about — providing those windows and doors and mirrors to the community.”
I think we need another word — there’s nothing conservative in the traditional sense about these people, nothing of value they are trying to conserve. It is more like a reactionary personality disorder of people who are just now figuring out that living in a civil, democratic, educated society means they can’t keep wallowing in the narcissistic narcosis they use to insulate themselves from reality.
Woke
It’s the “conservation of idiocy”: once an idiot, always and idiot.
Emboldened by the rise of the right, we are now seeing right wing overreach where conservatives attempt to impose their views on the public.
What would you call someone who broke into a library and destroyed a bunch of the books? A vandal. This is vandalism.
Jon, actually they are anarchists, trying to tear down and privatize public institutions.
Manchinators is what they are. (Hat tip to Diane, who coined the word)
Destroyers of everything that is good and decent.
The Manchinator
Conservative they ain’t
Environment they taint
The term is Manchinator
Destroyer and a hater
Good one!
Regressive reactionaries who want to go back to a golden time that never existed and never will.
As I often do, I see it differently. In this case, we are talking about none other than conservatives, in my estimation, social conservatives. They are trying to preserve or conserve their beliefs as what they perceive is truth, justice, and the American way, to borrow from Superman reruns. In the most formative experiences of many people, Superman was white and liked Lois Lane, for example. Americans were downright expected to be like Superman or John Wayne or shut up and make me a sandwich. Some people still live there. They’re not bad people. I kind of feel sympathetic, really. They feel defensive, as if cornered. It’s frustrating that they feel that way. It’s demoralizing when they act out because they don’t feel more sympathy for people who are different from them or have different beliefs than they do. If they were students in my class acting out, I would probably forgive them and subtly teach them — teach them using books, and that’s the problem with social conservatism.
…And along those lines, earlier today, I watched a video of Desmond Tutu speaking. He said we need justice that is restorative rather than retaliatory. There must be a way to open better lines of diplomatic communication with the anti-book petitioners.
Religious conservatives should be careful what they wish for. As an example, there’s been an estimated 50% increase in U.S. vasectomies over the past few years. It’d be tough not to draw a line from that statistic to attacks on reproductive rights. Are priests, evangelical pastors and Robert P. George happy with the unanticipated turn of events?
always desperate for keeping seats in the pews when tithing time comes around
And, to avoid paying taxes while they politic to gain advantage for their
institutions that promote sex discrimination and that have a deplorable record relative to social justice, especially for Black people.
Absolutely Agree! This is not Conserving as in preventing harmful use or waste of Precious Resources..like a Free Public Library. It hurt my ❤️ and my intellect when I read that a tax funded library system turned OFF Overdrive. A huge catalogue of e-Books which are a life line during this Pandemic assault on our culture. There is a lot of tech $$$ in and around Llano. A beautiful place to “retire” with your millions. But many of these folks use their wealth as insulation against the ignorant book terrorists. Wake up rich gearheads. It is time to take out a library card and rock this mean-spirited, shuttered universe.
“I see the disinfectant that knocks out uncomfortable ideas in a minute, one minute. And is there a way we can do something like that by injection inside or almost a cleaning? As you see, an idea gets in the brain, it does a tremendous number on the mind, so it would be interesting to check that.”
All T rexes live in Texas
Texas is the place they really love to be
All T rexes live in Texas
That’s why the little mammals always flee
Rex Tillerson, for example.
Troubled by thoughts? This is only naturel. After all, we wuz ALL bornt with Originul Sin, so dont you worry none. Everbody has em. Why, even I, the Reverund Billy Bob Sheephead, put out uh info-mercial bout are prayer groops in which I rote that they would “bathe you in the heeling lite of Jesus.” Yup, I used the word “bathe.” Thats how Satan works. He sneeks it in–into yore school lie-beries, into yore TV shows. But no that you KIN fite bak! Jist send a pound of 20 doller bills to the Reverund Billy Bob Sheephead’s Heeling Lite Ministries, an become uh Gold Medallion Member of the Rapture Club (TM). You will git an official Reverund Billy Bob Bible Bookmark AND, at no extra charge, a 4 ounce botle of are Naughty Thoughts Disinfectant, which you kin take orally or by innerjection. Oh, darn. I used the word “orally”! Git thee behind me, Satan! But join now. You have no idea how this will change yore life. Pretty soon, you wont have any thoughts at all, and lite as a feather, when the Rapture comes, you”ll float right off to Jesus, leavin the Socialists and the Sinners behind. So, don’t be left out. Order today! Offer void in Portland, Oregan, Warshington, DC, and other Territories and Dominions of the Evil One.
I laughed so hard reading this (this is Roy’s daughter).
By the way, I think it is just disgusting that they are trying to censor books with such important messages. Books aren’t just collections of words; they change the way we see the world and ourselves. Unfortunately, some want to take advantage of that. My dad showed me this article because he knows what books mean to me and to a lot of my friends. Books can be an escape, but they’re also mirrors to our own problems, like discrimination and inequality. Some people would rather remove all the conversation about these issues than deal with them, or completely ignore the problems.
A brilliant and beautiful comment! Roy has shown me a couple pieces of your writing, and I was quite impressed. Of course, if you write that well, this means that you are a reader. It is in young people like you that I place my hopes for the future and for a better world. Thank you for your beautiful, important post and for your defense of freedom of the press and of thought!!!
Have you read Siddhartha, by Herman Hesse, yet? I fell head over heels in love with that book when I was your age. And take a crack at 1984, by Orwell, which may be the most important book to be read at this time in history. And here, a few suggestions for short fiction:
MY CANDIDATES FOR THE BEST SHORT STORIES EVER WRITTEN
Asimov, Isaac. “The Last Question”
Atwood, Margaret. “Bread”
Benet, Stephen Vincent. “By the Waters of Babylon”
Bierce, Ambrose. “Chickamauga”
Bierce, Ambrose. “Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge”
Borges, Jorge Luis, “The Library of Babel”
Bostrom, Nick. “The Dragon Tyrant”
Bradbury Ray. “The Veldt”
Bradbury, Ray. “The End of the World”
Bradbury,. Ray. “There Will Come Soft Rains”
Chiang, Ted. “Stories of Our Lives”
Chopin, Kate. “Story of an Hour”
Crane, Stephen. “A Mystery of Heroism”
Du Maurier, Daphne. “The Birds”
Faulkner, William. “The Bear”
Gallico, Paul. “The Snowgoose”
Goldstein, Rebecca. “The Legacy of Raizel Kaidish”
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. “Rappaccini’s Daughter”
Hathorne, Nathaniel. “Young Goodman Brown”
Hemingway, Ernest. “Hills Like White Elephants”
Hemingway, Ernest. “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place”
Hemingway, Ernest. “The Long Wait”
Liu, Ken. “An Advanced Readers’ Picture Book of Comparative Cognition”
Jackson, Shirley. “The Lottery”
Marquez, Gabriel Garcia. “A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings”
O’Conner, Flannery. “A Good Man Is Hard to Find”
Roth, Phillip. “The Conversion of the Jews”
Thurber, James. “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty”
Tolstoy, Leo. “The Life and Death of Ivan Illych”
Updike, John. “A & P”
Updike, John. “The Music School”
Vonnegut, Kurt. “Who Am I This Time?”
Walker, Alice. “Everyday Use”
I sent you a reply, but it is in moderation. I hope it gets to you! Warm regards. Oh, and give that smart father of yours a hug for me! He must be very proud to have raised a daughter like you.
Trust me. We are very proud of her, even when she vacates this life for whichever fantasy is dominant at whichever time. Her choir performance around Christmas was wonderful, and I decided Sinatra needed to sit down after she sang “Havr Yourself a Merry Little Christmas “. Well, ok. There is the thing about bias, I admit, but Frank never made my eyes moisten.
Ha!!!! I hope you have a recording of this, Roy!!!
A couple additions to that list for your daughter:
“The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street,” Rod Serling
And this wonderful little short story by Terry Bisson:
Roy is a deep thinker and obviously a wonderful Dad.
Agreed!
Just endlessly amusing that the same people who work hard every day to privatize every public entity they can get their hands on are ALSO the people who pile endless new rules on every public entity.
On the one hand they all lobby to send public dollars to the private sector with no regulation or accountability at all, and while they’re doing that they impose restriction after restriction on the remaining public entities.
Every ed reformer who is banning books in public schools and public libraries spend their rest of the work days setting up a privatized system of schools they won’t be able to reach with all these rules.
It’s incoherent and because it makes no sense we should all assume it’s wholluy ideological. They don’t want any public entities. They prefer privatized systems IDEOGICALLY. It’s a belief system. So they punish the public entities and promote and market and fund the private entities.
The ed reform “movement” doesn’t contibute anything of value to public schools. So why are we stuck with their gimmicky and politically driven mandates? Shouldn’t they have to support our schools and students if they want to run them? Public school students get the worst on both ends. They get a “movement” that lobbies against the existence of the schools AND ed reform gimmicks, fads and mandates. They lose twice.
This is one of the things that happens, I suppose, when morons are given power.
It’s inevitabull, inenviabull and incorrigibull.
And unmanageabull
And uninhAbbottabull
And abominabull.
And untameabull.
And perhaps worst of all, unreasonabull
I’m glad I read the story about the baby’s homecoming first.
I’m exhausted from disgust and anger at reading about the never-ending madness caused by turgid MAGA Trumpism. What will it take to shut these lunatics up and make them crawl back into their underground Morlock warrens?
We are the Eloi. They are the Morlocks.
At least I read this latest crap from Trumpistan after finishing a much warmer story first. Even after reading this one, I’m still smiling from the other story.
Oh, Lord, I love that book. A few years back, one of the most execrable films ever, alas, was made from it.
execrable. adj. Trumplike
Top 10 New Year’s Resolutions, 2022, by Robert Shepherd, Lifestyle Reporter
Resolved, with resolution, resolutely to do nothing in 2022 to curb the epidemic of school shootings. –The United States Congress
Petition the warden for Big Mac deliveries. –Donald Trump
Deputize and arm Citizen Militias to remove from public schools both Socialist librarians and books with the words bed or bladder in them. –Governor Abbott
Finish our monograph on Heidegger, Lacan, and the Hermeneutics of Gender Fluidity. –Donald Trump, Jr., and Kimberly Guilfoyle
Publish Not Sissies, our collection of Poems BY Real Men FOR Real Men. –Jordan Peterson and Josh Hawley
Annex Scandinavia. –Vladimir Putin
Complete rebranding by replacing antiquated GOP elephant with Pepe the Frog. –Republican Party
Make film history by releasing blockbuster new concept film about six teenagers, see, who rent a cabin in the woods, see, and like, omg, they start, like, disappearing, one by one because, because . . . THERE’S SOMETHING OUT THERE! –Amazon Originals
When adults start talking, close my eyes, put my fingers in my ears, and think about ponies. –Abigail, aged 6
It’s mine. It’s all mine. –Covid
You forgot (and this has been verified by local police forces everywhere):
Check Craigslist for fantasy hookups when our convention is in town — a vast minority of attendees of Republican conventions and state political meetings
MAGAts: Are you Socialism-curious but ashamed to let anyone know the thoughts you’ve been harboring? Then you’ve come to the right place. Act now and we’ll send, for the S-curious only, the complete regulations of the national healthcare and parental leave systems of Denmark, discretely packaged in a brown paper wrapper! The first 25 callers also get, absolutely free, our camo-green T-shirt with Red for Ed stitched on the label. Only you will know it’s there! Wear it with your MAGA hat. Just know that you are not alone. Others have these urges, too! Who knows, maybe that guy next to you at the gun range or the NASCAR rally! Also try in the privacy of your own home our phone foment service! Our bevy of beautiful young comrades will whisper sweet sedition about economic equity and racial justice into your ear and even call you a commie libtard pinko CRT-loving snowflake! Oh, yeah, baby! Sing me a little of that Union Maid song! or Joe Hill!!! Long distance and roaming charges may apply.
But yeah, that’s the truth of the matter, Greg. It was an extraordinarily busy time for the sex trade here in Tampa, or so the local news reported, when the Repugnican convention was in town. Opioid-addicted youth in hotel rooms with sanctimonious old Repugnican hypocrites.
I was in Austin for a day last week and that experience once again underscored how the humanity embodied in much near the UT campus is nothing like the backwardness of the political culture of the state leadership. Consider that in a relatively short walking distance on either side of the governor’s mansion and state capitol (how can a state that elects individuals who desecrate the concept of governing be housed in what is arguably the most beautiful in the nation?) are two of the best bookstores in the nation (BookPeople to the south and Malvern Books, a gem of an independent bookstore with wonderful, dedicated staff, to the north). Would that all Texans valued these wonderful places as much as some people in Austin obviously do. And remember to support university presses too. Self-educating in Texas and around the country may soon be considered subversive, unconstitutional activity.
That may be , but soon there will also be a University of Austin,Tacious which embodies the backwardness of the political culture of the state.
Which is just awesome. I say, herd all the court singers for the oligarchy into a single madhouse. First step in stopping a viral contagion: isolate and contain it. It’s not even open, and it is already a laughingstock. Downhill from here, unless, ofc, the Repugnicans win in 2022 and 2024, in which case it will become the official Ministry of Truth. And doubtless, if the thing gets off the ground, it will be supported by rivers of green.
I can see it now: UATX, a place with unparalleled amenities, such as the Jeffrey Epstein Lounge in Hubris Hall.
Now, now. Remember, I advised against ever using that acronym in respect to the actual university. And I have a very, very strong feeling the people who frequent Malvern Books and BookPeople have stronger opinions about this monstrosity than any of us do!!
Austin is one of the many oases across this country which–just as they have done and are doing with language for obvious political gain–the Right will try to pollute, with success, over the next few years.
Well, I’ll stretch this to be on topic. E.O. Wilson died today and his books are as good as any that should stock libraries anywhere. Here’s a nice lecture that ties together the ideas many of you express, biodiversity, pluralism, sociology, and governing. Perhaps we shouldn’t give him too much notice. His might be one of the sources of resistance in the coming dark age.
I loved his work on ants and biodiversity so much that I forgave him the ridiculous genetic determinism of his Sociobiology. Perhaps, being resident at Harvard, he contracted that infection from the likes of Stephen Pinker. Over the years, I read everything of his I could lay my hands on. His autobiography is an inspiring read. Even when he was wrong, he was brilliantly so.
Evolutionary Psychology. n. A body of sketchy just-so stories told by well-remunerated court singers to flatter members of the white, heterosexual patriarchy and oligarchy
Ofc, it was not that Pinker influenced Wilson (it was much more likely the other way around) but that there is a lesson to be learned from Wilson’s example. Even a very great scientist like Wilson is capable of overgeneralizing from his own work–a classic example of being in possession of a hammer and so treating everything as if it were a nail.
Ignorance breeds what is happening in our country today. If you feel that strongly about your child not “being exposed” to “bad things” in books, monitor them and don’t let them read it, but don’t tell me what my child can or can’t read. You are the same people that don’t want your child to wear a mask to protect themselves and others in a classroom, so please don’t try to “protect” my child from ideas!
Good points.
Here is a piece I just did https://www.laprogressive.com/author/cynthia-mcdermott/ [https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/cb0fb856bee897406cee4219bf56c8b7?s=500&d=blank&r=g] Cynthia McDermott – LA Progressive Cynthia McDermott is Chair of the Education Department at Antioch University, Los Angeles. McDermott was awarded a Fulbright Scholar grant to do research and teach at the University of Sarajevo in … http://www.laprogressive.com
________________________________