
A friend in Sweden sent this article via Twitter. It was written by Jenny Maria Nilsson. I went to Google and asked for a translation from Swedish to English. Sweden is even farther down the road to privatization than we are. A conservative government in the early 1990s opened the way to public funding of independent schools, many of which operate for profit.
She writes:
The goal for primary school is not millions of different things but first and foremost education. If that goal is achieved, it certainly also provides other things: life opportunities, education and freedom, social interaction, a place for children to be and so on, but the school’s goal is teaching a basic curriculum.
In the book about the digitalisation of the Swedish school, which I have contributed to, I write: “What is the school’s task? To be a marketplace for all kinds of commerce, an arena for the edtech industry, a pseudo-market for welfare entrepreneurs and consultants, an advertising opportunity for municipalities, schools and individual teachers, a leisure center where children can thrive while parents are at work, an institution that organizes social support, a place where educators are responsible for identifying and developing great talent, an organization that will kick-start your child’s career, rank your child and let it make contacts with others in its social group, a place for admiration and curling of young people or vice versa a place where you put children in place and so on. ”
Tax-financed primary school is none of this but a “room” organized by us where previous generations through teachers and other school staff strive to convey the basic practical and theoretical knowledge that has been accumulated in various fields. The goal often seems to me to be distorted, the school system has increasingly been characterized by what I call the era of panic, where more people are looking for things that have nothing to do at school. The school has become a means for various special interests rather than a goal in itself.
To leave the era of panic, we need to navigate an era where school and school institutions and administration can maintain integrity. An era where the school is a cohesive unit that honors its knowledge and education mission – what I call the era of the monolith.
Reminded me of continue relevance of something I wrote 6 years ago that answers: What’s the purpose of education in the 21st century? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2015/02/12/whats-the-purpose-of-education-in-the-21st-century/
Thanks for the link! Well stated.
But at the same time lacking a little in the foundational purpose of public education. What might that be? Where might we find a fundamental purpose?
I address those questions in Ch. 1 “The Purpose of Public Education” of “Infidelity to Truth: Education Malpractice in American Public Education”. “All together then, there are 25 states with no stated fundamental purpose, five with a purpose that extol the benefits of public education to the state, fifteen commending the benefits to the individual and five a combination of benefit to both state and individual, resulting in 80% of those with a stated purpose of having the benefits for the individual as the primary rationale.
Is it possible, then, to discern a fundamental purpose of public education? Yes, I believe it can be ascertained, by starting with the fundamental purpose of government in this country as stated in each state’s constitution (sometimes as troublesome to recognize a stated purpose as that of public education). Since public education is a function of each state and not the federal government we must begin at the state level to determine what the fundamental purpose of the state is. . . .
Tying together the aims of our constitutional government with the purpose of public education as stated in some of the state’s constitution allows us to propose a common fundamental statement of purpose. Since 20 of the 25 state constitutions give a reason attending to the rights and liberties of the individual through public education combined with the mandate of state constitutional government as reflected in Missouri’s constitutional language of “That all constitutional government is intended to promote the general welfare of the people; that all persons have a natural right to life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness and the enjoyment of the gains of their own industry. . .” it follows that the rights and liberties of the individual in being educated as each sees fit supersede those of supporting and maintaining the government. And that one can logically conclude that if the educational wants and needs of the citizens obtain then those of the state will follow. But without an educated citizenry who can promote their own interests, and who can understand and tolerate others thoughts, opinions and desires, the state would surely be subject to tyranny by those whose knowledge and wants exceeds most.
I propose, then, the following statement of the purpose of public education with which, hopefully, most in the United States could agree:
“The purpose of public education is to promote the welfare of the individual so that each person may savor the right to life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, and the fruits of their own industry.”
Any educational practice that is shown to hinder, block and/or otherwise cause an individual to not be able to indulge in any of aspect of his/her rights as stated has to be considered as harmful and unjust not only to the individual but also to society and therefore must rightly be condemned as educational malpractice and ought to be immediately discontinued. Trampled rights are rights that are non-existent and the educational malpractice that tramples any right is unjust and as noted in Alabama’s constitution “is usurpation and oppression” and as Missouri’s declares “. . . when government does not confer this security, it fails in its chief design.”
My apologies for going off topic-
The Koch network is a driver of school privatization and other noxious plans. A couple of articles from Slate (12-10-2021) and PRWatch (3-13-2019) command our attention. Caving into men like Bloomberg, Koch and Gates who reject democratic principles will be disastrous for America.
Slate- “Tucker Carlson is America’s Most Watched Kremlin Propagandist”. PRWatch -“Who Bankrolls Tucker Carlson’s Hateful Propaganda? Why the Kochs, Of Course.”.
Swedish standardization has produced a couple of good things like Volvos, now owned by a Chinese company, and IKEA. The Swedes have also had their fair share of blunders. Its “herd immunity” approach to Covid has backfired with deadly consequences. Sweden is the largest Nordic country. Its population is about twice the size of Denmark, Norway or Finland’s. Sweden embraces modernization more than the other Nordic countries. All things “new and modern” are not necessarily better. Jumping on and off bandwagons in education, including technology, is reckless education policy. Every curriculum project I have ever worked on had to have its basis in EVIDENCE. Evidence seems to have been replaced by marketing. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1113834/cumulative-coronavirus-deaths-in-the-nordics/
perfect summation
Sweden’s death rate per million in population is lower than most European countries, including Lithuania, Belgium, Italy, UK, Spain, France, Portugal, and Luxembourg. If Sweden’s approach backfired with deadly consequences, how should we view the approaches of these countries which experienced higher deaths per million? A gigantic backfire with even deadlier consequences?
Source, Statista for Europe, not just Nordic countries: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1111779/coronavirus-death-rate-europe-by-country/
You are saying there is a correlation between covid-19 deaths and education profiteering? Do tell, how so?
I posted this at OEN. https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Do-Not-Forget-the-True-Pur-in-General_News-Diane-Ravitch_Education_Integrity_School-Reform-211213-569.html#comment799903
The true purpose of school is to get the kids out of the house during the day so that whatever adult who has responsibility for them can get some work done.
cx: the adult who has responsibility for them
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/teachers-cash-contest_n_61b84bb5e4b0911ceb59fa85
!!!!!!